Revealing diatom-inspired materials multifunctionality

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.01229
• Title: Revealing diatom-inspired materials multifunctionality
• Authors: L. Musenich, D. Origo, F. Gallina, M. J. Buehler, F. Libonati
• Classification: cond-mat.mtrl-sci
• Publication Date: January 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.01229

Abstract

Diatoms are renowned as "nanoscale lithographers" due to their ability to create complex three-dimensional amorphous silica exoskeletons. The hierarchical architecture of these structures provides diatoms with mechanical protection while enabling filtration, flotation, and light manipulation capabilities. Through numerical simulation, analytical modeling, and experimental testing, this study reveals the structural and hydrodynamic efficiency of Coscinodiscus species diatoms and proposes a novel 3D-printed multifunctional biomimetic material applicable to porous filters, heat exchangers, drug delivery systems, lightweight structures, and robotic systems.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Core Problem: Traditional material design faces performance trade-offs, such as the contradiction between strength and toughness, limiting applications in extreme environments. Multifunctional materials can simultaneously possess multiple structural and non-structural functions, yet their complex characterization requirements restrict the availability of suitable materials.
2. Problem Significance: In critical applications such as nuclear pressure vessels, bridges, ships, medical prostheses, and aerospace engines, "damage-tolerant" materials requiring both high strength and high fracture toughness are essential for improving efficiency, safety, and sustainability.
3. Limitations of Existing Approaches: Although composite materials and additive manufacturing technologies offer new possibilities for multifunctional material design, available multifunctional materials remain limited, primarily due to their complex characterization requirements.
4. Research Motivation: The complex multi-scale structures of diatoms, evolved over billions of years, can simultaneously perform multiple functions, providing valuable biological inspiration for multifunctional material design. Notably, the siliceous frustule of diatoms not only provides mechanical protection but also regulates nutrient acquisition, sedimentation rates, viral filtration, and light absorption.

Core Contributions

1. Established a comprehensive biomimetic material design framework: Developed and validated a biomimetic material model based on Coscinodiscus species diatom morphology
2. Revealed the mechanisms of hierarchical structure on multifunctionality: Systematically analyzed the contributions of each structural layer to bending stiffness, compressive strength, and hydrodynamic performance through experiments and numerical simulations
3. Developed 3D-printed multifunctional materials: Scaled diatom structures to millimeter dimensions, achieving lightweight materials with optimized structural and hydrodynamic performance
4. Proposed a multifunctional efficiency evaluation system: Established an efficiency parameter evaluation method comprehensively considering both structural and hydrodynamic performance
5. Validated the effectiveness of natural optimization design: Demonstrated that natural diatom structures exhibit superior multifunctional performance compared to deformed geometric configurations

Methodology Details

Task Definition

This study aims to design multifunctional materials through biomimetic approaches based on the hierarchical structure of Coscinodiscus species diatoms, achieving optimal combinations of structural performance (bending stiffness, compressive strength) and hydrodynamic performance (filtration efficiency, flow distribution).

Model Architecture

Biomimetic Material Model Design

The hierarchical structure of diatom frustules comprises three primary levels:

1. Foramen Layer: Biomineralized plate with reinforced pores
2. Areolae Layer: Intermediate honeycomb-like structure
3. Cribrum Layer: Final porous biosilica layer

Modeling Methodology

A modular approach was employed to construct the biomimetic material model:

• Definition of representative volume elements (RVE)
• Formation of periodic porous materials through 2D replication
• CAD modeling based on natural diatom geometric data
• Validation beginning with 1:1 scale models, followed by scaling to millimeter dimensions for 3D printing

Numerical Analysis Methods

1. Finite Element Analysis (FE): Structural analysis using Abaqus CAE 2017
2. Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD): Fluid performance analysis using ANSYS 2019 R2
3. Analytical Modeling: Establishment of analytical formulas for bending moment of inertia and critical buckling stress

Technical Innovations

1. Multi-scale Validation Strategy: Initial validation of the biomimetic model against natural structures at 1:1 scale, followed by scaled experimental verification
2. Hierarchical Performance Decoupling Analysis: Systematic analysis of each layer's contribution to overall performance, identifying critical structural elements
3. Geometric Variation Impact Study: Exploration of structure-performance relationships through parameter variation including pore position, size, and reinforcement ring design
4. Multifunctional Efficiency Quantification: Establishment of a comprehensive efficiency parameter system evaluating both structural and fluid performance

Experimental Setup

Material Preparation

• 3D Printing Equipment: Objet500 Connex1 multi-material polyjet 3D printer
• Printing Materials: VeroBlack® for structure, water-soluble wax-like material for support
• Scale Magnification: 5000× magnification relative to natural diatoms

Mechanical Testing

1. Three-Point Bending Test: MTS Synergie testing machine, 1 kN load cell, 2 mm/min displacement control
2. Four-Point Bending Test: Following ASTM D6272-17 standard at 1 mm/min speed
3. Compression Test: MTS Alliance RF150 machine, 150 kN load cell, following ASTM C365/C365M-16 standard
4. Tensile Test: Following ASTM D638-14 standard to determine VeroBlack® elastic properties

Numerical Simulation Setup

• Material Parameters: VeroBlack® elastic modulus 1567 MPa, Poisson's ratio 0.35
• Mesh: Structured hexahedral element mesh with approximately 850,000 finite elements
• Boundary Conditions: Surface contact friction coefficient 0.15, periodic boundary conditions for honeycomb compression analysis
• CFD Settings: Water as fluid medium, inlet flow velocity 1 m/s, outlet atmospheric pressure

Evaluation Metrics

1. Structural Performance:
   • Bending stiffness k₃ₚB (N/mm)
   • Bending efficiency η^flex = k₄ₚB/m
   • Critical buckling stress σbuckl
2. Fluid Performance:
   • Hydrodynamic efficiency η^fluid = ṁoutlet,out/ṁoutlet,in
   • Flow distribution efficiency η^force = 1/Fmaxforamen
3. Comprehensive Performance:
   • Multifunctional efficiency η^multi = η^flex + η^fluid + η^force

Experimental Results

Primary Results

Biomimetic Model Validation

The biomimetic structure exhibited a bending elastic modulus of EflexBI = 28.3 GPa, compared to the natural structure EflexN = 36.4±8.3 GPa. Numerical calculation results fell within experimental uncertainty ranges, validating the reliability of the biomimetic model.

