Note on the local calculation of decoherence of quantum superpositions in de Sitter spacetime

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.00213
• Title: Note on the local calculation of decoherence of quantum superpositions in de Sitter spacetime
• Author: Ran Li (Department of Physics, Qufu Normal University)
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory), gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology), quant-ph (Quantum Physics)
• Publication Date: December 31, 2024
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.00213

Abstract

This paper investigates the decoherence of quantum superposition states in de Sitter (dS) spacetime induced by the presence of the cosmological horizon. Using algebraic methods from quantum field theory on curved spacetime, the author derives exact expressions for the expected number of entangled particles in the scalar field case and establishes the relationship between decoherence and local two-point correlation functions. The paper analyzes quantum superposition thought experiments performed by a local observer at the center of dS spacetime and calculates the number of entangled particles for scalar, electromagnetic, and gravitational fields. The results demonstrate that quantum spatial superposition states undergo decoherence through the emission of entangled particles toward the cosmological horizon. This setup is equivalent to an accelerated observer in 5-dimensional Minkowski spacetime. The results for scalar and electromagnetic fields agree with reference 1, but the numerical prefactor for gravitational decoherence is determined for the first time.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

The central problem addressed in this paper is: how does the cosmological horizon in de Sitter spacetime induce decoherence of quantum superposition states, and how can this phenomenon be described from the perspective of a local observer?

Problem Significance

1. Quantum-gravity unification: The unification of quantum mechanics and gravity remains one of the most challenging open problems in modern fundamental physics
2. Gravitational decoherence: Gravitational interactions cannot be shielded, and fluctuations of spacetime as a dynamical variable necessarily lead to decoherence of quantum systems
3. DSW effect: The effect proposed by Danielson, Satishchandran, and Wald (DSW) regarding decoherence of quantum superpositions induced by black hole horizons requires further investigation in cosmological backgrounds

Limitations of Existing Approaches

1. Insufficiency of global descriptions: Previous studies primarily analyzed decoherence from a global perspective, lacking descriptions from local observers
2. Uncertain numerical coefficients: Precise numerical coefficients for decoherence rates of different spin fields remain undetermined
3. Model dependence: Existing results often depend on specific interaction Hamiltonian models

Research Motivation

The author aims to provide a model-independent local description of decoherence effects in dS spacetime through algebraic quantum field theory methods and to determine the exact numerical coefficients of decoherence rates for various field types.

Core Contributions

1. Derived exact expressions for the expected number of entangled particles in the scalar field case using algebraic methods from quantum field theory on curved spacetime
2. Established direct relationships between decoherence and local two-point correlation functions, providing a model-independent theoretical framework
3. Calculated decoherence rates for three types of fields in dS spacetime: scalar, electromagnetic, and linearized gravitational fields
4. Determined the numerical prefactor for gravitational decoherence for the first time, resolving previous uncertainties in the literature
5. Verified equivalence with accelerated observers, demonstrating that observers at the center of dS are equivalent to accelerated observers in 5-dimensional Minkowski spacetime

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigation of decoherence effects caused by radiation of various fields when a local observer at the center of dS spacetime performs a Stern-Gerlach quantum superposition experiment. The input is the initial superposition state of the particle, and the output is the decoherence rate and expected number of entangled particles.

Theoretical Framework

1. Quantum Superposition State Setup

The experimental particle, after passing through a Stern-Gerlach apparatus, is in a spatially separated superposition state: $|Ψ⟩ = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(|ψ_L, ↑⟩ + |ψ_R, ↓⟩)$

The total particle-radiation system state is: $|Ψ⟩ = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(|ψ_L, ↑⟩ ⊗ |Ψ_L⟩ + |ψ_R, ↓⟩ ⊗ |Ψ_R⟩)$

2. Decoherence Measure

The degree of decoherence is defined by: $D = 1 - |⟨Ψ_L|Ψ_R⟩|$

Using coherent state theory, the overlap of radiation states is: $|⟨Ψ_L|Ψ_R⟩| = \exp\left[-\frac{1}{2}⟨N⟩\right]$

where $⟨N⟩$ is the expected number of entangled particles.

3. Key Derivation for the Scalar Field Case

For the scalar field, the number of entangled particles can be expressed as: $⟨N⟩ = ⟨Ω|[\hat{φ}^{in}(ρ_R - ρ_L)]^2|Ω⟩$

Through geometric analysis and algebraic representation of field operators, the final result is: $⟨N⟩ = q^2\int dτdτ' d(τ)d(τ')s^as^b⟨∇_a\hat{φ}^{in}(τ,x^i)∇_b\hat{φ}^{in}(τ',x'^i)⟩$

Technical Innovations

1. Application of algebraic methods: Using algebraic methods from quantum field theory on curved spacetime avoids model dependence
2. Connection to local correlation functions: Directly links global geometric effects to local physical quantities
3. Geometric treatment: Simplifies calculations through the geometric picture of embedding in 5-dimensional Minkowski spacetime
4. Unified framework: Provides a unified computational framework for fields of different spins

Specific Calculations in dS Spacetime

dS Spacetime Geometry

Using static coordinates, the metric is: $ds^2 = -\left(1 - \frac{r^2}{L^2}\right)dt^2 + \frac{dr^2}{1 - r^2/L^2} + r^2dΩ^2$

The cosmological horizon is located at $r = L$, with Hawking temperature $T_H = \frac{1}{2πL}$.

