2025-11-25T12:55:16.468133

Orbital stability of smooth solitary waves for the modified Camassa-Holm equation

Deng, Lafortune, Liu
In this paper, we explore the orbital stability of smooth solitary wave solutions to the modified Camassa-Holm equation with cubic nonlinearity. These solutions, which exist on a nonzero constant background $k$, are unique up to translation for each permissible value of $k$ and wave speed. By leveraging the Hamiltonian nature of the modified Camassa-Holm equation and employing three conserved functionals-comprising an energy and two Casimirs, we establish orbital stability through an analysis of the Vakhitov-Kolokolov condition. This stability pertains to perturbations of the momentum variable in $H^1(\mathbb{R})$.
academic

Orbital stability of smooth solitary waves for the modified Camassa-Holm equation

Basic Information

  • Paper ID: 2412.19342
  • Title: Orbital stability of smooth solitary waves for the modified Camassa-Holm equation
  • Authors: Xijun Deng (Hubei University of Automotive Technology), Stéphane Lafortune (College of Charleston), Zhisu Liu (China University of Geosciences)
  • Classification: math.AP (Mathematical Analysis), nlin.SI (Nonlinear Integrable Systems)
  • Submission Date: December 31, 2024
  • Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.19342

Abstract

This paper investigates the orbital stability of smooth solitary wave solutions for the modified Camassa-Holm equation with cubic nonlinearity. These solutions exist on a nonzero constant background kk and are unique up to translation for each admissible value of kk and wave speed. By exploiting the Hamiltonian structure of the modified Camassa-Holm equation and three conserved functionals (including one energy and two Casimirs), the authors establish orbital stability through analysis of the Vakhitov-Kolokolov condition. This stability applies to perturbations of the momentum variable in H1(R)H^1(\mathbb{R}).

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

The modified Camassa-Holm (mCH) equation is an important integrable partial differential equation: mt+((u2−ux2)m)x=0,m=u−uxxm_t + ((u^2 - u_x^2)m)_x = 0, \quad m = u - u_{xx}

This equation possesses the following important characteristics:

  1. Integrability: Admits a bi-Hamiltonian structure and Lax pair
  2. Physical Significance: Can be derived from two-dimensional Euler equations, where uu represents fluid velocity
  3. Geometric Significance: Arises from intrinsic invariant planar curve flows in Euclidean geometry

Research Motivation

  1. Theoretical Completeness: Although the stability of peakons for the mCH equation has been studied, the stability theory for smooth solitary waves remains incomplete
  2. Technical Challenges: Due to the cubic nonlinearity, the classical Grillakis-Shatah-Strauss framework is difficult to apply directly
  3. Methodological Innovation: New analytical techniques are needed to handle smooth solutions on nonzero backgrounds

Limitations of Existing Methods

  • Classical GSS theory encounters difficulties when handling cubic nonlinearity
  • The integrands of conserved functionals are quartic terms, increasing analytical complexity
  • Smooth traveling wave solutions do not exist under zero boundary conditions

Core Contributions

  1. Existence and Uniqueness: Proves existence and uniqueness of smooth solitary wave solutions on nonzero background k∈(c/3,3c/3)k \in (\sqrt{c/3}, \sqrt{3c/3})
  2. Variational Characterization: Establishes variational characterization of solitary waves as critical points of the action functional
  3. Conservation Law Verification: Rigorously proves conservation of two Casimir invariants F2F_2 and F3F_3
  4. Stability Theory: Establishes complete orbital stability theory via the Vakhitov-Kolokolov condition
  5. Analytical Verification: Provides analytical proof of stability conditions

Methodology Details

Problem Formulation

Studies the orbital stability of smooth solitary wave solutions m(t,x)=μ(x−ct)m(t,x) = \mu(x-ct) of the mCH equation on nonzero background k>0k > 0, where solutions belong to the function space: Xk:={m−k∈H1(R):m(x)>0,x∈R}X_k := \{m-k \in H^1(\mathbb{R}) : m(x) > 0, x \in \mathbb{R}\}

Theoretical Framework

1. Construction of Conserved Functionals

Three conserved functionals are constructed:

  • Momentum Conservation: F1(m)=∫R(m−k)dxF_1(m) = \int_{\mathbb{R}} (m-k) dx
  • First Casimir: F2(m)=∫R(1m−1k)dxF_2(m) = \int_{\mathbb{R}} \left(\frac{1}{m} - \frac{1}{k}\right) dx
  • Second Casimir: F3(m)=∫R(mx2m5+14m3−14k3)dxF_3(m) = \int_{\mathbb{R}} \left(\frac{m_x^2}{m^5} + \frac{1}{4m^3} - \frac{1}{4k^3}\right) dx

2. Hamiltonian Structure

The equation can be written in Hamiltonian form: mt=JδF1δmm_t = J\frac{\delta F_1}{\delta m} where JJ is a nonlocal Hamiltonian operator.

