Impact of Nitrogen-Vacancy Color Centers on the Optical Kerr Effect in Diamond: A Femtosecond Z-Scan Study

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.01379
• Title: Impact of Nitrogen-Vacancy Color Centers on the Optical Kerr Effect in Diamond: A Femtosecond Z-Scan Study
• Authors: Wojciech Talik, Mariusz Mrózek, Adam M. Wojciechowski, Krzysztof Dzierżęga
• Institution: Marian Smoluchowski Institute of Physics, Jagiellonian University, Poland
• Classification: physics.optics, physics.atom-ph
• Publication Date: January 2, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.01379

Abstract

This study explores nonlinear optical effects in diamond crystals doped with nitrogen-vacancy (NV) color centers, with particular focus on the optical Kerr effect in the infrared spectral region. Using Z-scan techniques with 230 fs laser pulses at 1032 nm wavelength, the nonlinear refractive index of high-purity and NV-containing diamond crystals at NV concentrations of 0.3 ppm and 4.5 ppm was investigated. Results demonstrate that the nonlinear refractive index exhibits pronounced anisotropy with fourfold rotational symmetry, with amplitude decreasing as NV concentration increases. The reduction in nonlinear susceptibility is associated with negative contributions from NV centers, modeled as two-level systems red-detuned relative to their resonance frequency under strong laser fields.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Unique Properties of NV Centers: Nitrogen-vacancy color centers in diamond are crystal defects formed by nitrogen atom substitution for carbon atoms accompanied by adjacent vacancies, creating additional energy levels within the diamond bandgap with long spin coherence times and room-temperature stability.
2. Application Potential: NV centers have been widely applied in high-precision magnetometry, temperature sensing, pressure detection, nanoscale biological imaging, quantum sensing, and quantum information processing.
3. Insufficient Nonlinear Optical Research: Despite extensive investigation of NV centers' magnetic properties and sensing applications, exploration of their nonlinear optical properties remains relatively limited.

Research Motivation

1. Symmetry Breaking: Introduction of NV centers locally disrupts diamond's inversion symmetry, resulting in nonzero second-order nonlinear susceptibility χ(2)≠0, potentially enhancing third-order nonlinear optical effects.
2. Commercialized Materials: Commercial availability of high-quality, uniformly doped NV-center diamond plates provides a reliable material foundation for systematic investigation.
3. Application Prospects: Understanding the influence of NV centers on nonlinear optical properties offers potential pathways for tunable nonlinear optical applications.

Core Contributions

1. First Observation of Fourfold Rotational Symmetry: Fourfold rotational symmetry anisotropy in the nonlinear refractive index n₂ was observed in all investigated diamond crystals (both undoped and NV-doped).
2. Quantification of NV Concentration Effects: Systematic investigation of the impact of different NV concentrations (0.3 ppm and 4.5 ppm) on the optical Kerr effect, revealing that n₂ amplitude decreases with increasing NV concentration.
3. Theoretical Model Development: NV centers were modeled as two-level systems, successfully explaining the observed reduction in nonlinear susceptibility.
4. Elucidation of Red-Detuning Mechanism: Demonstrated that under 1032 nm laser excitation, the red-detuning of NV centers relative to their effective resonance frequency (~520 nm) leads to negative third-order susceptibility contributions.

Methodology Details

Experimental Setup

Sample Characteristics

Three commercial diamond crystals were investigated:

Z-Scan Technique

• Laser Parameters: Yb fiber laser, 230 fs pulses, 1032 nm wavelength, 1 kHz repetition rate, maximum pulse energy 10 μJ
• Focusing Parameters: Focal length f=10 cm, beam diameter 2w₀=70 μm, Rayleigh length 2z₀=7.3 mm
• Measurement Modes: Closed-aperture (CA) and open-aperture (OA) modes for measuring nonlinear refraction and nonlinear absorption, respectively

Theoretical Model

Effective Third-Order Susceptibility

For cubic diamond (m3m point group), the effective third-order susceptibility is expressed as:

$\chi_{eff}^{(3)}(\theta) = \chi_{xxxx}^{(3)}\left(1 - \frac{\sigma}{2}\sin^2(2\theta)\right)$

where σ is the anisotropy coefficient:

$\sigma = 1 - \frac{\chi_{xxyy}^{(3)} + \chi_{xyxy}^{(3)} + \chi_{xyyx}^{(3)}}{\chi_{xxxx}^{(3)}}$

Two-Level Model for NV Centers

NV centers are modeled as two-level systems, with nonlinear refractive index contribution:

$n_{2,NV} = N\frac{|\mu_{ba}|^4 T_1 T_2^2}{n_0^2 \epsilon_0^2 c \hbar^3} \frac{\Delta T_2}{(1 + \Delta^2 T_2^2)^2}$

In the non-resonant limit |ΔT₂|≫1, this simplifies to:

$n_{2,NV} \approx N\frac{|\mu_{ba}|^4}{n_0^2 \epsilon_0^2 c \hbar^3} \frac{1}{\Delta^3} \frac{T_1}{T_2}$

where Δ=ω-ω_ is the detuning, and N is the number density of NV centers.

