Magnon-Phonon Coupling in Layered Antiferromagnet

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2412.19526
• Title: Magnon-Phonon Coupling in Layered Antiferromagnet
• Authors: Somsubhra Ghosh, Mainak Palit, Sujan Maity, and Subhadeep Datta
• Institution: School of Physical Sciences, Indian Association for the Cultivation of Science, Kolkata, India
• Classification: cond-mat.mes-hall cond-mat.mtrl-sci
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.19526

Abstract

This paper presents a fully analytical model to explain the magnon-phonon hybridization phenomenon observed in van der Waals (vdW) antiferromagnets through magnetic field Raman scattering experiments. Using FePS₃ as the representative material, the study demonstrates that it is a quasi-2D Ising antiferromagnet, with spin-phonon coupling features appearing in the Raman spectrum below the Néel temperature of approximately 120K. Through magnetic field Raman spectroscopy as an optical probe of magnetic structure, a Raman-active mode with frequency 3.7 THz (approximately 122 cm⁻¹) is identified as a magnon in the magnetically ordered state. Furthermore, one magnon band and three phonon bands are coupled through magnetoelastic coupling, manifesting as anticrossing phenomena in the complete spectrum.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Questions

1. Theoretical modeling of magnon-phonon interactions: How to establish an analytical theoretical model of magnon-phonon hybridization in 2D antiferromagnets
2. Theoretical explanation of experimental phenomena: How to explain the anticrossing phenomena observed in magnetic field Raman spectra of FePS₃
3. Magnetoelastic coupling mechanisms: Understanding the coupling mechanism between spin waves and lattice vibrations in 2D magnetic materials

Significance

1. Fundamental physics importance: Magnon-phonon coupling is key to understanding relaxation processes in magnetic insulators, particularly below the magnetic transition temperature
2. Technological application prospects:
   • Spin-caloritronics
   • Topological magnonics
   • Magnon spintronics devices
3. Thermal transport characteristics: The contribution of magnons to thermal conductivity at low temperatures (K_magnon ~ T²) exceeds that of phonons (K_phonon ~ T³)

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Lack of complete analytical models for magnon-phonon hybridization in 2D vdW antiferromagnets
2. Existing theories struggle to quantitatively explain experimentally observed anticrossing phenomena
3. Insufficient understanding of the microscopic mechanisms of magnetoelastic coupling

Advantages of FePS₃ Material

1. Stability of transition temperature in the atomic layer limit (T_N ~ 120K)
2. Relatively high magnon transition temperature in few-layer materials (T_M ~ 60K in trilayers)
3. Higher magnon frequencies compared to conventional antiferromagnetic insulators (~3.7 THz)
4. Excellent air stability (over 6 months)

Core Contributions

1. Established a fully analytical magnon-phonon hybridization theoretical model capable of quantitatively explaining the anticrossing phenomena observed in FePS₃
2. Proposed an effective magnetoelastic coupling Hamiltonian considering in-plane nearest-neighbor exchange coupling and perpendicular magnetic anisotropy
3. Obtained band structures through exact diagonalization methods, successfully predicting avoided crossings between magnon-phonon branches
4. Established quantitative correspondence between experimental parameters and theoretical models, determining key physical parameters
5. Provided magnetic point group symmetry analysis explaining the polarization characteristics of Raman scattering for different magnon branches

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Establish a theoretical model for magnon-phonon coupling in FePS₃ antiferromagnet, explain the energy band anticrossing phenomena observed in magnetic field Raman spectra, and predict the magnetoelastic properties of the system.

Model Architecture

1. Magnetic Hamiltonian

Considering an effective model on a honeycomb lattice with in-plane nearest-neighbor exchange coupling and z-axis anisotropy:

H_mag = -J∑(S_r·S_{r+δ₁} + S_r·S_{r+δ₂} - S_r·S_{r+δ₃}) - Δ∑(S_r^z)² - H∑S_r^z

Where:

• J > 0: exchange coupling constant
• Δ > 0: anisotropy coefficient
• H = μ_B gh: Zeeman coupling term

2. Holstein-Primakoff Transformation

Applying Holstein-Primakoff transformation to four magnetic sublattices respectively:

Sublattices a₁(b₁):

• S_j^z = -S + b_{j,A(B)}† b_{j,A(B)}
• S_j^+ = b_{j,A(B)}†√(2S - b_{j,A(B)}† b_{j,A(B)})

Sublattices a₂(b₂):

