Estimating the track-reconstruction efficiency in phenomenological proposals of long-lived-particle searches

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.00857
• Title: Estimating the track-reconstruction efficiency in phenomenological proposals of long-lived-particle searches
• Authors: Emilie Bertholet, Abner Soffer (Tel Aviv University)
• Classification: hep-ex (High Energy Physics - Experiment), hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology)
• Publication Date: January 1, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.00857

Abstract

Phenomenological studies of new long-lived particle (LLP) searches face challenges in estimating track-reconstruction efficiency for displaced charged particles. Reconstruction efficiency depends not only on the momentum vector of charged particles but also on their production point relative to detector boundaries and substructure elements. Phenomenological studies typically cannot access the GEANT4 simulations used in experimental analyses to calculate efficiency. To address this need, the authors developed TrackEff—a Python software package for estimating track-reconstruction efficiency. TrackEff's default detector geometry corresponds to the Belle II drift chamber, but adjustable parameters allow modification of the geometry to accommodate other track detector configurations.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Description

1. Core Challenge: Accurately estimating reconstruction efficiency for displaced tracks in phenomenological studies of long-lived particle searches is a critical problem
2. Technical Barriers: Phenomenological studies typically lack access to complete GEANT4 detector simulations, which are the standard tool for calculating reconstruction efficiency in experimental analyses
3. Current Limitations: Current phenomenological papers either completely ignore efficiency issues or employ oversimplified parameterizations

Research Significance

1. Experimental Importance: Displaced vertex (DV) signals provide efficient background suppression, making such searches experimentally attractive
2. Prediction Accuracy: Accurate efficiency estimation is crucial for predicting search sensitivity
3. Detector Design: In early stages of new detector concepts, rapid assessment of geometric performance is needed without constructing complete GEANT4 models

Application Context

• Belle II Experiment: Asymmetric-energy B factory with 7 GeV electrons and 4 GeV positrons
• Operating Conditions: Center-of-mass energy √s = 10.58 GeV, corresponding to the Υ(4S) resonance
• Physical Processes: BB̄, τ⁺τ⁻, cc̄ pair production and other bottomonium or hadronic states

Core Contributions

1. Development of TrackEff Package: First specialized tool for estimating track-reconstruction efficiency in phenomenological studies
2. Simplified Geometric Model: Based on the Belle II Central Drift Chamber (CDC) with extensibility to other detector configurations
3. Experimental Validation: Method effectiveness verified through comparison with Belle II real data and Monte Carlo simulations
4. Open-Source Release: Publicly available through Zenodo platform for academic use

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Input: Generator-level charged particle information (production point coordinates, momentum vector) Output: Track-reconstruction efficiency estimation Constraint: Track reconstructability judgment based on geometric hit count

Basic Principle

TrackEff is based on the core assumption that a charged particle track will be reconstructed if it leaves a sufficient number of hits in the track detector. For Belle II, considering hits in the CDC, physics analyses typically require 20 CDC hits as a track quality requirement.

Detector Model

CDC Geometric Structure

• 9 Radial Superlayers: Each superlayer contains multiple layers
• Layer Configuration: Innermost superlayer with 8 layers, remaining superlayers with 6 layers each
• Azimuthal Segmentation: From 160 cells in the innermost layer to 384 cells in the outermost layer
• Cell Structure: Each cell occupies a rectangular region (Δr, Δφ) in rφ space

Simplifying Assumptions

• All layers treated as axial layers (ignoring stereo layer complexity)
• Uniform magnetic field Bz = 1.5 T
• Geometric calculations in cylindrical coordinates

Algorithm Implementation

Track Parameter Calculation

Using helical trajectory model through the following steps:

1. Point of Closest Approach (POCA) Calculation:

ω = (q/c) * Bz/√(px² + py²)
tanλ = pz/√(px² + py²)

2. Trajectory Parameterization:

x = x₀ - s sinc((φ-φ₀)/2) cos((φ+φ₀)/2)
y = y₀ - s sinc((φ-φ₀)/2) sin((φ+φ₀)/2)  
z = z₀ + s tanλ

Hit Counting Algorithm

1. Arc Length Stepping: Progress along particle trajectory with step size Δs = 1 mm
2. Cell Traversal: Count steps within each cell
3. Hit Criterion:
   • Regular cells: ns = 10 steps required to count as one hit
   • Innermost layer cells: n^inner_s = 2 steps required (accounting for smaller radial extent)

Technical Innovations

1. Geometric Approximation Method: Avoids complex ionization and drift time calculations, based purely on geometric path length
2. Parameterized Design: Allows users to adjust detector geometry parameters for different experimental configurations
3. Efficiency-Oriented: Focuses on track discovery efficiency rather than precise hit timing or position reconstruction
4. Fast Computation: Significantly faster than complete GEANT4 simulation

Experimental Setup

Validation Data

• Data Source: Track efficiency measurements from Belle II official report BELLE2-NOTE-PL-2020-014
• Event Type: e⁺e⁻ → τ⁺τ⁻ events with one τ lepton decaying and the other decaying to three charged pions
• Efficiency Definition: Fraction of events where all three pions are successfully found

