2025-11-13T13:13:11.278536

DW-genesis: generating the baryon number from domain walls

Vanvlasselaer
We show that axionic domain walls, when they couple to the lepton number, can generate a net baryon and lepton number through the mechanism of spontaneous baryogenesis. We study systematically the baryon asymmetry produced by these domain walls (DWs) at annihilation, and refer to this process as DW-genesis. We find that the baryon number is maximised when the DW network collapses approximately at the moment when the $L$-violating interaction decouples. We explore the expected gravitational wave signal from the DW network annihilation and the prospects for detecting it, but conclude that successful DW-genesis is typically in tension with observable GW signal. Morever, we briefly discuss a possible suppression induced by the cancellation between the asymmetry created by "opposite" axionic domain walls attached to the string.
academic

DW-genesis: generating the baryon number from domain walls

Basic Information

  • Paper ID: 2501.00491
  • Title: DW-genesis: generating the baryon number from domain walls
  • Author: Miguel Vanvlasselaer (Vrije Universiteit Brussel)
  • Classification: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology)
  • Conference: 9th Symposium on Prospects in the Physics of Discrete Symmetries (DISCRETE2024), Ljubljana, Slovenia
  • Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.00491

Abstract

This paper proposes a novel baryon genesis mechanism—DW-genesis—that generates net baryon and lepton numbers through the coupling of axion domain walls with lepton number under spontaneous baryon genesis. The study systematically analyzes the baryon asymmetry generated during domain wall annihilation, finding that the baryon number reaches its maximum when the domain wall network collapses at the moment when lepton-number-violating interactions decouple. The paper also explores gravitational wave signals produced by domain wall network annihilation and their detection prospects, concluding that successful DW-genesis typically exhibits tension with observable gravitational wave signals.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Issues

  1. Cosmic Baryon Asymmetry Problem: The observed cosmic baryon asymmetry parameter YΔB≈(8.69±0.22)×10−11Y_{\Delta B} \approx (8.69 \pm 0.22) \times 10^{-11} cannot be explained through initial conditions within the inflationary paradigm, requiring a dynamical baryon genesis mechanism.
  2. Detection Challenges in High-Scale Baryon Genesis: Most baryon genesis mechanisms involve energy scales far exceeding the electroweak scale, making them difficult to probe with terrestrial experiments.
  3. New Opportunities in Gravitational Wave Detection: Recent theoretical efforts have linked baryon genesis to possible gravitational wave backgrounds, providing new pathways for indirect detection of high-energy physics processes.

Research Motivation

Domain walls in axion models, as topological defects, naturally form in the early universe and eventually annihilate, providing an ideal non-equilibrium environment for baryon genesis. This work aims to establish a unified framework that can simultaneously explain cosmic baryon asymmetry and produce gravitational wave signals.

Core Contributions

  1. Proposes the DW-genesis mechanism: First systematic study of how axion domain walls generate baryon asymmetry through coupling with lepton number
  2. Establishes complete theoretical framework: Derives complete dynamics of domain wall formation, evolution, and annihilation starting from the axion Lagrangian
  3. Quantifies baryon production efficiency: Provides quantitative predictions of final baryon asymmetry through Boltzmann equation solutions
  4. Analyzes gravitational wave signals: Calculates the gravitational wave spectrum produced by domain wall network annihilation and assesses detection prospects for future detectors
  5. Identifies key tensions: Discovers fundamental tension between successful baryon genesis and observable gravitational wave signals

Methodology Details

Theoretical Foundation

Axion Model Lagrangian

The low-energy effective Lagrangian of the axion model is: L=∂μΦ†∂μΦ−λ(∣Φ∣2−va2/2)2−V(a)\mathcal{L} = \partial_\mu\Phi^\dagger\partial^\mu\Phi - \lambda\left(|\Phi|^2 - v_a^2/2\right)^2 - V(a)

where Φ=ρ/2exp⁡(ia/va)\Phi = \rho/\sqrt{2} \exp(ia/v_a), ρ\rho is the radial mode, and aa is the axion field.

Axion Potential

The axion potential induced by dark gauge group confinement: V(a)=ma2fa2(1−cos⁡(afa))V(a) = m_a^2 f_a^2\left(1 - \cos\left(\frac{a}{f_a}\right)\right)

where ma=Λ2/fam_a = \Lambda^2/f_a is the axion mass and fa=va/NDWf_a = v_a/N_{DW} is the axion decay constant.

