Improved bounds for Serre's open image theorem

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.00202
• Title: Improved bounds for Serre's open image theorem
• Authors: Imin Chen, Joshua Swidinsky
• Classification: math.NT (Number Theory)
• Publication Date: January 3, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.00202

Abstract

Let $E$ be an elliptic curve defined over the rational numbers $\mathbb{Q}$ without complex multiplication. Serre proved that the $\ell$-adic representations attached to $E/\mathbb{Q}$ have open image; specifically, there exists a minimal natural number $C_E$ such that for all primes $\ell > C_E$, the mod $\ell$ representation $\bar{\rho}_{E,\ell}$ is surjective. Under the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis (GRH), Mayle-Wang provided explicit bounds for $C_E$ that are logarithmic in the conductor of $E$ with explicit constants. Their method combines the effective form of the Chebotarev density theorem with the Faltings-Serre method, particularly utilizing the "deviation group" of 2-adic representations attached to two elliptic curves. By considering quotient groups of the deviation group and employing the characterization of the image of $\rho_{E,2}$ by Rouse and Zureick-Brown, this paper demonstrates how to further reduce the constants in the Mayle-Wang result. Another independently interesting result concerns an improved effective isogeny theorem for elliptic curves over the rationals.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

This research addresses the effective version of Serre's open image theorem. For an elliptic curve $E$ defined over $\mathbb{Q}$ without complex multiplication, Serre proved that there exists a minimal natural number $C_E$ such that for all primes $\ell > C_E$, the mod $\ell$ Galois representation $\bar{\rho}_{E,\ell}$ is surjective.

Significance of the Problem

1. Theoretical Significance: This result is a foundational theorem in algebraic number theory and elliptic curve theory, connecting Galois representation theory with the arithmetic properties of elliptic curves
2. Computational Significance: Effective bounds on $C_E$ are of considerable importance for computational studies of elliptic curves
3. Applied Value: Extensive applications in elliptic curve cryptography and isogeny problem research

Limitations of Existing Methods

• The constant $C_1$ in Serre's original result is quite large and insufficiently explicit
• Although Mayle-Wang provided explicit bounds, the constants still admit improvement
• Existing methods do not fully exploit the special structure of 2-adic representations

Research Motivation

This paper aims to improve the constants in the Mayle-Wang result through more refined analysis of the deviation group structure, particularly by considering its quotient groups and the results of Rouse-Zureick-Brown.

Core Contributions

1. Improved Effective Isogeny Theorem: Provides better constant bounds when the mod 2 representation satisfies specific conditions (Theorem 1.3)
2. Special Results for Quadratic Twists: Provides specialized improved bounds for elliptic curves that are quadratic twists of each other (Theorem 1.5)
3. Improved Bounds for Serre's Open Image Theorem: Improves the Mayle-Wang bound from $964 \log \text{rad}(2N_E) + 5760$ to $446 \log \text{rad}(2N_E) + 2254$ (Theorem 1.7)
4. Technical Innovation: Replaces the complete deviation group $\delta(G)$ with quotient groups $\varphi(G)$ and utilizes the classification results of Rouse-Zureick-Brown for 2-adic images

Detailed Methodology

Problem Formulation

Given two non-isogenous elliptic curves $E$ and $E'$, find a prime $p$ with good reduction such that $a_p(E) \neq a_p(E')$, and provide an effective upper bound for such a prime.

Core Technical Framework

1. Deviation Group Theory

For two $\ell$-adic representations $\rho_1, \rho_2: G \to GL_n(\mathcal{O}_\lambda)$, define the deviation group: $\delta(G) = \text{Image}(G \to (M/\lambda M)^\times)$ where $M$ is the $\mathcal{O}_\lambda$-subalgebra generated by the image of $\rho_1 \times \rho_2$.

2. Quotient Group Construction

When the mod 2 representations are isomorphic and absolutely irreducible, construct the homomorphism: $\varphi: G \to M_n(\mathbb{F}_2) \rtimes GL_n(\mathbb{F}_2)$$g \mapsto (\theta(g) \bmod 2, \rho_1(g) \bmod 2)$

Key observation: The image of $\varphi(G)$ is easier to estimate in size than $\delta(G)$.

3. Application of Chebotarev Density Theorem

Using the explicit form of Bach-Sorenson (Theorem 2.5): $p \leq (a \log |d_K| + bn_K + c)^2$

Technical Innovations

1. Refined Analysis of Deviation Groups

• Core Insight: In the 2-adic case, when the mod 2 representation is absolutely irreducible, one can replace $\delta(G)$ with $\varphi(G)$
• Size Estimate: $|\varphi(G)| \leq |M_2^0(\mathbb{F}_2) \rtimes GL_2(\mathbb{F}_2)| = 48$, significantly smaller than the general upper bound for $\delta(G)$ of $2^{2n^2} = 2^8 = 256$

2. Application of Rouse-Zureick-Brown Results

Utilizing the complete classification of 2-adic images:

• 1208 arithmetic maximal subgroups with infinitely many rational points
• 8 exceptional $j$-invariants

3. Quotient Group Technique

Through Corollary 5.3, if $\delta(G)$ has a quotient group of order $> 3$, one can replace it with a smaller quotient group.

