Non-extensive Hard Thermal Loop Resummation and Its Applications: Analysis in Zero and Finite Magnetic Fields

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2411.17090
• Title: Non-extensive Hard Thermal Loop Resummation and Its Applications: Analysis in Zero and Finite Magnetic Fields
• Authors: He-Xia Zhang (Quanzhou Normal University), Yu-Xin Xiao (Central China Normal University)
• Classification: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology)
• Publication Date: December 31, 2024 (v2)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.17090

Abstract

This study investigates the effects of non-extensive statistics on hard thermal loop (HTL) resummation techniques, with analysis conducted in both zero and finite magnetic field conditions. Using non-extensive bare propagators within the real-time formalism of finite-temperature field theory, the authors determine the non-extensive deformations of single-loop HTL gluon self-energy and resummed gluon propagator. The research reveals that introducing non-extensivity leads to significant shifts in the Debye mass of retarded/advanced and symmetric gluon self-energies. Applying the non-extensive-corrected resummed gluon propagator to calculate the dielectric constant of the quark-gluon plasma (QGP), the authors subsequently derive the static heavy quark potential, which contains both short-range Yukawa interactions and long-range string interactions between heavy quarks and the QGP medium. The real part of the potential exhibits stronger screening effects as the non-extensive parameter q (q ≥ 1) increases, reducing the binding energy of heavy quarkonia. Furthermore, non-extensivity enhances the imaginary part of the potential, leading to increased decay widths of heavy quarkonia. Based on these observations, the melting temperatures of heavy quarkonia are estimated. Results demonstrate that non-extensivity lowers the melting temperature of heavy quarkonia, promoting their dissociation, while the presence of magnetic fields suppresses this dissociation.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Questions

This study aims to address how non-extensive statistical effects influence the properties of quantum chromodynamics (QCD) plasma in high-temperature, high-density strongly interacting matter, particularly the behavior of heavy quarkonia in such a medium.

Significance of the Problem

1. Experimental Relevance: Relativistic heavy-ion collision experiments (RHIC, LHC) provide compelling evidence for QGP existence; understanding its properties is crucial for both theory and experiment
2. Strong Magnetic Field Effects: Strong magnetic fields (eB ~ 5-70 m²π) generated in non-central heavy-ion collisions significantly affect QGP properties
3. Non-extensive Phenomena: Strong dynamical correlations, long-range color interactions, and microscopic memory effects observed in high-energy collisions require non-extensive statistics for description

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Standard HTL Theory: HTL resummation techniques based on standard quantum statistics have limitations in handling non-equilibrium and non-extensive effects
2. Magnetic Field Treatment: Existing theories insufficiently address non-extensive effects in magnetic fields
3. Heavy Quarkonium Properties: Systematic studies of non-extensive corrections to heavy quarkonium melting temperatures are lacking

Research Motivation

Incorporating Tsallis non-extensive statistics into the HTL resummation framework to systematically investigate the effects of non-extensive parameter q on QGP properties and heavy quarkonium behavior, providing theoretical foundations for understanding non-equilibrium phenomena in high-energy heavy-ion collisions.

Core Contributions

1. Established Non-extensive HTL Theoretical Framework: First systematic introduction of Tsallis non-extensive statistics into HTL resummation techniques, deriving non-extensive-corrected gluon self-energy and propagators
2. Revealed Non-extensive Corrections to Debye Mass: Discovered that non-extensivity causes retarded/advanced Debye mass to differ from symmetric Debye mass, breaking the equivalence relation in standard statistics
3. Computed Non-extensive Effects in Magnetic Fields: Systematically investigated the impact of Landau level quantization on non-extensive gluon self-energy, providing complete calculations in magnetic fields
4. Derived Non-extensive Heavy Quark Potential: Obtained complex heavy quark potential with non-extensive corrections, analyzing its effects on heavy quarkonium properties
5. Predicted Non-extensive Dependence of Melting Temperature: Found that non-extensivity lowers heavy quarkonium melting temperature, while magnetic fields raise it

Methodology Details

Theoretical Framework

The research is based on the real-time formalism of finite-temperature field theory, employing Keldysh representation to handle non-equilibrium systems.

Non-extensive Distribution Functions

For quarks/antiquarks and gluons, non-extensive distribution functions are defined as:

f±q,F(Ef) = 1/([expq(β(Ef ∓ μf))]q + 1)
fq,B(k) = 1/([expq(βE)]q - 1)

where expq(x) = 1 + (q-1)x^(1/(q-1)) is the non-extensive exponential function.

HTL Gluon Self-Energy Calculation

Zero Magnetic Field Case

Through single-loop diagram calculations, contributions to retarded gluon self-energy from quarks and gluons are obtained:

Πquark_R(Q) = (Nfg²/(2π)³) ∑b=± ∫ kdkf^b_q,F(k) dΩk/2 [(1-x²)/[x+(ω+iε)/q̃]² + (1-x²)/[-x+(ω+iε)/q̃]²]

Finite Magnetic Field Case

Considering Landau level quantization, the dispersion relation for light quarks becomes E^f_kz,n = √(k²z + 2n|efB|), leading to more complex gluon self-energy structure.

