Analysis of nonlinear dynamics in a single magnetic pendulum driven by plate-magnet interaction

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.00454
• Title: Analysis of nonlinear dynamics in a single magnetic pendulum driven by plate-magnet interaction
• Authors: Hoang X. Nguyen (Hanoi-Amsterdam High School for the Gifted), Duy V. Nguyen (Phenikaa University)
• Classification: physics.class-ph (Classical Physics), nlin.PS (Nonlinear Science)
• Publication Date: December 31, 2024
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.00454

Abstract

This paper provides a theoretical analysis of the nonlinear dynamics of a ferromagnetic pendulum consisting of a cylindrical neodymium magnet pendulum oscillating toward a metal plate. The oscillatory heavy damping of the pendulum is caused by eddy currents induced in the metal plate. The paper proposes a mathematical model to describe the braking force acting on the magnetic pendulum and its nonlinear motion.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

This research addresses the nonlinear dynamics of magnetic pendulums in magnetic braking systems, particularly the complex damping phenomena that occur when a neodymium magnet pendulum approaches a conductive metal plate.

Significance

1. Educational Value: Magnetic braking experiments are frequently used in physics demonstrations and scientific exhibitions, requiring quantitative theoretical models
2. Engineering Applications: Magnetic braking has widespread applications in engineering, such as magnetic dampers and eddy current brakes
3. Nonlinear Dynamics: The system exhibits rich nonlinear phenomena, ranging from damped oscillations to chaotic motion

Limitations of Existing Research

Existing literature primarily focuses on:

• Braking of magnets falling through conductive tubes
• Thomson jumping phenomena
• Unipolar motor effects

However, it lacks quantitative theoretical analysis of the interaction between magnetic pendulums and metal plates.

Research Motivation

The paper was inspired by a YouTube video demonstrating the rapid cessation of a neodymium magnet pendulum approaching a copper plate. The authors sought to establish a quantitative theory to explain this phenomenon.

Core Contributions

1. Established a comprehensive mathematical model: Derived the braking force expression for the interaction between a magnetic pendulum and metal plate from Maxwell's equations
2. Proposed a nonlinear damping function η(φ): Quantified the relationship between braking force and pendulum angle
3. Numerically solved the nonlinear equations of motion: Employed the fourth-order Runge-Kutta method to solve the system dynamics
4. Revealed two-stage motion characteristics: Discovered that the system exhibits two distinct stages: free oscillation and rapid braking

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Input: Initial pendulum angle φ(0), system physical parameters (magnetic moment Pm, mass M, pendulum length L, metal plate conductivity σ) Output: Time evolution of pendulum angle φ(t) and angular velocity φ̇(t) Constraints: Motion is confined to the Oxz plane; the metal plate is a semi-infinite thin plate

Theoretical Framework

1. Magnetic Braking Force Calculation

The system treats the magnet as a magnetic dipole with magnetic moment:

P⃗m = Pm(-cosφẑ + sinφx̂)

According to Faraday's law, the moving magnet induces an electric field in the metal plate:

E⃗ ≈ -∂A⃗/∂t

where the magnetic vector potential is:

A⃗(r) = km(P⃗m × r⃗)/r³

2. Eddy Current Calculation

Eddy current density is calculated using Ohm's law:

j⃗ = σE⃗

The electric field components are expressed as complex functions with fifth-order denominators (Equation 8).

3. Interaction Force

The magnetic field produced by eddy currents is calculated using the Biot-Savart law, and the interaction force is then computed using the energy method:

W = -½P⃗m · B⃗
F⃗ = -∇⃗W

4. Equation of Motion

The final nonlinear differential equation is:

φ̈ + (σkm²Pm²)/(2ML²)η(φ)φ̇ + (g/L)sinφ = 0

where η(φ) is a complex integral function describing how the damping coefficient varies with pendulum angle.

Technical Innovations

1. Complete electromagnetic theory derivation: Derived the magnetic braking force expression from first principles
2. Nonlinear damping function η(φ): Discovered and quantified the strongly nonlinear characteristics of the damping coefficient
3. Two-stage dynamics analysis: Revealed different dynamical behaviors of the system in different pendulum angle ranges

Experimental Setup

Physical Parameters

• Magnetic moment of magnet: Pm = 1.29 Am²
• Mass of magnet: M = 10 g
• Pendulum length: L = 1 m
• Copper plate conductivity: σ = 5.85×10⁸ S/m
• Plate thickness: δ = 1×10⁻³ m
• Initial conditions: φ(0) = 0.33 rad, φ̇(0) = 0

Numerical Method

The fourth-order Runge-Kutta method (RK4) was used to solve the nonlinear differential equation.

