3D Carrollian Gravity from 2D Euclidean Symmetry

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.00205
• Title: 3D Carrollian Gravity from 2D Euclidean Symmetry
• Authors: Patrick Concha, Evelyn Rodríguez, Sebastián Salgado
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory), gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology)
• Publication Date: December 31, 2024
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.00205

Abstract

Carroll symmetry emerges from Poincaré symmetry in the limit as the speed of light approaches zero. This study applies the Lie algebra expansion method to identify Carroll versions of different gravitational models in three-dimensional spacetime. The research begins with two-dimensional Euclidean AdS algebras and their flat counterparts. Novel and known Carrollian algebras are discovered, such as AdS-Carroll and Carroll-Galilei algebras, and Chern-Simons gravitational theories based on them are constructed. Notably, after expansion, the vanishing cosmological constant limit applied to the two-dimensional Euclidean AdS algebra transforms into a non-relativistic limit in three-dimensional spacetime. The research further extends to Post-Carroll-Newtonian algebras, which can be obtained through expansion of a family of two-dimensional Euclidean algebras.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

The core problem addressed in this research is how to systematically construct three-dimensional Carrollian gravitational theories from two-dimensional Euclidean symmetries. Carroll symmetry, as the limit of Poincaré symmetry when the speed of light c→0, forms a dual relationship with the traditional non-relativistic limit (c→∞ yielding the Galilei group).

Significance

1. Theoretical Physics Significance: Carroll symmetry has important applications in multiple physics domains, including tachyon condensation, twisted conformal field theory, tensionless superstring theory, asymptotic symmetries, flat holography, and black hole horizons.
2. Gravitational Theory Development: In three-dimensional spacetime, Carroll gravity can be expressed as a Chern-Simons (CS) action, providing an important platform for studying non-Lorentzian gravitational theories.
3. Symmetry Unification: The research aims to establish systematic connections between two-dimensional Euclidean symmetries and three-dimensional Carrollian gravity.

Limitations of Existing Methods

• Traditional contraction methods, while capable of obtaining Carroll algebras, lack systematicity
• Degenerate invariant tensors exist in the Carroll-Galilei case
• Absence of a unified framework for constructing higher-dimensional Carrollian theories from lower-dimensional symmetries

Research Motivation

Based on the successful application of the S-expansion method and the importance of Carrollian symmetry in multiple physics domains, this research proposes a novel approach to systematically construct three-dimensional Carrollian gravitational theories from two-dimensional Euclidean algebras.

Core Contributions

1. Systematic Methodology: Proposes a systematic method for constructing three-dimensional Carrollian gravitational theories from two-dimensional Euclidean AdS and Poincaré algebras via the S-expansion method.
2. Novel Correspondence: Discovers the correspondence between the vanishing cosmological constant limit Λ→0 in two-dimensional Euclidean algebras and the non-relativistic limit c→∞ in three-dimensional spacetime.
3. Degeneracy Resolution: Solves the degeneracy problem of invariant tensors in the Carroll-Galilei case by introducing central extensions of the two-dimensional Euclidean Maxwell algebra.
4. Theory Extension: Constructs a family of Post-Carroll-Newtonian algebras through expansion of two-dimensional Euclidean Bₖ algebras, achieving further generalization of the theory.
5. Complete CS Action: Provides corresponding three-dimensional Chern-Simons gravitational actions for all constructed Carrollian algebras.

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Construct three-dimensional Carrollian gravitational theories with input from two-dimensional Euclidean symmetry algebras and output as three-dimensional Carrollian algebras and their corresponding Chern-Simons actions, subject to the constraint of maintaining algebraic structure consistency and non-degeneracy of invariant tensors.

Core Methodological Framework

1. S-Expansion Method

Employs expansion based on the semigroup S_E^(1) = {λ₀, λ₁, λ₂} with multiplication rules:

λ_α λ_β = {
    λ_{α+β}, if α+β ≤ 1
    λ₂,      otherwise
}

where λ₂ is the zero element of the semigroup.

2. Algebraic Construction Procedure

Starting from the two-dimensional Euclidean AdS algebra:

[J̃, P̃ₐ] = ϵₐᵦP̃ᵦ
[P̃ₐ, P̃ᵦ] = -ϵₐᵦJ̃

Through S-expansion, generators of the three-dimensional AdS-Carroll algebra are obtained:

J = λ₀J̃, H = λ₁J̃, Pₐ = λ₀P̃ₐ, Gₐ = λ₁P̃ₐ

3. Invariant Tensor Construction

Invariant tensors of the original two-dimensional algebra:

⟨P̃ₐP̃ᵦ⟩ = β̃δₐᵦ, ⟨J̃J̃⟩ = -β̃

Invariant tensors of the expanded three-dimensional algebra:

⟨PₐPᵦ⟩ = β₀δₐᵦ, ⟨PₐGᵦ⟩ = β₁δₐᵦ
⟨JJ⟩ = -β₀, ⟨JH⟩ = -β₁

Technical Innovations

1. Dimensional Correspondence

Establishes a novel correspondence between the two-dimensional flat limit and the three-dimensional non-relativistic limit, analogous to the cga/bms₃ duality.