Resummed Propagator

Solving the Dyson-Schwinger equation for the resummed propagator:

G*R/A(K) = GR/A(K) + GR/A(K)ΠR/A(K)G*R/A(K)

Heavy Quark Potential Calculation

The heavy quark potential in the medium is obtained through convolution of the Cornell potential with the dielectric constant:

V(r) = ∫ d³q̃/(2π)^(3/2) (e^(iq̃·r) - 1)VCornell(q̃)ε^(-1)(q̃)

Experimental Setup

Parameter Settings

• Temperature range: T = 0.1-0.6 GeV
• Non-extensive parameter: q = 1.0-1.2
• Magnetic field strength: eB = 0, 15m²π
• Quark masses: mc = 1.275 GeV, mb = 4.66 GeV
• String tension: σ = 0.18 GeV²

Computational Methods

Numerical integration methods are employed to calculate various physical quantities, using Coulomb gauge to simplify calculations.

Experimental Results

Non-extensive Corrections to Debye Mass

At zero chemical potential, the correction to retarded/advanced Debye mass is:

m̃²D,R/m²D = 1 + (21ζ(3)/π² - 2)(q-1)

The correction to symmetric Debye mass is:

m̃²D,F/m²D = 1 + (42ζ(3)/π² - 3)(q-1)

Behavior of Heavy Quark Potential

1. Real Part: Exhibits stronger screening effects as q increases
2. Imaginary Part: Amplitude increases with q, indicating increased decay width
3. Magnetic Field Effects: Magnetic fields enhance screening effects, but non-extensive effects are more significant

Heavy Quarkonium Properties

Melting Temperature Results

Major Findings

1. Non-extensivity significantly lowers heavy quarkonium melting temperature
2. Magnetic fields raise melting temperature, suppressing dissociation
3. Non-extensive effects become more pronounced at large separation distances
4. Anisotropy of the imaginary potential becomes important in magnetic fields

Related Work

HTL Theory Development

• HTL resummation techniques developed by Braaten and Pisarski represent the standard method for treating infrared divergences in finite-temperature QCD
• Recent extensions to anisotropic and viscous effects

Non-extensive Statistics Applications

• Successful applications of Tsallis statistics in high-energy physics for transverse momentum spectrum fitting
• Research on fluid mechanics, thermodynamics, and transport coefficients

QCD in Magnetic Fields

• Effects of strong magnetic fields on QCD phase transitions and transport properties
• Corrections to gluon self-energy from Landau level quantization

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Systematicity of Non-extensive Corrections: Non-extensive statistics produces systematic corrections across all aspects of HTL theory
2. Splitting of Debye Mass: Non-extensivity breaks the equivalence between retarded and symmetric Debye masses
3. Promotion of Heavy Quarkonium Dissociation: Non-extensive effects promote heavy quarkonium dissociation at lower temperatures
4. Protective Role of Magnetic Fields: Magnetic fields suppress heavy quarkonium dissociation by enhancing screening effects

Limitations

1. Small Deviation Approximation: Calculations only consider linear terms in (q-1)
2. Static Approximation: Heavy quark potential calculations employ static limit
3. Gauge Choice: Coulomb gauge is used; though physical results are gauge-independent
4. Phenomenological Parameters: The specific value of non-extensive parameter q requires experimental determination

Future Directions

1. Extension to higher-order (q-1) corrections
2. Investigation of dynamic heavy quark potential
3. Consideration of finite chemical potential effects
4. Quantitative comparison with experimental data

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Completeness: Systematic introduction of non-extensive statistics into HTL framework with rigorous theoretical derivations
2. Comprehensive Calculations: Simultaneous consideration of zero and finite magnetic field cases with detailed computations
3. Physical Insights: Reveals deep impacts of non-extensivity on QGP properties
4. Practical Value: Provides theoretical tools for understanding non-equilibrium phenomena in heavy-ion collisions

Weaknesses

1. Parameter Dependence: Determination of non-extensive parameter q lacks first-principles foundation
2. Approximation Limitations: Small deviation approximation may underestimate non-extensive effects
3. Experimental Verification: Lacks direct comparison with latest experimental data
4. Computational Complexity: Calculations in magnetic fields are extremely complex, potentially containing numerical errors

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides important foundation for non-extensive QCD theory
2. Experimental Guidance: Offers theoretical predictions for heavy quarkonium studies in heavy-ion collision experiments
3. Methodological Innovation: Established computational framework applicable to other non-equilibrium systems
4. Interdisciplinary Value: Non-extensive statistical methods generalizable to other fields

Applicable Scenarios

1. Heavy-Ion Collision Physics: Understanding non-equilibrium properties of QGP
2. Astrophysics: Plasma behavior in strong magnetic field environments
3. Condensed Matter Physics: Applications of non-extensive statistics to other quantum many-body systems
4. Theoretical Physics: Non-equilibrium extensions of finite-temperature field theory

References

The paper cites 92 important references covering core works in HTL theory, non-extensive statistics, QCD in magnetic fields, and heavy quark physics, providing solid theoretical foundations for the research.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that systematically investigates applications of non-extensive statistics in high-temperature QCD. The theoretical derivations are rigorous, calculations are comprehensive, and the physical picture is clear, providing important theoretical tools for understanding non-equilibrium phenomena in heavy-ion collisions. Despite certain approximations and parameter dependencies, its theoretical contributions and practical value are significant.