Gauge-invariant scalar and vector operators in the $SU(2)\times U(1)$ Higgs model: Ward identities and renormalization

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2412.09406
• Title: Gauge-invariant scalar and vector operators in the $SU(2)\times U(1)$ Higgs model: Ward identities and renormalization
• Author: Giovani Peruzzo (Institute of Physics, Federal Fluminense University, Brazil)
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory), hep-lat (Lattice Field Theory)
• Publication Date: December 2024
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.09406

Abstract

This paper investigates the renormalization of gauge-invariant composite operators in the $SU(2)\times U(1)$ Higgs model from the perspective of gauge invariance. The author employs algebraic renormalization methods to establish relationships between counterterms and derives a complete set of Ward identities for the model with these composite operators. Through these Ward identities, important exact relationships between correlation functions of fundamental and composite fields are established.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Core Problem: When quantizing gauge field theories in continuous spacetime, one must choose a gauge fixing, while physical observables should be independent of the gauge condition. Traditional approaches rely on gauge-dependent fundamental field correlation functions to extract physical information, which is a non-trivial task.
2. Importance of the Problem:
   • The Faddeev-Popov method fails in the non-perturbative regime due to Gribov-Singer copies
   • Gauge-dependent correlation functions may contain non-physical thresholds and even violate the positivity of the Källén-Lehmann spectral representation
   • The electroweak interaction part of the Standard Model requires a gauge-invariant description framework
3. Limitations of Existing Methods:
   • Difficulty in physical interpretation of gauge-dependent correlation functions
   • Nielsen identities only partially resolve gauge dependence
   • Complex treatment of nonlinear gauges (e.g., maximal Abelian gauge)
4. Research Motivation:
   • Establish a completely gauge-invariant theoretical framework
   • Ensure positivity of correlation functions
   • Provide a comparison basis for lattice simulations and continuum theory
   • Lay foundations for Standard Model extensions

Core Contributions

1. Established a complete renormalization theory for gauge-invariant operators in the $SU(2)\times U(1)$ Higgs model
2. Derived a complete system of Ward identities including composite operators, with three new Ward identities
3. Proved exact relationships between fundamental and composite field correlation functions
4. Determined the algebraic structure of all counterterms and renormalization factors
5. Established exact results for anomalous dimensions of gauge-invariant operators

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Study the renormalization of gauge-invariant composite operators $\{O, O_\mu, O_\mu^3, O_\mu^\alpha\}$ in the $SU(2)\times U(1)$ Higgs model, where:

• $O(\phi) = \phi^\dagger\phi - \frac{\vartheta^2}{2}$ (scalar operator)
• $O_\mu(\phi) = \frac{1}{2i}(\phi^\dagger D_\mu\phi - (D_\mu\phi)^\dagger\phi)$ (vector operator)
• $O_\mu^3(\Phi), O_\mu^\alpha(\Phi)$ ('t Hooft-type operators)

Model Architecture

1. Higgs Action

S_Higgs = ∫d⁴x [1/4 W^a_μν W^a_μν + 1/4 X_μν X_μν + (D_μφ)†D_μφ + λ(φ†φ - ϑ²/2)²]

where the covariant derivative is:

D_μφ = ∂_μφ - ig(τ^a/2)W^a_μφ - (1/2)ig'X_μφ

2. Construction of Gauge-Invariant Operators

Using $U(1)$ gauge-invariant scalar operators:

Φ(x) = exp(-ig'/2 ∫d⁴y (1/∂²)_{x,y} (∂_μX^μ)(y)) φ(x)

Localization is achieved through introduction of auxiliary Stueckelberg field $\xi(x)$:

∂²ξ = ∂_μX^μ
Φ(x) = e^{-ig'ξ(x)/2} φ(x)

3. BRST Structure

Define BRST operator $S$:

Sη = iθ, Sθ = 0, SX_μ = 0, Sξ = -η, Sη̄ = 0

satisfying nilpotency: $S² = 0$

Technical Innovations

1. Systematic Application of Stueckelberg Field Method: Localization of non-local operators $\Phi$ through introduction of auxiliary field $\xi$ while maintaining BRST invariance
2. Partial Recovery of Local $SU(2)$ Symmetry: Through introduction of sources $\Upsilon^a_μ$ and term $S_Υ$, partial recovery of local $SU(2)$ gauge symmetry is achieved
3. Algebraic Renormalization Method: Systematic application of Ward identities to constrain counterterm structure, avoiding dependence on specific regularization schemes

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Framework Setup

• Gauge Choice: Landau gauge ($\partial_μW^a_μ = 0, \partial_μX_μ = 0$)
• Renormalization Scheme: Algebraic renormalization method based on Ward identities
• Field Expansion: Expansion around the minimum of the Higgs potential $\vartheta$

Comparison Methods

• Traditional fundamental field renormalization
• Background field method
• Standard composite operator renormalization

Main Results

Ward Identity System

1. BRST Slavnov-Taylor Identities

S₁(Σ) = 0  (U(1) BRST)
S₂(Σ) = 0  (SU(2) BRST)

2. New Ward Identities

$X_μ$ Field Equation of Motion:

