Thermodynamic properties of an ideal Quark-Gluon plasma under quantum gravitational effects

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.01159
• Title: Thermodynamic properties of an ideal Quark-Gluon plasma under quantum gravitational effects
• Authors: Djamel Eddine Zenkhri, Abdelhakim Benkrane (Université Kasdi Merbah Ouargla, Algeria)
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Publication Date: January 2, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.01159

Abstract

This study investigates the thermodynamic properties of an ideal quark-gluon plasma (QGP) at zero chemical potential under the influence of quantum gravitational effects, specifically within the framework of the Linear-Quadratic Generalized Uncertainty Principle (LQGUP). The analysis examines the impact of LQGUP on critical thermodynamic quantities, including the grand canonical potential, pressure, energy density, entropy, speed of sound, and the response of bulk viscosity coefficient to changes in sound speed. Furthermore, the analysis extends to the temporal evolution of cosmic temperature under LQGUP effects.

Research Background and Motivation

Physical Background

1. Quark-Gluon Plasma (QGP): A state of matter existing microseconds after the Big Bang, composed of unconfined quarks and gluons, which can be recreated in high-energy nuclear collisions (such as RHIC and LHC experiments).
2. Quantum Gravitational Effects: At extremely high energies and extremely small length scales, the traditional Heisenberg uncertainty principle requires modification. The Generalized Uncertainty Principle (GUP) is introduced to describe the combination of quantum mechanics and gravitational effects.

Research Motivation

1. Theoretical Requirements: In the early universe, both QGP and quantum gravitational effects are important simultaneously, necessitating study of their mutual interactions.
2. Experimental Relevance: The QGP properties observed in high-energy physics experiments may be affected by quantum gravitational corrections.
3. Cosmological Applications: Understanding the evolution of the early universe requires considering quantum gravitational corrections to the state of matter.

Core Contributions

1. First Systematic Study: Systematic calculation of thermodynamic properties of ideal QGP within the Linear-Quadratic Generalized Uncertainty Principle (LQGUP) framework.
2. Complete Thermodynamic Analysis: Derivation of analytical expressions for the corrected partition function, pressure, energy density, entropy, and speed of sound.
3. Bulk Viscosity Analysis: Investigation of quantum gravitational effects on the bulk viscosity coefficient of QGP, revealing the breaking of conformal invariance.
4. Cosmological Applications: Analysis of LQGUP effects on the evolution of temperature and energy density in the early universe.
5. Physical Insights: Discovery that quantum gravitational effects cause the speed of sound to approach 1/5 in the high-temperature limit rather than the classical value of 1/3.

Detailed Methodology

Theoretical Framework

Linear-Quadratic Generalized Uncertainty Principle (LQGUP)

The commutation relation for LQGUP is:

[xi, pj] = iℏ[δij - β(pδij + pipj/p) + β²(p²δij + 3pipj)]

The corresponding uncertainty relation:

Δx Δp ≥ (1/2)(1 + βΔp + β²Δp²)

where β = α₀/Mpc = α₀lp/ℏ is the GUP parameter.

Modified Dispersion Relation

Under the LQGUP framework, the relativistic dispersion relation is modified to:

E²(k) = k²c²(1 - βk + β²k²)² + M²c⁴

In the chiral limit (M = 0) and zero chemical potential (μ = 0):

E(k) = k(1 - βk + β²k²)

Partition Function Calculation

Boson (Gluon) Case

The grand canonical partition function:

ln ZB = -Vg/(2π²) ∫₀^∞ k² ln[1 - exp(-E(k)/T)] dk/(1 - βk + β²k²)⁴

After variable substitution and expansion to second order in β:

ln ZB = (π²/90)VgT³ + 24Vg/(π²)βT⁴ζ(5) + (32/70)Vgπ⁴β²T⁵

Fermion (Quark) Case

Similarly, the fermion partition function is:

ln ZF = (7/8)(π²/90)VgT³ + (45/2π²)VgβT⁴ζ(5) + (31/70)Vgπ⁴β²T⁵

Derivation of Thermodynamic Quantities

Grand Canonical Potential

Ω = -(gg + 7/8 gq)(π²V/90)T⁴ - β(24gg + 45gq/2)(VT⁵ζ(5)/π²) - β²(32gg + 31gq)(Vπ⁴T⁶/70) - BV

Pressure and Energy Density

Pressure:

P = (σSB/3)T⁴ + β(24gg + 45gq/2)(T⁵ζ(5)/π²) + β²(32gg + 31gq)(π⁴T⁶/70) - B

Energy density:

ε = σSBT⁴ + 3β(24gg + 45gq/2)(T⁵ζ(5)/π²) + 3β²(32gg + 31gq)(π⁴T⁶/70) + B

where σSB = (gg + 7/8 gq)π²/30 is the Stefan-Boltzmann constant.

Experimental Setup

Parameter Selection

• Effective Degrees of Freedom: For nf = 2 light quark flavors, gq = 24, gg = 16, totaling gQGP = 37
• GUP Parameter: β ranges from 0 to 0.08 GeV⁻¹
• Critical Temperature: Tc = 170 MeV
• Bag Constant: Determined through phase transition conditions

Computational Methods

1. Grand canonical ensemble approach
2. Chiral limit approximation (massless quarks and gluons)
3. Zero chemical potential condition
4. Expansion to second order in GUP parameter β

Experimental Results

Main Thermodynamic Properties

Pressure and Energy Density

• No GUP Limit: P/T⁴ approaches the Stefan-Boltzmann limit σSB
• LQGUP Correction: At high temperatures, P/T⁴ exceeds the Stefan-Boltzmann limit, indicating that quantum gravitational effects alter the properties of radiation and matter.

