Josephson Diode Effect via a Non-equilibrium Rashba System

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.05671
• Title: Josephson diode effect via a non-equilibrium Rashba system
• Authors: Michiyasu Mori, Wataru Koshibae, Sadamichi Maekawa
• Classification: cond-mat.supr-con cond-mat.mes-hall
• Publication Date: October 17, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.05671

Abstract

This paper identifies the non-equilibrium state in a Rashba system under in-plane magnetic fields as the origin of the Josephson diode effect. This non-equilibrium state is induced by the current bias necessary for measuring current-voltage characteristics, causing the Fermi momentum to deviate from equilibrium. This critical mechanism has been overlooked in previous studies, primarily due to the implicit assumption that equilibrium-state formulas suffice to describe the Josephson effect. The authors establish a theory of Josephson coupling through non-equilibrium Rashba systems using a tunneling Hamiltonian, modeling the Rashba system as one-dimensional. When the magnetic field is applied perpendicular to the current direction, the Josephson coupling becomes asymmetric, producing the diode effect. The magnitude and sign of this effect depend on the distance d between superconducting electrodes, the in-plane magnetic field, and the spin-orbit coupling strength.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Problem to be Addressed: The critical current Ic of conventional Josephson junctions has equal magnitude in both positive and negative directions, whereas the Josephson diode effect makes the magnitude of Ic dependent on current direction. This paper aims to clarify the microscopic origin of this effect.
2. Problem Significance: The Josephson diode effect has important applications in superconducting electronics and quantum devices. Understanding its physical mechanism is crucial for device optimization and design.
3. Limitations of Existing Approaches: Previous studies were based on equilibrium-state theoretical frameworks, neglecting the non-equilibrium effects induced by current bias—a critical deficiency in understanding the Josephson diode effect.
4. Research Motivation: By considering non-equilibrium states under current bias, establish a complete theoretical framework to explain the microscopic mechanism of the Josephson diode effect and provide guiding principles for device optimization.

Core Contributions

1. Identified the Key Mechanism: For the first time, explicitly identified that the Josephson diode effect originates from non-equilibrium states induced by current bias, rather than equilibrium-state theory.
2. Established Theoretical Framework: Developed a theory of Josephson coupling in non-equilibrium Rashba systems under current bias using the tunneling Hamiltonian.
3. Revealed Distance Dependence: Discovered and analyzed the sensitive dependence of the diode effect on the distance d between superconducting electrodes, providing new pathways for device optimization.
4. Provided Design Guidance: Through analytical results, clarified how to optimize the magnitude and sign of the diode effect by adjusting d.

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Study the transport properties of a Josephson junction composed of two superconductors connected via a Rashba system under in-plane magnetic fields and current bias, particularly the asymmetry of critical current (diode effect).

Model Architecture

Total Hamiltonian:

H = H_SCL + H_SCR + H_M + H_TL + H_TR

Where:

• H_SCL, H_SCR: Hamiltonians of left and right superconducting electrodes
• H_M: Hamiltonian of one-dimensional Rashba system
• H_TL, H_TR: Tunneling Hamiltonians between superconductors and Rashba system

Key Physical Parameters:

• αR: Rashba spin-orbit coupling strength
• hy: In-plane magnetic field in y-direction
• d: Distance between superconducting electrodes
• qex: Fermi momentum shift induced by current bias

Josephson Coupling Expression:

F = -t^4 U V cos φ

Where the V factor includes spin-orbit interaction:

V = cos(Λ-d/ℏvF)cos(Λ+d/ℏvF) - (γhz)²/(Λ-Λ+)sin(Λ-d/ℏvF)sin(Λ+d/ℏvF) + (λ--λ+)/(Λ-Λ+)sin(Λ-d/ℏvF)sin(Λ+d/ℏvF)

Technical Innovations

1. Non-equilibrium State Treatment: Describe the non-equilibrium state under current bias through Fermi momentum shift qex = -2πIB/(ev0).
2. Gauge Invariance: Utilize gauge transformation to convert phase difference into vector potential, naturally introducing Fermi momentum shift.
3. Fourth-order Perturbation Theory: Calculate Josephson coupling under fourth-order perturbation of tunneling matrix elements, including spin-flip processes.
4. Analytical Solution: For the case hz = 0, obtain analytical expression:

V = cos[(αRqex/ℏvF + 2γhy/ℏvF)d]

