On the eigenvectors of the 5D discrete Fourier transform number operator in Newtonian basis

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.00148
• Title: On the eigenvectors of the 5D discrete Fourier transform number operator in Newtonian basis
• Author: Natig Atakishiyev
• Classification: math-ph (Mathematical Physics)
• Submission Date: December 30, 2024
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.00148

Abstract

This paper presents a simple analytical method for computing the eigenvalues and eigenvectors fₙ of the 5-dimensional discrete number operator N₅ = A₅ᵀA₅. The method is based on the symmetry properties of the ladder operators A₅ and A₅ᵀ with respect to the discrete reflection operator. The paper develops a sparsification procedure for ladder operators, enabling the establishment of discrete analogues of celebrated formulas from the continuous case, and constructs another discrete analogue of a continuous formula using Newton basis polynomials.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

The core problem addressed in this paper is the solution of eigenvectors for the 5-dimensional discrete Fourier transform (DFT) operator Φ₅. Direct solution is hindered by the degeneracy of eigenvalues in the DFT operator (which has only four distinct eigenvalues: ±1 and ±i).

Research Significance

1. Theoretical Value: The discrete Fourier transform is a fundamental tool in signal processing and numerical analysis; explicit expressions for its eigenvectors have important theoretical significance
2. Practical Applications: Widespread applications in quantum mechanics, optics, and digital signal processing
3. Mathematical Structure: Reveals deep connections between the discrete case and the continuous case (quantum harmonic oscillator)

Limitations of Existing Methods

Traditional methods for directly solving the eigenvector problem of the DFT operator face difficulties with eigenvalue degeneracy and lack systematic analytical approaches to construct explicit eigenvector expressions.

Research Motivation

By introducing the discrete number operator N₅ = A₅ᵀA₅ and utilizing its commutation property with the DFT operator N₅, Φ₅ = 0, one can determine the eigenvectors of Φ₅ using the eigenvectors of N₅, thereby circumventing the eigenvalue degeneracy problem.

Core Contributions

1. Proposed a systematic analytical method: Developed a complete method for solving the eigenvectors of the 5-dimensional discrete number operator based on the symmetry properties of ladder operators
2. Established sparsification techniques: Achieved operator sparsification by separating symmetric and antisymmetric components of ladder operators
3. Constructed discrete analogue formulas: Established discrete versions of the continuous formula ψₙ(x) = (1/√n!)(a†)ⁿψ₀(x)
4. Developed Newton basis representation: Expressed eigenvectors using Newton basis polynomials Pₙ(X₅) in the form fₙ = dₙ⁻¹Pₙ(X₅)f₀
5. Revealed recurrence relations: Established discrete versions of three-term recurrence relations similar to the continuous case

Detailed Methodology

Problem Definition

Solve for the eigenvalues λₙ and eigenvectors fₙ of the 5-dimensional discrete number operator N₅ = A₅ᵀA₅, where:

• A₅ = (1/√2)(X₅ + D₅) is the lowering operator
• A₅ᵀ = (1/√2)(X₅ - D₅) is the raising operator
• X₅ = diag(s₀, s₁, s₂, s₃, s₄), sₙ = 2sin(2πn/5)
• D₅ = i(C₅ᵀ - C₅), C₅ is the cyclic permutation matrix

Core Algorithm Architecture

1. Symmetry Analysis

Utilizing properties of the discrete reflection operator Pₐ = C₅ᵀJ₅:

• Ladder operators A₅ and A₅ᵀ are both Pₐ-antisymmetric
• Eigenvectors must be either Pₐ-symmetric or Pₐ-antisymmetric

2. Sparsification Technique

Proposition 1: The product Φ₅X₅ can be expressed in two forms:

Φ₅X₅ = s₂⁻¹A⁽ˢ⁾ + iB⁽ˢ⁾  (symmetric decomposition)
Φ₅X₅ = s₂⁻¹(A⁽ᵃ⁾ + B⁽ᵃ⁾)  (antisymmetric decomposition)

where A⁽ˢ⁾ and A⁽ᵃ⁾ are symmetric and antisymmetric annihilation operators respectively, and B⁽ˢ⁾ and B⁽ᵃ⁾ are sparse matrices.

3. Ladder Construction Method

Following the ladder operator method analogous to the quantum harmonic oscillator:

1. Ground State: Solve A₅f₀ = 0 to obtain the Pₐ-symmetric ground state
2. Sequential Construction: Construct excited states via fₙ₊₁ = cₙA₅ᵀfₙ
3. Normalization: Ensure ⟨fₖ, fₗ⟩ = δₖₗ

Technical Innovations

1. Symmetry Exploitation: Fully utilize Pₐ-symmetry to simplify calculations, reducing the 5×5 matrix problem to lower dimensions
2. Sparsification Strategy: By isolating the annihilation part, only sparse matrices need to be handled, significantly simplifying computations
3. Geometric Interpretation: Introduce parameter η = cos φ, φ = arctan(s₂₁/4) ≈ 42.13°, providing clear geometric insight

Main Results

Eigenvalues

Five distinct eigenvalues are obtained:

• λ₀ = 0 (ground state)
• λ₁ = c₁(s₂ - 1) + 7/2
• λ₂ = s₁(s₁ - c₂)/2
• λ₃ = s₁(s₁ + c₂)/2
• λ₄ = 7 - c₁(1 + s₂)/2

where c₁ = 2cos(2π/5), c₂ = 2cos(4π/5), s₁ = 2sin(2π/5), s₂ = 2sin(4π/5).

