Curvature effects on the regimes of the lateral van der Waals force

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2411.16717
• Title: Curvature effects on the regimes of the lateral van der Waals force
• Authors: Alexandre P. Costa, Lucas Queiroz, Danilo T. Alves
• Classification: quant-ph physics.class-ph
• Publication Date: November 22, 2024 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.16717

Abstract

Recent research has demonstrated that neutral anisotropic polarizable particles in vacuum, subject to lateral van der Waals forces generated by perfectly conducting corrugated planes, can be attracted not only to the nearest corrugation peak but also to corrugation valleys or intermediate points between peaks and valleys. These behaviors are respectively termed peak, valley, and intermediate regimes. This paper calculates the van der Waals interaction between polarizable particles and grounded conducting corrugated cylinders, and investigates how cylindrical curvature effects influence the emergence of these regimes.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Complexity of lateral van der Waals forces: Traditional research has primarily focused on vertical interactions between particles and planar surfaces, while lateral force studies remain relatively limited. Recent discoveries reveal that stable equilibrium positions of particles on corrugated surfaces may occur at peaks, valleys, or intermediate locations.
2. Importance of geometric effects: Existing research concentrates mainly on planar geometries, yet surfaces in practical applications often possess curvature. Understanding how curvature affects lateral van der Waals forces is crucial for nanomanipulation and surface engineering.
3. Challenges in theoretical calculations: Development of analytical calculation methods beyond the proximity force approximation (PFA) is necessary to accurately describe interactions under curved surface geometries.

Research Motivation

• Explore the influence of surface geometric properties on lateral van der Waals force regimes
• Develop theoretical frameworks for handling cylindrical corrugated surfaces
• Provide theoretical guidance for particle manipulation at the nanoscale

Core Contributions

1. Extension of theoretical methods: Generalization of Clinton et al.'s perturbative calculation method to cylindrical geometry, establishing Green's function solutions for point charges in the presence of grounded conducting corrugated cylinders.
2. Novel interaction formulas: Derivation of analytical expressions for van der Waals interactions between polarizable particles and corrugated cylinders.
3. Curvature effect analysis: Systematic investigation of how cylindrical curvature affects the emergence of peak, valley, and intermediate regimes, revealing that curvature generally suppresses the appearance of valley and intermediate regimes.
4. Discovery of directional dependence: Revelation of distinct mechanisms by which corrugation direction (along z-axis or φ-axis) influences curvature effects.

Detailed Methodology

Problem Definition

Investigation of van der Waals interactions between polarizable particles near grounded conducting corrugated cylinders, with particular focus on different equilibrium regimes generated by lateral forces and their dependence on surface curvature.

Theoretical Framework

1. Perturbative Green's Function Solution

For a cylinder of radius a with surface described by ρ = a + εh(φ,z), where h(φ,z) is the corrugation function and ε is the perturbation parameter, the Green's function is expanded as:

G(r,r') = G^(0)(r,r') + Σ(n=1 to ∞) ε^n G^(n)(r,r')

2. Boundary Condition Treatment

• Unperturbed solution G^(0) satisfies: G^(0)(r,r')|_{ρ=a} = 0
• Perturbative corrections G^(n) satisfy complex recursive boundary conditions

3. Solution in Cylindrical Coordinates

Utilizing separation of variables in cylindrical coordinates, the Green's function is expressed as a series of modified Bessel functions:

G^(0)(r,r') = 2Σ_j ∫(dk/2π) e^{ik(z-z')} e^{ij(φ-φ')} K_j(|k|ρ_>) 
              × [I_j(|k|ρ_<) - K_j(|k|ρ_<) I_j(|k|a)/K_j(|k|a)]

Van der Waals Interaction Calculation

Application of Eberlein-Zietal Formula

Van der Waals interaction is calculated through:

U_vdW(r_0) = (1/8πε_0) Σ_{i,j} ⟨d̂_i d̂_j⟩ ∇_i ∇'_j G_H(r,r')|_{r=r'=r_0}

where ⟨d̂_i d̂_j⟩ is the expectation value tensor of dipole moment operators.

Perturbative Expansion

The interaction energy is expanded as: U_vdW ≈ U_vdW^(0) + U_vdW^(1), where U_vdW^(1) contains information about lateral forces.