Experimental Results

Main Results

Nonlinear Refractive Index Measurements

Nonlinear parameters measured at 1032 nm wavelength:

Anisotropy Characteristics

• All samples exhibit fourfold rotational symmetry
• Nonlinear susceptibility varies by approximately 50% with angle
• Increasing NV concentration leads to systematic reduction in n₂ amplitude

Nonlinear Absorption

• EGSC and MCNV samples show negligible nonlinear absorption
• HCNV sample exhibits saturable two-photon absorption (S2PA), attributed to two-photon transitions in NV centers

Theoretical Verification

Calculations based on the two-level model demonstrate:

• Under red-detuned conditions (Δ<0), NV centers contribute negative values to n₂
• Calculated |n₂,NV| can reach 6×10⁻¹⁸ m²·W⁻¹, sufficient to explain observed reductions

Related Work

Historical Research

• Early Studies: Four-wave mixing experiments by Rand and pioneering work by Sheik-Bahae et al.
• Recent Progress: Z-scan studies using 800 nm lasers by Motojima et al., second harmonic generation research by Abulikemu et al.

Theoretical Foundation

• Sheik-Bahae Model: Theoretical framework for analyzing nonlinear optical properties of wide-bandgap semiconductors
• Parametric Two-Photon Processes: When ℏω<E_g, nonlinear response primarily originates from instantaneous two-photon parametric absorption processes

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Anisotropy Discovery: First observation of fourfold rotational symmetry anisotropy in diamond's nonlinear refractive index
2. NV Impact Quantification: Demonstrated that increasing NV center concentration leads to systematic reduction in nonlinear susceptibility
3. Mechanism Clarification: Successfully explained negative contributions from NV centers under red-detuned conditions using the two-level model

Limitations

1. Model Simplification: Complex NV center systems simplified to single effective two-level systems
2. Parameter Uncertainty: Lack of precise data for critical parameters such as T₁, T₂, and dipole moment μ_
3. Single Wavelength: Investigation conducted only at single 1032 nm wavelength

Future Directions

1. Multi-Wavelength Studies: Systematic exploration of wavelength dependence using tunable femtosecond laser sources
2. Quantitative Modeling: Development of more accurate NV-laser interaction models
3. Application Exploration: Investigation of potential applications in ultrafast optical switching and modulation

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Rigorous Experimental Design: Standard Z-scan technique with well-controlled experimental parameters
2. In-Depth Theoretical Analysis: Integration of classical nonlinear optics theory and quantum mechanical models
3. Novel Results: First systematic investigation of NV center effects on diamond's nonlinear optical properties
4. Commercial Samples: Use of high-quality commercial samples ensures result reproducibility

Weaknesses

1. Oversimplified Theoretical Model: Two-level model may not fully capture complex NV center dynamics
2. Imprecise Parameter Estimation: Critical physical parameters based on estimates, affecting quantitative analysis accuracy
3. Limited Wavelength Range: Single-wavelength investigation restricts understanding of spectral dependence

Impact

1. Academic Contribution: Opens new research directions in nonlinear optics of NV-doped diamond
2. Application Prospects: Provides foundation for NV-center-based photonics and quantum technologies
3. Methodological Value: Demonstrates Z-scan technique application in nonlinear optical studies of quantum materials

Applicable Scenarios

1. Quantum Photonics: Tunable nonlinear optical applications of NV centers
2. Ultrafast Optics: Diamond-based ultrafast optical switches and modulators
3. Quantum Technology: Multi-photon excitation quantum coherence research

References

The paper cites 26 relevant references covering fundamental physics of NV centers, nonlinear optics theory, Z-scan techniques, and other key research areas, providing a solid theoretical foundation for the investigation.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality experimental physics paper that systematically investigates for the first time the influence of NV centers on diamond's nonlinear optical properties. The experimental design is rigorous, theoretical analysis is in-depth, and results possess significant academic value and application prospects. Despite some limitations in theoretical model simplification, the work establishes an important foundation for further development in this field.