Bounds on Coloring Trees without Rainbow Paths

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.01302
• Title: Bounds on Coloring Trees without Rainbow Paths
• Authors: Wayne Goddard, Tyler Herrman, Simon J. Hughes (Clemson University)
• Classification: math.CO (Combinatorics)
• Publication Date: January 2, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.01302

Abstract

For a vertex coloring of a graph, a rainbow subgraph is a subgraph in which all vertices have distinct colors. For a graph $G$, let $c_k(G)$ denote the maximum number of distinct colors in a coloring that contains no rainbow path on $k$ vertices, and let $cp_k(G)$ denote the maximum number of colors under the requirement of proper coloring (adjacent vertices have different colors). The parameter $c_3$ has been studied by multiple scholars. This paper investigates trees and the case $k \geq 4$. First, the authors compute these parameters when $G$ is a path and determine the uniqueness conditions for optimal colorings. Then for an $n$-vertex tree $T$, they prove that the minimum values of $c_4(T)$ and $cp_4(T)$ are $(n+2)/2$, with crown graphs being exactly the trees achieving the minimum for $cp_4(T)$. Furthermore, the minimum values of $c_5(T)$ and $cp_5(T)$ are $(n+3)/2$, with octopus graphs being the trees achieving the minimum for either parameter.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Research Problem: This paper investigates the problem of avoiding rainbow paths in vertex colorings of graphs. Given a graph $G$ and a positive integer $k$, the goal is to determine the maximum number of distinct colors that can be used without producing a rainbow path on $k$ vertices (a path where all vertices have different colors).
2. Problem Significance:
   • This is an application of anti-Ramsey theory to vertex coloring with important theoretical value
   • It is closely related to structural properties of graphs and coloring theory
   • It provides new perspectives for understanding the relationship between chromatic number and graph structure
3. Limitations of Existing Research:
   • The parameter $c_3$ has been extensively studied, but the case $k \geq 4$ has received less attention
   • For trees, an important graph class, systematic research is lacking
   • There is an absence of complete characterization of extremal graph structures
4. Research Motivation: To fill the gap in the theory of rainbow path-avoiding colorings of trees for $k \geq 4$, with particular focus on the structural characteristics of extremal cases.

Core Contributions

1. Exact Formulas for Path Graphs: Provides exact formulas for $c_k(P_n)$ and $cp_k(P_n)$ on paths $P_n$, and determines necessary and sufficient conditions for uniqueness of optimal colorings.
2. Complete Resolution of the $P_4$ Case for Trees:
   • Proves that the minimum values of $c_4(T)$ and $cp_4(T)$ for an $n$-vertex tree $T$ are $(n+2)/2$
   • Completely characterizes trees achieving the minimum for $c_4(T)$ (crown graphs)
   • Partially characterizes the tree structure achieving the minimum for $cp_4(T)$
3. Extremal Results for the $P_5$ Case of Trees:
   • Proves that the minimum values of $c_5(T)$ and $cp_5(T)$ are $(n+3)/2$
   • Completely characterizes the unique extremal graph achieving the minimum (octopus graphs)
4. Important Structural Lemmas: Establishes general results on the impact of graph augmentation operations on parameter values.

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

• Input: Tree $T$ and positive integer $k$
• Output: $c_k(T)$ (maximum number of colors in arbitrary coloring) and $cp_k(T)$ (maximum number of colors in proper coloring)
• Constraint: The coloring cannot produce a rainbow path $P_k$ on $k$ vertices

Core Methodological Framework

1. Fundamental Lemma (Lemma 1)

On the impact of graph augmentation operations:

• If $G_1$ is obtained from $G$ by attaching $P_{k-1}$ to vertex $w$, then $c_k(G_1) = c_k(G) + k - 2$
• If $G_2$ is obtained from $G$ by attaching $P_{k-2}$ at endpoint $w$, then $cp_k(G_2) = cp_k(G) + k - 3$

2. Recurrence Formulas for Paths

Theorem 1: For path $P_n$ and $k \geq 2$: $c_k(P_n) = \lfloor\frac{(k-2)n}{k-1}\rfloor + 1$

Theorem 2: For $k \geq 3$: $cp_k(P_n) = \lfloor\frac{(k-3)n+1}{k-2}\rfloor + 1$

3. Blocking Set Theory (Theorem 3)

For tree $T$, the equality holds: $c_H(T) = n - \theta_H(T)$ where $\theta_H(T)$ is the $H$-blocking number (minimum number of edges needed to destroy all copies of $H$).

Technical Innovations

1. Structural Decomposition Method: Determines extremal graphs by analyzing structural characteristics such as diameter and degree distribution.
2. Inductive Proof Techniques:
   • Induction on path length
   • Induction on tree diameter
   • Induction on the number of vertices in the core graph
3. "Boring Vertex" Concept: Introduces vertex classification method to simplify analysis of proper colorings.
4. Constructive Proofs: Not only proves tightness of bounds but also provides explicit extremal coloring schemes.

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Verification Methods

The paper employs pure theoretical methods with verification through:

1. Concrete Example Verification:
   • Optimal coloring of $P_{11}$ without rainbow $P_5$: 12344567789 (9 colors)
   • Optimal proper coloring of $P_{11}$ without rainbow $P_5$: 12343565787 (8 colors)
2. Boundary Case Verification: Verifies that small-scale graph cases are consistent with formulas.
3. Constructive Proofs: Validates results by explicitly constructing colorings achieving the bounds.

