A Holographic Realization of Correlation and Mutual Information

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.07091
• Title: A Holographic Realization of Correlation and Mutual Information
• Authors: Ashis Saha, Anirban Roy Chowdhury, Sunandan Gangopadhyay (S.N. Bose National Centre for Basic Sciences)
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Publication Date: January 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.07091

Abstract

This paper explicitly investigates the inequality between mutual information and normalized thermal two-point connected correlation functions through gauge/gravity correspondence: $I(A:B)\ge\frac{(\langle\mathcal{O}_{A}\mathcal{O}_{B}\rangle_\beta-\langle\mathcal{O}_{A}\rangle_\beta\langle\mathcal{O}_{B}\rangle_\beta)^2}{2\langle\mathcal{O}_{A}^2\rangle_\beta\langle\mathcal{O}_{B}^2\rangle_\beta}$. The study employs the geodesic approximation method for heavy operators ($\Delta\sim mR$). The authors find that non-trivial insights emerge depending on different methods for computing thermal objects $\langle\mathcal{O}^2\rangle_\beta$. For specific computational results of $\langle\mathcal{O}^2\rangle_\beta$, the authors propose that all existing quantum mechanical dependencies (correlations) and classical correlations between subsystems A and B vanish at two distinct separation lengths: $sT|_c$ and $sT|_I$, where $sT|_I>sT|_c$.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

This research addresses the status of a fundamental inequality in information theory at finite temperature in quantum field theory. The inequality connects mutual information (measuring all dependencies between systems) with normalized connected two-point correlation functions (measuring only quantum mechanical dependencies).

Significance

1. Theoretical Foundation: The inequality holds important status in both classical and quantum information theory, but explicit investigation at the quantum field theory level remains unreported
2. Holographic Duality: The gauge/gravity correspondence provides new research tools for large-N quantum field theories
3. Information-Theoretic Quantities: The study of information-theoretic quantities in quantum many-body systems becomes extremely interesting, particularly the area law of von Neumann entropy

Existing Limitations

• Previous research primarily focused on zero-temperature cases
• Lack of explicit verification of the inequality within quantum field theory framework
• Insufficient understanding of result discrepancies arising from different computational methods

Research Motivation

To systematically investigate the inequality through holographic methods, exploring its behavior in finite-temperature quantum field theory, particularly the impact of different methods for computing $\langle\mathcal{O}^2\rangle_\beta$ on results.

Core Contributions

1. First Holographic Verification: First explicit verification of the inequality between mutual information and correlation functions using gauge/gravity correspondence
2. Multiple Computational Methods: Provides three different methods for computing $\langle\mathcal{O}^2\rangle_\beta$, revealing the importance of method selection
3. Novel Physical Insights: Discovers two critical separation lengths $sT|_c$ and $sT|_I$, corresponding to the disappearance of quantum and classical dependencies
4. Temperature Effect Analysis: Systematically investigates behavioral differences in low and high temperature limits
5. Theoretical Framework Extension: Applies Lifshitz black hole geometry to the study of information-theoretic quantities

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Investigate the inequality relationship $I(A:B) \geq C$ between mutual information $I(A:B)$ and normalized connected correlation function $C = \frac{(\langle\mathcal{O}_A\mathcal{O}_B\rangle_\beta-\langle\mathcal{O}_A\rangle_\beta\langle\mathcal{O}_B\rangle_\beta)^2}{2\langle\mathcal{O}_A^2\rangle_\beta\langle\mathcal{O}_B^2\rangle_\beta}$ at finite temperature.

Holographic Setup

1. Bulk Geometry

Employs Lifshitz$_{d+1}$ black hole spacetime as the bulk geometry: $ds^2 = \frac{1}{z^2}\left[-\frac{f(z)}{z^{2(\xi-1)}}dt^2 + \frac{dz^2}{f(z)} + \sum_{i=1}^{d-1}dx_i^2\right]$ where $f(z) = 1-\left(\frac{z}{z_+}\right)^{d-1+\xi}$ and $\xi$ is the dynamical scaling exponent.

2. Hawking Temperature

$T = \left(\frac{d-1+\xi}{4\pi}\right)\frac{1}{z_+^\xi}$

Holographic Computation of Thermodynamic Quantities

1. Thermal Two-Point Correlation Function

Using geodesic approximation: $\langle O(t,x)O(t,y)\rangle_\beta \sim e^{-\Delta L(|x-y|)}$

Low Temperature Limit ($|x-y|T^{1/\xi} \ll 1$): $\langle O(t,x)O(t,y)\rangle_\beta = \frac{1}{|x-y|^{2\Delta}[1-\Delta a_d\{|x-y|T^{1/\xi}\}^{d+\xi-1}]}$

High Temperature Limit ($|x-y|T^{1/\xi} \gg 1$): $\langle O(t,x)O(t,y)\rangle_\beta = b_dT^{2\Delta/\xi}e^{-|x-y|/\chi_c}$

2. Thermal One-Point Function

$\langle O\rangle_\beta = 2^{2\Delta(1/\xi-1/(d+\xi-1))}\left[\frac{\pi T}{d+\xi-1}\right]^{\Delta/\xi}e^{-i\pi\Delta/(d-1+\xi)}$

3. Three Computational Methods for $\langle O^2\rangle_\beta$

Method 1: Based on one-point function $\langle O^2\rangle_\beta = \langle O\rangle_\beta^2 = 2^{4\Delta(1/\xi-1/(d+\xi-1))}\left[\frac{\pi T}{d+\xi-1}\right]^{2\Delta/\xi}$

