Threshold resummation for double-deeply virtual Compton scattering

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2411.11686
• Title: Threshold resummation for double-deeply virtual Compton scattering
• Author: J. Schoenleber (RIKEN BNL Research Center, Brookhaven National Laboratory)
• Classification: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology)
• Publication Date: November 2024 (v2: January 2, 2025)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.11686

Abstract

This paper discusses the threshold region of double-deeply virtual Compton scattering (DDVCS) and derives resummation formulas for parton threshold logarithms in the flavor non-singlet case. The resummation is achieved through the (re)factorization theorem of coefficient functions near the parton threshold. As a byproduct, the leading terms of the two-loop coefficient function threshold limit in DDVCS are obtained, which are consistent with recently explicit calculations, providing a highly non-trivial cross-check.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Problem

The core problem addressed in this paper is the logarithmic resummation in the parton threshold region of double-deeply virtual Compton scattering (DDVCS). Specifically, it involves the virtual photon-nucleon scattering process: $\gamma^{(*)}\!(q)N(p) \to \gamma^{(*)}\!(q')N(p')$

Importance of the Problem

1. Theoretical Completeness: Threshold resummation is an indispensable tool in perturbative QCD, achieved by solving evolution equations to resum logarithmic terms
2. Precision Enhancement: In certain kinematic regions, threshold logarithms can become large and require resummation techniques to sum them to all orders
3. Conceptual Significance: While phenomenological impact may be limited, it is conceptually interesting, particularly regarding its simplicity

Limitations of Existing Methods

• Fixed-order calculations may be insufficiently precise in the threshold region
• Lack of systematic theoretical treatment of the DDVCS threshold region
• Need for better theoretical frameworks to handle multi-scale problems

Research Motivation

By decomposing the problem into single-scale problems through all-order factorization, effective resummation of threshold logarithms is achieved, and theoretical predictions for future multi-loop calculations are provided.

Core Contributions

1. Derived threshold resummation formulas for DDVCS: Provided complete resummation expressions for parton threshold logarithms in the flavor non-singlet case
2. Established factorization theorems for coefficient functions: Proved all-order factorization of coefficient functions near the parton threshold
3. Obtained leading terms of two-loop coefficient functions: As a byproduct, predicted the leading behavior of DDVCS two-loop coefficient functions in the threshold limit
4. Provided non-trivial theoretical verification: Predictions are in perfect agreement with recent explicit calculations
5. Connected threshold behavior of DIS and DVCS: Unified the threshold resummation theory for deep inelastic scattering and deeply virtual Compton scattering

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Study the behavior of double-deeply virtual Compton scattering in the parton threshold region $x \sim \rho$, where:

• $\rho$ is the generalized Bjorken variable
• $x$ is the parton momentum fraction
• The parton invariant mass $\hat{s} = \frac{x-\rho}{\rho}Q^2$ becomes small near threshold

Theoretical Framework

Factorization Formula

The authors derived the factorization of the flavor non-singlet amplitude:

$F^{\text{ns}}_\perp(\rho,\xi,t,Q) = H(-q^2,\mu)H(-q'^2,\mu)\int_{-1}^1 \frac{dx}{\rho-x-i0}\left[G\left(\frac{\rho-x-i0}{\rho}Q^2,\mu\right) + \hat{O}(\rho-x)\right]F_q(x,\xi,t,\mu)$

where:

• $H$ is the hard matching coefficient of the Sudakov form factor
• $G$ is the quark propagator in light-cone gauge
• $F_q$ is the generalized parton distribution function

Factorization of Coefficient Functions

For the coefficient function itself:

$C(x/\rho,\xi/\rho,\mu,Q) = \frac{Q^2}{-\hat{s}-i0}H(-q^2,\mu)H(-q'^2,\mu)G(-\hat{s},\mu) + \hat{O}((|\hat{s}|/Q^2)^0)$

Technical Innovations

Region Expansion Method

1. Hard region: Loop momentum $l_\pm \sim Q$
2. n-collinear region: $l_+ \sim \eta^2 Q$, $l_- \sim Q$, where $\eta \sim \sqrt{|\hat{s}|}/Q$
3. Soft and n̄-collinear regions: Lead to scaleless integrals, which can be neglected

Power Counting

Two power counting parameters are introduced:

• $\lambda \sim m/Q \sim \Lambda_{\text{QCD}}/Q \sim \sqrt{-t}/Q$ (asymptotic limit)
• $\eta \sim \sqrt{|\hat{s}|}/Q$ (threshold approach)

Ward Identity Arguments

Through standard Ward identity arguments, scalar polarized gluons merge into Wilson lines, simplifying the factorization structure.

