Compositeness of hadrons, nuclei, and atomic systems

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2411.12285
• Title: Compositeness of hadrons, nuclei, and atomic systems
• Authors: Tomona Kinugawa, Tetsuo Hyodo
• Classification: hep-ph nucl-th
• Published Journal: European Physical Journal A
• Received: September 30, 2024 / Accepted: March 25, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.12285

Abstract

Recent observations of exotic hadrons have stimulated theoretical investigations into the internal structure of hadrons. Although all hadrons are ultimately composed of quarks and gluons bound through strong interactions, quark clustering phenomena can produce hadronic molecules—weakly bound hadronic systems—expected to appear near double-hadron thresholds. However, it should be noted that pure hadronic molecules do not exist, as strong interactions induce mixing with other possible configurations. The concept of compositeness has been developed as an effective quantitative tool to characterize the proportion of hadronic molecular components. This paper summarizes the modern understanding of hadron internal structure through compositeness studies and reviews the application of compositeness to quantum systems at different energy scales, such as atomic nuclei and atomic systems.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Discovery of exotic hadrons: Beginning with the observation of X(3872), numerous exotic hadron candidates including pentaquark states Pc and tetraquark states Tcc have been discovered, which do not conform to the traditional classification of q̄q mesons and qqq baryons
2. Internal structure problem: These exotic hadrons may possess multiple internal structures, including multiquark states, hadronic molecules, and gluon-mixing states, requiring quantitative methods to distinguish these different configurations
3. Specificity of hadronic molecules: Unlike ordinary hadrons, the primary building blocks of hadronic molecules are ground-state hadrons, with hadron-hadron interactions driving the formation of self-bound systems

Research Motivation

1. Theoretical requirement: The need to introduce a certain measure to quantitatively describe internal structure, since hadronic molecules cannot be distinguished from ordinary hadrons through conserved quantum numbers
2. Method development: The compositeness concept, used in the 1960s to distinguish composite particles from fundamental particles, now needs to be modernized for application to unstable hadrons
3. Universal applicability: Due to low-energy universality, the compositeness concept can be applied to quantum systems at different hierarchical levels

Core Contributions

1. Systematic review: Provides comprehensive coverage of the theoretical foundations of hadron compositeness, including the latest developments
2. Methodological unification: Unifies the expression of compositeness under different frameworks including non-relativistic quantum mechanics and effective field theory
3. Weakly bound relations: Elaborates in detail the model-independent properties of compositeness in the weakly bound limit
4. Extension to unstable resonances: Summarizes various schemes for generalizing the compositeness concept to unstable resonances
5. Cross-scale applications: Demonstrates the application of compositeness to hadrons, atomic nuclei, and atomic systems at different energy scales

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Compositeness research aims to quantitatively determine the probability distribution of scattering state components in bound or resonant states, specifically manifested as:

• Input: Eigenstate decomposition of the Hamiltonian, scattering amplitudes, binding energies, etc.
• Output: Compositeness X (probability of scattering state components) and fundamentalness Z (probability of bare state components)
• Constraint: X + Z = 1, with X, Z ≥ 0 (for stable bound states)

Theoretical Framework

1. Basic Definition

Under completeness relations, the physical bound state |B⟩ can be decomposed as:

|B⟩ = ∫dp χ(p)|p⟩ + c|B₀⟩

Compositeness and fundamentalness are defined as:

X = ∫dp |⟨p|B⟩|² = ∫dp |χ(p)|²
Z = |⟨B₀|B⟩|² = |c|²

2. Different Formulations

Energy integral formulation:

X = 4π√(2μ³)g²ₜₕ ∫₀^∞ dE √E|F(E)|²/(E+B)²

Scattering amplitude formulation:

X = 4π√(2μ³) ∫₀^∞ dE √E/(E+B) [t(E) - v - 4π√(2μ³)∫₀^∞ dE' √E'|t(E')|²/(E-E'+i0⁺)]

Pole residue formulation:

X = -g²G'(E)|_{E=-B}

3. Effective Field Theory Framework

Employing non-relativistic effective field theory with contact interactions, the Hamiltonian is:

H = H₀ + V
H₀ = kinetic energy term + ω₀B₀†(r)B₀(r)
V = g₀(B₀†ψφ + φ†ψ†B₀) + v₀ψ†φ†φψ

Compositeness can be expressed as:

X = G'(E)/[G'(E) - [1/v(E)]'] |_{E=-B}

Technical Innovations

1. Model dependence analysis: Clearly distinguishes between model-dependent quantities (such as form factors F(E), matrix elements v) and model-independent observables (such as scattering amplitudes t(E), binding energies B)
2. Weakly bound relations: In the weakly bound limit B ≪ Eₜᵧₚ, the compositeness of s-wave bound states becomes model-independent:

a₀ = 2X/(X+1) R + O(Rₜᵧₚ)
rₑ = (X-1)/X R + O(Rₜᵧₚ)

3. Extension to unstable resonances: Through the introduction of Gamow vectors ⟨R̃| with generalized inner products, the compositeness concept becomes applicable to unstable resonances, though the results are complex-valued

Experimental Setup

Research Objects

The paper primarily analyzes the following physical systems:

1. Hadronic systems: Deuteron, f₀(980), a₀(980), Λ(1405), X(3872), Tcc
2. Nuclear systems: ³ΛH (hypernuclei)
3. Atomic systems: ⁴He dimers
4. Cold atomic systems: Molecular states in Bose gases

