Tricritical behavior of a relativistic field theory in one dimension

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.00518
• Title: Tricritical behavior of a relativistic field theory in one dimension
• Authors: Heron Caldas, A. L. Mota (Universidade Federal de São João del Rei, Brazil)
• Categories: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory), cond-mat.str-el (Condensed Matter Physics - Strongly Correlated Electrons), hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology), nucl-th (Nuclear Theory)
• Publication Date: December 31, 2024
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.00518

Abstract

This paper analyzes tricritical behavior in a class of one-dimensional field theories that exhibit spontaneous symmetry breaking at zero temperature and zero chemical potential. In the Gross-Neveu (GN) type massless fermion model, discrete chiral symmetry is spontaneously broken. Upon doping, the symmetry is restored at a critical chemical potential. The temperature effects of this doped one-dimensional system under an applied constant Zeeman magnetic field B₀ are investigated. It is found that B₀ suppresses the gapless behavior existing at specific chemical potential values and can induce a gapless-gapped phase transition at a critical field strength. The influence of spatially inhomogeneous condensate on the tricritical point is also discussed within the Ginzburg-Landau expansion framework.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Questions

This paper investigates tricritical phenomena in one-dimensional relativistic field theories, with particular focus on:

1. The influence of applied Zeeman magnetic fields on the phase diagram of the Gross-Neveu model
2. The mechanism of magnetic field-induced gapless-gapped phase transitions
3. The effect of inhomogeneous condensate on the tricritical point location

Significance

1. Theoretical Importance: The GN model is an important theoretical tool for studying fundamental features of quantum field theory, demonstrating basic QCD characteristics including 1/N expansion, renormalization, asymptotic freedom, and chiral symmetry breaking
2. Practical Applications: The model can describe phase transitions from soliton to metallic phases in trans-polyacetylene (TPA) and properties of other one-dimensional organic conductors
3. Methodological Contribution: Provides a theoretical framework for studying metal-insulator transitions in low-dimensional electronic systems under strong magnetic fields

Limitations of Existing Methods

• Previous studies primarily focused on zero magnetic field scenarios
• Insufficient understanding of the mechanisms of magnetic field-induced phase transitions
• Lack of systematic analysis of inhomogeneous condensate effects

Core Contributions

1. Discovery of Magnetic Field Suppression Effect: Demonstrated that Zeeman magnetic field B₀ suppresses gapless behavior at specific chemical potential values and induces a gapless-gapped phase transition at critical field strength B₀,c
2. Establishment of Complete Phase Diagram: Constructed a complete phase diagram in the (μ↑,↓, T) plane through Ginzburg-Landau expansion up to (∆/kᵦT)⁶ and (μ↑,↓/kᵦT)⁴ orders
3. Discovery of Reentrant Behavior: At zero temperature, for μ < μc, as δμ (i.e., B₀) increases, the system exhibits "reentrant" behavior: a gapped-gapless-gapped phase sequence
4. Determination of Tricritical Point Evolution: Clarified that applied Zeeman magnetic field shifts the tricritical point in a direction opposite to B₀ growth, significantly reducing the gapped region in the phase diagram
5. Proof of Inhomogeneous Effects: Demonstrated that when considering spatially inhomogeneous ∆(x) condensate, the tricritical point location in the GN phase diagram remains unchanged

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigation of phase transition behavior in the one-dimensional Gross-Neveu model under finite temperature, chemical potential, and applied Zeeman magnetic field, with particular emphasis on tricritical phenomena.

Input Parameters:

• Temperature T
• Chemical potential μ and chemical potential imbalance δμ = gμᵦB₀/2
• Applied magnetic field B₀

Output:

• Gap parameter ∆(T, μ, δμ)
• Phase diagram structure
• Tricritical point location

Model Architecture

1. Gross-Neveu Model Lagrangian

The basic GN model Lagrangian density is:

L_GN = Σ_{s=↑,↓} ψ̄^s (iℏγ⁰∂_t - iℏv_F γ¹∂_x)ψ^s + (λℏv_F)/(2N) (ψ̄ψ)²

Under large N (mean-field) approximation:

L_GN = Σ_s ψ^s† (iℏ∂_t - iℏv_F γ⁵∂_x - γ⁰∆(x))ψ^s - N/(2ℏv_F λ) ∆²(x)

2. Chemical Potential and Zeeman Terms

Introduction of chemical potential and Zeeman magnetic field effects:

L_CP = Σ_{s=↑,↓} μψ̄^s γ⁰ψ^s
L_Z = Σ_{s=↑,↓} (σ_s/2) gμ_B B₀ ψ̄^s γ⁰ψ^s

Definition of effective chemical potentials: μ↑ = μ + δμ, μ↓ = μ - δμ, where δμ = gμᵦB₀/2

3. Effective Potential Construction

Through imaginary time formalism, construction of the partition function:

Z = ∫ Dψ̄ Dψ exp{∫₀^β dτ ∫ dx [L_GN]}

After integrating out fermionic fields, the effective action is obtained:

S_eff[∆] = -β/(2ℏv_F λ) ∫ dx ∆²(x) + Σ_{s=↑,↓} Tr ln(D_s)

Technical Innovations

1. Asymmetric System Treatment

Introduction of δμ ≠ 0 to systematically study spin-imbalanced systems and magnetic field-induced phase transitions.

