On the Origin and Fate of Our Universe

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.00966
• Title: On the Origin and Fate of Our Universe
• Author: Cumrun Vafa (Harvard University)
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Publication Date/Conference: January 1, 2025, Lemaitre Conference 2024 Lecture
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.00966

Abstract

This review paper, directed at high energy physics and astrophysics researchers, explores the implications of recent theoretical advances in string theory and the Swampland program for understanding constraints on positive potential structures in quantum gravity. The research addresses inflationary models of the early universe as well as the ultimate fate of the cosmos. The paper reviews the de Sitter conjecture and the TransPlanckian Censorship Conjecture (TCC) and their relationship to species scaling, providing evidence and phenomenological predictions for these principles.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Core Problem: The discovery of dark energy and cosmic acceleration presents one of the greatest challenges in modern theoretical physics: understanding the existence of positive energy density Λ ~ 10^-122 (in Planck units) within the ultraviolet-complete description of quantum gravity such as string theory.
2. Significance: This problem is fundamental to understanding both the origin of the universe (inflationary models) and its fate (dark energy evolution), and represents a core issue that quantum gravity theories must address.
3. Existing Limitations: The conventional view holds that any positive scalar potential is permissible, but string theory research reveals this contradicts reality. The Swampland program indicates that only a finite number of quantum gravity theories are self-consistent.
4. Research Motivation: By imposing constraints on potentials with V > 0 through Swampland principles, to understand string theory's restrictions on cosmology and provide theoretical guidance for early universe models and dark energy evolution.

Core Contributions

1. Systematically reviewed Swampland constraints on positive potentials, including the Distance Conjecture, species scaling, dS conjecture, and TCC conjecture
2. Established consistency between TCC and string theory observables, demonstrating that TCC can reproduce potential behavior observed in string theory
3. Imposed strict constraints on inflationary models, showing that TCC requires the inflationary energy scale V^1/4 ≤ 10^-10 (in Planck units)
4. Proposed alternative inflationary scenarios based on string duality, explaining early universe problems through topological phase transitions
5. Predicted finite cosmic lifetime, estimating maximum universe lifetime at approximately 2 trillion years based on TCC

Detailed Methodology

Theoretical Framework

This paper is based on several core conjectures of the Swampland program:

Distance Conjecture: At large distances in field space (φ ≫ 1), the mass of light states decays exponentially:

m ~ exp(-αφ)

where α is constrained to the range: 1/√(d-2) ≤ α ≤ √(d-1)/√(d-2)

Species Scaling: When N light states exist, the black hole description breaks down at the energy scale Λs:

Λs(φ) ~ exp(-βφ)

where β satisfies: 1/√((d-1)(d-2)) ≤ β ≤ 1/√(d-2)

de Sitter Conjecture

Asymptotic Behavior: At large distances in field space, the potential decays exponentially:

V(φ) ~ exp(-γφ), γ ≥ 2/√(d-2)

Refined Version: Throughout field space:

|V'/V| ≥ O(1) or V''/V < -O(1)

TransPlanckian Censorship Conjecture (TCC)

Core Principle: In a homogeneously expanding universe, sub-Planckian regions should not become larger than the Hubble horizon:

a(tf)/a(ti) · 1 ≤ 1/H(tf)

Potential Constraints: TCC derives potential decay rates consistent with string theory: γ ≥ 2/√(d-2)

Experimental Setup and Observational Constraints

Observational Data

• Observational constraints on dark energy variation: |V'/V| ≲ 0.5
• CMB power spectrum: P ~ 10^-9
• Current Hubble parameter: H0 ~ T0^2, where T0 ~ 10^-32 (in Planck units)

Theoretical Calculations

Using the Friedmann equation and scalar field equations of motion:

(d-1)(d-2)/2 · H^2 = 1/2 · φ̇^2 + V
φ̈ + (d-1)Hφ̇ + V' = 0

Main Results

Constraints on Inflation

Energy Scale Limit: TCC requires the inflationary energy scale to satisfy:

