String theory in twistor space and minimal tension holography

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2411.08836
• Title: String theory in twistor space and minimal tension holography
• Authors: N. M. McStay, R. A. Reid-Edwards (University of Cambridge)
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Submission Date: November 2024
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.08836

Abstract

This paper investigates a concrete tractable example of the AdS/CFT correspondence: minimal tension string theory on $AdS_3 \times S^3 \times T^4$. The authors discuss the construction of sigma models in twistor space and apply these techniques to the aforementioned string theory. The paper derives new correlation relations that help understand the extent to which minimal tension strings encode bulk information. The authors identify vertex operators using bulk twistor variables and provide mappings from twistor space to spacetime. Furthermore, the paper demonstrates the existence of a partially broken global superconformal algebra in minimal tension strings and argues that this implies an $\mathcal{N} = 2$ formulation of the theory.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

Although the AdS/CFT correspondence represents a major breakthrough in theoretical physics, it lacks explicit examples where both the bulk theory and boundary theory are tractable. The minimal tension string with $k=1$ on $AdS_3 \times S^3 \times T^4$ is one of the few such examples.

Significance

1. Theoretical Foundation: Provides a concrete calculable model for understanding quantum gravity
2. Technical Development: Application of twistor methods in string theory remains incomplete
3. Holographic Duality: Understanding how string theory encodes bulk geometric information

Existing Limitations

1. RNS Formalism: Leads to non-unitary theory at $k=1$
2. Bulk Physics Understanding: Unclear to what extent the theory probes bulk geometry
3. Constraint Origin: Geometric origin of additional constraints $Q$ in hybrid formalism remains obscure

Research Motivation

The authors aim to provide a conceptual foundation for $k=1$ string theory from the perspective of twistor geometry, understanding its naturalness as a sigma model on minitwistor space.

Core Contributions

1. Construction of Twistor Sigma Models: Constructs sigma models on minitwistor space of $AdS_3$ from first principles
2. New Correlation Relations: Proposes string correlation relations mixing left and right moving degrees of freedom
3. Partially Broken Global Supersymmetry: Discovers and analyzes the PBGS algebra in $k=1$ strings
4. $\mathcal{N}=2$ Formulation: Argues for the existence of a "doubly supersymmetric" formulation of the theory
5. Vertex Operator Reconstruction: Reexpresses vertex operators using bulk twistor variables, demonstrating recovery of bulk-boundary propagators

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Construct a twistor geometric description of $k=1$ string theory on $AdS_3 \times S^3 \times T^4$, understanding how physical states encode bulk geometric information.

Model Architecture

1. Twistor Sigma Model Construction

For complexified $AdS_3$, the authors define the relations: $\omega^\alpha = g^{\alpha\dot{\alpha}}\pi^{\dot{\alpha}}, \quad \mu^{\dot{\alpha}} = -\lambda^\alpha g^{\alpha\dot{\alpha}}$

where $g \in SL(2;\mathbb{C})$ and $(α, \dot{\alpha})$ are two-component spinor indices.

2. Action

$S = \frac{1}{2\pi}\int_\Sigma d^2z \left(\omega^\alpha \partial_{\bar{z}}\lambda^\alpha + \pi^{\dot{\alpha}}\partial_z \mu^{\dot{\alpha}}\right)$

3. Supertwistor Generalization

Introducing supertwistors: $Z^m = \begin{pmatrix} \omega^\alpha \\ \pi^{\dot{\alpha}} \\ \psi^A \\ \eta^{\dot{A}} \end{pmatrix}, \quad W^m = (\lambda^\alpha, \mu^{\dot{\alpha}}, \chi^A, \zeta^{\dot{A}})$

Technical Innovations

1. Mixed Correlation Relations

Unlike traditional twistor string constructions with purely holomorphic correlation relations, this work proposes correlation relations mixing left and right moving sectors, which are natural for AdS geometry.

2. Boundary Localization Mechanism

In Euclidean $AdS_3$, the constraint $U = \tilde{U} = 0$ (where $U = \langle\omega\lambda\rangle$) localizes physical states to the boundary: $\langle\omega\bar{\pi}\rangle = e^\phi|\gamma - x|^2 + e^{-\phi}$ which approaches the boundary as $\phi \to \infty$.

