Entanglement and Bell Nonlocality in $\tau^+ \tau^-$ at the BEPC

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.04801
• Title: Entanglement and Bell Nonlocality in $\tau^+ \tau^-$ at the BEPC
• Authors: Tao Han (University of Pittsburgh), Matthew Low (University of Pittsburgh), Youle Su (Fudan University)
• Categories: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology), hep-ex (High Energy Physics - Experiment)
• Publication Date: October 13, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.04801

Abstract

Quantum entanglement and Bell nonlocality are phenomena unique to quantum systems, manifesting as correlations between subsystems that cannot be explained by classical physics. Traditionally, these phenomena have been measured in low-energy photon and electron experiments, but in recent years have also been observed in high-energy particle collider environments. This study proposes measuring quantum entanglement and Bell nonlocality in $\tau^+\tau^-$ states at and above their kinematic threshold at the Beijing Electron-Positron Collider (BEPC). The research finds that entanglement is observable in the existing dataset if systematic uncertainties are controlled below 1%. In the upcoming 4.0-5.6 GeV run, entanglement is expected to be measurable with precision better than 4%, and Bell nonlocality can be established at 5σ confidence level, provided systematic uncertainties are controlled at the 0.5%-2.0% level.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

This study aims to explore the possibility of measuring quantum information phenomena in high-energy particle collider environments, particularly observing quantum entanglement and Bell nonlocality in the $e^+e^- \to \tau^+\tau^-$ process.

Significance

1. Intersection of Quantum Information and High Energy Physics: Extending quantum information theory to the high energy physics domain, opening new research directions
2. Experimental Verification: Verifying fundamental principles of quantum mechanics in real particle collider environments
3. Technology Development: Advancing the application of quantum tomography techniques in high-energy experiments

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Traditional quantum entanglement experiments are primarily limited to low-energy systems
2. Quantum information research at high-energy colliders is nascent, focusing mainly on $t\bar{t}$ systems
3. Quantum information properties of $\tau^+\tau^-$ systems have not been fully explored experimentally

Research Motivation

The unique advantages of BEPC-II operating near the $\tau^+\tau^-$ threshold: controllable energy, clean backgrounds, and high energy resolution, providing an ideal environment for quantum information measurements.

Core Contributions

1. First systematic proposal for measuring quantum entanglement and Bell nonlocality in $\tau^+\tau^-$ systems at BEPC-II
2. Development of two methods: decay method and kinematic method, for reconstructing quantum density matrices
3. Establishment of theoretical framework: providing predictions for quantum properties of $\tau^+\tau^-$ systems at different energies
4. Provision of experimental feasibility analysis: detailed sensitivity studies based on BES-III existing and planned datasets
5. Demonstration of kinematic method superiority: showing significantly smaller statistical errors compared to traditional decay methods

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Input: Reconstructed information from $e^+e^- \to \tau^+\tau^-$ events Output: Fano-Bloch coefficients of the quantum density matrix, subsequently calculating concurrence and Bell variables Constraints: Energy-momentum conservation, $\tau$ mass constraint, neutrino mass constraint

Theoretical Framework

Quantum State Parameterization

Using Fano-Bloch decomposition to describe the $\tau^+\tau^-$ system: $\rho = \frac{1}{4}\left(I_2 \otimes I_2 + \sum_i B^+_i \sigma_i \otimes I_2 + \sum_j B^-_j I_2 \otimes \sigma_j + \sum_{ij} C_{ij}\sigma_i \otimes \sigma_j\right)$

where $B^{\pm}_i$ represents net polarization and $C_{ij}$ represents the spin correlation matrix.

Low-Energy Approximation

Near threshold, the density matrix can be written as a linear combination of mixed and pure states: $\rho = (1-\lambda)\rho_{mixed} + \lambda\rho_{pure}$ where $\lambda = \frac{\beta^2\sin^2\theta}{2-\beta^2\sin^2\theta}$, and $\beta$ is the $\tau$ velocity in the center-of-mass frame.

Two Reconstruction Methods

Decay Method

Reconstructing spin information using angular distributions of $\tau$ decay products: $\frac{1}{\sigma}\frac{d^2\sigma}{d\cos\theta_{A,i}d\cos\theta_{B,j}} = \frac{1}{4}(1 + \kappa_A B^+_i \cos\theta_{A,i} + \kappa_B B^-_j \cos\theta_{B,j} + \kappa_A\kappa_B C_{ij}\cos\theta_{A,i}\cos\theta_{B,j})$

Extracting Fano coefficients by measuring asymmetries in decay angular distributions: $C_{ij} = \frac{4}{\kappa_A\kappa_B}A(\cos\theta_{A,i}\cos\theta_{B,j})$

Kinematic Method

Directly utilizing kinematic information of $\tau$ ($\beta$, $\theta$) and theoretically predicted correlation matrices to reconstruct the quantum state, without requiring measurement of decay angles.