2. Degeneracy Treatment

Resolves invariant tensor degeneracy problems by introducing central extensions of the Maxwell algebra:

[P̃ₐ, P̃ᵦ] = -ϵₐᵦZ̃

3. Systematic Generalization

Constructs Euclidean versions of the Bₖ algebra family, achieving systematic construction of Post-Carroll-Newtonian theories.

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Verification Methods

As a purely theoretical work, verification methods include:

1. Algebraic Consistency Verification: Validates consistency of Jacobi identities and commutation relations
2. Invariant Tensor Non-degeneracy: Checks whether constructed invariant tensors satisfy non-degeneracy conditions
3. Action Construction: Verifies gauge invariance of the Chern-Simons action

Comparative Analysis

• Comparison with known Carroll algebras
• Comparison with results obtained from traditional contraction methods
• Analysis of relationships with relativistic gravitational theories

Main Results

1. AdS-Carroll Gravity

Constructs the complete AdS-Carroll algebra:

[J, Pₐ] = ϵₐᵦPᵦ, [J, Gₐ] = ϵₐᵦGᵦ, [Pₐ, Pᵦ] = -ϵₐᵦJ
[Pₐ, Gᵦ] = -ϵₐᵦH, [H, Pₐ] = ϵₐᵦGᵦ

Corresponding CS action:

S_CS^{AdS-Carroll} = (k/4π)∫[β₀(R(eₐ)eₐ - ωdω) + β₁(R(ωₐ)eₐ + R(eₐ)ωₐ - 2ωdτ)]

2. Carroll-Galilei Gravity

Obtains the Carroll-Galilei algebra:

[J, Pₐ] = ϵₐᵦPᵦ, [J, Gₐ] = ϵₐᵦGᵦ, [H, Pₐ] = ϵₐᵦGᵦ

Although degeneracy exists, it provides important theoretical foundations.

3. Extended Carroll-Galilei Gravity

Resolves degeneracy through Maxwell algebra extension:

[Gₐ, Pᵦ] = -ϵₐᵦM, [Pₐ, Pᵦ] = -ϵₐᵦS

Obtains non-degenerate invariant tensors and complete CS action.

4. Post-Carroll-Newtonian Generalization

Constructs the pcnₘ algebra family where m = k-2, with Carroll-Galilei (m=1) and extended Carroll-Galilei (m=2) as special cases.

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. Carroll Symmetry Theory: Lévy-Leblond's pioneering work and the Bacry-Lévy-Leblond cube
2. Non-Lorentzian Gravity: Including electric and magnetic Carroll gravity
3. Chern-Simons Gravity: CS formulation of three-dimensional gravity
4. S-Expansion Method: Systematic methods for Lie algebra expansion

Advantages of This Work

• Provides systematic construction methods
• Establishes novel dimensional correspondences
• Resolves degeneracy problems
• Achieves systematic theory generalization

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully establishes a systematic method for constructing three-dimensional Carrollian gravity from two-dimensional Euclidean symmetries
2. Discovers the correspondence between two-dimensional flat limits and three-dimensional non-relativistic limits
3. Resolves invariant tensor degeneracy problems through central extensions
4. Constructs a complete family of Post-Carroll-Newtonian theories

Limitations

1. Research is limited to three-dimensional spacetime
2. Primarily focuses on bosonic theories; supersymmetric extensions require further investigation
3. Degeneracy problems become more complex in supersymmetric cases

Future Directions

1. Supersymmetric Extensions: Construct Carroll CS supergravity models
2. Higher-Spin Coupling: Study coupling with higher-spin gauge fields
3. Asymptotic Symmetries: Analyze asymptotic symmetries of generalized Carrollian gravity models
4. Higher-Dimensional Generalization: Extend to higher-dimensional spacetimes

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Methodological Innovation: Systematic application of the S-expansion method provides new construction pathways for Carrollian gravity
2. Theoretical Completeness: Forms a complete theoretical framework from algebraic construction to action construction
3. Problem Resolution: Effectively resolves degeneracy problems in the Carroll-Galilei case
4. Systematic Generalization: Construction of the Post-Carroll-Newtonian family demonstrates the universality of the method

Weaknesses

1. Physical Interpretation: Lacks in-depth physical interpretation of newly discovered dimensional correspondences
2. Application Discussion: Lacks discussion of specific physical applications of constructed theories
3. Numerical Verification: As a purely theoretical work, lacks numerical or experimental verification

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new theoretical tools for non-Lorentzian gravitational theory research
2. Methodological Value: Application of the S-expansion method can be generalized to other non-Lorentzian theories
3. Future Development: Establishes solid foundations for further research in Carroll gravity

Applicable Scenarios

1. Non-Lorentzian gravity research in theoretical physics
2. Holographic duality theory research
3. Black hole physics and asymptotic symmetry analysis
4. Effective field theory construction in condensed matter physics

References

This paper cites 100 relevant references, covering multiple important research areas including Carroll symmetry, non-Lorentzian gravity, Chern-Simons theory, and Lie algebra expansion, providing solid theoretical foundations for the research.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that makes important contributions to Carrollian gravitational theory through systematic mathematical methods. The research methodology is rigorous, the results are complete, and it provides valuable theoretical tools and new research directions for further development in this field.