• S_j^z = S - a_{j,A(B)}† a_{j,A(B)}
• S_j^- = a_{j,A(B)}†√(2S - a_{j,A(B)}† a_{j,A(B)})

3. Magnon Dispersion Relations

After diagonalization via Bogoliubov transformation, four magnon branches are obtained:

ε_{k,m}^{1(2)} = H + √(A² + |B|² - |C|²) ∓ √(4A²|B|² + (B*C - BC*)²)
ε_{k,m}^{3(4)} = -H + √(A² + |B|² - |C|²) ∓ √(4A²|B|² + (B*C - BC*)²)

Where:

• A = 3JS + 2ΔS
• B = -2JS exp(-ik_ya/2)cos(√3k_xa/2)
• C = JS exp(ik_ya)

4. Phonon Hamiltonian

Considering elastic coupling between nearest-neighbor Fe²⁺ ions:

H_ph = (1/2M)∑(p_r^z)² + (K/2)∑∑(u_r^z - u_{r+δ}^z)²

After diagonalization, acoustic and optical phonon branches are obtained:

H_ph = ℏ∑(ω_{k,p}^- η_k†η_k + ω_{k,p}^+ ζ_k†ζ_k) + const

Where ω_{k,p}^± = √(K/M)(3 ± |G(k)|)

5. Magnetoelastic Coupling

Obtained through Taylor expansion of anisotropy energy in elastic strain components:

H_coupled = κ∑∑S_r^z(S_r·δ̂)(u_r^z - u_{r+δ}^z)

Where κ is the magnetoelastic coupling constant.

Technical Innovations

1. Simplified yet effective model: Considering only in-plane nearest-neighbor exchange coupling, yet successfully reproducing complex magnetic structures
2. Exact diagonalization method: Precisely solving the coupled system through Bogoliubov transformation
3. Symmetry analysis: Utilizing magnetic point group theory to explain polarization characteristics of Raman scattering
4. Parameter fitting strategy: Determining quantitative values of model parameters through experimental data

Experimental Setup

Experimental Conditions

• Temperature: 4K low-temperature magnetic field Raman spectroscopy
• Sample: FePS₃ flakes (lateral dimensions 15μm)
• Laser: 514nm excitation, sample power 400μW
• Magnetic field configuration:
  • Faraday configuration: magnetic field perpendicular to substrate plane
  • Voigt configuration: magnetic field parallel to substrate plane
  • Magnetic field range: -20T to +30T

Experimental Techniques

• Backscattering geometry: incident and scattered light along z-axis
• Polarization analysis: left circularly polarized light incidence, analyzing co-polarized and cross-polarized scattering

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Magnon-Phonon Hybridization Observation

• Clear anticrossing phenomena observed near ±10T
• Strong coupling between M⁻ magnon branch and P1 phonon branch
• Weaker coupling of M⁺ branch with phonon branches

2. Model Parameter Fitting

Through comparison with experimental data, optimal fitting parameters are determined:

• J = 2.20 meV: exchange coupling constant
• Δ = 2.50 meV: anisotropy parameter
• ℏ√(K/M) = 5.75 meV: phonon energy scale
• κ = 115 meV/nm: magnetoelastic coupling constant

3. Zero-Field Splitting

• Theoretical prediction of magnon branch splitting at zero field
• High-resolution experimental measurements confirm this prediction
• Splitting originates from magnetoelastic coupling breaking Z₂ symmetry

Polarization Characteristics Analysis

Irreducible Representations of Magnetic Point Group 2'/m

• A' representation: invariant under symmetry operations
• A" representation: changes sign under certain operations

Raman Tensors

R_A' = [A B 0; D B 0; 0 0 I]
R_A" = [0 0 C; 0 0 F; G H 0]

Polarization Selection Rules

• M⁻ branch: co-polarized, satisfying A - iB + iD + E ≈ 0
• M⁺ branch: cross-polarized, satisfying A + iB + iD - E ≈ 0

Related Work

Foundations of Magnon Physics

1. Holstein-Primakoff theory: quantum mechanical treatment of spin waves
2. Bogoliubov transformation: diagonalization of interacting boson systems
3. Magnetoelastic theory: theoretical framework established by Kittel and others

Research on 2D Magnetic Materials

1. vdW magnetic materials: magnetic studies of CrI₃, Cr₂Ge₂Te₆, etc.
2. MPS₃ family compounds: magnetic properties of transition metal phosphorus sulfides
3. Mermin-Wagner theorem: quantum fluctuation effects on 2D magnetic order

