Finite width effects in nonleptonic D-decays

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.00117
• Title: Finite width effects in nonleptonic D-decays
• Authors: Girish Kumar, Sudheer Muhammad, Alexey A. Petrov (University of South Carolina)
• Classification: hep-ph (theoretical high energy physics), hep-ex (experimental high energy physics)
• Publication Date: January 3, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.00117

Abstract

Many analyses of two-body non-leptonic decays of $D$-mesons rely on flavor SU(3) symmetry relations and fits of experimental data of decay rates to extract the universal transition amplitudes. Such fits assume that the final state mesons are well-defined asymptotic states of QCD. We develop a technique to take into account the finite width effects of the final state mesons and study their effects on the extracted values of transition amplitudes.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Problem

The core problem addressed in this study is how to accurately account for the finite width effects of final state particles when analyzing non-leptonic D-meson decays within the flavor SU(3) symmetry framework, and how these effects impact the extraction of transition amplitudes.

Importance of the Problem

1. Significance of charm physics: The charm quark mass lies between heavy and light quarks, making charm physics an important laboratory for understanding non-perturbative QCD effects
2. Abundant experimental data: Experiments such as BESIII, LHCb, and Belle II provide extensive high-precision charm meson decay data
3. Theoretical calculation challenges: Due to the special nature of the charm quark mass, neither heavy quark effective theory nor massless quark limit methods can be directly applied

Limitations of Existing Methods

Traditional flavor SU(3) amplitude fitting analyses assume that final state mesons are asymptotic states of QCD (i.e., stable particles). However, this is not a good approximation for light quark vector and scalar mesons produced in D decays, since these particles may have substantial widths that differ significantly from each other.

Research Motivation

1. Finite width effects introduce an additional source of SU(3) breaking
2. The effect magnitude is proportional to $\Gamma_f/E_{rel}$, where $\Gamma_f$ is the final state particle width and $E_{rel} = m_D - \sum_f m_f$
3. Certain D→VV decays are only allowed due to finite width effects of final state particles
4. These effects may have substantial impact on the numerical values of extracted transition amplitudes

Core Contributions

1. Development of new theoretical framework: Established a systematic method for accounting for finite width effects of final state particles based on the Cutkosky rule
2. Correction of decay rate formulas: Derived modified expressions for D→PP and D→PV decay rates including finite width effects
3. Quantification of width effects: Demonstrated through fitting analysis the specific impact of finite width on extracted amplitude parameters
4. Discovery of significant physical effects: Proved that branching ratio predictions for certain decay channels (e.g., D⁰→K*⁰η') change significantly due to width effects

Methodology Details

Task Definition

The task of this paper is to reanalyze Cabibbo-allowed two-body non-leptonic D-meson decays within the flavor SU(3) symmetry framework, accounting for finite width effects of final state particles, and extract the corrected transition amplitude parameters.

Theoretical Framework

1. Complex Mass Scheme

For each unstable particle, width effects are incorporated by introducing a complex mass: $m_f^2 \rightarrow \tilde{m}_f^2 = m_f^2 - im_f\Gamma_f$

2. Modified Cutkosky Rule

Using the optical theorem to relate decay rates to the imaginary part of forward scattering amplitudes: $\Gamma(D \rightarrow f) = \frac{1}{m_D} \text{Im} M_{loop}(D \rightarrow D)$

3. Modified Formula for D→PP Decays

$\Gamma(D \rightarrow P_1P_2) = -\frac{|A_{D\rightarrow P_1P_2}|^2}{16\pi^2 m_D} \text{Im} \int_0^1 dx \log\Delta(x)$

where $\Delta(x) = \tilde{m}_{P1}^2 - x\{\tilde{m}_{P1}^2 - \tilde{m}_{P2}^2 + m_D^2(1-x)\}$

In the zero-width limit, this recovers the standard formula: $\Gamma(D \rightarrow P_1P_2) = \frac{p^*}{8\pi m_D^2}|A_{D\rightarrow P_1P_2}|^2$

4. Modified Formula for D→PV Decays

Considering vector meson polarization, the Lorentz decomposition of the decay amplitude is: $M[D(p_D) \rightarrow P(p_P)V(p_V)] = (A+B) p_D^\mu \epsilon_\mu(p_V) A_{D\rightarrow PV}$

The modified decay rate: $\Gamma(D \rightarrow PV) = \frac{(A+B)^2 m_D}{4\pi^2 m_V^2}|A_{D\rightarrow PV}|^2 \times \text{Im}\int_0^1 dx \left[\frac{\Delta(x)}{2} + \left(\frac{m_V^2 - m_D^2 x^2}{2} - \frac{\Delta(x)}{2}\right)\log\Delta(x)\right]$

Technical Innovations

1. Systematic treatment of unstable particles: Systematically handles final state unstable particles through the complex mass scheme and modified Cutkosky rule
2. Preservation of unitarity: Proves the validity of cutting unstable particle propagators under the narrow width approximation
3. Flavor symmetry analysis: Systematically analyzes the impact of finite width effects on various amplitude parameters within the topological diagram framework

Experimental Setup

Dataset

Uses Particle Data Group (PDG) 2024 experimental data, including:

• D→PP decays: Branching ratio data for 8 Cabibbo-allowed decay channels
• D→PV decays: Branching ratio data for 16 measured channels out of 18 Cabibbo-allowed decay channels

Topological Amplitude Parameterization

• D→PP: 4 tree diagram amplitudes T, C, E, A, totaling 7 parameters (T taken as real, the other 3 amplitudes each have magnitude and phase)
• D→PV: 8 amplitudes $T_V$, $T_P$, $C_V$, $C_P$, $E_V$, $E_P$, $A_V$, $A_P$, totaling 15 parameters

