Heitler effect and resonance fluorescence in quantum magnonics

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.01254
• Title: Heitler effect and resonance fluorescence in quantum magnonics
• Authors: Enes Ilbuğa, V. V. Dobrovitski, Ya. M. Blanter
• Classification: cond-mat.mes-hall quant-ph
• Publication Date: January 3, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.01254
• Affiliations: Kavli Institute of Nanoscience, Delft University of Technology; QuTech, Delft University of Technology

Abstract

This study investigates a system comprising a qubit coupled to a magnon mode under weak driving. The spectral steady-state response of both the qubit and magnon exhibits, in addition to two sidebands displaying coupling-induced splitting, a nearly zero-linewidth peak at the driving frequency. This phenomenon exists in both strong and weak coupling regimes and represents an analogue of the Heitler effect from atomic physics, pointing toward the development of coherent magnon sources.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Quantum magnonics development requirements: Magnonics, as a discipline studying the properties of magnetic excitations (magnons), holds enormous potential for classical and quantum information transmission. To achieve functionality, controlled excitation, manipulation, and detection of individual magnons are required.
2. Material limitations: The primary material currently used, yttrium iron garnet (YIG), despite possessing the highest magnetic quality factor (exceeding 10⁴), has a magnon lifetime of approximately 100 ns at GHz frequencies, far shorter than that of qubits and cavities, representing a significant limiting factor for quantum technology applications.
3. Insufficiency of existing methods: Although traditional cavity magnonics has achieved strong coupling, magnon lifetime remains a limiting factor, and prospects for material parameter improvement are limited.

Research Motivation

This work aims to overcome material lifetime limitations by realizing an analogue of the Heitler effect in magnonics to create long-lived magnon streams with nearly zero linewidth, thereby providing novel solutions for quantum information processing.

Core Contributions

1. Theoretical discovery: First identification and analysis of the Heitler effect analogue in quantum magnonics, wherein a weakly driven qubit-magnon coupled system produces a zero-linewidth spectral peak at the driving frequency.
2. Universality verification: Demonstration that the effect exists in both strong and weak coupling regimes, extending the applicability of the phenomenon.
3. Coherent magnon source proposal: Establishment of theoretical foundations for constructing highly stable single-magnon sources with fixed phase and frequency.
4. Quantum correlation establishment: Creation of long-lived stable correlations with fixed phase between qubit and magnon modes, providing resources for quantum information tasks.

Methodology Details

System Model

The study considers a linearly coupled qubit-magnon system. The Hamiltonian in the rotating frame is:

$\hat{H} = \frac{1}{2}\Delta_q\hat{\sigma}_z + \Delta_m\hat{m}^\dagger\hat{m} + g(\hat{\sigma}_+\hat{m} + \hat{\sigma}_-\hat{m}^\dagger) + \Omega(\hat{\sigma}_+ + \hat{\sigma}_-)$

where:

• $\Delta_q = \omega_q - \omega_L$, $\Delta_m = \omega_m - \omega_L$ are the detunings of qubit and magnon frequencies relative to the driving frequency
• $g$ is the interaction strength
• $\Omega$ is the driving strength

Master Equation Description

System evolution is described by the Lindblad master equation with dissipation:

$\frac{d}{dt}\hat{\rho}(t) = i[\hat{\rho}(t), \hat{H}] + \frac{\gamma}{2}(2\hat{\sigma}_-\hat{\rho}(t)\hat{\sigma}_+ - \{\hat{\sigma}_+\hat{\sigma}_-, \hat{\rho}(t)\}) + \frac{\kappa}{2}(2\hat{m}\hat{\rho}(t)\hat{m}^\dagger - \{\hat{m}^\dagger\hat{m}, \hat{\rho}(t)\})$

where $\gamma$ and $\kappa$ are the spontaneous decay rates of the qubit and magnon, respectively.

Spectral Response Functions

The spectral steady-state response of the system is defined through Fourier transforms of correlation functions:

$S_q(\omega) = 2\text{Re}\int_0^\infty d\tau e^{-i(\omega-\omega_L)\tau}\langle\hat{\sigma}_+(\tau)\hat{\sigma}_-(0)\rangle_{ss}$

$S_m(\omega) = 2\text{Re}\int_0^\infty d\tau e^{-i(\omega-\omega_L)\tau}\langle\hat{m}^\dagger(\tau)\hat{m}(0)\rangle_{ss}$

Weak Driving Approximation

Under weak driving conditions ($\Omega \ll \gamma$ or $\Omega \ll \kappa$), the system can be restricted to a three-level subspace: $|0\rangle \equiv |g,0\rangle$, $|m\rangle \equiv |g,1\rangle$, $|q\rangle \equiv |e,0\rangle$.