Analysis Methods

1. Scattering parameter analysis: Utilizing experimentally measured scattering lengths, effective ranges, and other low-energy parameters
2. Pole analysis: Extracting resonance pole information from theoretical models such as chiral perturbation theory
3. Spectral function integration: Computing compositeness through integration of spectral densities
4. Weakly bound relation application: Applying model-independent relations to near-threshold states

Evaluation Metrics

• Numerical values of compositeness X and their uncertainties
• Consistency checks among different interpretation schemes
• Agreement with experimental data

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Deuteron Compositeness

• Zero-range limit: X = 1.68⁺²·¹⁵₋₀.₈₃ (exceeding 1, indicating the need for finite-range corrections)
• Including finite-range corrections: 0.74 ≤ X ≤ 1, establishing the composite-dominated nature of the deuteron

2. Scalar Mesons

• f₀(980): KK̄ compositeness approximately 67%, exhibiting molecule-dominated characteristics
• a₀(980): Smaller KK̄ components, results dependent on specific analysis, requiring more precise experimental data

3. Λ(1405) Resonance

• K̄N compositeness in different chiral models: 82%-114% (|X| form)
• Weakly bound relations yield X = 1.2 + 0.1i, consistent with pole analysis
• Establishes the K̄N molecular picture of Λ(1405)

4. Exotic Hadrons

• X(3872): D⁰D̄*⁰ compositeness approximately 90-95%, showing molecule dominance
• Tcc: D⁰D*⁺ compositeness 67-84%, supporting the molecular picture

Important Findings

1. Universality verification: Weakly bound relations verified across different physical systems, from hadrons to atomic systems
2. Convergence of interpretation schemes: Different complex compositeness interpretation schemes yield consistent results for narrow resonances
3. Threshold effects: Near-threshold states universally exhibit high compositeness, consistent with low-energy universality expectations

Related Work

Historical Development

1. 1960s: Weinberg and others established the field renormalization constant criterion Z=0 for composite particles
2. Early 2000s: With the discovery of exotic hadrons, the compositeness concept regained attention
3. Recent developments: Extension to unstable resonances, coupled-channel cases, and effective field theory frameworks

Theoretical Methods

1. Spectral function method: Defining real compositeness through integration of spectral densities
2. Pole residue method: Computing compositeness using pole residues of scattering amplitudes
3. Effective field theory method: Systematic study of compositeness within the EFT framework
4. CDD zero method: Considering the effects of Castillejo-Dalitz-Dyson zeros

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Refined theoretical framework: Establishes a complete compositeness theoretical framework from stable bound states to unstable resonances
2. Model independence: In the weakly bound limit, the compositeness of s-wave bound states can be determined model-independently
3. Universal applicability: The compositeness concept successfully applies to multi-scale quantum systems including hadrons, atomic nuclei, and atoms
4. Experimental verification: Analysis of multiple physical systems supports theoretical expectations

Limitations

1. High partial wave limitation: Compositeness of ℓ≥1 bound states remains model-dependent
2. Unstable state interpretation: Multiple interpretation schemes exist for complex compositeness, with no experimental discrimination method
3. Fine-tuning problem: Theory cannot completely exclude the possibility of parameter fine-tuning breaking weakly bound relations
4. Experimental precision: Compositeness determination for certain systems (such as a₀(980)) is limited by experimental data precision

Future Directions

1. More precise experimental data: Particularly precision measurements of a₀(980), Tcc, and other states
2. Higher-order corrections: Systematic study of finite-range corrections, coupled-channel effects, etc.
3. New system applications: Extension to more exotic hadron candidates
4. Theoretical development: Further refinement of compositeness theory for unstable resonances

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong systematicity: Provides a complete picture of the compositeness concept from fundamental theory to practical applications
2. Mathematical rigor: Provides strict mathematical expressions under different frameworks including quantum mechanics and effective field theory
3. High practical value: Provides quantitative tools for exotic hadron structure research
4. Cross-disciplinary impact: Demonstrates universal applicability of the concept across different physics fields

Weaknesses

1. Unresolved complex interpretation: Physical interpretation of compositeness for unstable resonances remains controversial
2. Model dependence: Except for weakly bound s-wave cases, compositeness remains model-dependent
3. Limited experimental verification: Some theoretical predictions lack sufficiently precise experimental verification

Impact

1. Theoretical contribution: Provides important structural analysis tools for hadron physics
2. Experimental guidance: Provides theoretical basis for experimental search and confirmation of exotic hadrons
3. Methodological value: Establishes a unified framework for structural analysis of cross-scale quantum systems

Applicable Scenarios

1. Exotic hadron research: Particularly suitable for structural analysis of near-threshold resonances
2. Few-body physics: Applicable to various weakly bound quantum systems
3. Effective theory verification: Provides tools for testing low-energy effective theories
4. Experimental data interpretation: Helps understand results from scattering and spectroscopic experiments

References

The paper contains 147 references, covering the complete history of compositeness theory development, primarily including:

1. Weinberg's pioneering work (1963-1965)
2. Recent experimental discoveries of exotic hadrons
3. Development of chiral perturbation theory and effective field theory
4. Compositeness applications in different physical systems

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality review paper that systematically summarizes the development and application of the compositeness concept in modern hadron physics. The paper is theoretically rigorous, widely applicable, and provides important theoretical tools for understanding the internal structure of exotic hadrons. Although certain technical details remain to be refined, the theoretical framework established has been successfully applied to multiple physical systems and possesses significant academic value and practical significance.