Abrupt changes in the spectra of the Laplacian with constant complex magnetic field

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2412.17419
• Title: Abrupt changes in the spectra of the Laplacian with constant complex magnetic field
• Authors: David Krejčiřík, Tho Nguyen Duc, Nicolas Raymond
• Classification: math.SP (Spectral Theory), math-ph (Mathematical Physics), math.AP (Analysis of PDEs), math.MP (Mathematical Physics), quant-ph (Quantum Physics)
• Publication Date: December 23, 2024
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.17419

Abstract

This paper analyzes the spectrum of the Laplacian operator on the plane subject to a uniform complex magnetic field. For real magnetic fields, it is well-known that the spectrum consists of infinitely degenerate isolated eigenvalues (Landau levels). We prove that when the magnetic field has a nonzero imaginary part, the spectrum extends to cover the entire complex plane. Furthermore, we demonstrate that Landau levels (embedded in the complex plane after appropriate rotation) persist, unless the magnetic field is purely imaginary, in which case they vanish and the spectrum becomes purely continuous.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

The core problem addressed in this research is understanding the spectral properties of the magnetic Laplacian operator under complex magnetic fields. Traditionally, research on the magnetic Laplacian has focused on the real magnetic field case:

1. Classical Results: For real magnetic field $b \in \mathbb{R}$, the spectrum of the magnetic Laplacian $L_b = (-i∇-A)^2$ consists of Landau levels, namely infinitely degenerate isolated eigenvalues
2. Physical Significance: Landau levels play a fundamental role in describing magnetic phenomena such as the quantum Hall effect

Research Motivation

Recent research on complex magnetic fields has gained new physical motivation:

• Superconductivity theory
• Quantum statistical physics
• Stability of black holes in general relativity
• New concepts of quasi-self-adjointness in quantum theory

Technical Challenges

The complex magnetic field case presents unprecedented mathematical challenges:

1. Non-self-adjointness: Complex magnetic fields cause the operator to lose self-adjointness
2. Technical Difficulties: Problems arising from unbounded vector potentials
3. Lack of Standard Tools: Traditional methods such as the Lax-Milgram theorem no longer apply

Core Contributions

1. Established a rigorous mathematical framework for the magnetic Laplacian with complex magnetic fields: Overcame technical difficulties of non-self-adjoint operators through an innovative "weak core method"
2. Completely characterized the spectral structure under complex magnetic fields: Proved the phenomenon of abrupt spectral changes
3. Discovered classification theorems for the spectrum:
   • When $b \in \mathbb{C} \setminus (\mathbb{R} \cup i\mathbb{R})$, the spectrum is the entire complex plane
   • When $b \in i\mathbb{R}\setminus\{0\}$, the spectrum is the entire complex plane but with no point spectrum
4. Revealed the persistence and vanishing mechanisms of Landau levels: Rotation of complex Landau levels in the complex plane and conditions for their disappearance

Detailed Methodology

Problem Formulation

Study the magnetic Laplacian operator: $L_b = (-i∂_{x_1})^2 + (-i∂_{x_2} - bx_1)^2$ where $b \in \mathbb{C}$ is the complex magnetic field strength, acting on $L^2(\mathbb{R}^2)$.

Core Technical Innovations

1. Weak Core Method

Innovation: Addressing the problem that $C_c^∞(\mathbb{R}^2)$ is no longer dense for complex magnetic fields, a weak core method is proposed.

Theorem 2.1: For any $\psi \in \text{Dom}(L_b)$, there exists a sequence $(\psi_n) \subset C_c^∞(\mathbb{R}^2)$ such that:

• $\psi_n \to \psi$ strongly in $L^2(\mathbb{R}^2)$
• $L_b\psi_n \to L_b\psi$ weakly in $L^2(\mathbb{R}^2)$

Proof Strategy:

1. Construct cutoff functions $\chi_n$ and mollifiers $\rho_n$
2. Define $\psi_n = \chi_n(\rho_n * \psi)$
3. Handle each term in $L_b\psi_n - L_b\psi = I_n + J_n + K_n$ through refined analysis

2. Complex Self-Adjointness

Proposition 1.1: $L_b$ is a closed densely defined operator whose adjoint is: $L_b^* = L_{\overline{b}} = CL_bC^{-1}$ where $C$ is the conjugation operator: $(C\psi)(x_1,x_2) = \psi(-x_1,x_2)$.

Spectral Analysis Methods

1. Spectral Reducibility

Proposition 2.2: Through scaling, symmetry, and reflection symmetry, the analysis can be reduced to the first quadrant arc of the unit circle.

2. Weyl Sequence Construction

For $b = e^{i\theta}$, $\theta \in (0,\frac{\pi}{2})$, construct Weyl sequences: $\Psi_n(x,\xi_2) = \mathbf{1}_{[n-1,n+1]}(\xi_2)\varphi_\theta\left(\frac{x}{\xi_2}\right)u(x,\xi_2)$ where: $u(x,\xi_2) = e^{-\frac{1}{4}Z^2(x,\xi_2)}Z(x,\xi_2)^{\frac{\lambda}{2b}-\frac{1}{2}}$$Z(x,\xi_2) = \sqrt{2b}\left(x-\frac{\xi_2}{b}\right)$

Key Estimates:

• Proposition 3.1: $\|\Psi_n\|^2 \gtrsim n^{\text{Re}(\frac{\lambda}{b})-1}e^{\frac{\sin^2\theta}{\cos\theta}(n-1)^2}$
• Proposition 3.2: $\lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{\|(L̂_b-\lambda)\Psi_n\|^2}{\|\Psi_n\|^2} = 0$