Domain Wall Dynamics

Domain Wall Formation

When temperature drops below the confinement scale T≲Λ≃mafaT \lesssim \Lambda \simeq \sqrt{m_a f_a}, the discrete symmetry ZNDWZ_{N_{DW}} spontaneously breaks, forming domain walls connecting different vacua.

Scaling Law Evolution

The domain wall network rapidly enters the scaling regime, where:

  • The average number of domain walls per Hubble patch is constant (~1)
  • Domain wall average velocity is moderately relativistic
  • Energy density scales as ρDW∼σH\rho_{DW} \sim \sigma H (where σ≈8mafa2\sigma \approx 8m_a f_a^2 is the domain wall tension)

Bias-Induced Collapse

A small energy difference ΔV\Delta V biases the vacuum, inducing network collapse at temperature Tann=(90/π2g∗)1/4ΔVMpl/σT_{ann} = (90/\pi^2 g_*)^{1/4}\sqrt{\Delta V M_{pl}/\sigma}.

DW-genesis Mechanism

Lepton Number Coupling

Consider the Lagrangian in the right-handed neutrino sector: L=yN(H~ℓˉ)NR+12MNNˉRcNR+cL∂μafajLμ+h.c.\mathcal{L} = y_N(\tilde{H}\bar{\ell})N_R + \frac{1}{2}M_N\bar{N}_R^c N_R + \frac{c_L\partial_\mu a}{f_a}j_L^\mu + \text{h.c.}

where jLμ=ℓˉγμLj_L^\mu = \bar{\ell}\gamma^\mu L is the lepton current.

Effective Chemical Potential

When domain walls sweep through the plasma, the axion-lepton coupling produces an effective chemical potential within the domain wall: La−L=θ˙jL0≃μjL0\mathcal{L}_{a-L} = \dot{\theta}j_L^0 \simeq \mu j_L^0

where: θ˙=a˙DW(t,z)fa=2maγwvwcosh⁡[maγwvw(t−tpassage)]\dot{\theta} = \frac{\dot{a}_{DW}(t,z)}{f_a} = \frac{2m_a\gamma_w v_w}{\cosh[m_a\gamma_w v_w(t-t_{passage})]}

Boltzmann Equation

The evolution of lepton number is described by the Boltzmann equation: dYΔLdt=−(γDnLeq(YΔL+YΔLeq(t))+2γ2→2nLeq(YΔL+YΔLeq(t)))\frac{dY_{\Delta L}}{dt} = -\left(\frac{\gamma_D}{n_L^{eq}}(Y_{\Delta L} + Y_{\Delta L}^{eq}(t)) + 2\frac{\gamma_{2\to2}}{n_L^{eq}}(Y_{\Delta L} + Y_{\Delta L}^{eq}(t))\right)

where the equilibrium lepton asymmetry is: YΔLeq(t)=nLeqs2cLa˙faTY_{\Delta L}^{eq}(t) = \frac{n_L^{eq}}{s}\frac{2c_L\dot{a}}{f_a T}

Gravitational Wave Production

GW Spectrum Parameterization

The gravitational wave spectrum produced by domain wall motion can be parameterized as a broken power law:

