Circular orbits and thin accretion disk around a quantum corrected black hole

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2412.05670
• Title: Circular orbits and thin accretion disk around a quantum corrected black hole
• Authors: Yu-Heng Shu, Jia-Hui Huang (School of Physics, South China Normal University)
• Classification: gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology)
• Publication Date: December 16, 2024 (arXiv v2)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.05670

Abstract

This paper first investigates the shadow radius of a recently proposed quantum-corrected black hole and provides constraints on the correction parameter based on observational data from Sagittarius A*. Subsequently, it discusses the effects of the correction parameter on the energy, angular momentum, and angular velocity of particles in circular orbits within the accretion disk. The study reveals that the correction parameter significantly influences the angular momentum of particles on circular orbits, even in regions far from the black hole. The value of the correction parameter may be identified through observations of particle angular momentum in the disk. It is found that the radius of the innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO) increases with the correction parameter, while the radiation efficiency of the black hole decreases. Finally, the paper examines how the correction parameter affects the emission and observed radiation flux of thin accretion disks around black holes, and determines polynomial fitting functions for the relationship between three typical radiation flux maxima and the correction parameter.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Spacetime Singularity Problem: General relativity predicts the existence of spacetime singularities surrounded by event horizons in black holes, but singularities may lead to deep theoretical difficulties, such as the black hole information paradox.
2. Quantum Gravity Corrections: To address the singularity problem, researchers employ various methods to modify Einstein's general relativity, including string theory, loop quantum gravity, and others.
3. Hamiltonian Constraint Formulation: A particular method for modifying general relativity has recently resolved the issue of maintaining general covariance in spherically symmetric vacuum gravity.

Research Motivation

1. Verification of New Black Hole Models: The recently proposed quantum-corrected spherically symmetric black hole requires verification through multi-faceted studies of its physical properties.
2. Observational Constraints: Observations from the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) and similar instruments provide opportunities to constrain quantum correction parameters.
3. Accretion Disk Physics: Accretion disks serve as important tools for studying black hole properties and testing gravitational theories, with their electromagnetic spectra useful for determining central black hole characteristics.

Core Contributions

1. Shadow Constraints: Based on M87* observational data, new constraints on the quantum correction parameter ξ are provided: 0 ≤ ξ ≲ 2.304 (1σ), which are more stringent than constraints based on Sgr A*.
2. Orbital Dynamics Analysis: A systematic study of the effects of the correction parameter on particle energy, angular momentum, and angular velocity in circular orbits, revealing that angular momentum remains significantly affected even in the far-field region.
3. ISCO Characteristics: The variation of ISCO radius with the correction parameter is determined, and corresponding changes in radiation efficiency are calculated.
4. Radiation Flux Modeling: The effects of the correction parameter on thin accretion disk radiation flux are investigated, and polynomial fitting relationships are established.

Methodology Details

Quantum-Corrected Black Hole Metric

The quantum-corrected black hole metric employed in this study is:

ds² = -f(r)dt² + 1/f(r)dr² + r²(dθ² + sin²θdφ²)

where:

f(r) = (1 - 2M/r)(1 + ξ²/r²(1 - 2M/r))

M is the black hole mass, and ξ is the quantum correction parameter.

Shadow Radius Calculation

• Photon Ring Radius: Determined through the equation rω'(r) = ω(r), where ω(r) = √f(r)
• Shadow Radius: Rsh = rph/√f(rph) = 27/√(27 + ξ²)

Particle Orbit Analysis

Particle motion is studied on the equatorial plane (θ = π/2):

1. Lagrangian:

L = 1/2 m(-f(r)ṫ² + ṙ²/f(r) + r²φ̇²)

2. Conserved Quantities:

• Energy: E = mf(r)ṫ
• Angular Momentum: L = mr²φ̇

3. Effective Potential:

Veff = 1/2 f(r)(L²/r² + 1)

4. Circular Orbit Conditions:

• Veff(r) = 1/2 E²
• ∂rVeff(r) = 0

ISCO Determination

The ISCO radius RI satisfies the additional condition: ∂²rVeff = 0, yielding the equation:

r⁶(r-6) + 3ξ²r³(r²-8r+12) - 2ξ⁴(r-2)²(2r²-13r+24) = 0

Radiation Flux Calculation

1. Emission Flux:

F = -Ṁ/(4π√(-g/gθθ)) × (Ω,r/(E-ΩL)²) × ∫[RI to r](E-ΩL)L,rdr

2. Observed Flux:

Fobs = F/(1+z)⁴

where (1+z) is the redshift factor.

