Radiative properties of thin accretion disks around rotating short-hairy black holes

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.10716
• Title: Radiative properties of thin accretion disks around rotating short-hairy black holes
• Authors: Shou-Qi Liu, Jia-Hui Huang
• Classification: gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology)
• Publication Date: February 4, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.10716

Abstract

This study investigates the radiative properties of accretion disks surrounding rotating short-hairy black holes. The research derives the geodesic motion of massive particles on the equatorial plane of short-hairy black holes and analyzes the effects of the rotation parameter a, short-hair parameter Q, and power-law exponent parameter k on geodesic motion. Based on this foundation, thin accretion disks around short-hairy black holes are considered, and the radiative flux density, effective temperature, differential luminosity, and spectral luminosity of accretion disks under different parameters are investigated. The effects of parameters a, Q, and k on these characteristics are also discussed.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Development of Black Hole Theory: Although the Kerr black hole is the unique stationary, axially symmetric, and asymptotically flat vacuum solution to Einstein's field equations, counterexamples and violations of the no-hair theorem have been extensively studied in the literature, particularly when gravity couples with matter fields.
2. Astrophysical Observation Requirements: With major observational breakthroughs such as LIGO/Virgo gravitational wave detection and Event Horizon Telescope imaging of M87* and Sgr A* black holes, more precise theoretical models are needed to describe realistic astrophysical black holes.
3. Theoretical Significance of Short-Hairy Black Holes: Real astrophysical black holes typically exist in non-vacuum environments coupled with surrounding matter; therefore, hairy black holes should better describe astrophysical black holes.

Research Motivation

• Short-hairy black holes violate the "no-short-hair" theorem for black holes, providing a new theoretical framework for black hole physics
• The electromagnetic spectrum of accretion disks can be used to determine the characteristics of central black holes and potential gravitational theories
• Studying accretion disk properties further enhances understanding of black hole near-horizon features and tests gravitational theories

Core Contributions

1. Systematic study of geodesic motion around rotating short-hairy black holes: Derives the equations of motion for massive particles on the equatorial plane and analyzes the effects of three key parameters (a, Q, k)
2. Calculation of complete radiative properties of thin accretion disks: Including radiative flux density, effective temperature, differential luminosity, and spectral luminosity distribution
3. Quantification of observational effects of short-hair parameters: Detailed analysis of how the short-hair parameter Q and power-law exponent k affect observable features of accretion disks
4. Provision of theoretical foundation for distinguishing Kerr black holes from short-hairy black holes: Provides theoretical predictions for future observations to differentiate between different types of black holes

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigation of radiative properties of thin accretion disks around rotating short-hairy black holes, including:

• Input: Black hole parameters (mass M, rotation parameter a, short-hair parameter Q, power-law exponent k)
• Output: Various radiative properties of accretion disks (flux density, temperature, luminosity, etc.)
• Constraints: Thin disk approximation, steady-state accretion, local thermodynamic equilibrium

Theoretical Framework

1. Short-Hairy Black Hole Metric

The line element of a rotating short-hairy black hole is: $ds^2 = -\left(1-\frac{2Mr - Q^{2k}r^{2k-2}}{\rho^2}\right)dt^2 + \frac{\rho^2}{\Delta}dr^2 - \frac{2a\sin^2\theta(2Mr - Q^{2k}r^{2k-2})}{\rho^2}dtd\phi + \rho^2d\theta^2 + \frac{\Sigma\sin^2\theta}{\rho^2}d\phi^2$

Where:

• $\rho^2 = r^2 + a^2\cos^2\theta$
• $\Sigma = (r^2 + a^2)^2 - a^2\Delta$
• $\Delta = r^2 - 2Mr + a^2 + \frac{Q^{2k}}{r^{2k-2}}$

2. Geodesic Motion Analysis

For particle motion on the equatorial plane ($\theta = \pi/2$), two conserved quantities exist:

• Specific energy: $\tilde{E} = -\dot{t}g_{tt} - \dot{\phi}g_{t\phi}$
• Specific angular momentum: $\tilde{L} = \dot{t}g_{t\phi} + \dot{\phi}g_{\phi\phi}$

The angular velocity of circular orbits is: $\Omega_{\pm} = \frac{ak Q^{2k}r - ar^{2k} \pm r^{2+2k}\sqrt{\frac{1}{r} - \frac{kQ^{2k}}{r^{2k}}}}{a^2kQ^{2k}r + r^{2k}(-a^2 + r^3)}$

3. Accretion Disk Radiation Model

The radiative flux density is given by: $F(r) = -\frac{\dot{M}}{4\pi\sqrt{-g/g_{\theta\theta}}} \frac{\Omega_{,r}}{(\tilde{E} - \Omega\tilde{L})^2} \int_r^{R_I} (\tilde{E} - \Omega\tilde{L})\tilde{L}_{,r}dr$

The effective temperature is related through the Stefan-Boltzmann law: $F = \sigma T_{eff}^4$

Technical Innovations

1. Complete parametric study: Systematic analysis of the effects of three independent parameters on black hole properties
2. Precise numerical computation: Solving complex geodesic equations and integrals through numerical methods
3. Quantification of observational effects: Calculation of redshift effects on observations by distant observers
4. Multi-level analysis: Provides a complete physical picture from basic orbital motion to complex radiation spectra

Experimental Setup

Parameter Selection

• Rotation parameter: $a \in [0, 0.8]$
• Short-hair parameter: $Q \in [0, 0.8]$
• Power-law exponent: $k \in [1, 5]$ (where $k > 1$ corresponds to short-hair conditions)
• Black hole mass: $M = 1$ (normalized units)

Computational Methods

• Numerical solution of horizon equation $\Delta = 0$
• Numerical calculation of innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO) radius
• Integration to compute radiative flux and luminosity distribution
• Consideration of gravitational redshift and Doppler effects

Comparison Benchmarks

• Schwarzschild black hole ($a = Q = 0$)
• Kerr black hole ($Q = 0$)
• Kerr-Newman black hole ($k = 1$)

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Horizon and ISCO Characteristics

• As $a$ or $Q$ increases, the outer horizon radius decreases and the inner horizon radius increases
• Parameter $k$ has minimal effect on horizon radius
• ISCO radius: decreases with increasing $a$ for prograde orbits, opposite for retrograde orbits
• Short-hair parameter $Q$ produces significant effects on ISCO only when sufficiently large

2. Radiative Efficiency

• Rotation parameter $a$ significantly enhances radiative efficiency
• Short-hair parameter $Q$ also increases radiative efficiency, particularly for highly rotating black holes
• Parameter $k$ has minimal effect on radiative efficiency

3. Accretion Disk Radiative Properties

• Flux Density: Rotation parameter $a$ increases maximum flux by approximately 4 times ($a=0.8$ compared to $a=0.5$)
• Effective Temperature: Short-hair parameter $Q=0.8$ increases maximum temperature by approximately 10%
• Luminosity Distribution: All radiation quantities reach maximum values at certain radii
• Spectral Features: Short-hair effects enhance overall radiation intensity

Parameter Impact Analysis

1. Effect of rotation parameter $a$ is most significant:
   • Substantially enhances radiative flux, temperature, and luminosity
   • Shifts maximum value positions inward
2. Effect of short-hair parameter $Q$:
   • Produces significant effects only when $Q$ is sufficiently large (~0.8)
   • Enhances all radiative properties by approximately 5-45%
3. Role of power-law exponent $k$:
   • Primarily suppresses the effects of short-hair parameter
   • Larger $k$ results in smaller deviations from Kerr case

Observational Predictions

• Accretion disk temperature around short-hairy black holes is higher than around corresponding Kerr black holes
• Radiation enhancement effects are most pronounced in near-black-hole regions
• Spectral peak frequency increases with rotation parameter

Related Work

Hairy Black Hole Theory

• Scalar Hairy Black Holes: Gauss-Bonnet coupling, spontaneous scalarization
• Proca Hairy Black Holes: Vector field hair
• Electroweak Hairy Black Holes: Hair solutions in electroweak theory

Accretion Disk Theory

• Shakura-Sunyaev Model: Classical thin disk theory
• Page-Thorne Model: Standard accretion disk around Kerr black holes
• Accretion Disks in Modified Gravity: f(R) gravity, Hořava-Lifshitz gravity, etc.

