Photon-photon coupling induced bound state in the continuum and transparency

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.00900
• Title: Photon-photon coupling induced bound state in the continuum and transparency
• Authors: Ekta Tunwal, Kuldeep Kumar Shrivastava, Rakesh Kumar Nayak, Ravi Kumar, Somak Bhattacharyya, Rajeev Singh, Biswanath Bhoi
• Classification: quant-ph (Quantum Physics), cond-mat.mtrl-sci (Condensed Matter Physics - Materials Science)
• Publication Date: January 3, 2025
• Institutions: Department of Physics and Department of Electronic Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology (Banaras Hindu University)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.00900

Abstract

This study achieves coherent and dissipative coupling in hybrid photonic resonators through constructive and destructive interference of photonic resonator fields with radiation from a common transmission line. In the dissipative coupling system, the coexistence of the exotic phenomenon of bound states in the continuum (BIC) near the frequency crossing of uncoupled resonators is discovered by satisfying the Friedrich-Wintgen BIC condition. Through rotating one of the samples and dynamically adjusting parameters, coupling-induced transparency (CIT) between photonic resonators is realized. The transition from BIC in absorbing systems to transparency opens new pathways for applications in various oscillators, filters, quantum information processors, and sensors.

Research Background and Motivation

Problems Addressed

This research aims to realize and control two key quantum optical phenomena in hybrid photonic systems—bound states in the continuum (BIC) and coupling-induced transparency (CIT)—and to explore the dynamic conversion mechanism between them.

Significance of the Problem

1. Fundamental Scientific Value: BIC, as an exotic wave phenomenon capable of maintaining localization within the continuous radiation spectrum, is crucial for understanding light-matter interactions
2. Technical Application Prospects: CIT and BIC phenomena have broad application potential in quantum devices, sensors, filters, and quantum information processing
3. Device Miniaturization Requirements: Modern quantum technology demands more compact and controllable photonic devices

Limitations of Existing Methods

Existing BIC research primarily focuses on complex engineered quantum potentials, coupled waveguide arrays, and periodic metallic gratings, lacking simple, planar, and dynamically tunable device designs.

Research Motivation

To develop a simple device based on planar resonators capable of simultaneously realizing BIC and CIT phenomena, with controlled conversion between the two phenomena through geometric parameter adjustment.

Core Contributions

1. Proposed a planar BIC device based on CSRR-CELC hybrid system: Constructed a hybrid photonic system using complementary split-ring resonators (CSRR) and complementary LC resonators (CELC)
2. Achieved controlled conversion from BIC to CIT: Realized dynamic switching between BIC and CIT phenomena in a single device through resonator rotation and geometric parameter adjustment
3. Verified Friedrich-Wintgen BIC conditions: Satisfied the theoretical conditions for BIC existence through linear coupling in the microwave frequency band
4. Provided complete theoretical-simulation-experimental verification: Established quantum Hamiltonian models, performed electromagnetic simulations, and verified theoretical predictions experimentally
5. Demonstrated room-temperature photonic mode excitation: Achieved coherent manipulation of microwave photons under ambient conditions

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Input: Microwave signals input to the hybrid resonator system via microstrip transmission line Output: Transmission parameter S21, characterizing the frequency response of the system Objective: Achieve controlled switching between BIC and CIT phenomena through resonator geometry and relative orientation adjustment

Model Architecture

Theoretical Model

The system Hamiltonian is described as:

H/ℏ = ω₁X̂₁†X̂₁ + ω₂X̂₂†X̂₂ + ∫ωₖp̂ₖ†p̂ₖdk + Δ(X̂₁X̂₂† + X̂₂X̂₁†) + ∫[λ₁(X̂₁p̂ₖ† + X̂₁†p̂ₖ) + λ₂(X̂₂p̂ₖ† + X̂₂†p̂ₖ)]dk

Where:

• ω₁, ω₂: Eigenfrequencies of the two resonators
• Δ = J + iΓ: Complex coupling constant
• λ₁, λ₂: Coupling strengths between resonators and transmission line

Heisenberg-Langevin Equations

System dynamics are described by the coupling matrix:

Hcoupling = [ω₁ - iβ₁, Δ - i√(β₁β₂); Δ - i√(β₁β₂), ω₂ - iβ₂]

Friedrich-Wintgen BIC Condition

The condition for BIC existence is:

Δ(β₁ - β₂) = √(β₁β₂)(ω₁ - ω₂)

Device Design

Three-Layer Planar Structure

1. Bottom Layer: Copper ground plane with thickness 0.035 mm
2. Middle Layer: Dielectric substrate (40×40×1.6 mm³, εᵣ = 4.3)
3. Top Layer: Microstrip transmission line with width 3.064 mm and characteristic impedance 50 Ω

Resonator Configuration

• CSRR: Variable gap g (0.1-2.2 mm)
• CELC: Fixed geometric parameters
• Spacing: Resonators separated by 0.1 mm, symmetrically placed

Technical Innovations

1. Geometric Tuning Mechanism: Frequency tuning achieved by varying CSRR gap
2. Orientation Tuning Mechanism: Coupling properties modified (coherent ↔ dissipative) through 90° rotation
3. Linear Coupling BIC Realization: BIC phenomenon achieved without nonlinear effects
4. Multi-functional Single Device: Same planar structure enables different quantum optical phenomena

Experimental Setup

Experimental Configuration

• Frequency Range: 1-12 GHz microwave band
• Simulation Software: CST Microwave Studio full-wave electromagnetic solver
• Measurement Parameter: S21 transmission parameter
• Operating Temperature: Room temperature