Evaluation Metrics

Model predictions were evaluated through the time evolution of φ(t), φ̇(t), and braking force Fφ(t).

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Damping Function Characteristics

The η(φ) function exhibits strong nonlinear characteristics:

• Vertical asymptote exists at φ = 0.02
• Rapidly approaches horizontal asymptote for φ > 0.05
• Maximum value approximately 1750 (dimensionless)

2. Two-Stage Motion Characteristics

Numerical solutions reveal two distinct stages in the system:

First Stage (0 < t < 0.48s):

• Braking force Fφ ≈ 0
• System behaves as free oscillation of an ordinary pendulum
• Pendulum angle decreases slowly from 0.33 rad

Second Stage (0.48s < t < 0.58s):

• Braking force increases sharply (reaching order of -100 N)
• Pendulum stops rapidly within approximately 0.1 seconds
• Consistent with observations in the YouTube video

3. Dynamical Evolution

• φ(t): Monotonically decreases, approaching zero near 0.58s
• φ̇(t): Changes slowly initially, then rapidly approaches zero
• Fφ(t): Remains near zero for extended periods, then increases sharply at the end

Physical Mechanism Analysis

Results indicate that when the pendulum angle is small (φ < 0.05), η(φ) increases sharply, leading to significantly enhanced braking force. This explains the "instantaneous stopping" phenomenon observed when the magnet approaches the metal plate.

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. Braking of magnets in conductive tubes: Series of works by Donoso et al.
2. Thomson jumping phenomena: Research by Tjossem and Cornejo
3. Unipolar motor effects: Teaching experiments by Wong et al.
4. Magnetic pendulum experiments: Recent research applications in physics education

Advantages of This Work

Compared to existing work, this paper provides the first complete quantitative theory for the magnetic pendulum-metal plate system, filling a theoretical gap in the field.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully established a comprehensive theoretical model for the interaction between a magnetic pendulum and metal plate
2. Discovered two-stage dynamical characteristics of the system: free oscillation and rapid braking
3. The nonlinear damping function η(φ) is key to understanding system behavior

Limitations

1. Theoretical approximations: Neglected gradient terms of the electrostatic potential, which may affect accuracy in certain cases
2. Geometric simplifications: Assumed the metal plate is semi-infinite and thin; boundary effects from finite-sized plates in actual experiments may be significant
3. Lack of experimental validation: The paper provides only theoretical analysis without comparison to experimental data

Future Directions

1. Experimental verification of theoretical predictions
2. Consider boundary effects of finite-sized metal plates
3. Investigate the effects of different materials and geometric parameters on system dynamics

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical rigor: Complete derivation from Maxwell's equations with solid physical foundations
2. Mathematical treatment: Appropriate handling of complex integral expressions and numerical solution methods
3. Physical insights: Discovery of nonlinear characteristics of the η(φ) function, explaining the "instantaneous stopping" phenomenon
4. Educational value: Provides quantitative theoretical basis for physics demonstration experiments

Weaknesses

1. Absence of experiments: Lacks experimental data for validation; accuracy of theoretical predictions remains to be confirmed
2. Parameter sensitivity: No analysis of model sensitivity to various physical parameters
3. Scope of applicability: Does not clearly discuss the applicable conditions and limitations of the theoretical model

Impact

1. Academic contribution: Provides a new theoretical framework for the magnetic braking field
2. Educational value: Can serve as a teaching case for nonlinear dynamics and electromagnetism
3. Application potential: Provides theoretical guidance for magnetic damper design

Applicable Scenarios

• Theoretical analysis of physics demonstration experiments
• Design and optimization of magnetic braking systems
• Research cases for nonlinear dynamical systems

References

The paper cites 18 relevant references covering important works in magnetic braking, Thomson jumping, unipolar motors, and related fields, as well as electromagnetism textbooks and numerical computation methods. The citation is comprehensive and appropriate.