(f/f_{peak})^3 & f < f_{peak} \\ (f/f_{peak})^{-1} & f > f_{peak} \end{cases}$$ #### Present-Day Observable Quantity The gravitational wave amplitude redshifted to today: $$\Omega_{GW}(T) \approx 2.34 \times 10^{-6}\epsilon_{GW}A^2\left(\frac{g_*(T)}{10}\right)\left(\frac{g_{s*}(T)}{10}\right)^{-4/3}\left(\frac{T_{dom}}{T}\right)^4$$ Peak frequency: $$f_{peak}(T) \approx 1.15 \times 10^{-7}\text{Hz} \times \left(\frac{g_*(T)}{10}\right)^{1/2}\left(\frac{g_{s*}(T)}{10}\right)^{-1/3}\left(\frac{T}{\text{GeV}}\right)$$ ## Experimental Results ### Baryon Asymmetry Predictions #### Without Cancellation When not considering cancellation effects from opposite domain walls, the maximum lepton asymmetry is: $$Y_{\Delta L}^{\text{no cancellation}}\Big|_{\text{max}} \approx 10^{-10} \times \mathcal{O}(10)\left(\frac{T_{ann}}{10^9 \text{GeV}}\right)D$$ #### With Cancellation Considering cancellation from opposite domain walls: $$Y_{\Delta L}^{\text{cancellation}}\Big|_{\text{max}} \approx 10^{-10} \times \mathcal{O}(10)\left(\frac{T_{ann}}{10^{13} \text{GeV}}\right)\left(\frac{\Delta V/V_0}{10^{-4}}\right)D$$ where $D$ is the dilution factor accounting for entropy dilution during the axion matter-dominated era. ### Parameter Space Analysis #### Successful Baryon Genesis Region Numerical solutions reveal in the $(T_{ann}, M_N)$ parameter space: - Green region: lepton production rate too small to match observations - Red region: plasma cannot thermalize within domain walls - White region: viable lepton generation region #### Gravitational Wave Detection Prospects Analysis shows that the Einstein Telescope cannot observe gravitational wave signals corresponding to the DW-genesis parameter region, primarily due to: 1. Dilution effects from the axion matter-dominated era 2. Low annihilation temperatures required for successful baryon genesis ### Key Findings 1. **Optimal Conditions**: Baryon production efficiency is highest when $T_{dec} \sim T_{ann} \sim M_N/10$ 2. **Tension Relationship**: Successful DW-genesis exhibits fundamental tension with observable gravitational wave signals 3. **Cancellation Effects**: Cancellation from opposite domain walls can raise the required annihilation temperature to the $10^{13}$ GeV scale ## Related Work ### Traditional Baryon Genesis Mechanisms - **Electroweak Baryon Genesis**: Can be probed through low-energy experiments but requires new physics beyond the Standard Model - **Leptogenesis**: High-scale implementation difficult to probe directly - **GUT Baryon Genesis**: Involves extremely high energy scales, making experimental verification challenging ### Topological Defects and Baryon Genesis - Early studies of cosmic strings and baryon genesis - Magnetic monopole-driven baryon genesis - First systematic study of domain wall-driven baryon genesis in this work ### Gravitational Wave Cosmology Recent theoretical efforts linking baryon genesis to gravitational wave signals have opened new pathways for indirect detection of high-energy physics processes. ## Conclusions and Discussion ### Main Conclusions 1. **DW-genesis Feasibility**: Axion domain walls can indeed generate sufficient baryon asymmetry through coupling with lepton number 2. **Optimal Parameter Conditions**: Baryon number reaches maximum when domain wall network collapses near the decoupling of lepton-number-violating interactions 3. **Detection Challenges**: Successful DW-genesis typically cannot produce observable gravitational wave signals ### Limitations 1. **Model Dependence**: Results depend on specific axion models and coupling forms 2. **Numerical Uncertainties**: Systematic errors exist in numerical simulations of domain wall networks 3. **Cancellation Mechanism**: The precise cancellation degree of opposite domain walls requires more detailed study ### Future Directions 1. **Model Construction**: Explore new models that may avoid the gravitational wave-baryon genesis tension 2. **Numerical Simulations**: Improve numerical calculations of domain wall network evolution 3. **Observational Strategies**: Seek other observational signatures of DW-genesis ## In-Depth Evaluation ### Strengths 1. **Theoretical Innovation**: First systematic study of domain wall-driven baryon genesis, filling a theoretical gap 2. **Complete Calculations**: Establishes complete theoretical framework starting from fundamental Lagrangian 3. **Realistic Constraints**: Adequately considers cosmological constraints and observational limits 4. **Honest Assessment**: Objectively identifies limitations and challenges of the mechanism ### Weaknesses 1. **Limited Detection Prospects**: Main conclusions indicate the mechanism is difficult to verify through gravitational wave detection 2. **Model Specificity**: Results are relatively sensitive to specific axion model parameters 3. **Simplified Cancellation Treatment**: Treatment of opposite domain wall cancellation effects is relatively simplified ### Impact 1. **Academic Contribution**: Provides new research direction for baryon genesis theory 2. **Methodological Value**: Established theoretical framework can be generalized to other topological defects 3. **Practical Limitations**: Limited practical application value due to detection difficulties ### Applicable Scenarios This research is primarily applicable to: - Theoretical studies of axion cosmology - Phenomenological analysis of early universe phase transitions - Theoretical modeling of gravitational wave cosmology - Comparative studies of baryon genesis mechanisms ## References The paper cites 52 important references covering key works in baryon genesis, axion physics, topological defects, and gravitational wave cosmology, providing a solid theoretical foundation for the research.