Evolution of Pulse width modulation techniques of modular multilevel converter

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.00386
• Title: Evolution of Pulse width modulation techniques of modular multilevel converter
• Authors: Khushbu Saradva, Meeta Matnani, Tapankumar Trivedi
• Classification: hep-ex cond-mat.supr-con physics.soc-ph
• Publication Date: April 2018, IJIRT Volume 4 Issue 11
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.00386

Abstract

The Modular Multilevel Converter (MMC) is a promising converter technology applicable to various high-voltage, high-power applications. Its advantages lie in achieving low-distortion output at low average switching frequencies without requiring output filters. This paper evaluates pulse-width modulation (PWM) based control methods for modular multilevel converters, employing multi-carrier PWM techniques including Phase Disposition PWM (PDPWM), Phase Opposition Disposition PWM (PODPWM), and Alternate Phase Opposition Disposition PWM (APODPWM), with comparative analysis based on load voltage and current output quality. The paper presents simulation of single-phase modular multilevel converters based on half-bridge submodule topology, with various modulation techniques simulated using MATLAB/Simulink and results analyzed.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Problems to be Addressed: Traditional high-power converters face the following challenges in high-voltage, high-power applications:
   • Requirement for line-frequency transformers to step up voltage or current levels, resulting in bulky equipment
   • Generation of DC flux offset during single-phase ground faults
   • High switching losses and poor electromagnetic compatibility
2. Problem Significance:
   • High-power applications such as DC interconnections, DC microgrids, and offshore wind power generation require precise power flow control and efficient power conversion
   • Urgent need to reduce operational costs and environmental impact
3. Limitations of Existing Methods:
   • Complex topology of traditional multilevel converters
   • High switching frequency leading to increased losses
   • High harmonic content affecting power quality
4. Research Motivation: MMC possesses advantages including modular structure, distributed voltage stress, approximate stepped sinusoidal waveforms, and low harmonics. By comparing different PWM modulation techniques, its performance can be optimized.

Core Contributions

1. Systematic evaluation of multi-carrier PWM modulation techniques for MMC, including three main methods: PDPWM, PODPWM, and APODPWM
2. Establishment of single-phase MMC simulation model based on half-bridge submodules, providing complete mathematical modeling and equivalent circuits
3. Comprehensive performance comparative analysis based on total harmonic distortion (THD) metrics of load voltage and current
4. Detailed simulation results validating the performance of different modulation techniques in 3-level and 5-level MMCs

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigate the effects of different pulse-width modulation techniques on the output voltage and current quality of modular multilevel converters, comparing the performance of three modulation strategies (PDPWM, PODPWM, and APODPWM) through simulation.

MMC Structure and Modeling

1. Overall Architecture

• Three-phase MMC structure: Each phase contains two arms, with each arm composed of series-connected submodules and series inductance
• Submodule configuration: Half-bridge topology employed, containing switching half-bridge and capacitor
• Control mechanism: Insertion or bypass of specific submodules through control of relevant half-bridges

2. Mathematical Modeling

Based on single-phase equivalent circuit, the characteristic equations of MMC are:

Arm current equations:

i_pj = i_vj/2 + i_diffj  ... (1)
i_nj = -i_vj/2 + i_diffj ... (2)

Differential current definition:

i_diffj = (i_pj + i_nj)/2 ... (3)

System characteristic equations:

u_vj = e_j - R_0·i_vj - L_0·(di_vj/dt) ... (4)
U_dc/2 = (u_pj + u_nj)/2 + L_0·(di_diffj/dt) + R_0·i_diffj ... (5)

Internal electromotive force:

e_j = (u_nj - u_pj)/2 ... (6)

3. Half-Bridge Submodule Operation

• State 1: S1 conducting, S2 blocking → Output voltage = V_c
• State 2: S1 blocking, S2 conducting → Output voltage = 0
• Submodule capacitor charges or discharges based on switching state and current direction

Multi-Carrier PWM Modulation Strategies

1. Modulation Index Definition

Amplitude modulation index:

m_a = A_r / ((m-1)·A_c/2) ... (1)

Frequency modulation index:

m_f = f_c / f_r ... (2)

2. Phase Disposition PWM (PDPWM)

• Upper and lower arms employ two different carrier sets
• Carrier amplitude is V_dc/N, continuously distributed within V_dc range
• All carriers in-phase

3. Phase Opposition Disposition PWM (PODPWM)

• Upper and lower arms employ single carrier group
• Carriers above zero reference line phase-shifted 180° from those below
• Simplified control complexity

4. Alternate Phase Opposition Disposition PWM (APODPWM)

• Upper and lower arms employ single carrier group
• Adjacent carrier bands phase-shifted 180° from each other
• Same carrier frequency with adjustable amplitude

Experimental Setup

Simulation Parameters

Evaluation Metrics

• Total Harmonic Distortion (THD): Measures harmonic content of output voltage and current
• FFT Analysis: Frequency domain characteristic analysis
• Waveform Quality: Time-domain characteristics of output voltage and current

Simulation Tools

MATLAB/Simulink employed for modeling and simulation, with performance testing conducted on 3-level and 5-level MMCs.