Experimental Results

Main Results

Exact Values for Path Graphs

• Formula for $c_k(P_n)$: $\lfloor\frac{(k-2)n}{k-1}\rfloor + 1$
• Formula for $cp_k(P_n)$: $\lfloor\frac{(k-3)n+1}{k-2}\rfloor + 1$
• Uniqueness Conditions:
  • Optimal coloring for $c_k(P_n)$ is unique if and only if $n$ is a multiple of $k-1$
  • Optimal coloring for $cp_k(P_n)$ is unique if and only if $n$ is one more than a multiple of $k-2$

The $P_4$ Case for Trees

• Lower Bounds: $c_4(T) \geq cp_4(T) \geq \lceil n/2 \rceil + 1$ (Theorem 4)
• Minimum Values: The minimum values of $c_4(T)$ and $cp_4(T)$ are $(n+2)/2$
• Extremal Graphs:
  • Trees achieving $c_4(T) = (n+2)/2$ are exactly crown graphs (Theorems 5, 6)
  • For an $n$-vertex crown graph $H$: $c_4(H) = n/2 + 1$

The $P_5$ Case for Trees

• Lower Bounds: $c_5(T) \geq cp_5(T) \geq (n+3)/2$ (Theorem 9)
• Extremal Graphs: Octopus graph $O_b$ satisfies $c_5(O_b) = cp_5(O_b) = b + 2$ (Lemma 7)
• Uniqueness: Octopus graphs are the unique extremal graphs (Theorem 10)

Structural Characterization Results

1. Crown Graphs: Obtained by adding a leaf to each vertex of a core tree, achieving the minimum for $c_4$.
2. Octopus Graphs: Obtained by subdividing each edge of a star graph, achieving the minimum for both $c_5$ and $cp_5$.
3. Double Star Graphs: $cp_4(D_b) = b + 2$, where $D_b$ is a $b$-double star graph.

Related Work

1. Anti-Ramsey Theory:
   • Edge coloring versions have been more extensively studied
   • Vertex coloring version was initiated by Voloshin and others
2. Research on the $c_3$ Parameter:
   • Pioneering work by Bujtás and colleagues
   • Subsequent research by multiple scholars 4, 6, 7, 8
3. Research on Special Graph Classes:
   • General lower bounds for bipartite graphs
   • Related work on star graphs and induced subgraphs
4. Blocking Theory: Theoretical foundation for destroying specific subgraphs through edge deletion.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Complete Resolution for Path Graphs: Provides complete theory for rainbow path-avoiding colorings on paths, including exact formulas and uniqueness characterization.
2. Extremal Structures for Trees:
   • $P_4$ case: Crown graphs are the unique extremal graphs for $c_4$
   • $P_5$ case: Octopus graphs are the unique extremal graphs for both $c_5$ and $cp_5$
3. Methodological Contributions: Establishes systematic methods for handling such problems, including the impact of augmentation operations and structural decomposition techniques.

Limitations

1. Incomplete Characterization of $cp_4$: Unable to completely characterize all trees achieving $cp_4(T) = (n+2)/2$.
2. General $k$ Cases: Only resolves cases $k=4, 5$; larger values of $k$ remain open.
3. Other Graph Classes: Results primarily focus on trees; cases for other graph classes (such as planar graphs, regular graphs) require further investigation.

Future Directions

1. Complete Characterization Problem: Determine all trees achieving the minimum for $cp_4(T)$.
2. Larger Values of $k$: Establish theory for $c_k(T)$ and $cp_k(T)$ for $k \geq 6$.
3. Other Graph Classes:
   • Planar graphs
   • Verification of conjectures for regular graphs: $cp_4(G) \leq n/2 + 1$ for all connected cubic graphs
4. Algorithmic Problems: Design efficient algorithms to compute these parameters for given graphs.

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Completeness: Provides complete theory for path graphs, including exact formulas, uniqueness conditions, and constructive proofs.
2. Structural Depth: Not only provides numerical bounds but completely characterizes the structural features of extremal graphs.
3. Methodological Innovation:
   • Introduces the "boring vertex" concept to simplify analysis
   • Establishes general theory for augmentation operations
   • Combines blocking theory to provide new analytical tools
4. Rigorous Proofs: All results have complete mathematical proofs with clear logic.

Weaknesses

1. Limited Results: Main results concentrate on cases $k=4, 5$, with limited generality.
2. Incomplete Resolution of $cp_4$ Problem: While the minimum value is determined, not all extremal graphs are completely characterized.
3. Computational Complexity: Does not discuss the computational complexity of computing related parameters.
4. Application Background: Lacks discussion of practical application scenarios.

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides important progress for applications of anti-Ramsey theory to vertex coloring.
2. Methodological Value: The established analytical framework may be applicable to other related problems.
3. Foundation for Future Research: Provides a foundation for research on cases $k \geq 6$ and other graph classes.

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Research: Study of extremal problems in graph theory and combinatorics.
2. Algorithm Design: Theoretical analysis of graph coloring algorithms.
3. Network Analysis: Potential applications in network coloring problems requiring avoidance of specific patterns.

References

The paper cites 10 important references, primarily including:

• Pioneering work by Bujtás and colleagues on the $c_3$ parameter 3, 4
• Theoretical foundations by Voloshin on mixed interval hypergraphs 5, 10
• Related research by Goddard and Xu on vertex coloring avoiding rainbow subgraphs 7, 8, 9

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical paper that achieves important progress on the graph coloring problem of avoiding rainbow paths. Although results are primarily limited to specific cases, the methods have general value and provide a solid foundation for subsequent research. The paper's mathematical proofs are rigorous and the structure is clear, making it an excellent work in the field of combinatorial mathematics.