Explicit Expressions for Eigenvectors

All eigenvectors have explicit closed-form expressions:

f₀ = (2/√(λ₂λ₄))(s₁ - 2c₂, 1 + s₂, 1, 1, 1 + s₂)ᵀ
f₁ = (1/√(2λ₂))(0, s₁ - c₂, 1, -1, c₂ - s₁)ᵀ
f₂ = (1/√(λ₂λ₃))(2, c₂, c₂, c₂, c₂)ᵀ
f₃ = (1/√(2λ₃))(0, -(s₁ + c₂), 1, -1, s₁ + c₂)ᵀ
f₄ = (1/√(λ₂λ₄))(2, c₂ - 2s₁, 2s₁ - c₂ + 2c₁, 2s₁ - c₂ + 2c₁, c₂ - 2s₁)ᵀ

Discrete Analogue Formulas

1. Ladder Operator Formula

fₙ = (η ∏ₖ₌₁ⁿ λₖ^(1/2))⁻¹ (A₅ᵀ)ⁿ f₀, n = 1,2,3,4

2. Newton Basis Representation

fₙ = dₙ⁻¹ Pₙ(X₅)f₀

where:

• dₙ = η ∏ₖ₌₁ⁿ (2λₖ)^(1/2)
• Pₙ(X₅) is the Newton basis matrix polynomial

3. Recurrence Relations

For n = 2,3:

√(2λₙ₊₁) fₙ₊₁ + √(2λₙ) fₙ₋₁ = 2X₅fₙ

For n = 1, a four-term recurrence relation exists:

√(2λ₂) f₂ + √(2λ₁) η (f₀ + √(5c₂/4) f₄) = 2X₅f₁

Theoretical Analysis

Correspondence with the Continuous Case

The discrete formulas established in this paper have perfect correspondence with classical formulas from the continuous quantum harmonic oscillator:

Algebraic Structure

The ladder operators A₅ and A₅ᵀ form a cubic algebra Cᵩ, which is more complex than the Heisenberg-Weyl algebra of the continuous case, yet still permits similar ladder operator constructions.

Related Work

Historical Development

1. McClellan & Parks (1972): First study of eigenvalue decomposition of DFT
2. Mehta (1987): Investigation of eigenvalues and eigenvectors of finite Fourier transforms
3. Atakishiyeva & Atakishiyev (2015-2021): Development of ladder operator theory and cubic algebra framework

Uniqueness of This Paper's Contribution

Compared to existing work, this paper is the first to:

• Provide a complete analytical method for constructing all eigenvectors
• Establish precise correspondence with the continuous case
• Develop sparsification techniques based on symmetry

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Complete Solution: Provides a complete analytical solution to the eigenvector problem of the 5-dimensional discrete number operator
2. Methodological Contribution: Sparsification techniques and symmetry analysis provide an extensible framework for higher-dimensional cases
3. Theoretical Unification: Establishes deep connections between discrete and continuous cases

Limitations

1. Dimensional Restriction: Current method is specifically tailored for the 5-dimensional case; extension to general N-dimensional cases requires further research
2. Computational Complexity: Although analytical solutions are provided, computation remains complex for large-dimensional cases
3. Application Scope: Primarily theoretical contributions; practical application value requires further exploration

Future Directions

1. Generalization: Extend the method to arbitrary N-dimensional cases
2. Numerical Algorithms: Develop efficient numerical computation methods based on theoretical results
3. Application Exploration: Specific applications in quantum information processing and signal analysis

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Mathematical Rigor: All results have rigorous mathematical proofs with detailed and complete calculations
2. Methodological Innovation: Sparsification techniques and symmetry analysis provide novel solution approaches
3. Theoretical Depth: Reveals the deep algebraic structure of discrete Fourier transforms
4. Completeness: Provides a complete solution from theory to concrete formulas

Weaknesses

1. Limited Applicability: Restricted to the 5-dimensional case; generality remains to be improved
2. Lack of Practical Applications: Primarily theoretical research without concrete application examples
3. Computational Efficiency: Although analytical formulas are exact, computational complexity is relatively high

Impact Assessment

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new perspectives and tools for discrete Fourier transform theory
2. Methodological Value: Sparsification and symmetry analysis methods have broad applicability
3. Foundation for Future Research: Establishes a foundation for further research in related fields

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Research: Mathematical physics, algebraic geometry, special function theory
2. Numerical Analysis: Development of high-precision Fourier transform algorithms
3. Quantum Information: Quantum algorithms and quantum state manipulation

References

The paper cites 23 important references covering classical and cutting-edge work in discrete Fourier transforms, special functions, orthogonal polynomials, and quantum mechanics, providing a solid theoretical foundation for the research.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality mathematical physics theory paper that makes important contributions to the theory of eigenvectors of discrete Fourier transforms. Although currently limited to the 5-dimensional case, the developed methods and theoretical framework possess significant academic value and potential application prospects.