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Calculation Setup

• Perturbative Order: Calculations up to two-loop precision
• Renormalization Scheme: MS scheme in dimensional regularization
• Scale Selection: Discussion of selection strategies for different intermediate scales

Comparative Verification

• Comparison with explicit two-loop calculation results in reference 17
• Verification of the method correctness through the DIS case

Experimental Results

Main Results

Evolution Equations

Each factor satisfies the following evolution equations:

Quark propagator function: $\mu\frac{d}{d\mu}J(-\hat{s},\mu) = \left[-2\Gamma_{\text{cusp}}(\alpha_s(\mu))\log\frac{-\hat{s}}{\mu^2} - 2\gamma_J(\alpha_s(\mu))\right]J(-\hat{s},\mu)$

Sudakov form factor: $\mu\frac{d}{d\mu}H(Q^2,\mu^2) = \left[\Gamma_{\text{cusp}}(\alpha_s(\mu))\log\frac{Q^2}{\mu^2} + \gamma_H(\alpha_s(\mu))\right]H(Q^2,\mu^2)$

Exponentiation of Logarithms

At $\mu = Q$, the exponentiated form of leading double-logarithmic terms is:

$C(q^2,q'^2,-\hat{s},Q) = \exp\left[\frac{\alpha_s(Q)}{4\pi}\left(2\log^2\frac{-\hat{s}}{Q^2} - \log^2\frac{-q^2}{Q^2} - \log^2\frac{-q'^2}{Q^2}\right) + \cdots\right]$

Two-Loop Result Verification

The authors provide the two-loop expression for the leading term of the coefficient function $C$ in the $\eta$ expansion:

$C^{(2)}(\mu = Q) = C_F^2 C_F^{(2)} + C_F C_A C_A^{(2)} + \beta_0 C_F C_{\beta_0}^{(2)}$

where each coefficient is predicted through the factorization formula and is in perfect agreement with explicit calculations in reference 17, providing a highly non-trivial verification.

Recovery of the DIS Case

By taking the imaginary part in forward kinematics, the known threshold resummation results for deep inelastic scattering are successfully recovered:

$\frac{1}{\pi}\text{Im}F^{\text{ns,forward}}_\perp = (H(Q^2,\mu))^2 Q^2 \int_{x_B}^1 \frac{dx}{x_B} J(\hat{s},\mu)f_q^{\text{val}}(x,\mu) + \hat{O}((1-x_B)f_q^{\text{val}}(x_B,\mu))$

Related Work

Threshold Resummation Theory

• Pioneering work by Sterman, Catani-Trentadue and others in DIS
• General theoretical framework by Korchemsky-Marchesini
• Modern SCET methods by Becher-Neubert-Pecjak

DVCS and GPD Theory

• Original work on GPDs by Ji
• Research on GPD factorization by Diehl and others
• Author's previous work on DVCS threshold resummation 12

Multi-Loop Calculations

• Recent explicit two-loop DDVCS calculations by Braun et al. 17
• Precise results for jet functions and Sudakov form factors

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully established the threshold resummation theoretical framework for DDVCS, achieving all-order resummation of parton threshold logarithms
2. The factorization structure in momentum space is remarkably simple, providing new perspectives for understanding multi-scale problems
3. Perfect agreement between theoretical predictions and explicit calculations validates the correctness and power of the method

Limitations

1. Phenomenological impact may be limited: Due to GPD vanishing at $x=1$, contributions from the threshold region are small
2. Landau pole problem: IR sensitivity encountered in treating the real part requires further investigation
3. Complexity of scale selection: Optimal choice of intermediate scale $\mu_i$ still requires deeper analysis
4. Treatment of power corrections: Connection with power-suppressed corrections needs more detailed analysis

Future Directions

1. Generalization to other processes: Such as threshold meson production, quasi-GPDs and pseudo-GPDs threshold resummation
2. Complete phenomenological analysis: Including numerical studies and comparison with experimental data
3. Systematic study of power corrections: Issues related to Landau poles and IR sensitivity
4. Lattice QCD applications: Application of threshold resummation in lattice calculations of distribution amplitudes

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Rigor: Based on rigorous QCD factorization theory with clear derivation
2. Methodological Innovation: Successful application of region expansion methods to DDVCS with technical innovations
3. Result Reliability: Highly credible results verified through comparison with independent calculations
4. Theoretical Unification: Unified understanding of threshold behavior in DIS, DVCS, and DDVCS
5. Predictive Power: Capable of predicting higher-order corrections and guiding future calculations

Shortcomings

1. Limited Phenomenological Relevance: The author acknowledges that phenomenological impact may be minimal
2. Technical Complexity: Landau pole and scale selection issues complicate practical applications
3. Limited Scope: Only treats the flavor non-singlet case; complete theory requires gluon contributions
4. Lack of Numerical Verification: No concrete numerical analysis provided to assess correction magnitudes

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Adds important new cases to QCD threshold resummation theory
2. Methodological Value: Provides new insights and techniques for handling multi-scale problems
3. Computational Tool: Provides powerful theoretical tools for verifying multi-loop calculations
4. Educational Value: Serves as an excellent example of factorization theory applications

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical QCD Research: Particularly for multi-scale problems and threshold behavior studies
2. Precision Calculation Verification: As a theoretical tool for checking higher-order perturbative calculations
3. Related Process Research: Provides templates for threshold resummation in similar processes
4. Teaching and Research: Serves as a teaching case for modern QCD theoretical methods

References

The paper cites 27 important references, primarily including:

• Foundational Theory: Ji's pioneering work on GPD theory 2,3
• Threshold Resummation: Classical works by Sterman 7, Catani-Trentadue 8, Korchemsky-Marchesini 9
• Modern Methods: Becher-Neubert 10,20, author's previous DVCS work 12
• Recent Calculations: Two-loop DDVCS calculations by Braun et al. 17

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper making important contributions to QCD threshold resummation theory. While phenomenological impact may be limited, its theoretical value and methodological significance are substantial, providing important theoretical tools and profound insights for related research.