Unique Contributions of This Work

Compared to existing work, this paper is the first to systematically investigate accretion disk properties of short-hairy black holes, providing complete parametric analysis and observational predictions.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Confirmation of Short-Hair Effects: The short-hair parameter Q indeed affects accretion disk radiative properties, particularly when Q is sufficiently large
2. Hierarchical Parameter Effects: The rotation parameter a has the most significant effect, followed by short-hair parameter Q, while power-law exponent k primarily plays a regulatory role
3. Observable Distinguishability: Short-hairy black holes and Kerr black holes exhibit observable differences in accretion disk properties
4. Physical Consistency: All calculated results reduce to known Kerr or Schwarzschild cases in appropriate limits

Limitations

1. Thin Disk Approximation: Only considers geometrically thin disks, excluding thick disks or other accretion modes
2. Steady-State Assumption: Assumes constant mass accretion rate, neglecting time-dependent effects
3. Idealized Conditions: Ignores magnetic fields, radiation pressure, and other complex physical processes
4. Parameter Range: Short-hair effects require relatively large Q values to be significant

Future Directions

1. Observational Verification: Verify theoretical predictions using X-ray observation data
2. Numerical Relativity: Conduct fully relativistic numerical simulations
3. Thick Disk Models: Extension to geometrically thick disks and radiation-dominated accretion
4. Magnetized Accretion: Consider magnetic field effects on accretion flows

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Completeness: Provides a complete theoretical framework from basic geodesic motion to complex radiation processes
2. Numerical Precision: Extensive precise numerical calculations and comprehensive graphical presentations
3. Systematic Parameter Analysis: Systematically analyzes effects of three independent parameters
4. Physical Insights: Reveals essential differences between short-hairy black holes and Kerr black holes
5. Observational Relevance: Calculates actually observable quantities, such as temperature corrected for gravitational redshift

Weaknesses

1. Insufficient Physical Mechanism Explanation: Lacks deeper physical explanation for why short-hair parameters produce these effects
2. Lack of Observational Constraints: Does not discuss existing observational constraints on short-hair parameters
3. Insufficient Error Analysis: Numerical calculations lack error estimates and convergence analysis
4. Limited Applicability: Thin disk model may not be applicable in strong-field regions

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides important observational predictions for short-hairy black hole theory
2. Observational Guidance: Provides theoretical foundation for future black hole observations
3. Methodological Value: Provides a methodological template for studying other types of hairy black holes
4. Interdisciplinary Significance: Connects gravitational theory with astrophysical observations

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Astrophysics: Black hole physics and accretion theory research
2. Observational Astrophysics: X-ray binary and active galactic nuclei research
3. Gravitational Theory Testing: Testing modified gravitational theories through accretion disk observations
4. Numerical Relativity: Provides analytical benchmarks for numerical simulations

References

The paper cites 103 related references, covering:

• Black hole theory fundamentals (Kerr metric, no-hair theorem)
• Various models of hairy black holes
• Accretion disk theory and observations
• Recent advances in gravitational waves and black hole imaging

Key references include:

• Brown & Husain (1997): Original theory of short-hairy black holes
• Tang & Xu (2022): Construction of rotating short-hairy black holes
• Page & Thorne (1974): Classical accretion disk theory
• Shakura & Sunyaev (1973): Thin disk model foundation

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical astrophysics paper that systematically investigates the observational characteristics of an emerging black hole model. Although there are some theoretical limitations, it provides an important theoretical foundation for future observational research and possesses considerable academic value.