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Verification Methods

This paper employs rigorous mathematical proof methods, primarily through:

1. Analytical Verification: Construction of explicit Weyl sequences and eigenfunctions
2. Asymptotic Analysis: Using Laplace's method to analyze asymptotic behavior of integrals
3. Functional Analysis Techniques: Utilizing Fourier transforms and operator theory

Key Technical Tools

• Partial Fourier transform: $F_{x_2\to\xi_2}$
• Hermite function theory
• Principal value selection in complex analysis
• Asymptotic expansion of incomplete Gamma functions

Main Results

Core Theorem

Theorem 1.2: (i) When $b \in \mathbb{C} \setminus (\mathbb{R} \cup i\mathbb{R})$: $\text{Spec}(L_b) = \mathbb{C}, \quad \text{Spec}_c(L_b) = \mathbb{C} \setminus \Lambda_b, \quad \text{Spec}_p(L_b) = \Lambda_b$

(ii) When $b \in i\mathbb{R}\setminus\{0\}$: $\text{Spec}(L_b) = \mathbb{C}, \quad \text{Spec}_c(L_b) = \mathbb{C}, \quad \text{Spec}_p(L_b) = \emptyset$

where the complex Landau levels are defined as: $\Lambda_b = \{\pm(2k+1)b : k \in \mathbb{N}_0\} \text{ when } \pm\text{Re }b > 0$

Key Findings

1. Abrupt Changes in the Spectrum

• Real Magnetic Field: Spectrum is discrete Landau levels
• Complex Magnetic Field (neither real nor purely imaginary): Spectrum extends to the entire complex plane, but Landau levels persist as point spectrum
• Purely Imaginary Magnetic Field: Spectrum is the entire complex plane, Landau levels completely vanish

2. Properties of Complex Landau Levels

Proposition 3.5: When $b = e^{i\theta}$, $\theta \in (0,\frac{\pi}{2})$, we have $\text{Spec}_p(\hat{L}_b) \subset \Lambda_b$

Lemma 3.4: The function family $(h_{k\ell})_{(k,\ell)\in\mathbb{N}_0^2}$ is complete in $L^2(\mathbb{R}^2)$, where: $h_{k\ell}(x,\xi_2) = \psi_k\left(\sqrt{b}\left(x-\frac{\xi_2}{b}\right)\right)\psi_\ell\left(\frac{\xi_2}{\sqrt{\cos\theta}}\right)$

3. Specificity of the Purely Imaginary Case

For $b = i$, through gauge transformation we obtain: $\hat{L}_i = 2(i\xi_1 + \xi_2)\partial_{\xi_1} + \xi_1^2 + \xi_2^2 + i$

It is proved that no $L^2$ eigenfunctions exist, yet the spectrum remains the entire complex plane.

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Landau (1930): First discovered the quantized spectrum under real magnetic fields
2. Classical Magnetic Laplacian Theory: Foundational work by Avron-Herbst-Simon, Cycon-Froese-Kirsch-Simon, and others
3. Early Exploration of Complex Magnetic Fields: Authors' previous work 11,12 considered local complex magnetic fields

Uniqueness of This Work

• First systematic study of the constant complex magnetic field case
• Discovery of the abrupt spectral change phenomenon
• Establishment of a complete theory of non-self-adjoint magnetic Laplacian operators

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Complex Magnetic Fields Cause Abrupt Spectral Changes: From discrete spectrum to continuous spectrum over the entire complex plane
2. Persistence and Vanishing of Landau Levels: Rotation in the complex plane but vanishing in the purely imaginary case
3. Specificity of Purely Real or Purely Imaginary Magnetic Fields: The only cases with purely continuous spectrum

Limitations

1. Gauge Dependence: Results hold for the specific vector potential choice $A(x) = b(0,x_1)$
2. Technical Constraints: Some proofs depend on specific geometric configurations
3. Physical Interpretation: Physical realization of complex magnetic fields requires further investigation

Future Directions

1. Study spectral properties under other gauge choices
2. Explore practical applications of complex magnetic fields in physics
3. Generalize to higher-dimensional cases

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong Theoretical Innovation: The weak core method is an important technical innovation for handling non-self-adjoint operators
2. High Completeness of Results: Complete characterization of spectral structure in all cases
3. Mathematical Rigor: Refined proof techniques that address all technical difficulties arising from complex magnetic fields
4. Deep Physical Significance: Reveals the fundamental impact of magnetic field complexification on quantum systems

Weaknesses

1. Limited Application Scope: Results depend on specific gauge choices
2. Computational Complexity: Construction of Weyl sequences is relatively complex
3. Physical Realizability: The actual physical realization mechanism of complex magnetic fields requires further clarification

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new tools for spectral theory of non-self-adjoint operators
2. Interdisciplinary Value: Connects mathematical physics, operator theory, and quantum mechanics
3. Inspirational: Opens new research directions for complex magnetic field physics

Applicable Scenarios

• Non-Hermitian quantum systems in theoretical physics
• Theoretical research on superconductors and topological materials
• Spectral theory research in mathematical physics
• Development of quasi-self-adjoint operator theory

References

This paper cites 17 important references, including:

• Landau's pioneering work 14
• Classical magnetic Laplacian theory 2,6,9,15,16
• Authors' previous work on complex magnetic fields 11,12
• Standard textbooks on spectral theory 8,13

Technical Highlights: Through the innovative weak core method, this paper overcomes technical difficulties in the complex magnetic field case, provides the first complete characterization of the spectral structure of the magnetic Laplacian under constant complex magnetic fields, discovers the phenomenon of abrupt spectral changes, and makes important contributions to non-self-adjoint operator theory and complex magnetic field physics.