Ultralight axion or axion-like particle dark matter and 21-cm absorption signals in new physics

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2412.06213
• Title: Ultralight axion or axion-like particle dark matter and 21-cm absorption signals in new physics
• Author: C. R. Das (The Bogoliubov Laboratory of Theoretical Physics, Joint Institute for Nuclear Research, Dubna, Russia)
• Classification: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology)
• Publication Date: December 2024 (arXiv v2: October 16, 2025)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.06213v2

Abstract

This paper investigates how ultralight axions or axion-like particles (ALPs) as dark matter candidates can explain anomalies in 21-cm absorption signals. The author proposes that ultralight axion dark matter with mass approximately 10^-22 eV may be the source of the intense 21-cm absorption features observed during the cosmic "dark ages." The signal can be explained through two mechanisms: anomalous baryon cooling or anomalous cosmic microwave background photon heating. When ALPs thermalize and form a Bose-Einstein condensate, cold dark matter ALPs enter thermal contact with baryons and cool them. Simultaneously, under the influence of primordial black holes and/or interstellar magnetic fields, ALPs can resonantly convert into photons, significantly heating radiation in the frequency bands relevant to 21-cm observations.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Issues

1. The nature of dark matter: Despite extensive experimental verification of dark matter's existence, its exact nature remains elusive
2. WIMP search dilemma: The search for weakly interacting massive particles (WIMPs) has yielded no substantial discoveries
3. 21-cm signal anomalies: The EDGES collaboration observed anomalously low baryon temperatures during the cosmic dawn epoch
4. Strong CP problem: A long-standing theoretical challenge in particle physics

Research Significance

• Axions can both solve the strong CP problem and serve as a compelling dark matter candidate
• The 21-cm hydrogen line is the only means to probe the cosmic "dark ages"
• Early galaxies are larger, brighter, and more numerous than predicted by WIMP models

Limitations of Existing Approaches

• Traditional WIMP models cannot explain early cosmic structure formation
• Standard cosmological models struggle to explain the anomalously deep absorption signals observed by EDGES
• Lack of a unified theoretical framework explaining both 21-cm signal anomalies and dark matter properties

Core Contributions

1. Proposes a dual-mechanism ALP model: Establishes a theoretical framework for ALPs affecting 21-cm signals through both baryon cooling and photon heating mechanisms
2. Establishes thermal equilibrium conditions: Derives the thermal equilibrium relationship between baryon cooling and CMB photon heating
3. Resolves excess effective neutrino number problem: Demonstrates that heating effects can eliminate the theoretically excess effective neutrino species ΔNeff produced by cooling effects
4. Predicts observable effects: Provides specific parameter constraints and testing schemes for future axion experiments and CMB observations

Methodology Details

Task Definition

To investigate how ultralight ALPs with mass approximately 10^-22 eV affect 21-cm cosmological signals through baryon cooling and photon conversion mechanisms in the redshift range z=200-20, and to establish corresponding theoretical models.

Theoretical Framework

1. Baryon Cooling Mechanism

ALP-induced cooling occurs because coherent amplification enhances scattering energy loss, resulting in hydrogen/baryon cooling. The total cooling rate is:

Γbaryon cooling ≃ 4πGmanala(EH/Δp)

Where:

• ma, na, la are the ALP mass, number density, and correlation length respectively
• EH and Δp are the energy and momentum dispersion terms of hydrogen
• Correlation length la ∼ t1(a(t)/a(t1))

2. ALP-to-Photon Conversion Mechanism

The ALP-to-photon conversion rate in magnetic fields:

Γa→γ (CMB heating) ≃ -ln[1-(πrg²aB²⊥Ea/m²a)] × 4√(Ear/ma)|z=zres

Where:

• ga is the ALP-photon coupling strength
• B⊥ is the magnetic field strength perpendicular to the ALP momentum direction
• Ea is the ALP energy passing through the non-zero magnetic field region

3. Thermal Equilibrium Condition

The thermal equilibrium rate between baryon cooling and CMB photon heating:

|Γbaryon cooling ⇌ Γa→γ (CMB heating)|thermal equilibrium (z = 200 ⟺ 20)

Technical Innovations

1. Coherent amplification mechanism: Utilizes the coherent properties of ALPs to amplify scattering energy loss, achieving effective baryon cooling
2. Resonant conversion theory: Achieves resonant ALP-to-photon conversion when plasma frequency ω²p equals m²a
3. Thermal equilibrium analysis: Establishes dynamic balance between cooling and heating processes to explain observed phenomena
4. Bose-Einstein condensate: Considers collective behavior characteristics of ALPs after BEC formation

Experimental Setup

Observational Data

• EDGES observations: Anomalously deep 21-cm absorption signals during cosmic dawn
• Baryon acoustic oscillations: Consistent with theoretical predictions of ALP baryon cooling
• CMB observations: Cosmic microwave background temperature and polarization data

Parameter Ranges

• ALP mass: ma ∼ 10^-22 eV
• Redshift range: z = 200-20
• Magnetic field strength: Primordial interstellar magnetic field ≳10^-17 G, primordial black hole magnetic field ∼10^-20-10^-15 G
• ALP-photon coupling: ga = (several times)×10^-12 GeV^-1

Theoretical Constraints

• Resonant redshift: zres ≲ 2000 (to avoid bremsstrahlung absorption)
• Conversion probability: Pa→γ(Ea) ≈ 10^-10 (EDGES frequency band)
• Effective neutrino number: ΔNeff ∼ 4 (excess produced by cooling effects)

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Effective Neutrino Species Calculation

Standard model predicts Neff = 3.044, but considering ALP contributions:

ρrad = ργ[1 + 1/2 + 3.044 × (7/8) × (4/11)^(4/3) × 3/2]

Produces approximately Neff ≈ 7, roughly double the standard prediction.