δΣ/δX_μ + g'δΣ/δΩ_μ + (g'/2)Ω_μ δΣ/δJ = linear breaking terms

Integrated H Equation:

∫d⁴x (δΣ/δH - 2λϑδΣ/δJ) - ∂Σ/∂ϑ = linear breaking terms

$U_{EM}(1)$ Symmetry:

ŴΣ = linear breaking terms

Renormalization Results

1. Renormalization Factors

Main renormalization factors include:

Z_{WW}^{1/2} = 1 + ε(a₀ - 2b₁)/2
Z_g = 1 - εa₀/2  
Z_{g'}^{-1} = 1 + εa₁/2
Z_λ = 1 + εa₃/λ

2. Non-Renormalization Theorem

Z_c Z_{WW}^{1/2} Z_g = 1

3. Anomalous Dimension Results

The anomalous dimension of the current operator $O_μ$ is zero:

γ_{O_μO_μ} = μ d(log Z₀₀)/dμ = 0

Exact Relationships

1. Correlation Function Relations

g'²⟨O_μ(x)O_ν(y)⟩ = (∂⁴)ₓ⟨X_μ(x)X_ν(y)⟩ + (∂²δ_μν - ∂_μ∂_ν)ₓδ⁴(x-y)
                    + (g'²/2)δ_μνδ⁴(x-y)(⟨O(x)⟩ + ϑ²/2)

2. Transversality Property

∂_μ∂_ν/∂²⟨O_μ(x)O_ν(y)⟩ = (1/2)(⟨O(x)⟩ + ϑ²/2)

The longitudinal part is constant with no propagating modes.

Related Work

Historical Development

1. $U(1)$ and $SU(2)$ Higgs Models: Author's previous work 3-7 established gauge-invariant frameworks for these models
2. Algebraic Renormalization: Classical method of Piguet and Sorella 2
3. 't Hooft Operators: Applications in different contexts 35,7

Relationship to Existing Work

• Extends $U(1)$ and $SU(2)$ cases to electroweak unification theory
• Natural connection with lattice gauge theory
• Lays foundations for gauge-invariant description of the Standard Model

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Complete Renormalization Theory: Established a complete renormalization framework for gauge-invariant operators in the $SU(2)\times U(1)$ Higgs model
2. Power of Ward Identities: Ward identities determine relationships between all counterterms and renormalization factors
3. Exact Non-Perturbative Results: Certain correlation function relationships hold at all orders
4. Physical Consistency: Ensures positivity of the Källén-Lehmann representation

Limitations

1. Gauge Choice Dependence: Some results are specific to Landau gauge
2. Perturbative Framework: Primarily works within perturbative theory
3. Gribov Problem: Does not completely resolve Gribov copy issues in the non-perturbative regime
4. Missing Fermions: Does not yet include the fermionic sector of the Standard Model

Future Directions

1. Inclusion of Fermions: Extension to the complete Standard Model
2. Non-Perturbative Methods: Combination with lattice simulations and other non-perturbative approaches
3. Dark Matter Extensions: Framework for physics beyond the Standard Model
4. One-Loop Verification: Explicit one-loop calculations for verification

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Completeness: Provides a systematic and complete theoretical framework with all Ward identities and renormalization structures rigorously derived
2. Mathematical Rigor: Application of algebraic renormalization method is highly rigorous, avoiding dependence on specific regularization schemes
3. Physical Insights: Reveals deep connections between gauge-invariant operators and fundamental fields, particularly in the Higgs mechanism context
4. Technical Innovation: The localization method for Stueckelberg fields and partial recovery of local symmetry techniques are of general applicability

Weaknesses

1. Computational Complexity: Counterterm structure is extremely complex with 28 independent counterterms, making practical calculations difficult
2. Limited Practical Applicability: Primarily theoretical construction lacking concrete numerical results and physical predictions
3. Restricted Scope: Strongly dependent on Landau gauge and perturbative expansion
4. Insufficient Verification: Lacks explicit one-loop calculations to verify theoretical predictions

Impact and Significance

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides important theoretical tools for gauge-invariant description of gauge field theories
2. Standard Model Research: Offers new perspectives for deeper understanding of electroweak theory
3. Lattice Research: Provides continuum theory reference benchmarks for lattice simulations
4. Future Development: Lays foundations for physics research beyond the Standard Model

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Research: Fundamental theoretical research in gauge field theory
2. Lattice Simulations: Reference for continuum theory
3. Standard Model Extensions: Construction of new physics models
4. Teaching and Research: Instruction in gauge invariance and renormalization theory

References

The paper cites 59 important references, primarily including:

• 1 Author's previous work on $SU(2)\times U(1)$
• 2 Classical work on algebraic renormalization by Piguet & Sorella
• 3-7 Author's series of works on $U(1)$ and $SU(2)$ Higgs models
• 8,9 Original papers by Higgs and Englert-Brout
• 21 Important work on BRST invariance by Kugo-Ojima

This paper is of significant importance in the field of gauge field theory in theoretical physics. It provides a complete mathematical framework for gauge-invariant description of the Higgs model. While highly technical, it establishes a solid foundation for future theoretical development and practical applications.