Nucleon Electric Dipole Form Factor in QCD Vacuum

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.11856
• Title: Nucleon Electric Dipole Form Factor in the QCD Instanton Vacuum
• Authors: Wei-Yang Liu, Ismail Zahed (Stony Brook University)
• Classification: hep-ph, hep-lat, hep-th, nucl-th
• Publication Date: October 16, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.11856v4

Abstract

In the QCD vacuum, nucleon form factors receive contributions from topological pseudo-particle ensembles, which are sensitive to the finite vacuum angle θ. Leveraging this observation, the authors derive novel relationships between the Pauli form factor and the electric dipole moment form factor for light quark flavors. This relationship permits explicit derivation of proton and neutron electric dipole moments induced by small CP-violating θ angles, expressed in terms of the vacuum topological magnetization multiplied by the corresponding magnetic moments. The results show good agreement with recent lattice QCD calculations.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Core Problem: This study addresses the contribution of CP violation in strong interactions to the nucleon electric dipole moment (EDM), which is crucial for understanding the baryon asymmetry of the universe.
2. Problem Significance:
   • CP violation is a necessary condition for explaining cosmic baryon generation
   • CP violation in weak interactions is several orders of magnitude smaller than required
   • CP violation in strong interactions may provide sufficient contribution
   • Nucleon EDM serves as an important probe of strong CP violation
3. Limitations of Existing Methods:
   • Experimentally, nucleon EDM is extremely small (~10⁻²⁶ e·cm), making measurement difficult
   • Lattice QCD calculations face signal-to-noise ratio challenges
   • Lack of theoretical relationships connecting CP-even and CP-odd form factors
4. Research Motivation: Utilize the properties of topological pseudo-particles in the QCD instanton liquid model (ILM) to establish direct relationships between the Pauli form factor F₂ and the electric dipole form factor F₃.

Core Contributions

1. Establishment of New Theoretical Relationships: Derivation of "model-independent" relationships between CP-even (F₂) and CP-odd (F₃) electromagnetic form factors: $\frac{F_3^f(Q^2)}{\theta} = \sqrt{\frac{4}{b}}\left(1 + N_f\frac{m^*}{m}\right)^{-1} F_2^f(Q^2)$
2. Explicit Expression for Nucleon EDM: Direct relationship between proton and neutron EDM and magnetic moments: $\frac{d_p(0)}{\theta} = \sqrt{\frac{4}{b}}\left(1 + N_f\frac{m^*}{m}\right)^{-1} \times \left(\mu_p - Q_p\frac{e}{2M_N}\right)$
3. Good Agreement with Lattice Calculations: ILM predictions are consistent with recent lattice QCD calculations within reasonable ranges
4. Theoretical Insights: Reveals the crucial role of vacuum topological magnetization in connecting CP violation with nucleon properties

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Study the contributions of topological pseudo-particles (instantons and anti-instantons) in the QCD vacuum to nucleon electromagnetic form factors, particularly CP-violating effects under finite vacuum angle θ.

Model Architecture

1. QCD Instanton Vacuum Model

• Instanton Density: $n_{I+A} \equiv 1/R^4 \approx 1 \text{ fm}^{-4}$
• Average Size: $\rho \approx R/3$, where $R = 1$ fm is the hadronic scale
• Vacuum Expectation Values: $\frac{\langle F^2 \rangle_\theta}{32\pi^2} \approx n_{I+A} \cos\theta$$\frac{\langle FF\tilde{F} \rangle_\theta}{32\pi^2} \approx in_{I+A} \sin\theta$

2. Topological Magnetization

Accounting for light quark screening effects: $\chi_t = \frac{\langle\Delta^2\rangle}{V} \sim n_{I+A}\left(1 + N_f\frac{m^*}{m}\right)^{-1}$

where $m^*$ is the determinant mass, determined by chiral condensate: $m^* \simeq m - \frac{2\pi^2\rho^2}{N_c}\langle\bar{q}q\rangle$

3. Nucleon Electromagnetic Form Factors

General form of nucleon-photon coupling: $\langle N(P')|J_\mu^{EM}|N(P)\rangle = \bar{u}_{s'}(P')\left[\gamma_\mu F_1(Q^2) + \frac{i\sigma_{\mu\nu}q_\nu}{2M_N}(F_2(Q^2) - i\gamma_5 F_3(Q^2)) + \cdots\right]u_s(P)$

Technical Innovations

1. Instanton-Induced Vertex Corrections

Single instanton contribution to the electromagnetic vertex: $V_\pm^\mu(k',k) \simeq (2\pi)^4\delta(k-k'+q)\frac{8\pi^2\rho^4}{N_c}\frac{1\mp\gamma_5}{2}\frac{i\sigma^{\mu\nu}q_\nu}{2m^*} \times \mathcal{F}(\rho Q)$

where $\mathcal{F}(\rho Q)$ contains integrals of modified Bessel functions.

