Feasibility Study of a Hybrid Solid Liquid Vibration Energy Harvester: Numerical Simulation & Analysis

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.00993
• Title: Feasibility Study of a Hybrid Solid Liquid Vibration Energy Harvester: Numerical Simulation & Analysis
• Authors: Nadish Anand & Warren Jasper (North Carolina State University)
• Classification: physics.flu-dyn physics.app-ph
• Corresponding Author: Nadish Anand (nanand@alumni.ncsu.edu)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.00993

Abstract

This paper investigates the feasibility of a hybrid solid-liquid vibration energy harvester. The harvester comprises a tank partially filled with ferrofluids and piezoelectric beams mounted on the tank walls. The tank is positioned within a non-uniform magnetic field generated by two symmetrically placed permanent magnets. The study characterizes this two-dimensional multiscale, multiphysics, multiphase fluid-structure interaction system through piezoelectric beam configurations and oscillatory loads. The tank undergoes external oscillatory motion, causing the ferrofluids to slosh and vibrate the beams through two mechanisms: one induced by beam inertia and another by ferrofluids impacting the beam. The research reveals that when fluid motion vibrates the beam, the voltage output from piezoelectric materials peaks under certain conditions, indicating proximity to the resonant frequency; in other cases, voltage output varies with load, exhibiting broadband response characteristics.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

Traditional vibration energy harvesting (VEH) systems rely primarily on solid-state transducers (such as piezoelectric devices) and suffer from a critical limitation: their energy harvesting potential is highly "narrowband"—maximum output is achievable only near the resonant frequency mode. However, environmental vibrations are typically broadband, creating a mismatch that results in actual energy harvesting performance far below theoretical potential.

Research Significance

1. Energy Sustainability Requirements: The primary objective of VEH systems is to provide seamless power supply, ultimately replacing battery requirements in electronic devices
2. Broadband Energy Harvesting: The closely distributed resonant modes of ferrofluids sloshing systems are better suited for harvesting energy from broadband environmental vibrations
3. Technological Innovation: Combining ferrofluids sloshing and piezoelectric conversion mechanisms may achieve more efficient energy harvesting

Limitations of Existing Approaches

1. Solid-state VEH Systems: Single resonant frequency mismatches with broadband environmental vibrations
2. Pure Ferrofluids Systems: Power output heavily depends on magnetic parameters with inherent output limitations
3. Single Conversion Mechanism: Cannot fully utilize the system's kinetic energy

Core Contributions

1. Proposed a Hybrid Solid-Liquid Vibration Energy Harvester Concept: First integration of ferrofluids sloshing with piezoelectric conversion mechanisms
2. Established a Multiphysics Coupled Numerical Model: Achieved complete modeling of 2D multiscale, multiphysics, multiphase fluid-structure interactions
3. Systematic Parameter Study: Analyzed the effects of key parameters including piezoelectric material type, ferrofluids filling height, piezoelectric beam length, and oscillation frequency
4. Verified Broadband Response Characteristics: Demonstrated that the system achieves inherent broadband response similar to sloshing
5. Provided Design Guidance: Established theoretical foundation for practical hybrid energy harvester design

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Design and analyze a hybrid vibration energy harvester system containing:

• Input: External periodic lateral excitation $x = X_0\sin(\omega t)$
• Output: Voltage generated by piezoelectric beams and electromotive force from ferrofluids sloshing
• Constraints: Low-frequency excitation (0.8-1.2 Hz), 2D geometric configuration

System Architecture

Physical Configuration

• Tank: Length L, height H, partially filled with ferrofluids to height h
• Piezoelectric Bimorph Beam: Fixed on tank top wall, comprising steel substrate and piezoelectric layers
• Magnetic Field System: Two symmetrically placed permanent magnets generating non-uniform magnetic field

Mathematical Model

The system involves seven coupled physical phenomena:

1. Fluid Mechanics (Navier-Stokes Equations)

Continuity equation: ρ∇·v⃗ = 0
Momentum equation: ρ∂v⃗/∂t + ρ(v⃗·∇)v⃗ = -∇p + μ∇²v⃗ + F⃗ₘ + ρg + F⃗ₛₜ + F⃗_{FSI}

2. Free Surface Tracking (Level-set Method)

∂φ/∂t + v⃗·∇φ = γ∇·(ε_{ls}∇φ - φ(1-φ)∇φ/|∇φ|)

3. Magnetohydrodynamics

Magnetic force: F⃗ₘ = M⃗·∇H⃗
Magnetization: M⃗ = χₘH⃗

4. Structural Mechanics

ρ∂²u_{solid}/∂t² = ∇·σ + F⃗_V

5. Piezoelectric Effect

Strain relation: S = s^E σ + d'E
Electric displacement: D = dσ + ε^T E

Technical Innovations

1. Complete Multiphysics Coupling: Achieved fully coupled solution of fluid mechanics, electromagnetics, structural mechanics, and piezoelectric effects
2. Dual-Mode Energy Conversion:
   • Mode 1: Beam inertial response
   • Mode 2: Ferrofluids impact loading
3. Adaptive Broadband Response: System response can switch between narrowband (near resonance) and broadband
4. Level-set Interface Tracking: Accurately captures dynamic changes in ferrofluids-air interface

Experimental Setup

Material Parameters

Ferrofluids (EFH-3, FerroTec Corporation)

• Viscosity: 12 mPa·s
• Density: 1420 kg/m³
• Magnetic susceptibility: 3.52
• Saturation magnetization: 65 mT

Piezoelectric Materials

• PZT-7A: High piezoelectric constant, high stiffness
• PVDF: Low stiffness, high flexibility

