Efficient Relational Context Perception for Knowledge Graph Completion

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.00397
• Title: Efficient Relational Context Perception for Knowledge Graph Completion
• Authors: Wenkai Tu, Guojia Wan, Zhengchun Shang, Bo Du (Wuhan University)
• Classification: cs.LG cs.AI cs.CL
• Publication Date: December 31, 2024 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.00397

Abstract

Knowledge graphs (KGs) provide structured knowledge representation but typically suffer from incompleteness. Link prediction or knowledge graph completion (KGC) aims to infer missing facts based on existing knowledge. Existing knowledge graph embedding models have limited capacity in capturing expressive features and assign single static embeddings to each entity and relation, overlooking the fact that entities and relations may exhibit different behaviors across different graph contexts. Due to the complex contextual nature of knowledge graph fact triples, existing methods must utilize complex nonlinear context encoders (such as Transformers) to project entities and relations into low-dimensional representations, resulting in high computational costs. To overcome these limitations, this paper proposes a Triple Receptive Field Perception (TRP) architecture to model sequential information and enable learning of dynamic contexts for entities and relations. Tensor decomposition is then employed to compute triple scores, providing powerful relational decoding capability. This integration enables more expressive representations. Experiments on link prediction and triple classification tasks across benchmark datasets including YAGO3-10, UMLS, FB15k, and FB13 demonstrate that the method outperforms multiple state-of-the-art models.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

Knowledge graph completion (KGC) is an important research problem aimed at inferring missing facts in knowledge graphs. Knowledge graphs are typically represented as triples (head entity, relation, tail entity), but real-world knowledge graphs often contain numerous missing relations, limiting their effectiveness in applications such as question answering systems and recommendation systems.

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Limited Expressiveness: Traditional knowledge graph embedding methods primarily rely on additive or multiplicative operations, resulting in limited expressive capacity
2. Static Embeddings: Existing methods assign single static embeddings to each entity and relation, ignoring their different behaviors across different contexts
3. High Computational Cost: Transformer-based methods, while effective, suffer from scalability issues and high computational costs
4. Insufficient Context Modeling: Lack of effective modeling capability for complex relational contexts

Research Motivation

The core motivation of this work is to design a knowledge graph completion method that can capture dynamic contextual information while maintaining computational efficiency. By combining the advantages of sequential modeling and tensor decomposition, the method achieves a better performance-efficiency trade-off.

Core Contributions

1. Proposed Triple Receptive Field Perception (TRP) Architecture: A novel encoder capable of effectively modeling sequential information and dynamic contexts in knowledge graphs
2. Integrated Tucker Decomposition Decoder: Provides powerful relational decoding capability, enabling compact yet expressive relational structure representation
3. Achieved Better Performance-Efficiency Balance: Compared to complex methods like Transformers, significantly reduces computational costs while maintaining competitive performance
4. Achieved State-of-the-Art Results on Multiple Benchmark Datasets: Outperforms existing methods on both link prediction and triple classification tasks

Method Details

Task Definition

Given incomplete triples (h, r, ?) or (?, r, t) in a knowledge graph, the objective is to predict the missing tail or head entity. Formally, for a triple (h, r, t), the model needs to learn a scoring function φ(h, r, t) to measure the likelihood of the triple being true.

Model Architecture

1. Triple Receptive Field Perception (TRP) Encoder

The TRP architecture comprises multiple residual blocks, each containing two key sub-modules:

Time Mixing Module:

ot = Wo · (σ(rt) ⊙ wkvt)
rt = Wr · (μr ⊙ xt + (1-μr) ⊙ xt-1)

where wkvt is computed through the following recursive approach:

wkvt = (at-1 + e^(u+kt) ⊙ vt) / (bt-1 + e^(u+kt))
at = e^(-w) ⊙ at-1 + e^kt ⊙ vt  
bt = e^(-w) ⊙ bt-1 + e^kt

Channel Mixing Module:

r't = Wr' · (μ'r x't + (1-μ'r)x't-1)
k't = Wk' · (μ'k x't + (1-μ'k)x't-1)  
o't = σ(r't) · (Wv' ⊙ max(k't, 0)²)

Module Integration:

x' = x + Dropout(TimeMixing(LayerNorm(x)))
x'' = x' + Dropout(ChannelMixing(LayerNorm(x')))

2. Tucker Decomposition Decoder

Tucker decomposition is employed as the decoder to compute triple scores:

φ(h, r, t) = Wc ×1 ẽh ×2 ẽr ×3 et

where Wc ∈ R^(d×d×d) is a learnable core tensor, and ×n denotes n-mode tensor product.

