Crosscap Quenches and Entanglement Evolution

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2412.18610
• Title: Crosscap Quenches and Entanglement Evolution
• Authors: Zixia Wei (Harvard University), Yasushi Yoneta (RIKEN)
• Classification: hep-th, cond-mat.stat-mech, quant-ph
• Publication Date: October 14, 2025 (arXiv v3)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.18610

Abstract

Understanding how complex correlations emerge in the dynamics of quantum many-body systems remains a fundamental challenge in modern physics. To address this problem, quench dynamics starting from non-thermal states have been extensively studied with significant progress. This paper proposes a novel quench protocol called "crosscap quenches" to investigate how highly structured thermal pure states relax to typical states. The paper first analyzes conformal field theories (CFTs) and derives universal features of entanglement entropy time evolution. It further employs AdS/CFT duality to study holographic CFTs, providing analytically solvable examples for chaotic CFTs. Finally, these findings are verified through numerical simulations of non-integrable and integrable quantum spin systems.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problems

1. Thermalization mechanisms in quantum many-body systems: Understanding how quantum many-body systems evolve from highly ordered initial states to thermal equilibrium, particularly the generation mechanisms of complex correlation structures
2. Relaxation processes of special initial states: Investigating how initial states that are already in thermal equilibrium but possess special entanglement structures evolve toward more typical thermal states

Significance

• Quantum quench dynamics provides an important window into understanding non-equilibrium statistical physics
• Entanglement entropy, as a key measure of quantum correlations, reveals the hierarchical structure of systems evolving from microscopic thermal equilibrium to typical thermalization
• Possesses important applications in quantum information processing and quantum simulation

Limitations of Existing Methods

• Traditional quench studies primarily focus on processes from non-thermal initial states to thermalization
• Lack systematic investigation of initial states already in thermal equilibrium but with special structures
• Need effective probes capable of distinguishing different levels of thermal equilibrium states

Research Innovation

Proposes the crosscap quench as a novel quantum quench protocol, utilizing entanglement entropy as a probe to investigate the relaxation dynamics of thermal pure states.

Core Contributions

1. Proposes crosscap quench protocol: First systematic study of quantum quench dynamics starting from crosscap/EAP states
2. Establishes CFT theoretical framework: Derives universal behavior of entanglement entropy evolution in conformal field theory, discovering that single intervals maintain thermal equilibrium while antipodal intervals exhibit non-trivial evolution
3. Holographic duality analysis: Employs AdS/CFT duality to provide analytically solvable examples for chaotic systems, computing holographic entanglement entropy via RT/HRT formulas
4. Numerical verification: Validates theoretical predictions in non-integrable and integrable spin chains, revealing the impact of integrability on relaxation dynamics
5. Universal findings: Demonstrates that the entanglement evolution patterns exhibited by crosscap quenches possess universality across different systems

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigates the time evolution of entanglement entropy during quantum quench processes starting from special thermal pure states (crosscap/EAP states), with input being the initial crosscap state and output being the evolution curves of entanglement entropy for different subsystems over time.

Theoretical Framework

Crosscap states in CFT

In two-dimensional CFT, crosscap states are realized through Euclidean path integrals on Möbius strips, satisfying the constraint:

(Ln - (-1)^n L̄_{-n})|C⟩ = 0, (n = 0,1,2,...)

Entanglement Rényi entropy calculation

Using the replica trick, the entanglement Rényi entropy of subsystem A is:

S_A^(n) = 1/(1-n) log(Z_{Σn}/(Z_{Σ1})^n)

where Z_{Σn} is the partition function on the n-fold replica manifold.

Twist operator correlation functions

Computed through twist operator correlation functions on the Klein bottle:

S_A^(n) = 1/(1-n) log⟨σn(0,0)σ̃n(0,l)⟩_{K2}

Holographic Calculation

Using AdS₃/CFT₂ duality, the gravitational dual of crosscap quench is the RP² geon geometry. The RT/HRT formula is applied to compute holographic entanglement entropy, with the key challenge being handling homological constraints on non-orientable manifolds.

Numerical Methods

Constructing EAP states in lattice spin systems:

|EAP⟩ = ⊗_{j=1}^N |Φ⟩_{j,j+N}

where |Φ⟩_{j,j+N} is the maximally entangled state of antipodal spin pairs, with time evolution studied through exact diagonalization.