Simulation Parameters

• Frequency Range: 0.8-1.2 Hz
• Excitation Amplitude: X₀ = L
• Geometric Configuration: Four different combinations of filling heights and beam lengths
• Magnetic Field Strength: 10-24 kA/m

Numerical Methods

• Solver: COMSOL Multiphysics
• Mesh: Adaptive refinement with Laplace mesh smoothing
• Time Integration: Second-order backward differentiation formula (BDF)
• Linear Solver: PARDISO and MUMPS direct solvers

Experimental Results

Main Findings

Voltage Output Comparison

• PVDF generates approximately twice the voltage of PZT-7A
• Reason: PVDF stiffness is one order of magnitude lower than PZT-7A

Frequency Response Characteristics

• Voltage peaks appear at certain frequencies, indicating proximity to resonance
• Other frequencies exhibit broadband response, similar to inherent sloshing characteristics

Magnetic Field Effects

• PVDF achieves maximum RMS voltage at 10 kA/m magnetic field strength
• Voltage from sloshing increases with maximum magnetic field strength

Parameter Impact Analysis

Case Study Results (Four geometric configurations):

1. Case 1: h/H = 0.35, h_b/L = 0.7, h_p = h_b/4
2. Case 2: h/H = 0.35, h_b/L = 0.7, h_p = h_b/2
3. Case 3: h/H = 0.4, h_b/L = 0.7, h_p = h_b/4
4. Case 4: h/H = 0.4, h_b/L = 0.7, h_p = h_b/2

Results show that increased piezoelectric layer coverage area (Cases 2 and 4) enhances voltage output.

Power Analysis

Using optimal impedance matching theory:

R_opt = 1/(C₀ω)
C₀ = ε₃₃ˢ A/L

Calculated power is at the nanoWatt level, primarily because the bimorph beam's natural frequency is far higher than the excitation frequency.

Related Work

Ferrofluids Energy Harvesting

• Bibo et al. (2012) first proposed electromagnetic ferrofluids energy harvesters
• Alazmi et al. (2015-2016) conducted experimental studies on internal resonance sloshing modes
• Liu et al. (2018) performed computational modeling and experimental validation

Traditional VEH Systems

• Magnetostrictive material VEH (Wang & Yuan, 2008)
• Flutter energy harvesters (McCarthy et al., 2016)
• Piezoelectric energy harvesters (Beeby et al., 2006)

Innovation of This Work

First proposal of a hybrid system combining ferrofluids sloshing with piezoelectric conversion, overcoming limitations of single mechanisms.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Feasibility Verification: The hybrid piezoelectric-ferrofluids VEH system is technically feasible
2. Broadband Response Capability: The system achieves broadband response characteristics similar to sloshing
3. Material Selection: PVDF is more suitable than PZT-7A for this application
4. Design Guidance: Provides design criteria for geometric parameters and material selection

Limitations

1. Low Power Output: Current configuration produces only nanoWatt-level power
2. Simplified Assumptions:
   • Magnetic field uses simple functions rather than realistic magnet configurations
   • Bimorph beam assumed sufficiently thick to not interfere with flow field
3. Frequency Mismatch: Excitation frequency mismatches with beam natural frequency

Future Directions

1. System Optimization: Extensive optimization studies needed to increase power output
2. Experimental Validation: Prototype fabrication and experimental verification required
3. Practical Applications: Evaluate utility in low-power applications
4. Magnetic Field Design: Replace simplified magnetic field functions with realistic magnet configurations

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong Innovation: First proposal of hybrid solid-liquid vibration energy harvesting concept with originality
2. Complete Modeling: Established comprehensive multiphysics coupled model encompassing seven physical phenomena
3. Systematic Analysis: Conducted systematic parametric studies on key parameters
4. Solid Theoretical Foundation: Rigorous mathematical models with clear physical mechanisms

Weaknesses

1. Practical Limitations: NanoWatt-level power output restricts practical application value
2. Insufficient Validation: Lacks experimental verification; purely numerical simulation study
3. Limited Optimization Depth: Primarily feasibility exploration rather than in-depth system optimization
4. Cost-Benefit Concerns: Complex manufacturing requirements may impact cost-effectiveness

Impact and Significance

1. Academic Value: Provides new insights for hybrid energy harvester design
2. Technical Inspiration: Can inspire research on other multiphysics coupled systems
3. Application Potential: Holds potential applications in low-power sensors and IoT devices
4. Methodological Contribution: Multiphysics coupled modeling methodology has universal applicability

Applicable Scenarios

1. Low-Power Devices: Wireless sensor nodes, IoT devices
2. Environmental Monitoring: Long-term self-powered monitoring equipment
3. Research Platform: Tool for studying multiphysics coupled phenomena
4. Concept Validation: Exploration platform for novel energy harvesting mechanisms

References

This paper cites 24 related references, primarily covering:

• Ferrofluids fundamental theory (Rosensweig, 1970)
• Ferrofluids energy harvesting (Bibo et al., 2012; Alazmi et al., 2015-2016)
• Traditional vibration energy harvesting (Wang & Yuan, 2008; Beeby et al., 2006)
• Piezoelectric theory and modeling (Shu & Lien, 2006; Smits et al., 1991)

Summary: This paper proposes an innovative hybrid vibration energy harvester concept and validates its technical feasibility through rigorous numerical modeling. Although current power output is limited, it provides important theoretical foundation and design guidance for developing novel broadband energy harvesters. The research also demonstrates significant academic value in multiphysics coupled modeling methodology.