3. PBGS Analysis

Through imposition of the scaling constraint $C_L = 0$, certain global supersymmetries are nonlinearly realized:

• Broken Symmetries: $J^+_0, S^{+A+}_0$ (nonlinearly realized)
• Unbroken Symmetries: $S^{+A-}_0$ (linearly realized)

Experimental Setup

Theory Verification Methods

1. Free Field Realization: Verifies that twistor variables reproduce the known $psu(1,1|2)_1$ current algebra
2. Boundary Limit: Checks that bulk correlation relations recover boundary correlation relations in the near-boundary limit
3. Vertex Operator Analysis: Reexpresses known vertex operators and recovers bulk-boundary propagators

Comparison Benchmarks

• Wakimoto representation of $SL(2;\mathbb{C})/SU(2)$ coset model
• Free field realization of hybrid formalism
• Traditional twistor string constructions

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Verification of Twistor Realization

Successfully realizes $psu(1,1|2)_1$ currents using twistor variables $(ω^α, λ^α, ψ^A, χ^A)$: $J^± = ±λ^±ω^∓, \quad K^± = χ^±ψ^∓, \quad S^{±A+} = ±ω^∓χ^A$

2. Recovery of Boundary Correlation Relations

In the $\phi \to \infty$ limit, bulk correlation relations simplify to boundary correlation relations: $\omega^+ - \gamma\omega^- = 0$

3. Picture Changing Operator

Determines the unique form of the picture changing operator: $P^+ = e^{-2\rho-iH}Q$ where $Q = \frac{1}{2}\epsilon^{\alpha\beta}\epsilon^{AB}\chi^A\chi^B\omega^\alpha\partial\omega^\beta$.

Vertex Operator Reconstruction

For ground states with $w$ units of spectral flow, provides the projected representation: $\Omega_w = C_w \prod_{j=0}^{(w-1)/2} \partial^j\psi^- \prod_{k=0}^{(w-1)/2} \partial^k\psi^+ \left(\frac{\langle A, \partial^w\omega\rangle}{\langle A_\infty, \omega\rangle}\right)^{-m_w} \delta_{-2}(A,\omega)\prod_{n=1}^{w-1}\delta_{-1}(A, \partial^n\omega) e^{2\rho+i\sigma+iH}$

Recovery of Bulk-Boundary Propagators

Through integral transformation: $O_{\Delta,\bar{\Delta}}(g|x) = \int_{CP^1_g} D\omega D\mu \frac{1}{[\bar{\omega}\pi]^\Delta\langle\bar{\mu}\lambda\rangle^{\bar{\Delta}}} V(\omega,\mu|x)$ recovers the bulk-boundary propagator: $O_{\Delta,\bar{\Delta}}(g|x) = \frac{(-1)^{\bar{\Delta}}}{(\langle AgA\rangle)^{\Delta+\bar{\Delta}}}$

Related Work

Twistor String Theory

• Witten Twistor Strings 25: Twistor description of four-dimensional conformal supergravity
• Berkovits Construction 26: Resolution of conformal anomaly through $c=+28$ current algebra

Twistor Methods in AdS/CFT

• AdS5 Twistor Geometry 37: Relationship between twistor space of $AdS_5$ and double twistor space of $S^4$
• Boundary Double Twistor Theory 18: Twistor description of boundary theory

Minimal Tension Holography

• Hybrid Formalism 24: Superstring construction on $AdS_3 \times S^3$
• Free Field Realization 6: Tractable description of $k=1$ strings

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Geometric Origin: $k=1$ strings naturally arise from sigma models on minitwistor space of $AdS_3$
2. Boundary Localization: Physical constraints localize the theory to the boundary of $AdS_3$, yet still encode bulk information
3. $\mathcal{N}=2$ Structure: PBGS analysis indicates the existence of twisted $\mathcal{N}=2$ worldsheet supersymmetry
4. Necessity of Constraints: The existence of constraint $Q$ is necessary for constructing critical string theory

Limitations

1. Complexified Geometry: Main results apply to complexified $AdS_3$; the Lorentzian case remains unclear
2. Generalization to $k>1$: Methods strongly depend on special properties of $k=1$, difficult to generalize
3. Explicit Construction: Lacks explicit construction of the $\mathcal{N}=2$ formulation

Future Directions

1. AdS5 Generalization: Apply the construction to $AdS_5 \times S^5$
2. $\mathcal{N}=2$ Realization: Explicitly construct the doubly supersymmetric formulation
3. Ramond Flux: Generalization including non-zero Ramond flux

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Conceptual Clarity: Provides clear geometric interpretation for $k=1$ strings
2. Technical Innovation: New correlation relations and PBGS analysis are original
3. Rich Results: Validates twistor description from multiple perspectives
4. Excellent Exposition: Paper is well-structured with detailed technical content

Weaknesses

1. Limited Scope: Results primarily restricted to $k=1$ case with limited generalizability
2. Lack of Explicit Construction: $\mathcal{N}=2$ formulation remains conjectural
3. Absence of Experimental Verification: Primarily theoretical consistency checks without independent physical predictions

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new tractable example for AdS/CFT
2. Methodological: Systematic application of twistor methods in AdS string theory
3. Technical Value: PBGS analysis potentially applicable to other string theory constructions

Applicable Scenarios

1. AdS3/CFT2 Research: Provides geometric foundation for minimal tension holography
2. Twistor String Theory: Offers insights for constructing new twistor string models
3. Supersymmetric Theory: PBGS mechanism potentially applicable to other supersymmetric theories

References

The paper cites 70 relevant references, covering important works in AdS/CFT correspondence, twistor theory, string theory, and supersymmetric theory, reflecting the breadth and depth of the research.