Quantum Computing for Partition Function Estimation of a Markov Random Field in a Radar Anomaly Detection Problem

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.01154
• Title: Quantum Computing for Partition Function Estimation of a Markov Random Field in a Radar Anomaly Detection Problem
• Authors: Timothé Presles (Thales Defense Mission Systems), Cyrille Enderli (Thales Defense Mission Systems), Gilles Burel (Lab-STICC, CNRS, Univ. Brest), El Houssaın Baghious (Lab-STICC, CNRS, Univ. Brest)
• Classification: cs.ET (Emerging Technologies), quant-ph (Quantum Physics)
• Publication Date: January 2, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.01154

Abstract

This paper proposes a quantum computing-based solution for the partition function estimation problem in probability theory. The partition function is a critical factor for normalizing probability functions into density functions with total probability equal to 1. As a Markov Random Field (MRF) effectively represents statistical dependencies between variables, the number of terms in its partition function grows exponentially with the number of variables, making exact computation infeasible for large-scale instances within reasonable time. This paper leverages the exponential scalability advantage of quantum computing to accelerate the estimation of partition functions for MRFs representing operational variable dependencies in airborne radar systems, implementing a quantum algorithm for partition function estimation within the single-qubit model.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Radar Anomaly Detection Requirements: Modern airborne radar systems (such as RBE2, RDY) comprise numerous components requiring extremely high flight reliability. Built-in test equipment collects substantial operational data; however, due to limited onboard computational capacity, only major faults can be processed, overlooking anomalies that do not cause system collapse.
2. Partition Function Computation Challenges: In probabilistic graphical models, the partition function ZΩ is defined as:

   pΩ(x) = (1/ZΩ) · ϕ1(D1) · ϕ2(D2) · ... · ϕk(Dk)
   

   
   Its computational complexity grows exponentially with the number of variables n, making enumeration infeasible for large-scale instances.
3. Limitations of Existing Methods:
   • Sampling methods require 10^5 intermediate steps and hours of computation
   • Variational methods' performance is tightly coupled with distribution properties, with complexity increasing as potential function values grow
   • Belief propagation methods' performance depends on graph structure
   • All methods face trade-offs between accuracy and computational time

Research Motivation

To leverage the exponential scalability advantage of quantum computing to overcome the bottleneck of classical computation in partition function estimation, providing more efficient solutions for radar anomaly detection.

Core Contributions

1. Quantum Algorithm Adaptation: Adapting the partition function estimation algorithm in the single-qubit model to the Markov Random Field problem in radar anomaly detection
2. Quadratic Hamiltonian Construction: Proposing a method to transform binary quadratic form problems into quantum Hamiltonians whose eigenvalues correspond to probability configurations
3. Experimental Verification and Analysis: Verifying algorithm performance through IBM Qiskit simulation and comparing with theoretical results
4. Parameter Optimization Strategy: Discovering parameter settings superior to theoretical values, reducing computational overhead while maintaining accuracy

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Input: Parameter matrix Θ of binary Markov Random Field, where FC(xC) = xC^T Θ xC Output: Estimated value of partition function ZC = Σ_{xC∈{0,1}^n} exp(FC(xC)) Constraint: Achieving exponential acceleration within polynomial time using quantum computing

Model Architecture

1. Single-Qubit Model

The initial state consists of one pure-state qubit |0⟩ and q completely mixed-state qubits:

ρ = |0⟩⟨0| ⊗ (Iq/2^q)

Through controlled unitary operator U gate operations, measuring the auxiliary qubit yields probability p0:

p0 = 1/2 + Re(Tr(U))/2^{q+1}

2. Block Encoding of Unitary Operators

Representing the Hamiltonian H as a linear combination of unitary operators (LCU):

H = Σ_{l=1}^L α_l H_l

Defining "preparation" quantum oracle P and "selection" quantum oracle S:

P|0⟩_m = Σ_{l=1}^L √α_l |l⟩_m
S = Σ_{l=1}^L H_l ⊗ |l⟩⟨l|_m

3. Chebyshev Polynomial Approximation

Utilizing Chebyshev approximation expansion of the exponential operator:

e^{-βH} = Σ_{k=-∞}^∞ (-1)^k I_k(β) T_k(H)

Generating k-th order Chebyshev polynomials through k successive applications of the walk operator WH:

T_k(H) = ⟨0|(I_n ⊗ P')(W_H)^k (I_n ⊗ P'†)|0⟩_{n+m'}

Technical Innovations

1. Binary Operator Definition: Innovatively defining the B = (I-Z)/2 operator, directly mapping binary quadratic forms to quantum operator space
2. Hamiltonian Construction: Constructing Hamiltonian HC:

   HC = Σ_{i=1}^n θ_{i,i}B_i + Σ_{i≠j} θ_{i,j}B_{i,j}
   

   
   whose eigenvalues precisely correspond to {PC(xC)}_{xC∈{0,1}^n}
3. Parameter Optimization: Discovering that K=3 and εabs=0.1 parameter settings significantly reduce quantum gate count while maintaining accuracy