Evaluation Metrics

• Track Reconstruction Efficiency: As a function of τ lepton laboratory frame polar angle θ
• Hit Requirement: 20 CDC hits as track detection threshold

Parameter Optimization

Key parameters optimized through comparison with experimental data:

• n^inner_s: Hit criterion for innermost layer cells
• ns: Hit criterion for regular cells

Experimental Results

Main Results

Figure 2 presents comparison of TrackEff efficiency estimates with Belle II experimental measurements:

• Optimal Matching Parameters: n^inner_s = 2, ns = 10
• Angular Dependence: Efficiency varies from near 0 to approximately 0.8 in polar angle range 20°-140°
• Consistency: TrackEff predictions agree with experimental data within statistical uncertainties

Parameter Sensitivity Analysis

Impact of different parameter combinations tested:

• n^inner_s = 3, ns = 3: Efficiency slightly lower than experimental values
• n^inner_s = 2, ns = 7: Close to experimental data but inferior to default parameters
• Conclusion: Parameter choice affects results but is not highly sensitive; default values provide best match

Geometric Effect Verification

Figure 1 shows three example tracks propagating through the CDC model:

• Tracks 1 and 3: Originating from displaced vertex V₁ = (4.39, 50.1, 49.7) cm
• Track 2: Originating near beam V₂ = (4.39, 3.21, -1.27) cm
• Observation: Particles with different momenta and charges exhibit different helical trajectory characteristics

Related Work

Long-Lived Particle Searches

The paper cites extensive literature on DV searches from Belle II and predecessor B factory experiments (BABAR, Belle):

• Experimental Searches: Spin-0 mediators, heavy neutral leptons, dark photons, etc.
• Phenomenological Proposals: Covering light neutral particles, QCD axions, sterile neutrinos and various beyond-Standard-Model scenarios

Track Reconstruction Techniques

• Traditional Methods: Precise calculations based on complete GEANT4 simulation
• Simplified Methods: Crude parameterizations used in some phenomenological studies
• Advanced Algorithms: Recently developed graph neural network-based track reconstruction algorithms at Belle II

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Tool Effectiveness: TrackEff successfully provides efficiency estimates consistent with experimental data
2. Applicable Scope: Suitable for phenomenological studies and early-stage assessment of new detector concepts
3. Computational Efficiency: Significantly faster than complete simulations
4. Flexibility: Parameterized design accommodates different detector configurations

Limitations

1. Simplified Assumptions: Neglects complex physical processes including ionization, drift time, and electronics response
2. Algorithm Constraints: Does not account for non-idealities in track-finding algorithms and difficulties in high-multiplicity events
3. Vertex Reconstruction: Does not include limitations of displaced vertex reconstruction algorithms
4. Detector Specificity: Default parameters optimized for Belle II; other detectors require re-optimization

Future Directions

1. Algorithm Improvements: Incorporating more sophisticated physical effect models
2. Detector Extensions: Support for additional track detector types (silicon detectors, gas detectors, etc.)
3. Vertex Reconstruction: Integration of displaced vertex reconstruction efficiency estimation
4. Machine Learning: Leveraging modern ML techniques to improve efficiency prediction accuracy

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. High Practical Value: Fills important tool gap in phenomenological research
2. Thorough Validation: Method reliability verified through comparison with real experimental data
3. Open-Source Contribution: Open access through Zenodo platform promotes academic exchange
4. Reasonable Design: Balances computational complexity and prediction accuracy
5. Complete Documentation: Provides detailed mathematical derivations and implementation details

Weaknesses

1. Physical Simplification: Over-simplification may fail in certain extreme cases
2. Detector Limitations: Primarily designed for drift chambers; applicability to other detector types requires verification
3. Statistical Analysis: Lacks detailed uncertainty analysis and error propagation
4. Performance Benchmarking: Lacks systematic comparison with other simplified methods

Impact

1. Academic Impact: Provides standard tool for long-lived particle phenomenological research
2. Experimental Guidance: Can guide detector design and search strategies for new experiments
3. Educational Value: Provides intuitive tool for students and researchers to understand track reconstruction
4. Reproducibility: Open-source code ensures research result reproducibility

Applicable Scenarios

1. Phenomenological Studies: Experimental sensitivity predictions for new physics models
2. Detector Design: Rapid performance assessment for new experimental concepts
3. Educational Training: Teaching demonstrations of track reconstruction principles
4. Preliminary Analysis: Quick feasibility studies before complete simulations

References

The paper cites 30 relevant references covering:

• Reviews and specific studies of long-lived particle searches
• Belle II experimental technical design and physics analyses
• Track reconstruction algorithms and detector technology
• Related phenomenological theoretical research

Overall Assessment: This is a highly practical tool-development paper that fills an important technical gap in high-energy physics phenomenological research. Although the method is relatively straightforward, its effectiveness has been verified through careful comparison with experimental data, making it valuable for advancing long-lived particle search research.