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. THD Performance Comparison

According to simulation results, current THD performance of different modulation techniques:

• PD modulation technique: THD range 0.97% - 1.40%
• POD modulation technique: Good THD performance
• PSC modulation technique: Excellent performance under specific conditions

2. Effect of Level Number

• 3-level MMC: Basic multilevel output with relatively high THD
• 5-level MMC: Better waveform quality with significantly reduced THD

3. Waveform Analysis

• Output voltage exhibits stepped waveform approximating sinusoidal shape
• Waveform becomes smoother with increased level number
• Different modulation techniques exhibit variations in harmonic distribution

FFT Analysis Results

FFT analysis in simulation demonstrates:

• Fundamental component dominates
• High-order harmonics effectively suppressed
• Different modulation strategies exhibit varying harmonic performance at specific frequency points

Case Analysis

Through specific voltage and current waveforms, the following observations are made:

• PD modulation produces output voltage with good symmetry
• POD modulation further reduces harmonics under certain operating conditions
• Load current exhibits approximately sinusoidal waveform with THD controlled at low levels

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. MMC topology optimization: Including various submodule configurations such as full-bridge and half-bridge
2. Control strategy research: Carrier phase-shift, capacitor voltage balancing, etc.
3. Application field expansion: FACTS, HVDC, motor drives, etc.

Relationship to Related Work

• Based on MMC topology proposed by Lesnicar and Marquardt in 2003
• Extends comparative research on multi-carrier PWM techniques
• Provides simulation verification for practical engineering applications

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. MMC technology demonstrates significant advantages: Achieving high-quality output at low switching frequencies
2. Modulation technique impacts performance: Different PWM strategies exhibit variations in THD and waveform quality
3. Level number enhancement shows obvious effects: 5-level MMC demonstrates superior harmonic suppression compared to 3-level MMC
4. Simulation validates theoretical analysis: MATLAB/Simulink simulation results confirm design effectiveness

Limitations

1. Single-phase system only: Does not address inter-phase coupling effects in three-phase systems
2. Idealized assumptions: Neglects switching losses, conduction voltage drops, and other practical factors
3. Limited load types: Only RL loads tested, lacking verification with other load types
4. Narrow parameter range: Testing range for modulation index, frequency index, and other parameters relatively limited

Future Directions

1. Fundamental frequency modulation techniques: Such as optimized harmonic stepped waveforms and selective harmonic elimination
2. Three-phase system extension: Considering inter-phase balance and coupling effects
3. Practical engineering verification: Transition from simulation to experimental and engineering applications
4. Intelligent control algorithms: Incorporating artificial intelligence techniques to optimize control strategies

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong systematicity: Comprehensive comparison of three main multi-carrier PWM techniques
2. Solid theoretical foundation: Complete mathematical modeling and analysis provided
3. Sufficient simulation verification: Detailed verification using industry-standard simulation tools
4. High practical value: Provides valuable reference data for engineering applications
5. Clear quantified results: Specific THD values and other metrics facilitate engineering judgment

Weaknesses

1. Limited novelty: Primarily comparative analysis of existing techniques lacking original contributions
2. Insufficient experimental depth: Lacks parameter sensitivity analysis and robustness testing
3. Inadequate theoretical analysis: Limited theoretical explanation for performance differences among modulation techniques
4. Single application scenario: Considers only idealized simulation environment without practical operating conditions

Impact

1. Academic contribution: Provides baseline comparative data for MMC modulation technique research
2. Engineering value: Guides selection of modulation strategies for practical MMC systems
3. Reproducibility: Detailed simulation parameters facilitate result reproduction by other researchers
4. Educational significance: Suitable as introductory material for MMC technology learning

Applicable Scenarios

1. High-voltage DC transmission: Voltage source converters in HVDC systems
2. Flexible AC transmission: Static synchronous compensators in FACTS devices
3. Renewable energy grid integration: Distributed power source connection for wind and solar power
4. Motor drive systems: Variable frequency drive applications for high-power motors

References

The paper cites 12 important references covering fundamental MMC theory, control strategies, and application domains, providing solid theoretical foundation for the research. Primarily references pioneering work by scholars such as Hirofumi Akagi in MMC classification and applications.

Overall Assessment: This is a foundational technical comparison paper that, while limited in novelty, provides valuable simulation data and analysis results for engineering applications of MMC pulse-width modulation techniques. The paper features clear structure and reliable methodology, making it suitable as introductory reference material in this field.