Experimental Setup

Parameter Ranges

• Coupling strength: $g = 0.5$ to $g = 100$ (arbitrary units)
• Driving strength: $\Omega = 0.01$ to $\Omega = 1$ (weak driving regime)
• Decay rates: $\gamma = 5$ to $\gamma = 15$, $\kappa = 0$ to $\kappa = 50$

Numerical Methods

1. Time evolution: Numerical integration of the master equation equations of motion
2. Spectral calculation: Discrete Fourier transform for spectral distribution computation
3. Steady-state solution: Matrix inversion to obtain steady-state operator expectation values

Analysis Methods

• Strong coupling limit: $g \gg \kappa, \gamma$
• Weak coupling limit: $g \ll \kappa, \gamma$
• Resonance condition: $\omega_q = \omega_m = \omega_L \equiv \omega_0$

Experimental Results

Main Findings

1. Appearance of δ-function Peaks

Observed in both qubit and magnon spectra:

• Sideband peaks: Lorentzian peaks with finite linewidth located at $\omega_0 \pm g$
• Elastic scattering peak: δ-function peak at the driving frequency $\omega_0$ with nearly zero linewidth

2. Strong Coupling Case

When $g = 100, \gamma = 15, \kappa = 0$:

• Scattering amplitudes of qubit and magnon are nearly identical
• δ-peak height grows linearly with integration time, confirming its δ-function character

3. Weak Coupling Case

When $g = 0.5, \gamma = 10, \kappa = 50$:

• Magnon still displays δ-peak despite smaller amplitude
• Qubit scattering amplitude is independent of magnon decay

Analytical Results

In the weak driving limit, analytical expressions for steady-state operator expectation values are:

Qubit: $|\langle\hat{\sigma}_+\rangle_{ss}|^2 = \frac{\Omega^2(\Delta^2 + \frac{1}{4}\kappa^2)}{g^4 + \Delta^4 + \frac{1}{4}\gamma^2\Delta^2 + \frac{1}{4}\kappa^2\Delta^2 - 2\Delta^2g^2 + \frac{1}{16}\kappa^2\gamma^2 + \frac{1}{2}g^2\gamma\kappa}$

Magnon: $|\langle\hat{m}^\dagger\rangle_{ss}|^2 = \frac{\Omega^2g^2}{g^4 + \Delta^4 + \frac{1}{4}\gamma^2\Delta^2 + \frac{1}{4}\kappa^2\Delta^2 - 2\Delta^2g^2 + \frac{1}{16}\kappa^2\gamma^2 + \frac{1}{2}g^2\gamma\kappa}$

Key Findings

1. Universality: The Heitler effect exists in both strong and weak coupling regimes
2. Phase locking: Stable long-range correlations with fixed phase are established between qubit and magnon states
3. Linewidth limitation: δ-peak linewidth is limited only by driving source stability, not by system dissipation

Related Work

Quantum Magnonics Development

1. Cavity magnonics: Strong coupling between magnons and electromagnetic fields via microwave cavities
2. Quantum state conversion: Applications of magnons in microwave-to-optical quantum state conversion
3. Direct coupling schemes: Direct coupling between qubits and magnons without cavity mediation

Heitler Effect

• Original theory: Resonance fluorescence phenomenon discovered by Heitler in atomic physics
• Application fields: Single-photon sources, quantum communication, entanglement generation
• Innovation in this work: First extension of this effect to quantum magnonics

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Theoretical verification: Successful realization of the Heitler effect analogue in quantum magnonics
2. Technical breakthrough: Novel pathway for constructing coherent magnon sources
3. Application prospects: New resources for high-precision sensing, metrology, and qubit entanglement

Limitations

1. Weak driving constraint: Effect is most pronounced under weak driving conditions
2. Three-level approximation: Theoretical analysis restricted to three-level subspace
3. Experimental verification: Experimental validation of theoretical predictions is needed

Future Directions

1. Experimental implementation: Verification of theoretical predictions on actual quantum magnonic platforms
2. Application development: Exploration of specific applications in quantum information processing
3. Parameter optimization: Investigation of optimal performance under different parameter conditions

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical innovation: First generalization of the classical Heitler effect to quantum magnonics with significant theoretical importance
2. Complete methodology: Combination of numerical simulation and analytical solutions providing a comprehensive theoretical framework
3. Strong universality: Verification of effect existence in both strong and weak coupling regimes
4. Practical value: Novel approach to addressing magnon lifetime limitations

Weaknesses

1. Experimental absence: Pure theoretical study lacking experimental verification
2. Parameter constraints: Weak driving conditions may limit signal strength in practical applications
3. Model simplification: Omission of complex factors present in actual systems

Impact

1. Academic contribution: New research direction for quantum magnonic theory development
2. Technical potential: Possible advancement of coherent magnon source technology
3. Cross-disciplinary value: Connection of concepts from atomic physics and condensed matter physics

Applicable Scenarios

1. Quantum sensing: High-precision magnetic field measurement and metrology applications
2. Quantum information: Qubit entanglement and information transmission
3. Fundamental research: Realization of quantum optical effects in solid-state systems

References

The paper cites 36 relevant references covering important works in quantum magnonics, cavity QED, quantum optics, and other related fields, providing a solid theoretical foundation for the research.

Summary: This work theoretically realizes the Heitler effect in quantum magnonics for the first time, providing a novel physical mechanism for constructing high-quality coherent magnon sources. Although experimental verification is still needed, this work opens new research directions for quantum magnonic development and possesses significant academic value and application prospects.