Method 2: From high-temperature two-point function $\langle O^2\rangle_\beta = b_dT^{2\Delta/\xi}$

Method 3: From low-temperature two-point function (requires $2\Delta = d+\xi-1$) $\langle O^2\rangle_\beta = \Delta a_dT^{2\Delta/\xi}$

4. Mutual Information Calculation

Using the Ryu-Takayanagi formula to compute mutual information for two subsystems of length $l$ separated by distance $s$: $I(A:B) = 2S_{vN}(l) - S_{vN}(2l+s) - S_{vN}(s)$

Experimental Setup

Parameter Selection

• Spatial dimension: $d = 3$
• Conformal dimension: $\Delta = 10$
• Dynamical exponent: $\xi = 1, 2, 3$
• Temperature parameters: $lT^{1/\xi} = 0.4$ (low temperature), $lT^{1/\xi} = 10$ (high temperature)

Analysis Methods

1. Numerical computation of $C$ and $I(A:B)$ under different methods
2. Plotting relationships as functions of separation distance
3. Determining critical separation lengths $sT|_c$ and $sT|_I$

Experimental Results

Main Results

Case 1: $\langle O^2\rangle_\beta = \langle O\rangle_\beta^2$

• Low Temperature ($lT = 0.4$): $sT|_c \approx 0.053$, $sT|_I \approx 0.0608$
• High Temperature ($lT = 10$): $sT|_c \approx 0.139$, $sT|_I \approx 0.16$
• Key Finding: Two distinct critical separation lengths exist

Results for Different $\xi$ Values

Case 2: $\langle O^2\rangle_\beta = b_dT^{2\Delta/\xi}$

• Results show $C \approx 0$, leading to $sT|_c = sT|_I$

Case 3: $\langle O^2\rangle_\beta = \Delta a_dT^{2\Delta/\xi}$

• Inequality fails to hold, possibly due to limitations of low-temperature approximation

Physical Interpretation

Physical Significance of Two Critical Lengths:

1. $sT|_c$: Critical point where quantum mechanical dependencies vanish; the inequality saturates
2. $sT|_I$: Critical point where all dependencies (including classical) vanish; mutual information becomes zero

Related Work

Information Theory Foundations

• Application of Pinsker inequality in quantum information theory
• Classical derivation of relationships between mutual information and correlation functions
• Area law in quantum many-body systems

Holographic Duality

• Fundamental principles of AdS/CFT correspondence
• Application of Ryu-Takayanagi formula in holographic entropy calculation
• Validity of geodesic approximation in heavy operator calculations

Lifshitz Geometry

• Holographic description of non-relativistic quantum critical points
• Application of Lifshitz scaling symmetry in condensed matter physics

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Method Dependence: The computational method for $\langle O^2\rangle_\beta$ significantly affects final results
2. Dual Critical Phenomenon: Discovers two distinct critical points where quantum and classical dependencies vanish
3. Temperature Effects: High and low temperature limits exhibit different behavioral patterns
4. Geometric Effects: The dynamical exponent $\xi$ has important influence on critical lengths

Limitations

1. Geodesic Approximation: Only applicable to heavy operators ($\Delta \sim mR$)
2. Temperature Range: Analysis limited to specific temperature regimes
3. Geometric Choice: Primarily considers Lifshitz black holes; behavior in other geometries may differ
4. Equal-Time Correlations: Study restricted to equal-time correlation functions

Future Directions

1. Other Geometries: Extension to other types of black hole geometries
2. Non-Equal-Time Correlations: Investigation of time-dependent correlation functions
3. Finite-Size Effects: Consideration of subsystem size effects
4. Experimental Verification: Search for corresponding phenomena in condensed matter systems

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: First systematic investigation of the inequality within holographic framework
2. Comprehensive Methods: Provides comparative analysis of multiple computational methods
3. Physical Insights: Reveals novel physical picture of dual critical phenomena
4. Mathematical Rigor: Detailed calculations and explicit approximation conditions

Weaknesses

1. Scope of Applicability: Geodesic approximation limits method universality
2. Numerical Verification: Lacks independent numerical verification methods
3. Connection to Experiments: Relationship to actual physical systems requires further establishment
4. Theoretical Explanation: Deeper physical mechanisms of dual critical phenomena need further understanding

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides new research direction for holographic information theory
2. Methodological Contribution: Establishes holographic framework for studying information inequalities
3. Cross-Disciplinary Impact: Connects high energy physics, information theory, and condensed matter physics

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Research: Applicable to information-theoretic property studies of large-N quantum field theories
2. Holographic Models: Provides reference for constructing holographic quantum information models
3. Critical Phenomena: Can be applied to studying information-theoretic characteristics of quantum critical points

References

The paper cites 42 important references, covering:

• Information theory foundations (Nielsen & Chuang, etc.)
• Classical AdS/CFT correspondence papers (Maldacena, Gubser, etc.)
• Holographic entropy theory (Ryu-Takayanagi, etc.)
• Lifshitz geometry related research (Balasubramanian & McGreevy, etc.)

Overall Assessment: This paper represents an important contribution to the field of holographic quantum information theory. Through rigorous theoretical analysis and numerical computation, it reveals novel characteristics of information-theoretic inequalities within the holographic framework. The discovery of dual critical phenomena provides new perspectives for understanding the disappearance mechanisms of different types of correlations in quantum systems, possessing significant theoretical value and potential application prospects.