2. Zero-Mode to Non-Zero-Mode Transitions

• Left-handed zero modes ↔ right-handed non-zero modes in instantons
• Right-handed zero modes ↔ left-handed non-zero modes in anti-instantons
• These chiral selection rules lead to magnetic-type coupling

3. Pseudo-Particle Number Fluctuations

Under finite θ angle: $\langle N_\pm \rangle_\theta = \frac{\bar{N}}{2} \pm i\frac{\langle\Delta^2\rangle}{2\bar{N}}\sqrt{\frac{4}{b}}\theta$

Experimental Setup

Model Parameters

ILM parameters employed:

• Instanton size: $\rho = 0.313$ fm
• Instanton density: $n_{I+A} = 1$ fm⁻⁴
• Quark mass: $m = 6$ MeV
• Determinant mass: $m^* = 103.6$ MeV

Comparison Data

1. Lattice QCD Results:
   • ETMC Collaboration: $N_f = 2+1+1$, $m_\pi = 139$ MeV
   • χQCD Collaboration: $m_\pi = 339$ MeV
   • CSSM/QCDSF Collaboration: $m_\pi = 310$ MeV
2. Experimental Data:
   • Proton magnetic moment: $\mu_p = 2.793 \, e/2M_N$
   • Neutron magnetic moment: $\mu_n = -1.913 \, e/2M_N$

Evaluation Metrics

• Agreement between topological charge distribution and lattice results
• Numerical prediction accuracy of nucleon EDM
• $Q^2$ dependence of form factor $F_3(Q^2)$

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Topological Magnetization

ILM prediction: $\chi_t = (73.19 \text{ MeV})^4$, consistent with lattice calculations.

2. Nucleon Electric Dipole Moments

3. Form Factor Relationships

In the low $Q^2$ region, the $F_3(Q^2)$ predicted by ILM shows good agreement with lattice calculations, validating the validity of equation (13).

Ablation Studies

By comparing unquenched and quenched cases, the important screening effect of light quarks on topological fluctuations is verified.

Experimental Findings

1. Scaling Relationships: The proportionality coefficient of $F_3/\theta \propto F_2$ is determined by topological magnetization
2. Flavor Dependence: Contributions from different quark flavors can be calculated separately
3. Mass Dependence: The determinant mass $m^*$ plays a crucial role

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. Lattice QCD Calculations: Direct numerical computation of nucleon EDM, but faces signal-to-noise ratio challenges
2. Chiral Perturbation Theory: Calculations based on low-energy effective theory
3. QCD Sum Rules: Utilization of operator product expansion
4. Instanton Models: Semi-classical methods based on topological solitons

Advantages of This Work

• Provides analytical relationships connecting CP-even and CP-odd form factors
• Based on topological structure of QCD vacuum with solid theoretical foundation
• Relatively simple calculations, avoiding technical difficulties of lattice computations

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Established direct relationships between nucleon Pauli form factor and electric dipole form factor
2. Nucleon EDM is proportional to magnetic moment and topological magnetization
3. ILM predictions are consistent with lattice calculations within reasonable ranges

Limitations

1. Quark-Diquark Approximation: Simplified description of nucleon internal structure
2. Neglect of Instanton Molecules: Approximately 10% corrections in deeply cooled regions
3. Dilute Approximation: High-density corrections not considered
4. Parameter Dependence: Results depend on choice of ILM parameters

Future Directions

1. Include contributions from instanton-anti-instanton molecules
2. Improve description of nucleon wave functions
3. Study contributions from heavy quarks
4. Compare with more precise lattice calculations

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: First analytical relationship between $F_2$ and $F_3$
2. Physical Insights: Reveals crucial role of topological magnetization
3. Practical Value: Provides useful theoretical guidance for lattice calculations
4. Computational Simplicity: Avoids complex numerical calculations

Weaknesses

1. Model Dependence: Results depend on validity of ILM
2. Approximation Accuracy: Multiple approximations may accumulate errors
3. Parameter Uncertainty: Ambiguity in determination of certain parameters
4. Applicable Range: Primarily applicable for small θ angle cases

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new perspective for understanding QCD vacuum structure
2. Experimental Guidance: Provides theoretical expectations for nucleon EDM experiments
3. Lattice Reference: Provides cross-checks for lattice calculations
4. Educational Value: Demonstrates role of topological effects in hadron physics

Application Scenarios

• Theoretical estimation of nucleon electric dipole moments
• Study of QCD topological effects
• Theoretical interpretation of lattice QCD results
• Exploration of CP violation mechanisms

References

The paper cites 44 important references, covering:

• Foundational literature on instanton liquid models 3-6
• Recent lattice QCD results 9-10
• Theoretical studies of topological magnetization 19-26
• Experimental measurements of nucleon form factors 32-33

Overall Assessment: This is an important contribution to hadron physics theory. Through the instanton liquid model, it establishes novel relationships between nucleon electromagnetic form factors, providing valuable theoretical tools for understanding the topological properties of the QCD vacuum and CP violation effects. Despite certain limitations from model approximations, its theoretical insights and good agreement with lattice calculations make it an important work in this field.