2. High-Temperature Expansion Technique

Evaluation of the effective potential at finite temperature using high-temperature expansion:

V_eff(μ↑,↓, T) = α₀ + α₂∆² + α₄∆⁴ + α₆∆⁶

where each coefficient contains temperature and chemical potential dependencies.

3. Inhomogeneous Condensate Analysis

Consideration of spatially dependent gap parameter ∆(x) using elliptic function solutions:

∆(x) = ∆₀√ν sn(∆₀x; ν)

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Calculation Methods

1. Numerical Computation: Direct numerical solution of effective potential equations
2. Analytical Approximation: Ginzburg-Landau expansion to various orders
3. Phase Diagram Construction: Identification of phase transition lines and tricritical points

Parameter Ranges

• Temperature: 0 ≤ T ≤ 2Tc(0)
• Chemical potential: 0 ≤ μ ≤ 2μc
• Magnetic field parameter: 0 ≤ δμ ≤ μc

Evaluation Metrics

• Behavior of gap parameter ∆
• Location and nature of phase transition lines
• Tricritical point coordinates (μtc, Ttc)

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Zero-Temperature Phase Diagram

At T = 0, the following is discovered:

• Critical magnetic field: δμc = 0.372∆₀, corresponding to B₀,c = 0.744∆₀/(gμᵦ)
• First-order phase transition from gapless to gapped occurs at μ = μc and δμ = δμc
• For μ < μc, reentrant behavior exists: gapped→gapless→gapped

2. Finite Temperature Effects

Through Ginzburg-Landau expansion:

• Second-order phase transition line: α₂ = 0
• First-order phase transition line: α₄² - 4α₂α₆ = 0
• Tricritical point: α₂ = α₄ = 0

3. Tricritical Point Evolution

Numerical results show:

• Second-order approximation: μtc ≈ 0.527∆₀, Ttc ≈ 0.344∆₀
• Sixth-order approximation: μtc ≈ 0.592∆₀, Ttc ≈ 0.321∆₀
• Numerical exact value: μtc = 0.608∆₀, Ttc = 0.318∆₀

Ablation Studies

1. Effect of Expansion Order

Comparison of results from different order Ginzburg-Landau expansions:

• μ²/T² order: provides qualitatively correct phase structure
• μ⁶/T⁶ order: significantly improves quantitative accuracy

2. Magnetic Field Strength Effects

Systematic investigation of phase diagram dependence on different δμ values:

• Increasing δμ leads to decreased tricritical chemical potential μtc
• Gapped phase region is significantly reduced

Important Findings

1. Fully Polarized State

When δμ ≥ δμc, the system enters a fully polarized state:

• n↑ = (1/πℏvF)√(μ↑² - ∆²)
• n↓ = 0

2. Magnetic Properties

Pauli susceptibility in the high-temperature limit:

χ(T) = gμᵦ²/(πℏvF) - (gμᵦ²/(πℏvF))[7ζ(3)/(4π²)]∆²/(kᵦT)²

Related Work

Theoretical Foundations

1. Gross-Neveu Model: Original GN model and its applications in QCD
2. Phase Transition Theory: Ginzburg-Landau theory and critical phenomena
3. One-Dimensional Systems: Phase transition behavior in low-dimensional electronic systems

Experimental Connections

1. Organic Conductors: Properties of one-dimensional organic conductors such as trans-polyacetylene
2. Magnetic Field Effects: Metal-insulator transitions in low-dimensional systems
3. Spintronics: Applications in spin-polarized conductors

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Zeeman magnetic field effectively suppresses gapless behavior in one-dimensional systems
2. Magnetic field-induced gapless-gapped phase transition exists with critical field strength B₀,c = 0.744∆₀/(gμᵦ)
3. The tricritical point shifts toward lower chemical potential as magnetic field strengthens
4. Inhomogeneous condensate does not alter the tricritical point location

Limitations

1. Limited applicability range of large N approximation
2. Insufficient accuracy of high-temperature expansion at low temperatures
3. Neglect of more complex interaction effects

Future Directions

1. Investigation of transport properties under combined electromagnetic fields
2. Exploration of experimental verification in actual materials
3. Extension to two- and three-dimensional systems

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Completeness: Systematic investigation of magnetic field effects on one-dimensional relativistic field theory
2. Methodological Innovation: Clever combination of analytical and numerical methods to obtain complete phase diagrams
3. Physical Insights: Discovery of interesting physical phenomena such as reentrant phase transitions
4. Practical Value: Provides important theoretical foundation for research on one-dimensional organic conductors

Weaknesses

1. Approximation Accuracy: Limited precision of high-temperature expansion in certain regions
2. Experimental Verification: Lack of direct comparison with experimental results
3. Generalizability: Primarily limited to one-dimensional systems

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Enriches understanding of low-dimensional quantum phase transitions
2. Application Prospects: Provides theoretical guidance for designing spin-polarized devices
3. Methodological Value: Demonstrates application of field theory methods in condensed matter physics

Applicable Scenarios

1. Phase transition research in one-dimensional organic conductors
2. Magnetic transport phenomena in quantum wires
3. Phase transition simulation in cold atom systems

References

This paper cites 47 important references covering theoretical foundations of the Gross-Neveu model, phase transition theory, experimental research, and other aspects, providing a solid theoretical foundation for the research.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that systematically investigates tricritical phenomena in one-dimensional relativistic field theory, discovers important physical effects such as magnetic field-induced phase transitions, and has significant implications for understanding low-dimensional quantum systems.