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Calculations

1. CFT universal behavior: Computing entanglement entropy for single intervals and antipodal intervals in the thermodynamic limit α/L≪1
2. Holographic duality: Computing holographic entanglement entropy of geon geometry in AdS₃/CFT₂

Numerical Simulations

1. Non-integrable system: Heisenberg chain with next-nearest-neighbor interactions

   H = Σ_j (σ^x_j σ^x_{j+1} + σ^y_j σ^y_{j+1} + σ^z_j σ^z_{j+1}) + J Σ_j (σ^x_j σ^x_{j+2} + σ^y_j σ^y_{j+2} + σ^z_j σ^z_{j+2})
   

   
   at quantum critical point J = 0.241167, central charge c = 1
2. Integrable system: Transverse field Ising chain

   H = -Σ_j σ^z_j σ^z_{j+1} - g Σ_j σ^x_j
   

   
   at quantum critical point g = 1, central charge c = 1/2

Evaluation Metrics

• Time evolution of entanglement entropy S_A
• Comparison between single intervals and antipodal intervals
• Deviation analysis from thermodynamic entropy

Experimental Results

CFT Universal Behavior

Initial entanglement structure

1. Single interval: Exhibits volume-law entanglement, with entanglement entropy

   S_A = (c/3)log[4α/(πε)sinh(πl/4α)]
   

   
   showing thermal spectrum in the high-temperature limit, corresponding to inverse temperature β = 4α
2. Antipodal intervals: Exhibits area-law entanglement

   S_A = (c/3)(1+1/n)log[4α/(πε)]
   

Time Evolution

1. Single interval: Maintains thermal equilibrium during quench, with entanglement entropy unchanged over time
2. Antipodal intervals: Exhibits non-trivial evolution
   • Initial stage: Area-law entanglement
   • Intermediate stage: Linear growth S_A ~ πct/(6α)
   • Late stage: Saturation to volume-law thermal spectrum

Holographic Results

Holographic calculations fully agree with CFT universal predictions:

• Single interval entanglement entropy remains constant
• Antipodal intervals exhibit transition from area-law to volume-law, with linear growth in the intermediate stage

Numerical Verification

Non-integrable system

• Antipodal interval entanglement entropy exhibits linear growth and saturation to thermodynamic value l log 2
• Deviation from thermodynamic entropy is sub-extensive, scaling as N⁰ in the thermodynamic limit

Integrable system

• Small subsystem behavior similar to non-integrable case
• Large subsystems (l ~ N) exhibit oscillations with incomplete thermalization
• Deviation from maximum entanglement is extensive, significantly larger than non-integrable case

Related Work

Quantum Quench Theory

• CFT quench theory framework established by Calabrese-Cardy and others
• Boundary state quench research provides analogy for crosscap quenches

EAP States and Thermal Pure States

• Microscopic thermal equilibrium (MITE) theory
• Thermal pure states represented by tensor networks

Holographic Entanglement Entropy

• Applications of RT/HRT formulas in AdS/CFT
• Holographic duality of geon geometries and non-orientable manifolds

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Universal evolution pattern: Crosscap quenches exhibit universal entanglement evolution patterns, with single intervals maintaining thermal equilibrium while antipodal intervals undergo transition from area-law to volume-law
2. Hierarchical thermal equilibrium: Reveals hierarchical structure from microscopic thermal equilibrium to few-body thermalization
3. Impact of integrability: Integrability significantly affects relaxation behavior of large subsystems, leading to incomplete thermalization

Limitations

1. CFT approximation: Theoretical analysis primarily conducted within CFT framework with limited consideration of finite-size effects
2. Numerical scale: Constrained by exact diagonalization, system sizes are relatively small
3. Specific geometry: Primarily considers specific subsystem geometries in one-dimensional systems

Future Directions

1. Extension to larger system sizes and more complex geometries
2. Investigation of other types of structured thermal states
3. Exploration of experimental implementation in quantum simulation

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Conceptual innovation: First systematic study of crosscap quenches, opening new directions for quench theory
2. Multiple verifications: Consistency verification through CFT theory, holographic duality, and numerical simulations enhances result reliability
3. Universal findings: Discovered evolution patterns demonstrate universality across different systems
4. Technical depth: Skillfully combines CFT, holographic theory, and numerical methods

Weaknesses

1. Experimental feasibility: Lacks discussion of practical experimental implementation
2. Finite-size analysis: Analysis of finite-size effects is insufficient
3. Higher-dimensional generalization: Primarily limited to one-dimensional systems with unclear higher-dimensional extensions

Impact

• Provides new research paradigm for non-equilibrium dynamics of quantum many-body systems
• Deepens understanding of different levels of thermal equilibrium states
• Offers theoretical guidance for quantum information and quantum simulation

Applicable Scenarios

• Cold atom quantum simulation experiments
• Quantum annealing and quantum computing
• Non-equilibrium dynamics research in strongly correlated electron systems

References

The paper cites 34 important references covering classical works in quantum quench theory, CFT, holographic duality, integrable systems and other fields, providing solid theoretical foundation for the research.