Two-Point Correlation Functions

Using the dS-invariant vacuum state, the two-point correlation functions for various fields are:

Scalar field: $⟨φ^{in}(x)φ^{in}(x')⟩ = \frac{1}{4π^2}\frac{1}{Δ^2(x-x')}$

Electromagnetic field: $⟨F_{tr}F_{t'r'}⟩ ≈ \frac{1}{16π^2L^4}\frac{1}{\sinh^4(τ-τ')/2L}$

Gravitational field: $⟨C_{rtrt}C_{r't'r't'}⟩ = -\frac{1}{16π^2L^6}\frac{1}{\sinh^6(t-t')/2L}$

Experimental Results

Main Results

Through Fourier transform techniques and long-time approximations, the decoherence rates for various fields are obtained:

1. Scalar field: $Γ_s = \frac{q^2d^2}{12π^2L^3}$
2. Electromagnetic field: $Γ_e = \frac{q^2d^2}{6π^2L^3}$
3. Gravitational field: $Γ_g = \frac{2m^2d^4}{15π^2L^5}$

where $q$ is the charge, $m$ is the mass, $d$ is the separation distance of the superposition state, and $L$ is the dS radius.

Important Findings

1. Linear time dependence: The number of entangled particles is proportional to the time the observer maintains the superposition state
2. Field-type dependence: The decoherence rate for the electromagnetic field is twice that of the scalar field
3. Gravitational field specificity: Gravitational decoherence depends on $d^4$ rather than $d^2$, reflecting the tensor nature of gravity
4. Numerical coefficient determination: The exact numerical prefactor $\frac{2}{15π^2}$ for the gravitational case is determined for the first time

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. DSW mechanism: Pioneering work on decoherence of quantum superpositions induced by black hole horizons
2. Rotating black holes: Study of decoherence effects in Kerr black holes
3. Accelerated observers: Description of decoherence for accelerated observers in Minkowski spacetime
4. Quantum gravity: Various approaches to unifying gravity and quantum mechanics

Advantages of This Paper

1. Model independence: Does not depend on specific interaction Hamiltonians
2. Local description: Provides a complete picture from the perspective of local observers
3. Exact results: Determines previously undetermined numerical coefficients
4. Unified framework: Covers fields of different spins

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Quantum superposition states in dS spacetime inevitably undergo decoherence due to the presence of the cosmological horizon
2. Decoherence rates are directly related to local two-point correlation functions, providing a local physical picture
3. Decoherence rates for different field types exhibit different scaling relations and numerical coefficients
4. Observers at the center of dS are equivalent to accelerated observers in 5-dimensional Minkowski spacetime

Limitations

1. Static Killing vector restriction: Calculations apply only to spacetimes with static Killing vectors
2. Point particle approximation: Neglects the spatial extent of the experimental particle
3. Linearized gravity: The gravitational field case only considers the linearized approximation
4. Specific geometry: Only considers radial separation cases

Future Directions

1. Rotating black holes: Extend local descriptions to rotating black hole spacetimes
2. Nonlinear effects: Consider nonlinear corrections to the gravitational field
3. Quantum gravity: Verify results in complete quantum gravity theories
4. Experimental verification: Seek possible experimental or observational verification pathways

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical rigor: Uses mature methods from quantum field theory on curved spacetime with strict mathematical derivations
2. Physical insight: Establishes profound connections between global geometric effects and local physical quantities
3. Result completeness: Covers three fundamental field types, providing a comprehensive picture
4. Numerical precision: Determines the exact numerical coefficient for gravitational decoherence for the first time
5. Methodological innovation: Algebraic methods avoid model dependence and possess universal applicability

Weaknesses

1. Limited scope: Restricted to static spacetimes, limiting applicability
2. Approximate treatments: Multiple approximations used, potentially affecting result precision
3. Experimental feasibility: Lacks discussion of possible experimental verification
4. Physical interpretation: Insufficient discussion of the physical nature of decoherence mechanisms

Impact

1. Theoretical contribution: Provides new theoretical tools for quantum gravity and cosmology
2. Method value: Algebraic methods can be generalized to other curved spacetime problems
3. Numerical benchmark: Provides important benchmarks for related numerical studies
4. Cross-disciplinary significance: Connects quantum information, gravitational theory, and cosmology

Application Scenarios

1. Theoretical research: Theoretical modeling in quantum gravity and cosmology
2. Numerical simulation: Provides analytical benchmarks for related numerical calculations
3. Concept verification: Verification of conceptual experiments for quantum gravitational effects
4. Educational application: Serves as a typical example in quantum field theory on curved spacetime

References

The paper cites important literature in related fields, including:

• Pioneering work by Danielson, Satishchandran & Wald 9,10
• Research on accelerated observers by Wilson-Gerow et al. 1
• Study of vector fields in maximally symmetric spaces by Allen & Jacobson 22
• Calculation of Weyl tensor two-point functions by Kouris 24

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that makes important contributions at the intersection of quantum gravity and cosmology. The author employs rigorous mathematical methods to address a problem of profound physical significance, providing new perspectives for understanding quantum effects in curved spacetime. Despite certain technical limitations, its theoretical value and methodological innovation make it an important advance in the field.