η-η' Mixing

Uses the mixing angle prescription $\theta = \arcsin(1/3)$: $\begin{pmatrix} \eta \\ \eta' \end{pmatrix} = -\begin{pmatrix} \cos\theta & \sin\theta \\ \sin\theta & -\cos\theta \end{pmatrix} \begin{pmatrix} \eta_8 \\ \eta_1 \end{pmatrix}$

Fitting Method

Uses $\chi^2$ minimization: $\chi^2 = \sum_{i=1}^{N} \frac{(B_i^{th} - B_i^{exp})^2}{(\Delta B_i^{exp})^2}$

Parameter optimization performed using Python's IMINUIT package.

Experimental Results

D→PP Decay Results

Since pseudoscalar meson widths are extremely small, finite width effects are negligible:

• Fitting quality: $\chi^2_{min} = 0.018$
• Amplitude parameters essentially consistent with zero-width case
• Maximum amplitude T ≈ 2.89×10⁻⁶ GeV, minimum amplitude A ≈ 0.65×10⁻⁶ GeV

D→PV Decay Results

Significant Improvement in Fitting Quality

• Without width effects: $\chi^2_{min} = 15.87$
• Including width effects: $\chi^2_{min} = 11.93$
• Improvement of approximately 4 units, demonstrating the importance of width effects

Key Finding: Dramatic Changes in Specific Decay Channels

1. D⁰→K*⁰η' Decay:
   • Without width effects: B = (0.009 ± 0.001)%
   • Including width effects: B = (0.177 ± 0.024)%
   • Increase of approximately 20-fold!
2. D_s⁺→ρ⁺η' Decay:
   • Without width effects: B = (2.4 ± 0.2)%
   • Including width effects: B = (3.5 ± 0.3)%
   • Increase of approximately 46%

Physical Interpretation

These dramatic changes arise from:

• Restricted final state phase space (heavy η' meson)
• Vector mesons (K*⁰, ρ⁺) possessing appreciable widths
• Width effects relatively increasing available phase space

Amplitude Parameter Changes

Most amplitude parameters show small changes, but the overall improvement in fitting quality indicates the systematic importance of width effects.

Related Work

Theoretical Method Development

1. Effective field theory methods: Effective field theory for unstable particles developed by Beneke et al.
2. Complex mass scheme: Applications in W, Z boson and top quark physics
3. QCD sum rules: Limited but steady progress in charm physics
4. Lattice QCD: High computational cost but steady progress

Flavor Symmetry Analysis

1. Wigner-Eckart theorem method: Using reduced matrix elements and Clebsch-Gordan coefficients
2. Topological diagram method: Using physically motivated flavor flow amplitudes
3. SU(3) breaking effects: Equivalence of the two methods has been established

Experimental Progress

Experiments such as BESIII, LHCb, and Belle II provide extensive high-precision data, providing the foundation for theoretical analysis.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Method validity: Successfully established a systematic method for handling finite width effects of final state particles
2. Effect magnitude: For D→PP decays, width effects are negligible; for D→PV decays, effects are significant
3. Specific decay channels: Decay channels with restricted phase space (e.g., decays containing η') are most affected by width effects
4. Fitting improvement: Including width effects significantly improves the fitting quality for D→PV decays

Limitations

1. Narrow width approximation: The method is based on the narrow width approximation and may not apply to very broad resonances
2. SU(3) breaking: Does not account for SU(3) breaking effects in amplitudes
3. Two-body decay limitation: Only considers two-body decays, not three-body or multi-body decays

Future Directions

1. D→VV decays: Authors plan to analyze vector-vector final states in subsequent work, with expected larger effects
2. Complete Dalitz plot analysis: Can more appropriately handle finite width effects
3. Experimental verification: More precise experimental data needed to verify theoretical predictions

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical rigor: Method established based on fundamental principles of quantum field theory (unitarity, Cutkosky rule)
2. Deep physical insight: Identifies the importance of width effects in phase-space-restricted decay channels
3. High practical value: Provides more accurate theoretical tools for experimental data analysis
4. Strong systematicity: Forms a complete system from theoretical derivation to numerical analysis

Weaknesses

1. Limited effects: For most decay channels, width effects are relatively small
2. Approximate treatment: Narrow width approximation limits the universality of the method
3. Insufficient experimental comparison: Lacks detailed comparison with latest experimental data

Impact

1. Theoretical contribution: Provides new tools for theoretical analysis in charm physics
2. Experimental guidance: Provides more accurate theoretical basis for experimental data analysis
3. Method generalization: Can be extended to other hadron decay processes

Applicable Scenarios

1. Precision measurement analysis: Suitable for theoretical analysis of high-precision experimental data
2. Phase-space-restricted decays: Particularly suitable for decays with heavy mesons in final states
3. Flavor symmetry studies: Systematic analysis within the SU(3) symmetry framework

References

The paper cites 20 important references, covering:

• Theoretical foundations of effective field theory for unstable particles
• Experimental data and theoretical analysis of charm meson decays
• Development of flavor symmetry and topological diagram methods
• Numerical fitting tools and statistical methods

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality paper with solid theoretical foundations and profound physical insights. Although corrections for most decay channels are relatively small, the dramatic impact on specific decay channels and the systematic improvement in fitting quality both demonstrate the important value of this method. The paper provides important tools for precision theoretical analysis in charm physics, with significant academic value and practical utility.