2. Thermal Equilibrium Eliminates Excess

Through ALP-to-photon conversion heating effects, the theoretical excess ΔNeff ∼ 4 produced by cooling effects can be eliminated.

3. Conversion Probability Constraints

An extremely low conversion probability Pa→γ(Ea) ≈ 10^-10 in the EDGES frequency band is required to explain the observed anomalies.

4. Energy Fraction Relations

The ALP radiation energy fraction in the EDGES band f^(EDGES)_a = 0.4, requiring an O(1) increase in photon energy density in that frequency band.

Physical Mechanism Verification

1. Cooling mechanism: Cooling process begins when Γcooling(t)/H(t) ∼ 1, occurring at redshift 200 > z > 20
2. Heating mechanism: Resonant conversion occurs around the matter-radiation equality epoch; ALP mass should be in the range ma ∼ 10^-22 eV
3. Thermalization process: ALPs thermalize and form BEC at approximately 500 eV photon temperature

Related Work

Axion Dark Matter Research

• QCD axions initially proposed to solve the strong CP problem (Peccei-Quinn, 1977)
• Axions as dark matter candidates (Ipser & Sikivie, 1983)
• Theoretical development of ultralight dark matter (Marsh, 2016; Hui et al., 2017)

21-cm Cosmology

• Cosmological significance of hydrogen atom spin-flip transitions
• Important observational results from the EDGES collaboration (Bowman et al., 2018)
• Research on anomalous 21-cm signal explanations

ALP Phenomenology

• Experimental searches for ALP-photon coupling
• ALP signals in astrophysical environments
• ALP predictions in string theory models

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Unified explanatory framework: Ultralight ALP dark matter can explain 21-cm absorption signal anomalies through dual cooling and heating mechanisms
2. Parameter constraints: ALP mass ma ∼ 10^-22 eV and extremely low conversion probability are key parameters
3. Cosmological consistency: The model is consistent with baryon acoustic oscillation observations
4. New physics predictions: Provides specific parameter targets and observational strategies for future experiments

Limitations

1. Theoretical complexity: Requires precise numerical simulations to verify thermal equilibrium processes
2. Parameter fine-tuning: Requires specific ranges of ALP mass and coupling strength
3. Magnetic field dependence: Conversion mechanism strongly depends on the nature and strength of primordial magnetic fields
4. Observational verification: Requires more independent observational data to confirm theoretical predictions

Future Directions

1. Experimental verification: Improved sensitivity of axion experiments such as IAXO and ADMX
2. CMB observations: Improved constraints from future CMB experiments like PIXIE and PRISM
3. 21-cm observations: Detection of the dark ages by projects such as DAPPER and FARSIDE
4. Theoretical development: More complete numerical simulations and multi-field coupling models

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Innovative theory: Proposes a novel theoretical framework for ALP dual mechanisms, providing a unified explanation for multiple cosmological anomalies
2. Mathematical rigor: Clear derivation process, accurate formula expression, and explicit physical picture
3. Observational connection: Closely integrated with actual observational data such as EDGES, with strong phenomenological motivation
4. Predictive power: Provides specific parameter targets and testing schemes for future experiments

Weaknesses

1. Model complexity: Involves coupling of multiple physical processes, increasing theoretical complexity and uncertainty
2. Parameter dependence: Strict requirements on ALP mass, magnetic field strength, and other parameters may limit model universality
3. Numerical verification: Lacks detailed numerical simulations to verify the self-consistency of thermal equilibrium processes
4. Competing models: Insufficient discussion of alternative theoretical schemes for explaining 21-cm anomalies

Impact

1. Interdisciplinary connection: Bridges multiple fields including particle physics, cosmology, and astrophysics
2. Experimental guidance: Provides important theoretical guidance for axion search experiments and cosmological observations
3. Theoretical advancement: Promotes theoretical research in ultralight dark matter and early universe physics
4. Technical applications: May facilitate development of related detection technologies and analysis methods

Applicable Scenarios

1. Early universe research: Applicable to physics research during the cosmic dark ages and cosmic dawn epochs
2. Dark matter detection: Provides theoretical foundation for experimental searches for ultralight dark matter
3. 21-cm cosmology: Guides observation and data analysis of 21-cm signals
4. New physics searches: Provides testing pathways for new physics phenomena beyond the Standard Model

References

This paper cites 43 important references covering recent advances in axion theory, dark matter research, 21-cm cosmology, and related experiments, providing a solid foundation for theoretical construction.

Overall Assessment: This is an important research paper at the intersection of theoretical physics and cosmology. The author's proposed dual-mechanism ALP model provides a novel theoretical framework for explaining 21-cm signal anomalies. Although the model is relatively complex, it is closely integrated with observational data and possesses strong predictive power and experimental guidance value. This work advances the development of ultralight dark matter theory and provides clear targets for future experimental verification.