Experimental Setup

Dataset

• Graph Scale: Small-scale binary Markov Random Fields with n ∈ {2,3,4}
• Graph Structure: Simulating variable dependencies in radar systems, represented using adjacency matrices
• Example Matrix: Θ matrix for 5-node graph containing diagonal and off-diagonal elements, satisfying normalization condition Σ|θi,j| = 1

Evaluation Metrics

• Relative Error: |Estimated Value - True Value|/True Value × 100%
• Theoretical Sample Count: Q = ⌈2^{2(n+m')+1} log(2K/δ)/(εabs/2e)^2⌉
• Theoretical Chebyshev Order: K = ⌈m + e + log2(1/εabs) + 2⌉

Comparison Methods

• Theoretical predicted values (based on theoretical analysis from reference 9)
• True partition function values computed through exact enumeration

Implementation Details

• Quantum Simulator: IBM Qiskit library
• Parameter Settings: K=3, εabs=0.1, δ=0.1
• Assumption: m'=n+1 (worst case, corresponding to complete graph)

Experimental Results

Main Results

Sample Count Impact Analysis

Chebyshev Order Impact Analysis

Key Findings

1. Sample Efficiency Improvement: For n=4, achieving approximately 10% error with only 10^4 samples, whereas theory predicts approximately 10^9 samples required
2. Chebyshev Order Optimization: Algorithm performance stabilizes at K=3; further increasing K does not significantly improve accuracy but increases quantum gate count
3. Scalability Analysis:
   • IBM Condor (1121 physical qubits) can support binary MRFs with up to 186 nodes (corresponding to ~10^56 partition function terms)
   • On quantum computers capable of preparing maximum mixed states, support extends to 373 nodes (corresponding to ~10^112 partition function terms)

Related Work

Classical Methods

1. Sampling Methods: Hamiltonian annealing importance sampling requires 10^5 intermediate steps and hours of computation
2. Variational Methods: Using convex programming hierarchies, but performance depends on distribution properties
3. Belief Propagation: Generalized belief propagation estimating partition functions of 2D Ising models, with performance dependent on graph structure

Quantum Computing Applications

1. DQC1 Problem Class: Decision problems solvable in polynomial time by the single-qubit model
2. Hamiltonian Simulation: Block encoding methods for linear combinations of unitary operators (LCU)
3. Trace Estimation Algorithms: Quantum algorithms' applications in spectral density estimation, integrability testing, and related fields

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully adapting the quantum partition function estimation algorithm to the Markov Random Field problem in radar anomaly detection
2. Experimental results demonstrate algorithm performance exceeding theoretical predictions, achieving satisfactory accuracy with fewer samples and lower Chebyshev orders
3. Quantum methods provide new possibilities for handling large-scale partition function computations

Limitations

1. NISQ Era Constraints: Current quantum hardware noise and error rates limit practical applications
2. Physical Qubit Requirements: Logical qubit construction requires multiple physical qubits, limiting practical usable scale
3. Continuous Variable Extension: Current methods apply only to binary variables, requiring further extension to continuous variables

Future Directions

1. Hybrid Graphical Models: Extending to complete anomaly detection models incorporating continuous variables
2. Quantum Gate Optimization: Optimizing circuit implementation to reduce quantum gate count
3. Hardware Adaptation: Considering parameter optimization for specific quantum hardware architectures and gate costs

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Problem Selection: Selecting the practically valuable radar anomaly detection problem, demonstrating quantum computing's utility
2. Solid Theory: Based on mature single-qubit model theory, with rigorous algorithm design
3. Parameter Analysis: Thoroughly analyzing sample count and Chebyshev order impacts on performance, discovering parameter settings superior to theory
4. Scalability Discussion: Objectively analyzing application potential of current and future quantum hardware

Weaknesses

1. Experimental Scale: Simulation verification only on small-scale problems (n≤4), lacking validation on large-scale instances
2. Noise Effects: Not considering quantum hardware noise impacts on algorithm performance
3. Comparison Baselines: Lacking direct performance comparisons with other classical partition function estimation methods
4. Practical Deployment: Algorithm performance not verified on real quantum hardware

Impact

1. Academic Contribution: Providing new insights for quantum computing applications in probabilistic graphical models
2. Practical Value: Offering quantum solutions for solving practical problems such as radar system anomaly detection
3. Technical Legacy: Laying foundations for subsequent quantum machine learning algorithm development

Applicable Scenarios

1. Large-Scale Probabilistic Graphical Models: Suitable for partition function estimation of Markov Random Fields with large numbers of variables
2. Real-Time Anomaly Detection: Applicable to anomaly detection systems requiring rapid response
3. Quantum Advantage Verification: Serving as a typical case demonstrating quantum computing's relative advantage over classical computing

References

The paper cites 21 important references covering fundamental quantum computing theory, Hamiltonian simulation, partition function estimation, and other key domains, providing solid theoretical foundations for the research.