3. Variational Characterization

Solitary waves are critical points of the action functional: Λ(m):=F3(m)+ω1F1(m)+ω2F2(m)\Lambda(m) := F_3(m) + \omega_1 F_1(m) + \omega_2 F_2(m) where the Lagrange multipliers are: ω1=c−9k24k4(c−k2),ω2=−c+3k22k2(c−k2)\omega_1 = \frac{c-9k^2}{4k^4(c-k^2)}, \quad \omega_2 = -\frac{c+3k^2}{2k^2(c-k^2)}

Technical Innovations

1. Phase Plane Analysis

By transforming the traveling wave equation into a two-dimensional dynamical system:

\phi_\xi = \psi \\ (c + \psi^2 - \phi^2)\psi_\xi = \phi(c + \psi^2 - \phi^2) - a \end{cases}$$ Homoclinic orbit theory is used to prove existence of smooth solutions. #### 2. Casimir Verification Two methods are employed to verify conservation: - Direct computation of time derivatives - Proof that they are Casimirs of the Hamiltonian operator #### 3. Spectral Analysis Analysis of spectral properties of the Hessian operator $L = \frac{\delta^2\Lambda}{\delta^2 m}$: - One simple negative eigenvalue - One simple zero eigenvalue (corresponding to translational symmetry) - Positive essential spectrum ## Experimental Setup ### Theoretical Verification Framework This paper is primarily theoretical analysis, with results verified through the following steps: 1. **Existence Proof**: Utilizes phase plane analysis and elliptic function theory 2. **Uniqueness Proof**: Achieved through parameter range restrictions 3. **Stability Conditions**: Verification of the Vakhitov-Kolokolov condition ### Parameter Ranges - Wave speed: $c > 0$ - Background parameter: $k \in (\sqrt{c/3}, \sqrt{3c/3})$ - Solution amplitude: $k < \phi(\xi) \leq \sqrt{2(c-k^2)} - k$ ## Experimental Results ### Main Results **Theorem 1.1** (Main Result): For fixed $c > 0$ and $k \in (\sqrt{c/3}, \sqrt{3c/3})$, there exists a unique smooth solitary wave $m(t,x) = \mu(x-ct)$ that is orbitally stable in the space $X_k$. #### Key Technical Results 1. **Existence** (Lemma 3.1): Smooth solitary waves exist if and only if $k \in (\sqrt{c/3}, \sqrt{3c/3})$ 2. **Variational Characterization** (Lemma 3.2): Solitary waves are critical points of the action functional $\Lambda$ 3. **Spectral Properties** (Proposition 3.1): The Hessian operator possesses the correct spectral structure 4. **Stability Conditions** (Lemmas 4.2, 4.3): The Vakhitov-Kolokolov condition is always satisfied ### Key Inequality Verification Through complex integral transformations, the stability criterion is proven: $$\frac{d}{dk}Q(\phi,k) = \frac{-8c}{k(c-k^2)}\sqrt{\frac{c-3k^2}{c-k^2}} < 0$$ ### Analytical Expressions Explicit integral representations and important scaling relations are obtained: $$3a\mu_a + 4E\mu_E + 2c\mu_c = \mu$$ ## Related Work ### Historical Development 1. **Camassa-Holm Equation**: Classical integrable shallow water wave equation 2. **Degasperis-Procesi Equation**: Another important peakon equation 3. **b-Family Equations**: Unified framework containing CH and DP equations 4. **Novikov Equation**: Integrable equation with cubic nonlinearity ### Stability Theory - **GSS Theory**: Classical framework for solitary wave stability - **Energy-Casimir Method**: Effective method for handling degenerate cases - **Vakhitov-Kolokolov Condition**: Key criterion for stability ### Innovations of This Work Compared to existing work, this paper is the first to: 1. Address smooth solutions on nonzero backgrounds for the mCH equation 2. Completely verify stability in the cubic nonlinearity case 3. Provide analytical proof of stability conditions ## Conclusions and Discussion ### Main Conclusions 1. **Completeness**: Establishes complete stability theory for smooth solitary waves of the mCH equation 2. **Technical Breakthrough**: Overcomes technical difficulties posed by cubic nonlinearity 3. **Method Generality**: The methods employed can be generalized to other integrable equations ### Limitations 1. **Parameter Restrictions**: Stability holds only within specific parameter ranges 2. **Background Requirements**: Requires nonzero background; cannot handle zero background cases 3. **Smoothness Requirements**: Applies only to smooth solutions, excluding peakon solutions ### Future Directions 1. **Generalization**: Extension to other integrable equations 2. **Numerical Verification**: Validation of theoretical results through numerical simulations 3. **Applications**: Investigation of applications in fluid mechanics ## In-Depth Evaluation ### Strengths 1. **Theoretical Rigor**: Complete and rigorous mathematical proofs 2. **Methodological Innovation**: Clever combination of multiple analytical techniques 3. **Result Completeness**: Complete theory from existence to stability 4. **Technical Depth**: Addresses challenging technical problems ### Weaknesses 1. **Limited Applications**: Primarily theoretical results; practical applications require further investigation 2. **Parameter Restrictions**: Relatively small stability region 3. **Computational Complexity**: Some computational procedures are quite involved ### Impact 1. **Theoretical Contribution**: Makes important contributions to stability theory of integrable systems 2. **Methodological Value**: Provides effective methods for addressing similar problems 3. **Foundation for Future Research**: Establishes foundation for further research in related fields ### Applicable Scenarios 1. **Theoretical Research**: Integrable systems and solitary wave theory 2. **Applied Mathematics**: Stability analysis of nonlinear wave equations 3. **Physical Applications**: Wave phenomena in fluid mechanics and plasma physics ## References The paper cites 63 related references, covering: - Classical literature on integrable systems theory - Important works on solitary wave stability - Literature on related mathematical analysis techniques - Recent advances in the field --- **Overall Assessment**: This is a high-quality theoretical mathematics paper that makes important contributions to the stability theory of the modified Camassa-Holm equation. The authors employ sophisticated mathematical analysis techniques to establish a complete theoretical framework, providing an important theoretical foundation for the development of this field.