Quantum Information Measures

Concurrence

$C(\rho) = \frac{1}{2}(C_{11} + C_{33} - C_{22} - 1)$

Bell Variable

$B_{max} = 2\sqrt{m_1 + m_2}$ where $m_1, m_2$ are the largest and second-largest eigenvalues of $C^TC$.

Experimental Setup

Datasets

1. Existing Dataset: $\psi(2S) \to \tau^+\tau^-$, $\sqrt{s} = 3.686$ GeV, $N = 3.5 \times 10^6$ events
2. Future Datasets:
   • Single-point run at 5.6 GeV: $L = 20$ fb$^{-1}$
   • Energy scan 4.0-5.6 GeV: total integrated luminosity $L = 20$ fb$^{-1}$

Event Selection

• Reconstruction efficiency: $\epsilon_{reco} = 0.9$
• Angular window cut: $\frac{\pi}{2} - \frac{\Delta\theta}{2} < \theta_\tau < \frac{\pi}{2} + \frac{\Delta\theta}{2}$
• Primary decay mode: $\tau^- \to \nu_\tau\pi^-$ (branching ratio 11%, spin analyzing power 1.00)

Systematic Error Benchmarks

Four systematic error levels considered: 0.5%, 1%, 2%, 5%, based on BES-III historical experience.

Experimental Results

Existing $\psi(2S)$ Dataset Results

Future 5.6 GeV Dataset Predictions

Key Findings

1. Kinematic method significantly outperforms decay method: statistical errors are 1-2 orders of magnitude smaller
2. Energy dependence: higher energies produce stronger quantum correlations
3. Critical role of systematic errors: Bell nonlocality observation requires stringent systematic error control

Related Work

Quantum Information at High-Energy Colliders

• $t\bar{t}$ systems at LHC: First observation of quantum entanglement at high-energy colliders ATLAS, CMS 2024
• Methodological advances: Development of fictitious state concepts and kinematic methods
• Other systems: Quantum information research in hyperon decays and charmed baryon decays

Advantages of $e^+e^-$ Colliders

• Early LEP attempts at testing Bell nonlocality
• Belle II studies of Bell nonlocality in flavor oscillations
• Advantages of beam control and kinematic constraints

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Existing dataset: Kinematic method can observe entanglement with 1% systematic error
2. Future dataset: Entanglement measurable to 4% precision, Bell nonlocality observable at 5σ with appropriate systematic error control
3. Methodology: Kinematic method provides important technical breakthrough for quantum information measurements

Limitations

1. Threshold-region operation: $\tau^+\tau^-$ states contain large separable components, limiting quantum effect strength
2. Systematic error requirements: Bell nonlocality observation requires stringent systematic error control
3. Statistical sample: Some measurements require angular cut optimization, potentially limiting available statistics

Future Directions

1. Other quantum information measures: Quantum discord, steerability, negative conditional entropy, etc.
2. Technical improvements: Further optimization of reconstruction methods, reducing systematic errors
3. Energy extension: Higher-energy runs to enhance quantum effects

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Innovation: First systematic study of quantum information in $\tau^+\tau^-$ at BEPC-II, filling a gap in the field
2. Methodological Contribution: Application and optimization of kinematic method provides important technical tools for the field
3. Experimental Feasibility: Detailed feasibility analysis based on realistic experimental conditions with strong practical value
4. Theoretical Completeness: Complete theoretical framework from fundamental principles to experimental implementation

Weaknesses

1. Quantum Effect Strength: Threshold-region operation limits the strength of observable quantum effects
2. Systematic Error Dependence: Key results strongly depend on systematic error control, presenting significant experimental challenges
3. Single Decay Mode: Primarily considers $\pi$ decay mode, not fully utilizing other decay channels

Impact

1. Interdisciplinary Integration: Promotes deep fusion of quantum information and high energy physics
2. Experimental Guidance: Provides new physics targets and analysis methods for BES-III experiment
3. Technology Dissemination: Kinematic method can be extended to other colliders and physics processes

Applicable Scenarios

1. $e^+e^-$ Colliders: Particularly suitable for environments with controllable energy and clean backgrounds
2. Threshold Physics: Applicable to various two-particle production processes near threshold
3. Precision Measurements: Experimental environments requiring high-precision systematic error control

References

The paper cites 88 related references, covering quantum information theory foundations, quantum phenomena at high-energy colliders, BES-III experimental techniques, and other areas, reflecting the interdisciplinary nature of the research. Key references include ATLAS and CMS $t\bar{t}$ entanglement measurement results, classical quantum information theory literature, and BES-III experimental technical papers.