Experimental Setup

Observational Data Constraints

• M87*: θsh = (42±3)μas, D = (16.8±0.8)Mpc, M = (6.5±0.7)×10⁹M☉
• Sgr A*: θsh = (48.7±7.0)μas, D = 8kpc, M = (4.0+1.1-0.6)×10⁶M☉

Fitting Functions

Three types of fitting functions are compared:

1. Exponential Function: F = a₁e^(-(ξ-a₂)/a₃)² + a₄e^(-(ξ-a₅)/a₆)²
2. Fourier Function: F = b₁ + b₂cos(b₃ξ) + b₄sin(b₅ξ)
3. Polynomial Function: F = c₁ξ⁶ + c₂ξ⁵ + c₃ξ⁴ + c₄ξ³ + c₅ξ² + c₆ξ + c₇

Experimental Results

Shadow Constraint Results

Based on M87* data, shadow radius constraints are obtained: 4.75 ≲ Rsh ≲ 6.25, yielding correction parameter constraints: 0 ≤ ξ ≲ 2.304 (1σ), which are more stringent than Sgr A* constraints (ξ ≲ 2.866).

Orbital Characteristics Analysis

1. ISCO Radius: Increases monotonically with ξ, showing significant deviation from the Schwarzschild case when ξ > 1
2. Radiation Efficiency: Decreases with increasing ξ
   • ξ = 0: ε = 5.7191%
   • ξ = 2.304: ε = 5.36199%

Angular Momentum Effects

• Energy E and angular velocity Ω exhibit asymptotic behavior independent of ξ in the far field
• Angular momentum L remains significantly dependent on ξ even in the far field
• This provides the possibility of identifying the value of ξ through observations of angular momentum distribution

Radiation Flux Results

1. Flux Peaks: The correction parameter significantly affects radiation flux peaks
2. Fitting Accuracy: Polynomial function fitting yields the best results with minimal mean square error
3. Directional Dependence: The degree to which flux is affected by ξ differs for different observation directions (α = π/2, 3π/2)

Related Work

Quantum-Corrected Black Hole Research

• Quasinormal mode studies 11-18
• Relationship between greybody factors and quasinormal modes 19
• Shadow and photon ring characteristics 20-23
• EHT observational constraints 18,24 and gravitational wave constraints 25
• Strong gravitational lensing effects 26-28

Thin Accretion Disk Models

• Classical Shakura-Sunyaev model 29
• Page-Thorne model 30,31
• Applications in modified gravity theories 32-39

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Observational Constraints: M87* data provides effective constraints on the quantum correction parameter
2. Orbital Effects: The correction parameter significantly affects particle angular momentum, providing avenues for observational identification
3. ISCO Characteristics: Increasing the correction parameter leads to increased ISCO radius and decreased radiation efficiency
4. Radiation Features: Quantitative relationships between radiation flux peaks and the correction parameter are established

Limitations

1. Parameter Range: The study primarily focuses on ξ values satisfying observational constraints
2. Thin Disk Approximation: Employs a geometrically thin disk model, which may not apply to all accretion scenarios
3. Observation Angle: Primarily considers specific observation angles, without comprehensively exploring angular dependence

Future Directions

1. Multi-wavelength Observations: Combining observational data from different wavelengths to further constrain parameters
2. Thick Disk Models: Extension to geometrically thick disks or other accretion models
3. Dynamical Evolution: Investigation of temporal evolution and variability effects

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Systematic Study: Comprehensive analysis from shadow, orbital dynamics to radiation flux
2. Observational Integration: Effective utilization of EHT observational data to provide practical constraints
3. Numerical Precision: Detailed numerical calculations and comparisons of multiple fitting functions
4. Physical Insights: Discovery of far-field angular momentum effects provides new avenues for observational identification

Weaknesses

1. Theoretical Foundation: Relatively brief discussion of the physical origins of quantum-corrected black holes
2. Observational Verification: Lack of direct comparison with actual observational data
3. Error Analysis: Insufficient discussion of uncertainties in numerical calculations and fitting
4. Applicability Range: Insufficient discussion of model applicability conditions and limitations

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides important observational testing methods for quantum-corrected black hole research
2. Practical Value: Established fitting relationships assist in future observational data analysis
3. Reproducibility: Methods and results demonstrate good reproducibility
4. Interdisciplinary Significance: Bridges theoretical physics and observational astrophysics

Application Scenarios

1. Theoretical Verification: Observational testing of quantum gravity theories
2. Data Analysis: Theoretical interpretation of high-resolution observations from EHT and similar instruments
3. Parameter Estimation: Observational determination of black hole physical parameters
4. Model Comparison: Observational discrimination between different black hole models

References

The paper cites 63 relevant references covering important works in black hole physics, quantum gravity, observational astrophysics, and other fields, providing a solid theoretical and observational foundation for the research.