Multiparticle States for the Flat Hologram

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.00462
• Title: Multiparticle States for the Flat Hologram
• Authors: Justin Kulp (Stony Brook University), Sabrina Pasterski (Perimeter Institute)
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Publication Date: December 31, 2024
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.00462

Abstract

This paper revisits the spectrum of operators in Celestial Conformal Field Theory (Celestial CFT) using the extrapolate dictionary. Under the celestial CFT mapping, each state in the 4D Hilbert space should map to a state in the 2D Hilbert space. This implies that beyond the familiar single-particle states/operators, multiparticle operators should appear in the celestial operator product expansion (OPE). The authors construct composite primary operators from both the Carroll and celestial perspectives, extending the existing flat space dictionary. In this process, they elucidate subtle aspects of deriving the Poincaré primary conditions from the Carroll limit, clarify the compatibility of principal series representations with highest weight representations and unitarity in celestial CFT, and discuss how celestial OPE block expansions emerge from the 2D CFT perspective.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problems

Flat space holography studies quantum gravity in asymptotically flat spacetime by encoding observables in a lower-dimensional dual theory. The core problems this research addresses are:

1. Completeness of the operator spectrum: The existing flat space holography dictionary primarily focuses on single-particle states, but a complete theory should include multiparticle states
2. State-operator correspondence: In 2D CFT, completeness of the Hilbert space requires the existence of operators that create multiparticle states
3. OPE consistency: The absence of multiparticle operators would violate the associativity of the OPE

Significance

1. Theoretical completeness: Establishing a complete flat space holographic correspondence requires understanding all possible boundary operators
2. Scattering theory: Multiparticle states are crucial for describing complex scattering processes
3. Infrared structure: Understanding a unified description of soft theorems, memory effects, and asymptotic symmetries

Limitations of Existing Approaches

1. Single-particle restriction: Previous work focused primarily on the celestial CFT description of single-particle states
2. Mass problem: The Carroll approach encounters difficulties when handling massive states
3. Representation theory: The reduction from Poincaré group representations to SL(2,ℂ) representations lacks systematic understanding

Core Contributions

1. Construction of multiparticle celestial operators: Systematically constructed composite primary operators from both Carroll CFT and celestial CFT perspectives
2. Clarification of representation theory issues: Resolved apparent contradictions between principal series representations and highest weight representations
3. Establishment of OPE block expansions: Provided two complementary approaches for multiparticle states in celestial CFT
4. Extension of the flat space dictionary: Generalized the bulk-to-boundary propagator method to the multiparticle case
5. Demonstration of Carroll-to-celestial mapping: Showed how dimensional reduction extends to multiparticle operators

Detailed Methodology

Carroll CFT Approach

Carroll Primary Operator Definition

In the zero-curvature limit, the authors define the transformation law of Carroll primary operators:

δξΦ(k,k̄)(u, z, z̄) = [(f + uα)∂u + Y∂ + k∂Y + Ȳ∂̄ + k̄∂̄Ȳ]Φ(k,k̄)(u, z, z̄)

where the weight relations are: k = ½(1 + J), k̄ = ½(1 - J)

Composite Operator Construction

For the n = 0, ℓ = 0 case:

[O₁O₂]₀,₀ = O₁O₂

In the Carroll limit this becomes:

:Φ(k₁,k̄₁)Φ(k₂,k̄₂): = Φ(k₁+k₂,k̄₁+k̄₂)

For the n = 0, ℓ = 1 case, the construction includes derivative composite operators:

[O₁O₂]₀,₁;μ = Δ₂(∂μO₁)O₂ - Δ₁O₁(∂μO₂)

Celestial CFT Approach

Representation Theory Framework

The unitary irreducible representations of the Poincaré group decompose into SL(2,ℂ) representations:

V₀,σ ≅ ∫⊕λ∈ℝ dλ μ₀,σ(λ)W₁₊ᵢλ,σ
Vₘ,s ≅ ∫⊕λ∈ℝ dλ ∑ⱼ₌₋ₛˢ μₘ,s(λ,J)W₁₊ᵢλ,J

OPE Block Method

The celestial OPE block expansion takes the form:

Oᴿ¹(z₁,z̄₁)Oᴿ²(z₂,z̄₂) = ∫dR d²zₚ ⟨Oᴿ¹(z₁,z̄₁)Oᴿ²(z₂,z̄₂)Õᴿ(zₚ,z̄ₚ)⟩Oᴿ(zₚ,z̄ₚ)

Momentum Space Partial Wave Method

Utilizing the momentum space partial wave expansion:

⟨ω₁,z₁,z̄₁;ω₂,z₂,z̄₂|M,y,z,z̄,S,σ⟩ = (ω₁²ω₂/E)^(-1/2) Yσₛ(z₁,z̄₁) × δ⁽⁴⁾(Mp̂μ(y,z,z̄) - ω₁qμ(z₁,z̄₁) - ω₂qμ(z₂,z̄₂))

Technical Innovations

1. Distribution state handling: Proper treatment of δ-normalized states in representation theory
2. Channel labeling: Introduction of channel indices to distinguish operators with identical quantum numbers from different Poincaré representations
3. Shadow transform: Utilization of shadow transforms to resolve technical issues with principal series representations
4. Mass handling: Unified treatment of massive and massless particles within the celestial framework

Experimental Verification and Theoretical Analysis

Verification of Carroll Limit

The authors verify the behavior of double-trace operators from AdS/CFT in the flat space limit:

n = 0 case: Composite operators satisfy Carroll primary conditions n = 1 case: Discovery of nontrivial multiplet structure under Carroll boost

Representation Theory Consistency

Proof of the following key results:

1. Action of translation operators in the z-basis: Δ → Δ + 1
2. Compatibility of principal series representations with highest weight representations
3. Euclidean unitarity of celestial CFT

Pole Structure of OPE Blocks

For three-point functions of two massless scalars and one massive scalar:

⟨O_Δ₁O_Δ₂Õᵐ_Δ⟩ = N/(Δ-1) K^(Δ₁,Δ₂,Δ̃) B((Δ₁₂+1-Δ)/2, (Δ₂₁+1-Δ)/2)

Pole positions: Δ± = 1 + 2k ± iν₁₂, k ∈ ℤ≥₀

Related Work

Celestial Holography

• Pasterski, Shao, Strominger (2017): Established the foundational celestial CFT framework
• Strominger (2021): Discovered the w₁₊∞ algebra structure
• Costello, Paquette (2022): Developed chiral algebra bootstrap

Carroll CFT

• Ciambelli et al. (2018): Established Carroll fluid dynamics
• Donnay et al. (2022): Developed connections between Carroll and celestial holography

Multiparticle State Research

• Fitzpatrick, Kaplan (2012): Multiparticle states in AdS/CFT
• Guevara (2021): Celestial OPE blocks
• Ball, Hu, Pasterski (2024): Multi-collinear singularities

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Complete operator spectrum: Celestial CFT must include continuous and discrete families of multiparticle operators
2. Unified representation theory: Poincaré representations and SL(2,ℂ) representations are unified through channel indices
3. OPE consistency: The existence of multiparticle operators ensures the associativity of the OPE

Limitations

1. Mass problem in Carroll method: Technical difficulties in preparing massive states within the Carroll framework
2. Infrared divergences: Soft divergences and memory effects in the theory require further treatment
3. Missing dynamics: Focus on kinematic structure with lack of complete dynamical description

Future Directions

1. OPE coefficient calculations: Computation of OPE coefficients between multiparticle operators
2. Bootstrap equations: Establishment of complete bootstrap equations for celestial CFT
3. Memory effects: Incorporation of memory effects into the multiparticle operator framework
4. Quantum gravity applications: Application to specific quantum gravity theories

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical completeness: Systematically addresses the multiparticle state problem in flat space holography
2. Methodological diversity: Provides three complementary methods for constructing multiparticle operators
3. Mathematical rigor: Provides rigorous mathematical treatment at the representation theory level
4. Problem resolution: Clarifies confusion in the literature regarding principal series representations

Weaknesses

1. Computational complexity: Concrete OPE coefficient calculations remain challenging
2. Physical intuition: Physical meaning of certain mathematical constructions requires further clarification
3. Experimental verification: Lacks direct connection to specific physical processes

Impact

1. Theoretical foundation: Provides solid theoretical foundation for flat space holography
2. Methodology: Established methods can be generalized to other holographic correspondences
3. Interdisciplinary: Connects CFT, representation theory, and scattering theory

Applicable Scenarios

1. High energy physics theory: Quantum gravity and scattering amplitude research
2. Mathematical physics: Infinite-dimensional Lie algebras and representation theory
3. Cosmology: Quantum effects in asymptotically flat spacetime

References

This paper cites 216 relevant references, covering major works in celestial holography, Carroll CFT, representation theory, and scattering theory, providing a comprehensive literature review for the field.

Summary of Technical Points:

• Established a complete theoretical framework for multiparticle celestial operators
• Resolved key technical problems in Poincaré group representation theory
• Laid the foundation for further development of flat space holography
• Provided a unified perspective connecting different approaches