V^1/4 ≤ T0^1/3 ~ 10^-10 ~ 10^9 GeV

Fine-Tuning: This leads to extremely small slow-roll parameters:

ε ≲ 10^-31

Tensor-to-Scalar Ratio: The tensor-to-scalar ratio becomes extremely small:

r = 16ε ≲ 10^-30

Constraints on Flat Potential Regions

Using species scaling constraints V ≲ Λs^2(φ), the field variation range in flat potential regions is obtained:

Δφ ≲ √((d-1)(d-2)) log(1/V0)

Cosmic Lifetime Predictions

According to TCC, the maximum lifetime of de Sitter-like vacua is:

τmax ≲ (1/H) log(1/H) ~ 2 trillion years

Innovative Alternative Inflationary Scenarios

Models Based on String Duality

Core Idea: At high temperatures, the radius of the thermal circle 1/T becomes smaller, triggering a takeover by the dual description, with our universe's phase transitioning from the dual phase.

Advantages:

1. Horizon Problem: The non-locality of the dual theory naturally explains cosmic homogeneity
2. Matter Production: Matter is produced during the phase transition from the dual phase to our phase
3. Power Spectrum: Scale invariance predicts a red-tilted scalar perturbation power spectrum

Topological Gravity Phases

Proposes that the early universe may be described by scale-invariant topological gravity, with our universe emerging through the breaking of scale invariance.

Predictions for Cosmic Fate

Dark Energy Evolution

Observational Constraints: Currently |V'/V| ≲ 0.5, but if the dS conjecture is correct, then |V'/V| ≠ 0

Asymptotic Limits: In the asymptotic region of field space, |V'/V| ≥ √2, inconsistent with observations, indicating we are not in the asymptotic region

DESI Results: Preliminary results favor discovering a non-zero slope in V, supporting the dS conjecture

Cosmic Finiteness

If TCC is correct, our universe will end on Hubble timescales, making "metastable" de Sitter vacua actually short-lived.

Related Work

The paper builds upon the following important works:

1. Swampland Program: Ooguri-Vafa's Distance Conjecture and related developments
2. Species Scaling: Dvali et al.'s black hole quantum mechanics with large N species
3. dS Conjecture: Obied et al.'s constraints on de Sitter space
4. String Cosmology: Brandenberger-Vafa's early string cosmology models

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Inflation Faces Challenges: TCC requires inflationary models to be extremely fine-tuned, questioning their naturalness
2. Dark Energy Instability: The Swampland program predicts dark energy should be unstable
3. Finite Cosmic Lifetime: TCC predicts a universe lifetime of approximately 2 trillion years
4. Alternative Cosmology: Early universe models based on string duality provide alternatives to inflation

Limitations

1. Strength of Evidence: Evidence for the dS conjecture in interior field space regions is weaker than in asymptotic regions
2. Model Dependence: Conclusions strongly depend on the correctness of TCC and related Swampland conjectures
3. Observational Verification: Many predictions require future observations to verify

Future Directions

1. Further verification of Swampland conjectures, particularly in interior field space regions
2. Development of concrete implementations of early universe models based on string duality
3. Search for observational evidence of dark energy evolution

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Depth: Connects profound insights from string theory with cosmological observations
2. Systematicity: Comprehensively reviews the impact of the Swampland program on cosmology
3. Predictive Power: Proposes observable phenomenological predictions
4. Innovation: Presents innovative alternatives to inflation

Weaknesses

1. Speculative Nature: Some conclusions are based on conjectures not yet fully verified
2. Technical Details: Certain technical arguments could be more detailed
3. Observational Connection: The connection with current observations could be more concrete

Impact

This paper has significant implications for theoretical cosmology and may transform our understanding of the early universe and dark energy, providing important guidance for future observations and theoretical research.

Applicable Scenarios

This research is applicable to:

1. Theoretical cosmology research
2. String phenomenology
3. Research on dark energy and inflationary models
4. Theoretical guidance for future cosmological observations

References

The paper cites 34 important references, covering core works across multiple fields including the Swampland program, string theory, and cosmology, providing a comprehensive literature foundation for understanding this field.