Generic Symmetry Analysis of Charmonium Decay

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.00670
• Title: Generic symmetry analysis of charmonium decay
• Author: X.H. Mo (Institute of High Energy Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences)
• Classification: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology)
• Submission Date: December 31, 2024 to arXiv
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.00670

Abstract

This paper establishes a systematic parametrization scheme based on SU(3) flavor symmetry for charmonium decays into final states involving only light quarks, encompassing two-body decays, three-body decays, and radiative decays.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Questions

1. Non-perturbative QCD Verification Needs: While quantum chromodynamics (QCD) has been extensively verified in the high-energy perturbative regime, its validity in non-perturbative regions such as the J/ψ and ψ' resonance regions requires further experimental guidance.
2. Theoretical Description of Charmonium Decays: A systematic theoretical framework is needed to describe various charmonium decay processes.
3. Completeness of Symmetry Analysis: Existing models lack a unified parametrization scheme to handle all types of charmonium decays.

Research Significance

• Charmonium production and decay provide an ideal laboratory for studying non-perturbative QCD
• Systematic symmetry analysis aids in understanding fundamental laws of strong interactions
• Provides theoretical guidance for e⁺e⁻ collider experiments

Limitations of Existing Methods

• Existing models primarily focus on two-body decays, lacking systematic treatment of three-body and radiative decays
• Incomplete consideration of symmetry breaking effects
• Absence of a unified parametrization framework

Core Contributions

1. Extended Parametrization Scheme for Two-Body Decays:
   • Incorporated symmetry breaking effects induced by quark magnetic moments
   • Extended mixing scenarios to include mixing between glueball scalar and pseudoscalar states
2. Established Parametrization Framework for Three-Body Decays: First systematic SU(3) symmetry analysis of three-body decays
3. Refined Symmetry Analysis of Radiative Decays: Extended symmetry analysis to radiative decay processes
4. Provided Complete Parametrization Scheme: Established a unified theoretical framework encompassing all types of charmonium decays

Methodology Details

Theoretical Foundation

Based on representation theory of the SU(3) group and the "flavor singlet principle," the effective interaction Hamiltonian is written as:

H_eff = H_0 + ΔH

where H₀ is the symmetry-conserving term and ΔH is the symmetry-breaking term.

Symmetry Breaking Effects

Three types of "pseudoscalar" octets are introduced to describe different symmetry breaking mechanisms:

1. Strong Interaction Breaking: S_m = diag1, 1, -2
2. Electromagnetic Interaction Breaking: S_e = diag2, -1, -1
3. Quark Magnetic Moment Breaking: S_μ = diag2, -1, 2

Parametrization Scheme

Baryon Parametrization

Complete parametrization forms are provided for octet-octet (O-O), decuplet-decuplet (D-D), and decuplet-octet (D-O) patterns in baryon final states.

Meson Parametrization

For octet mesons O₁ and O₂, three allowed terms are defined:

• Scalar term: O₁O₂₀ = (O₁)ⁱⱼ(O₂)ʲᵢ
• Antisymmetric tensor term: (O₁O₂_f)ⁱⱼ
• Symmetric tensor term: (O₁O₂_d)ⁱⱼ

Mixing Framework

Three-state mixing of η, η', and η₀ is considered:

⎛η ⎞     ⎛η₈⎞
⎜η'⎟ = O_R⎜η₁⎟
⎝η₀⎠     ⎝G ⎠

where O_R is an orthogonal matrix containing three mixing angles.

Three-Body Decays

According to the C-parity of three octets, the effective Hamiltonian has two possible forms:

• Antisymmetric form (applicable to odd C-parity combinations)
• Symmetric form (applicable to even C-parity combinations)

Radiative Decays

The photon field is represented as γ_μQ form, where Q is the charge matrix in the fundamental representation of the SU(3) group, thereby incorporating radiative decays into the unified symmetry analysis framework.

Experimental Setup

Physical Conditions

• Consideration of flavor-neutral initial states in e⁺e⁻ collider experiments
• Only OZI-rule-suppressed processes are considered
• Final states involve only light quarks (u, d, s)

Parametrization Tables

The paper provides detailed parametrization tables:

• Table I: Baryon decay modes
• Table II: VP final state decays
• Table III: VP decays including mixing effects
• Table IV: Three-body pseudoscalar decays
• Table V: Radiative decays

Main Results

Improvements in Two-Body Decays

1. New Breaking Effects: First systematic inclusion of symmetry breaking effects induced by quark magnetic moments
2. Extended Mixing: Extension of mixing framework from two-state to three-state, including glueball components

Breakthrough in Three-Body Decays

Complete parametrization scheme for three-body decays, filling a theoretical gap in this field.

Refinement of Radiative Decays

Established systematic parametrization method for radiative decays, forming a unified framework with hadronic decays.

Parameter Relations

Amplitudes of all decay modes can be expressed using a small number of fundamental coupling constants (g₀, g_m, g_e, g_μ) and their linear combinations.

Related Work

The paper cites important works in this field:

• Early models by Kowalski and Walsh (1976)
• Three-body decay analysis by Haber and Perrier (1985)
• Recent systematic parametrization work by Mo et al. (2022-2024)

Building on previous work, this paper provides the most complete and systematic parametrization scheme.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Established a unified parametrization framework encompassing all types of charmonium decays
2. Systematically incorporated three types of symmetry breaking effects
3. Provided complete description from two-body to three-body decays and from hadronic to radiative decays

Theoretical Significance

• Fully incorporated symmetry characteristics, leaving only dynamical aspects as remaining issues
• Provided systematic theoretical guidance for experimental analysis
• Promoted deeper understanding of decay mechanisms

Limitations

1. Increased Parameters: Introduction of numerous unknown parameters may affect practical applicability in experiments
2. Missing Dynamics: Primarily focuses on symmetry; dynamical mechanisms require further investigation
3. Higher-Order Corrections: Higher-order symmetry breaking corrections not considered

Future Directions

1. Development of methods to determine parameter relationships
2. Refinement of theoretical description by combining dynamical models
3. Verification of theoretical predictions through comparison with experimental data

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong Systematicity: First establishment of a complete parametrization scheme for charmonium decays
2. Theoretical Rigor: Based on group theory and symmetry principles with rigorous mathematical derivations
3. Clear Innovation:
   • Introduction of quark magnetic moment breaking effects
   • Extension to three-state mixing
   • Unified treatment of various decay processes
4. High Practical Value: Provides a standardized theoretical framework for experimental data analysis

Weaknesses

1. Excessive Parameters: Large number of unknown parameters may lead to over-parametrization issues
2. Lack of Experimental Verification: Pure theoretical work without comparison with experimental data
3. Unclear Dynamical Mechanisms: Primarily focuses on kinematic constraints; physical mechanisms remain unclear
4. Limited Scope of Applicability: Only applicable to light quark final states; heavy quark cases not considered

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides important theoretical tools for charmonium physics
2. Experimental Guidance: Facilitates data analysis and physical interpretation in e⁺e⁻ experiments
3. Theoretical Development: Promotes theoretical research in non-perturbative QCD and hadron physics

Application Scenarios

• Experimental data analysis of charmonium decays
• Symmetry studies in hadron physics
• Theoretical guidance for e⁺e⁻ collider experiments
• Phenomenological studies of non-perturbative QCD effects

References

The paper cites 13 relevant references spanning from 1976 to 2024, reflecting the development history of the field and the position of this work within it.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that makes important contributions to symmetry analysis of charmonium decays. While its practical applicability awaits experimental verification, its theoretical value and systematicity make it an important reference in this field.