Experimental Setup

Parameter Configuration

• Fermi velocity: vF = 10^4 m/s
• Critical current: Ic0 ~ 1 nA
• Rashba coupling: αR = 10-100 meVÅ
• Magnetic field: hy = 0.01-0.2 T
• Electrode separation: d = 50-200 nm

Evaluation Metrics

Asymmetry ratio defined as:

Q = (I+c - I-c)/(I+c + I-c)

Solution Method

Determine positive and negative critical currents by numerically solving the self-consistent equations:

I±c/Ic0 = cos[(ξαR(I±c/Ic0) ∓ ζhy)d]

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Distance Dependence:
   • At small distances: Q ∝ d²
   • Analytical approximation: Q ~ (ξαR)·(ζhy)·d²
   • Sign reversal point exists: d = π/(ζhy)
2. Parameter Dependence:
   • Q grows linearly with αR (for small αR)
   • Q grows linearly with hy
   • Saturation effects appear at large parameters
3. Optimization Conditions: By adjusting d, the magnitude and sign of the diode effect can be optimized, providing guidance for device design.

Key Findings

1. Necessity of Three Elements: The three factors αR, hy, and d are all essential; the diode effect vanishes if any one is zero.
2. Sign Regularity: The sign of I+c - I-c is determined by the sign of αR·hy, which can be used to determine the sign of αR.
3. Distance Tuning: Compared to adjusting spin-orbit coupling, tuning the electrode separation d is experimentally more feasible.

Related Work

The paper cites extensive related research (references 19-36), primarily including:

• Experimental studies of Josephson diode effect based on spin-orbit coupling
• Theoretical studies of diode effect on topological insulator surfaces
• Diode effect research in various material systems

The main advantages of this paper are:

1. First to emphasize the importance of non-equilibrium effects
2. Provides a complete microscopic theoretical framework
3. Reveals distance dependence as a new control dimension

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Non-equilibrium Nature: The Josephson diode effect is fundamentally a non-equilibrium phenomenon, induced by Fermi momentum shifts caused by current bias.
2. Microscopic Mechanism: The effect originates from spin-flip terms in fourth-order tunneling processes, requiring simultaneous presence of spin-orbit coupling, magnetic field, and current bias.
3. Distance Control: The electrode separation d is an effective parameter for optimizing the diode effect, more practical than adjusting material parameters.

Limitations

1. One-dimensional Model: Employs one-dimensional linearized dispersion relation, which may not fully describe actual two- or three-dimensional systems.
2. Constant Tunneling Matrix Element: Assumes tunneling matrix element is constant; actual situations may be more complex.
3. Low-order Approximation: Some results are based on small-parameter expansion; accuracy may decrease at large parameters.

Future Directions

1. Extension to two- and three-dimensional systems
2. Consideration of more complex tunneling processes
3. Experimental verification of distance-dependence predictions

In-depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: First to emphasize the critical role of non-equilibrium states in the Josephson diode effect, correcting a theoretical deficiency in the field.
2. Rigorous Methodology: Uses standard many-body theoretical methods with clear calculations and reliable results.
3. Practical Value: The revealed distance dependence provides new control mechanisms for experimental design.
4. Physical Insight: Provides deep understanding of the microscopic mechanism of the Josephson diode effect.

Weaknesses

1. Model Simplification: The one-dimensional model may be oversimplified; the complexity of actual materials is not fully considered.
2. Parameter Estimation: Selection of certain material parameters may be insufficiently accurate, affecting quantitative predictions.
3. Experimental Verification: Lacks direct experimental verification, particularly of distance-dependence predictions.

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides a new theoretical framework for the Josephson diode effect, potentially inspiring subsequent theoretical research.
2. Practical Value: The discovery of distance control offers new pathways for device optimization.
3. Reproducibility: Clear theoretical derivation makes results easy to reproduce and verify.

Application Scenarios

1. Device design for Josephson junctions based on Rashba systems
2. Development of superconducting spintronics devices
3. Optimization of superconducting qubits in quantum computing
4. Fundamental research related to topological superconductors

References

The paper cites 36 related references, covering experimental discoveries, theoretical studies, and relevant material systems of the Josephson diode effect, providing comprehensive literature foundation for the field.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that achieves important progress in understanding the Josephson diode effect. By emphasizing the importance of non-equilibrium states and revealing distance dependence, it provides new theoretical perspectives and practical guidance for the field. Despite limitations such as model simplification, its theoretical contributions and potential application value make it an important work in this field.