Two Experimental Cases

Case 1: Dissipative Coupling (BIC)

• Resonator gap perpendicular to microstrip line (θ = 0°)
• CSRR gap g varies from 0.1 mm to 1.5 mm
• CELC parameters remain constant

Case 2: Coherent Coupling (CIT)

• Resonator gap parallel to microstrip line (θ = 90°)
• CSRR gap g varies from 0.1 mm to 2.2 mm
• CELC parameters remain constant

Evaluation Metrics

• Transmission Parameter |S21|: Characterizes system frequency response
• Real and Imaginary Parts of Eigenfrequencies: Analyzes coupling properties
• Electric Field Distribution: Reveals energy localization mechanisms

Experimental Results

Main Results

Case 1: BIC Phenomenon

• Frequency Evolution: CSRR mode shifts from 6 GHz to 7.4 GHz; CELC mode remains at 6.75 GHz
• Mode Merging: Two modes merge into a single deep absorption peak at coupling center (g = 0.7 mm)
• Friedrich-Wintgen Condition Verification: Satisfies BIC conditions with Δ ≈ 0, β₁ ≈ β₂
• Dissipation Parameters: CSRR dissipation 0.076, CELC dissipation 0.048

Case 2: CIT Phenomenon

• Frequency Evolution: CSRR mode shifts from 5.7 GHz to 7.5 GHz; CELC mode remains at 6.65 GHz
• Level Repulsion: Two modes approach but do not merge; transparency window appears at coupling center
• Coupling Parameters: Δ = 0.12, CSRR dissipation 0.0227, CELC dissipation 0.0057

Electric Field Distribution Analysis

BIC State (Case 1, g = 0.7 mm)

• Electric field concentrated around CSRR structure
• Minimal electric field intensity in CELC
• Exhibits energy localization corresponding to single resonance peak

CIT State (Case 2, g = 1.2 mm)

• Electric field uniformly distributed between two resonators
• Energy shared between resonators
• Corresponds to two separated resonance peaks with intermediate transparency region

Theory-Simulation-Experiment Consistency

Results from all three approaches show high consistency, validating the correctness of the theoretical model and effectiveness of the experimental design.

Related Work

Current State of BIC Research

BIC phenomena have been observed in multiple systems:

• Engineered quantum potentials
• Coupled waveguide arrays
• Periodic metallic gratings
• Distributed feedback lasers
• Acoustic and water wave systems
• Topological insulators

Advantages Over Related Work

1. Simple Structure: Planar design facilitates fabrication and integration
2. Flexible Control: Multi-functionality achieved through geometric and orientation adjustment
3. Room-Temperature Operation: No special environmental conditions required
4. Linear Mechanism: BIC realization requires only linear coupling

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully realized BIC and CIT phenomena in planar hybrid photonic systems
2. Verified that BIC-to-CIT conversion can be achieved through resonator orientation control
3. Friedrich-Wintgen conditions experimentally verified in the microwave frequency band
4. Electric field distribution analysis reveals physical mechanisms of BIC (energy localization) and CIT (energy distribution)

Limitations

1. Frequency Range Restriction: Current experiments limited to microwave band
2. Control Method: Physical device rotation required; lacks electronic tuning capability
3. Quality Factor: Limited by inherent losses of microstrip line structure
4. Temperature Dependence: Material parameter temperature stability may affect device performance

Future Directions

1. Extended Frequency Range: Extension toward terahertz and optical frequencies
2. Electronic Tuning: Development of active tuning mechanisms using liquid crystals, phase-change materials, etc.
3. Multi-mode Systems: Investigation of complex BIC phenomena with multiple coupled resonators
4. Nonlinear Effects: Exploration of nonlinear BIC and dynamic control

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Completeness: Comprehensive theoretical framework established from quantum optical Hamiltonian
2. Ingenious Experimental Design: Complex quantum phenomena achieved through simple geometric control
3. Multiple Verification: Triple verification through theory, simulation, and experiment ensures result reliability
4. Broad Application Prospects: Provides new pathways for quantum information processing and sensing applications
5. Clear Physical Picture: Electric field distribution intuitively demonstrates BIC and CIT physical mechanisms

Weaknesses

1. Limited Novelty: BIC and CIT phenomena themselves are not newly discovered; main contribution lies in implementation method
2. Primitive Control Method: Physical rotation lacks sophistication and real-time dynamic control capability
3. Insufficient Performance Analysis: Lacks quantitative analysis of device performance parameters (quality factor, modulation depth, etc.)
4. Missing Application Demonstrations: Lacks demonstration experiments for specific application scenarios

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides new insights for BIC realization in simple planar structures
2. Technical Value: Offers new platform for microwave quantum device design
3. Strong Reproducibility: Simple experimental design facilitates reproduction and improvement by other research groups

Applicable Scenarios

1. Quantum Information Processing: Can serve as interface for quantum bit manipulation and readout
2. Microwave Sensing: Utilizes high quality factor of BIC for high-sensitivity sensing
3. Filter Design: Tunable transparency window applicable to adaptive filtering
4. Educational Demonstration: Simple structure suitable for teaching quantum optical phenomena

References

The paper cites 31 relevant references covering BIC theoretical foundations, experimental implementations, and related quantum optics and microwave engineering techniques, providing solid theoretical and experimental basis for the research.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality paper at the intersection of quantum optics and microwave engineering, achieving controlled manipulation of important quantum phenomena through ingenious device design. It possesses significant academic value and application prospects. The paper features in-depth theoretical analysis, reasonable experimental design, and highly credible results, providing valuable reference for further development in related fields.