Magnon Spintronics

1. Magnon transport: magnon flow in materials like YIG
2. Spin-caloritronics: magnon-mediated thermoelectric effects
3. Topological magnonics: topologically protected magnon states

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully established an analytical model for magnon-phonon coupling in FePS₃, capable of quantitatively explaining experimentally observed anticrossing phenomena
2. Magnetoelastic coupling strength κ = 115 meV/nm, indicating significant spin-lattice interaction in FePS₃
3. Prediction and verification of zero-field magnon splitting, demonstrating the important influence of magnetoelastic coupling on system symmetry
4. Establishment of polarization selection rules, providing theoretical foundation for understanding Raman activity of different magnon modes

Limitations

1. Model simplifications: Only considered vibrations of Fe²⁺ ions, neglecting contributions from P and S atoms
2. Exchange coupling simplifications: Only includes nearest-neighbor exchange; actual systems may require longer-range interactions
3. Selection rules: Some magnon branches not observed experimentally, possibly involving more complex selection rules
4. Temperature effects: Model primarily applicable at low temperatures; high-temperature behavior requires further investigation

Future Directions

1. Model extensions: Including vibrational modes of more atoms and longer-range exchange interactions
2. Temperature dependence: Studying evolution of magnon-phonon coupling at finite temperatures
3. Device applications: Exploring application potential of magnetoelastic coupling in magnon devices
4. Other materials: Generalizing the model to other 2D magnetic materials

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation:
   • First complete analytical model of magnon-phonon coupling in FePS₃
   • Successfully combines magnetic and elastic theories
   • Explains polarization characteristics through symmetry analysis
2. Sufficient Experimental Verification:
   • High agreement between theoretical predictions and experimental data
   • Quantitative determination of all key physical parameters
   • Successful prediction of zero-field splitting phenomenon
3. Systematic Methodology:
   • First-principles approach starting from microscopic Hamiltonian
   • Precise mathematical treatment and diagonalization techniques
   • Complete group theoretical analysis
4. Deep Physical Insights:
   • Reveals microscopic mechanisms of magnetoelastic coupling
   • Establishes connection between macroscopic phenomena and microscopic parameters
   • Provides new perspective for understanding 2D magnetism

Shortcomings

1. Model Limitations:
   • Neglects contributions of P and S atoms to phonon spectrum
   • Simplification of exchange coupling may affect quantitative accuracy
   • Does not consider inter-layer coupling effects
2. Limited Experimental Scope:
   • Primarily verified at low temperature (4K)
   • Magnetic field range, while broad, still limited
   • Lacks systematic study of temperature dependence
3. Theoretical Depth:
   • Insufficient explanation of some experimental phenomena (e.g., absence of high-energy magnon branches)
   • Relatively simple treatment of selection rules
   • Lacks discussion of dynamical processes

Impact

1. Academic Contributions:
   • Provides important theoretical tools for 2D magnetic materials research
   • Advances theoretical understanding of magnon-phonon coupling
   • Serves as exemplar for related material studies
2. Application Prospects:
   • Provides theoretical guidance for magnon device design
   • Facilitates development of novel spintronics devices
   • Establishes foundation for quantum magnetism applications
3. Reproducibility:
   • Clear theoretical model, easy to reproduce
   • Detailed experimental condition descriptions
   • Reliable parameter fitting results

Applicable Scenarios

1. Materials research: Magnetoelastic properties of 2D vdW magnetic materials
2. Device design: Development of novel devices based on magnon-phonon coupling
3. Fundamental physics: Theoretical studies of quantum magnetism and collective excitations
4. Spectroscopic analysis: Theoretical explanation and prediction of magnetic field Raman spectra

References

This paper cites important literature in the field, including:

1. Experimental foundations: Vaclavkova et al., Phys. Rev. B 104, 134437 (2021) - magnon polariton experiments
2. Material properties: McCreary et al., Phys. Rev. B 101, 064416 (2020) - FePS₃ magnetic structure
3. Theoretical foundations: Kittel, Rev. Mod. Phys. 21, 541 (1949) - magnetoelastic theory
4. Group theory methods: Cracknell, J. Phys. C 2, 500 (1969) - magnetic crystal Raman scattering

This research provides an important theoretical framework for understanding magnon-phonon coupling in 2D antiferromagnets, not only successfully explaining experimental phenomena but also laying a solid foundation for future magnonics research and device applications.