Entropy Density

The corrected entropy density:

s = (2π²/45)(gg + 7/8 gq)T³ + (15ζ(5)/π²)β(8gg + 15gq/2)T⁴ + (3π⁴/35)β²(32gg + 31gq)T⁵

Speed of Sound

The LQGUP-corrected speed of sound:

cs² ≈ 1/3 - 75ζ(5)/(2π⁴) × [(15gq/2 + 8gg)/(7gq/8 + gg)]βT + O(β²T²)

Key Findings:

• When β → 0: cs² → 1/3 (classical result)
• When T → ∞: cs² → 1/5 (rather than the classical 1/3)

Bulk Viscosity Coefficient

According to the Buchel bound:

ζ/η ≥ 2(1/3 - cs²)

LQGUP correction results in:

• Non-zero minimum value of bulk viscosity coefficient at finite temperature
• Breaking of conformal invariance
• High-temperature limit: ζ/η → 4/15

Cosmological Applications

Temperature Evolution

Under LQGUP effects:

• Quantum gravity reduces the temperature of the QGP phase
• The transition time from QGP phase to hadron phase is shortened
• When β = 0: tI = 20.62 μs
• When β = 0.08 GeV⁻¹: tI = 17.39 μs

Energy Density Evolution

The solution to the energy density evolution equation:

ε(t) = B coth²(√(32πBG/3) t)

LQGUP effects increase the energy density of the QGP phase, and this effect grows with time.

Related Work

GUP Theory Development

• Pioneering work by Kempf and others established the mathematical framework of GUP
• String theory and loop quantum gravity provide theoretical foundations for GUP
• Various forms of GUP: linear GUP, quadratic GUP, higher-order GUP, etc.

QGP Thermodynamics Research

• MIT bag model provides fundamental description of QGP
• Lattice QCD calculations provide non-perturbative results
• Experimental observations (RHIC, LHC) verify the existence of QGP

Quantum Gravity and QGP

• Importance of QGP and quantum gravitational effects in the early universe
• Previous work primarily focused on linear GUP; this paper extends to the linear-quadratic case

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Thermodynamic Corrections: LQGUP produces significant corrections to all thermodynamic quantities of QGP, with correction terms proportional to higher powers of temperature.
2. Breaking of Conformal Invariance: Quantum gravitational effects destroy the conformal invariance of massless particle systems, causing the speed of sound to deviate from the classical value of 1/3.
3. Bulk Viscosity Effects: LQGUP introduces a non-zero minimum value of bulk viscosity coefficient, reaching a specific value in the high-temperature limit.
4. Cosmological Significance: Quantum gravitational effects influence the evolution of the early universe, reducing temperature but increasing energy density.

Limitations

1. Ideal Gas Approximation: Neglects interactions between quarks and gluons.
2. Perturbative Expansion: Only considers second-order corrections in GUP parameter β.
3. Chiral Limit: Assumes massless quarks and gluons.
4. Zero Chemical Potential: Does not consider finite baryon density cases.

Future Directions

1. Interaction Effects: Include non-perturbative effects of QCD interactions.
2. Finite Chemical Potential: Study LQGUP effects at finite baryon density.
3. Experimental Verification: Search for observable quantum gravitational signals.
4. Numerical Simulations: Perform lattice QCD calculations to verify theoretical predictions.

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Completeness: Systematically derives complete thermodynamic properties of QGP within the LQGUP framework.
2. Mathematical Rigor: Detailed calculation process with clear formula derivations.
3. Physical Insights: Discovers important physical consequences of quantum gravitational effects, such as breaking of conformal invariance.
4. Cosmological Applications: Connects microscopic physics with cosmology, possessing significant importance.

Weaknesses

1. Difficulty in Experimental Verification: Predicted effects are difficult to observe under current experimental conditions.
2. Model Simplification: The ideal gas approximation may be overly simplified.
3. Parameter Uncertainty: The specific value of GUP parameter β lacks experimental constraints.
4. Higher-Order Corrections: Neglecting terms of β³ and higher may introduce significant effects.

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides a new theoretical framework for combining quantum gravity with strong interaction matter.
2. Practical Value: Provides theoretical predictions for future high-energy experiments and cosmological observations.
3. Reproducibility: Clear computational methods allow results to be independently verified.

Applicable Scenarios

1. Early Universe Physics: Study of matter states microseconds after the Big Bang.
2. High-Energy Nuclear Physics: Analysis of QCD matter properties under extreme conditions.
3. Quantum Gravity Phenomenology: Search for observable signals of quantum gravitational effects.
4. Theoretical Physics Research: Important case study for GUP applications.

References

This paper cites 53 important references, covering:

• Foundational literature on GUP theory (Kempf, Ali, et al.)
• Classical textbooks on QGP physics (Yagi, Hatsuda, Miake)
• Related theoretical and experimental research
• Work on cosmology and the early universe

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality research paper in theoretical physics that makes important contributions at the intersection of quantum gravity and strong interaction matter. While experimental verification remains challenging, it provides new theoretical perspectives for understanding matter properties under extreme conditions.