Impact of Hierarchical Design on Structural Performance

The bending stiffness-to-relative-density ratio of the hierarchical structure (k₃ₚB/ρrel = 9.73 N/mm) was nearly two orders of magnitude higher than single-layer structures:

• Foramen layer: k₃ₚB/ρrel = 0.11 N/mm
• Areolae layer: k₃ₚB/ρrel = 0.31 N/mm
• Cribrum layer: k₃ₚB/ρrel = 0.04 N/mm

Critical Role of Honeycomb Layer

Analysis of honeycomb layer wall thickness variations revealed:

• As wall thickness decreases, moment of inertia increases but bending stiffness decreases
• A critical buckling point exists, validating the cubic relationship σcr ∝ (t/l)³
• Natural structure wall thickness approaches optimal design

Hydrodynamic Performance of Porous Layer

CFD analysis revealed:

• Reinforcement rings produce counter-flow effects, enhancing nutrient capture efficiency
• Regular geometric structures promote uniform pressure distribution
• The original RVE design exhibits optimal multifunctional performance

Ablation Studies

Comparative experiments varying pore position, size, and reinforcement ring design showed:

• Multifunctional efficiency variations among Cribrum layer deformed configurations <5%
• Multifunctional efficiency decreased 26-35% after removing reinforcement rings from Foramen layer
• Original geometric design outperformed all alternative configurations

Multifunctional Performance Evaluation

Radar chart analysis indicated:

• Regular structure design of natural diatoms exhibits optimal multifunctional performance
• Reinforcement rings significantly enhance material multifunctional efficiency
• Structural optimization and hydrodynamic performance achieve good balance

Related Work

Multifunctional Materials Research

Existing multifunctional materials primarily concentrate in composite and metamaterial fields, yet remain limited by complex characterization requirements. Additive manufacturing technology provides new opportunities for multifunctional material design.

Biomimetic Materials Research

Bone and nacre-inspired biomimetic materials represent the most successful cases, though diatoms offer richer design inspiration for multifunctionality. Existing diatom research primarily focuses on single-function applications, lacking multidisciplinary comprehensive investigation.

Diatom Structure Research

Previous studies have investigated diatom structures through imaging techniques, mechanical testing, and numerical simulation, proposing various biomimetic applications from architecture to filtration devices. However, systematic multifunctional material development research remains lacking.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. The hierarchical structure of diatoms achieves significant enhancement in structural efficiency, with hierarchical design performance nearly two orders of magnitude higher than single-layer structures
2. Natural diatom structures, optimized through evolution, outperform artificial deformed designs in multifunctionality
3. The honeycomb layer is the critical element determining mechanical performance, while reinforcement rings are essential for fluid performance
4. The developed biomimetic materials show potential applications in porous filtration, heat exchange, and drug delivery

Limitations

1. Material Constraints: Use of polymeric materials alters the essential properties of diatom bioceramics
2. Scale Effects: 5000× magnification may introduce scale-related performance variations
3. Manufacturing Defects: Anisotropy and defects introduced by additive manufacturing affect experimental results
4. Functional Scope: Optical functions and other important diatom characteristics remain unexplored

Future Directions

1. Materials Informatics Application: Construct predictive models utilizing the diversity of diatom shapes and properties
2. Multi-material Design: Explore the impact of different base materials on hierarchical structure multifunctionality
3. Functional Extension: Investigate integration of optical, self-healing, and other functionalities
4. Application Development: Develop specific applications including microfluidic valves, catalytic systems, and tissue engineering scaffolds

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong Systematicity: Complete research framework from biomimetic design to experimental validation
2. Diverse Methodology: Multi-verification combining numerical simulation, analytical modeling, and experimental testing
3. High Innovation: First systematic investigation of diatom structure multifunctionality, establishing new evaluation systems
4. Practical Value: Proposed 3D-printed materials demonstrate clear application prospects
5. Theoretical Contribution: Reveals scientific principles underlying natural structure optimization design

Weaknesses

1. Single Material: Exclusive use of polymeric materials fails to fully exploit diatom ceramic characteristics
2. Scale Limitations: Significant magnification may obscure certain micro-scale effects
3. Incomplete Functionality: Important optical functions of diatoms remain unexplored
4. Application Verification: Lacks performance validation in actual application scenarios

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides new theoretical framework and experimental methods for biomimetic multifunctional material design
2. Engineering Applications: Direct applicability in filtration, heat exchange, and lightweight structure fields
3. Interdisciplinary Significance: Bridges biology, materials science, and engineering applications
4. Methodological Contribution: Established multifunctional evaluation system generalizable to other biomimetic material research

Applicable Scenarios

1. Aerospace: Lightweight high-strength structural materials
2. Biomedical: Drug delivery carriers, tissue engineering scaffolds
3. Environmental Engineering: High-efficiency filtration membranes, water treatment systems
4. Energy Systems: Heat exchangers, porous electrode materials
5. Robotics: Soft robot structures, intelligent material systems

References

The paper cites 68 relevant references spanning multifunctional materials, biomimetics, diatom biology, additive manufacturing, and other important research areas, providing a solid theoretical foundation for this investigation.