Experimental Setup

Computational Verification

Using the Magma computer algebra system to verify:

1. The validity of triples $(ā, b̄, c̄)$ in Table 1
2. Verification of inequalities (2.1), (2.2), (2.3), (2.4)
3. Classification and filtering of problematic groups

Data Sources

• Optimized version of Bach-Sorenson tables (Table 1)
• Classification of 1733 arithmetic maximal subgroups by Rouse-Zureick-Brown
• Concrete elliptic curve examples for verification

Experimental Results

Main Theorem Results

Theorem 1.3 (Improved Effective Isogeny Theorem)

Conditions: Mod 2 representations are non-isomorphic or isomorphic and absolutely irreducible Result: $p \leq (124 \log \text{rad}(2N_E N_{E'}) + 561)^2$Improvement: Compared to Mayle-Wang's $(482 \log \text{rad}(2N_E N_{E'}) + 2880)^2$, constants are significantly reduced

Theorem 1.5 (Quadratic Twist Case)

Result: $p \leq (223 \log \text{rad}(2N_E N_{E'}) + 1127)^2$

Theorem 1.7 (Serre's Open Image Theorem)

Mayle-Wang: $C_E \leq 964 \log \text{rad}(2N_E) + 5760$This Paper's Improvement: $C_E \leq 446 \log \text{rad}(2N_E) + 2254$Improvement Magnitude: Linear coefficient reduced by approximately 53%, constant term reduced by approximately 61%

Technical Verification Results

Optimization of Table 1

Optimizes Bach-Sorenson's two-dimensional table into a one-dimensional table, providing optimal triples for different degree ranges $n_{\tilde{K}}$:

Analysis of Problematic Groups

For $|\delta(G)| \in \{32, 48, 64, 96, 128, 192\}$, identifies problematic groups and proves that in most cases they can be replaced with smaller quotient groups.

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Serre (1972): Proved the existence of the open image theorem
2. Serre (1981): Provided the first effective bound, but with large constants
3. Lagarias-Odlyzko (1979): Effective version of Chebotarev density theorem
4. Bach-Sorenson (1996): Improved explicit constants
5. Mayle-Wang (2024): Bounds with explicitly small constants

Related Techniques

• Faltings-Serre Method: Uses deviation groups to distinguish non-isogenous elliptic curves
• Chebotarev Density Theorem: Finds primes with specific properties
• Galois Representation Theory: Mod $\ell$ representations of elliptic curves

Innovations in This Paper

Compared to existing work, the main innovations are:

1. More refined analysis of deviation groups
2. Exploitation of the special structure of 2-adic representations
3. Integration with the classification results of Rouse-Zureick-Brown

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Under appropriate conditions, the effective bound constants in Serre's open image theorem can be reduced by approximately 50%
2. Analysis of quotient groups of deviation groups is an effective approach to improving constants
3. The special properties of 2-adic representations can be fully utilized to obtain better bounds

Limitations

1. GRH Dependence: All results depend on the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis
2. Conditional Restrictions: Theorem 1.3 requires the mod 2 representation to satisfy specific conditions
3. Technical Complexity: The method involves multiple deep number-theoretic techniques and is complex to implement

Future Directions

1. Remove or weaken the dependence on GRH
2. Extend to other $\ell$-adic representations
3. Further optimize constants
4. Study computational complexity and practical applications

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Significant Theoretical Contribution: Achieves substantial improvements on an important number-theoretic problem
2. Technical Innovation: Cleverly combines multiple deep number-theoretic techniques
3. Concrete Results: Provides explicit numerical improvements with practical significance
4. Sufficient Verification: Uses computer algebra systems to verify key technical details

Weaknesses

1. Limited Scope: The best results (Theorem 1.3) require additional conditions
2. Computational Complexity: Practical implementation of the method requires complex group-theoretic computations
3. Theoretical Dependencies: Strongly depends on GRH and multiple deep number-theoretic results

Impact

1. Academic Value: Advances the development of Galois representation theory for elliptic curves
2. Practical Significance: Provides better tools for computational number theory research on elliptic curves
3. Methodological Contribution: Demonstrates how to improve constants in classical results through refined analysis

Applicable Scenarios

1. Computational number theory research on elliptic curves
2. Effectiveness problems in Galois representations
3. Security analysis in elliptic curve cryptography
4. Computational complexity research on isogeny problems

References

The paper contains 18 important references covering multiple related fields including Chebotarev density theorem, elliptic curve theory, and Galois representations, encompassing both classical and recent results. Particularly important are Serre's original work, the recent results of Mayle-Wang, and the classification work of Rouse-Zureick-Brown on 2-adic images.