Technical Innovations

1. Geometric Generalization

• First generalization of perturbative theory for corrugated surfaces from planar to cylindrical geometry
• Development of mathematical methods for handling complex boundary conditions in cylindrical coordinates

2. Directional Analysis

• Distinction between corrugations along z-direction and φ-direction with different effects on interactions
• Revelation of coupling effects between curvature and corrugation direction

3. Regime Classification Theory

• Establishment of regime classification scheme based on phase function Δ:
  • Peak regime: Δ = π
  • Valley regime: Δ = 0
  • Intermediate regime: Δ ≠ 0,π

Experimental Setup

Model Parameters

• Cylinder radius: a = 0.5, 1.0, 2.0
• Particle distance: d = ρ - a (distance from cylinder surface)
• Corrugation parameters: amplitude δ, wave vector k_c = 2π/λ_c
• Particle anisotropy parameter: β = ⟨d̂_n^2⟩/⟨d̂_p^2⟩

Computational Methods

• Numerical integration for infinite series and integrals of modified Bessel functions
• Comparative analysis of results between cylindrical and planar geometries
• Investigation of particle orientation effects on interactions

Experimental Results

Main Findings

1. Curvature Effects for z-direction Corrugations

• Point charge case: Lateral forces consistently attract particles to corrugation peaks; curvature weakens interaction strength
• Valley regime: Curvature has minimal effect on valley regime emergence
• Intermediate regime: Curvature suppresses intermediate regime at short distances but enhances it at larger distances

2. Curvature Effects for φ-direction Corrugations

• Enhancement effect: Unlike z-direction, lateral forces from φ-direction corrugations are amplified by curvature
• Valley regime suppression: Curvature significantly suppresses valley regime emergence
• Structural coupling: Curvature directly affects the corrugation structure itself

3. Quantitative Results

• For z-direction corrugations: U_^(1)/U_^(1) → 1 when d ≪ a
• For φ-direction corrugations: Curvature effects are most pronounced at d ~ a
• Ratio relationships approach the planar limit as cylinder radius a increases

Regime Transition Analysis

Through phase function Δ calculations, findings reveal:

• Peak regime remains stable under all geometries
• Valley regime emergence requires specific particle orientations and distance conditions
• Intermediate regime is most sensitive to curvature and easily suppressed

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Classical van der Waals theory: Hamaker constant method and Lifshitz theory
2. Surface geometric effects: Clinton et al.'s planar corrugation theory
3. Lateral force research: Peak/valley/intermediate regimes discovered by Nogueira et al.

Contributions of This Work

• First consideration of curvature effects on lateral van der Waals force regimes
• Provision of exact theoretical framework beyond planar approximation
• Revelation of deep connections between geometry and physics

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Universal suppression effect of curvature: Surface curvature generally suppresses the appearance of valley and intermediate regimes, favoring the stability of peak regimes.
2. Directional dependence: Corrugation direction determines the specific manifestation of curvature effects:
   • z-direction corrugations: Relatively weak curvature effects
   • φ-direction corrugations: Strong coupling between curvature and corrugation structure
3. Distance scale effects: Curvature effects vanish when d ≪ a and are most pronounced when d ~ a.

Limitations

1. Perturbative approximation: Only first-order perturbative corrections considered; may lack precision for large-amplitude corrugations
2. Electrostatic approximation: Retardation effects of electromagnetic fields not considered
3. Specific geometry: Only cylindrical geometry investigated; other curved surface geometries remain unexplored

Future Directions

1. Higher-order corrections: Inclusion of higher-order perturbative terms for improved accuracy
2. Retardation effects: Consideration of complete Casimir-Polder interaction forms
3. Experimental verification: Design of experiments to validate theoretical predictions
4. Application exploration: Applications in nanomanipulation and surface engineering

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical rigor: Complete mathematical derivations with clear physical insights
2. Strong originality: First systematic investigation of curvature effects on lateral van der Waals forces
3. Universal methodology: Developed theoretical framework generalizable to other geometries
4. Rich results: Provides quantitative predictions and deep physical insights

Weaknesses

1. Computational complexity: Involves extensive special function calculations with limited practical applicability
2. Absence of experimental comparison: Lacks verification with experimental data
3. Limited application guidance: Practical applicability requires further development

Impact

1. Theoretical contribution: Provides new perspectives and tools for surface force theory
2. Application potential: Significant value in nanotechnology and surface science fields
3. Methodological value: Generalization of perturbative methods has universal significance

Applicable Scenarios

• Particle manipulation and assembly at nanoscale
• Force design in surface engineering
• Interaction studies in colloidal science
• Precision measurement techniques such as atomic force microscopy

References

1 E. C. M. Nogueira, L. Queiroz, and D. T. Alves, "Peak, valley, and intermediate regimes in the lateral van der Waals force," Phys. Rev. A 104, 012816 (2021).

2 W. L. Clinton, M. A. Esrick, and W. S. Sacks, "Image potential for nonplanar metal surfaces," Phys. Rev. B 31, 7540 (1985).

3 C. Eberlein and R. Zietal, "Force on a neutral atom near conducting microstructures," Phys. Rev. A 75, 032516 (2007).

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper making significant contributions at the intersection of van der Waals forces and surface science. The theoretical derivations are rigorous, results possess important physical significance, and it provides new theoretical tools for understanding and controlling surface interactions at the nanoscale.