Technical Innovations

1. Dynamic Context Modeling: TRP enables entity and relation embeddings to dynamically adjust according to different contexts through sequential modeling mechanisms
2. Efficient Recursive Computation: Achieves efficient inference through recursive formulas, avoiding the quadratic complexity of Transformers
3. Causality Preservation: Design ensures causality during inference, allowing the model to perform inference as efficiently as RNNs
4. Tensor Decomposition Integration: Tucker decomposition provides parameter-efficient and expressive relational modeling capability

Experimental Setup

Datasets

Four standard benchmark datasets are employed:

Evaluation Metrics

• Mean Reciprocal Rank (MRR): MRR = 1/|S| Σ(1/ranki)
• Hits@k: Proportion of correct answers ranked in top k
• Accuracy: Used for triple classification tasks

Baseline Methods

Triple-only Methods: TransE, DistMult, ComplEx, RotatE, TuckER, ConvE, CoKE, HAKE, HousE

Context-aware Methods: Neural-LP, R-GCN, Rlogic, ChatRule

Implementation Details

• Embedding dimensions: {64, 96, 128, 192, 256}
• Number of TRP blocks: {2, 4, 6, 8}
• Dropout rate: {0.2, 0.3, 0.4, 0.5}
• Optimizer: Adam
• Learning rate: 0.0005-0.01
• Batch size: 512
• Maximum training epochs: 500

Experimental Results

Main Results

Link Prediction Results:

Triple Classification Results:

Ablation Study

Ablation studies on FB15k and YAGO3-10 demonstrate that:

• Removing Tucker decomposition decoder: 2-3 MRR point performance drop
• Removing TRP encoder: Significant 6-10 MRR point performance drop
• The combination of both components achieves optimal performance

Parameter Efficiency Analysis

• Parameter Count: TRP requires significantly fewer parameters compared to Transformers
• Training Time: TRP exhibits shorter per-epoch training time with slower growth as hop count increases
• Performance Comparison: TRP demonstrates superior efficiency at comparable performance levels

Visualization Analysis

• Entity Embeddings: t-SNE visualization shows entities of different categories forming clearly separated clusters
• Relation Embeddings: Symmetric relations and their inverses cluster tightly, while asymmetric relations distribute more sparsely, demonstrating TRP's effective modeling of different semantic relations

Related Work

Knowledge Graph Embedding Methods Classification

1. Translation Models: TransE, TransH, TransR, RotatE, etc., establishing linear translation rules from head to tail entities
2. Semantic Matching Models: RESCAL, DistMult, ComplEx, TuckER, etc., using various scoring functions to measure embedding similarity
3. Neural Network Models: ConvE, R-GCN, CoKE, etc., employing deep learning to obtain expressive representations

Relationship to Related Work

This work combines the advantages of sequential modeling and tensor decomposition, offering stronger expressiveness compared to pure translation models while maintaining higher efficiency than complex neural network models, achieving a better balance between performance and efficiency.

Conclusion and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. The TRP architecture effectively models dynamic contextual information in knowledge graphs
2. Tucker decomposition provides parameter-efficient relational decoding capability
3. The combination of both achieves excellent performance across multiple benchmark datasets
4. Demonstrates superior parameter efficiency compared to methods like Transformers

Limitations

1. Dataset Scale: Primarily validated on medium-scale datasets; effectiveness on ultra-large-scale knowledge graphs requires further verification
2. Relation Types: Modeling capability for certain complex relation patterns may have room for improvement
3. Multi-hop Reasoning: The paper primarily focuses on single-hop link prediction; multi-hop reasoning capability requires further research

Future Directions

1. Extension to larger-scale knowledge graphs
2. Integration of external textual information to enhance representation learning
3. Exploration of applications in multi-hop reasoning tasks
4. Investigation of combination with large language models

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong Technical Innovation: The TRP architecture cleverly combines advantages of RNNs and attention mechanisms, achieving efficient sequential modeling
2. Comprehensive Experiments: Thorough evaluation across multiple datasets and tasks, including ablation studies and visualization analysis
3. High Practical Value: Significantly improves computational efficiency while maintaining competitive performance, demonstrating strong practical utility
4. Clear Presentation: Well-structured paper with accurate technical descriptions, facilitating understanding and reproduction

Weaknesses

1. Insufficient Theoretical Analysis: Lacks deep theoretical analysis of why the TRP architecture is effective
2. Limited Large-Scale Validation: Primarily validated on medium-scale datasets; lacks experiments on truly large-scale knowledge graphs
3. Relatively Limited Baseline Comparisons: Missing comparisons with some recent strong baseline methods
4. Insufficient Error Analysis: Lacks in-depth analysis of model failure cases

Impact

1. Academic Contribution: Provides new efficient modeling approaches for the knowledge graph completion field
2. Practical Value: The method's efficiency makes it highly promising for real-world applications
3. Reproducibility: Detailed technical descriptions and clear experimental settings ensure good reproducibility

Applicable Scenarios

1. Resource-Constrained Environments: Applications requiring good performance with limited computational resources
2. Real-Time Inference Requirements: Knowledge graph query and reasoning tasks requiring rapid responses
3. Dynamic Knowledge Graphs: Knowledge graph applications requiring frequent updates and incremental learning
4. Edge Computing: Deployment of knowledge graph applications on mobile or edge devices

References

The paper cites important literature in the knowledge graph completion field, including:

• TransE (Bordes et al., 2013): Pioneering work on translation models
• TuckER (Balažević et al., 2019): Application of Tucker decomposition in knowledge graphs
• CoKE (Wang et al., 2019): Transformer-based contextualized knowledge graph embeddings
• RWKV (Peng et al., 2023): Inspiration source for the TRP architecture

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality knowledge graph completion paper that proposes a TRP architecture with significant technical innovations and comprehensive experimental validation, achieving a good balance between performance and efficiency. The paper's main contribution lies in introducing sequential modeling concepts to knowledge graph completion, providing new research directions for the field. While there is room for improvement in theoretical analysis and large-scale validation, it represents valuable research work overall.