Floquet Engineering of Point-Gapped Topological Superconductors

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.12129
• Title: Floquet engineering of point-gapped topological superconductors
• Authors: Xiang Ji, Hao Geng, Naeem Akhtar, Xiaosen Yang (Department of Physics, Jiangsu University)
• Classification: cond-mat.supr-con, quant-ph
• Publication Date: January 22, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.12129

Abstract

Non-Hermitian systems exhibit two distinct topological classifications based on their gap structure: line-gapped and point-gapped topology. Although point-gapped topology is intrinsic to non-Hermitian systems, its systematic construction remains a challenge. This paper proposes a Floquet engineering approach to realize point-gapped topological superconductors. By combining Floquet theory with particle-hole symmetry (PHS), the authors demonstrate that point gaps carrying robust Majorana edge modes emerge at the overlap of Floquet bands with opposite winding numbers. In the thermodynamic limit, even weak non-Hermiticity can open point gaps from gapless spectra, driving topological phase transitions and breaking non-Bloch parity-time (PT) symmetry. This transition is accompanied by the emergence of a Floquet Z₂ skin effect. Furthermore, the point-gapped topological phase and non-Bloch PT symmetry exhibit size-dependent phenomena driven by critical skin effects.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Rise of non-Hermitian topological physics: Non-Hermitian systems have attracted widespread attention due to their unique topological phases, exhibiting phenomena absent in Hermitian systems
2. Two gap structures: Non-Hermitian systems support two distinct gap structures—the line gap inherited from Hermitian systems and the point gap unique to non-Hermitian systems
3. Importance of point-gapped topology: Point-gapped topological phases are unique to non-Hermitian systems, introducing new pathways for topological classification

Research Challenges

1. Difficulty in systematic construction: Despite the fundamental role of point-gapped topology in non-Hermitian systems, universal methods for realizing point-gapped topological states remain lacking
2. Boundary condition sensitivity: Non-Hermitian systems exhibit significant spectral differences between periodic boundary conditions (PBC) and open boundary conditions (OBC), resulting in different gap structures
3. Non-Hermitian skin effect: The nonzero winding number of the PBC spectrum is related to the non-Hermitian skin effect under OBC, leading to energy collapse and breakdown of conventional bulk-boundary correspondence

Research Motivation

This paper aims to provide a universal framework for realizing point-gapped topological phases in non-Hermitian systems by combining Floquet theory and particle-hole symmetry, offering new pathways for exploring point-gapped topological phases.

Core Contributions

1. Proposed Floquet engineering method: Systematically constructed point-gapped topological superconductors by combining Floquet theory with particle-hole symmetry
2. Revealed dual phase transition mechanism: Discovered that non-Hermiticity-induced topological phase transitions occur simultaneously with non-Bloch PT symmetry breaking
3. Discovered Floquet Z₂ skin effect: Due to particle-hole symmetry protection, particle and hole bands possess opposite winding numbers, resulting in Z₂ skin effect
4. Clarified critical skin effect: Revealed size-dependent phenomena in point-gapped topological phases and non-Bloch PT symmetry
5. Established universal theoretical framework: Validated the method's effectiveness across various non-Hermitian systems

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Construct a periodically driven non-Hermitian system that exhibits point-gapped topological phases under open boundary conditions, carrying robust Majorana edge modes.

Model Architecture

1. Periodically Driven Non-Hermitian Kitaev Chain

The system's Bloch Hamiltonian is:

H(k,t) = H₀(k) + λcos(ωt)σz

Where:

• H₀(k) = h₀(k) + h⃗(k)·σ⃗ represents the non-Hermitian Kitaev chain
• h⃗(k) = (0, hy(k), hz(k))
• h₀(k) = 2iδsin k (non-Hermitian term)
• hy(k) = -2Δsin k (pairing term)
• hz(k) = μ + 2t cos k (chemical potential and hopping term)

2. Floquet Theory Framework

In the frequency domain, the Schrödinger equation is written as:

∑_{m'} H_{m,m'}(k,ω)|ψ^{m'}_{n,R}(k)⟩ = εn(k)|ψ^m_{n,R}(k)⟩

Where the Floquet Hamiltonian satisfies particle-hole symmetry: CH^T(k,ω)C^{-1} = -H(-k,ω)

3. Winding Number Analysis

The winding number of the PBC spectrum is defined as:

W(ε) = ∮₀^{2π} dk/(2πi) ∂/∂k log det[H(k,ω) - ε]

Due to particle-hole symmetry, the winding numbers of particle and hole bands satisfy: W(ε) = -W(-ε)

Technical Innovations

1. Point Gap Formation Mechanism

• Band overlap: Point gaps are created when two Floquet bands with opposite winding numbers overlap, generating zero winding number regions
• Gap emergence: In zero winding number regions, OBC quasienergies do not collapse, forming point gaps
• Edge state protection: Majorana modes within the point gap are surrounded by bulk quasienergies, providing topological protection

2. Non-Bloch Theory Description

Using generalized Brillouin zone (GBZ) theory:

• Non-Bloch factor: β = re^{ik}
• Characteristic equation: f(β,ε) = detH(β,ω) - ε = 0
• Reciprocal relation: |β(nω/2 + ε)| = |β(nω/2 - ε)|^{-1}

3. Critical Skin Effect

• Finite-size GBZ depends on system size
• Decay length scaling: κ ∝ ±c/L^{4/3}
• Critical system size: Lc ∼ 1/δ

Experimental Setup

Model Parameters

• Hopping strength: t = 1
• Pairing strength: Δ = 0.8
• Driving strength: λ = 0.8
• Driving frequency: ω = 10
• Non-Hermitian strength: δ (variable parameter)
• Chemical potential: μ (variable parameter)

Evaluation Metrics

1. Quasienergy spectrum: Analysis of complex energy distribution under PBC and OBC
2. Winding number: Calculation of topological invariants for different Floquet bands
3. Fidelity susceptibility: χ(μ) = lim_{δμ→0} -2ln|F(μ,δμ)|/(δμ)²
4. Density of states distribution: Analysis of eigenstate localization properties

Comparative Analysis

• Hermitian limit: Topologically trivial gapless phase at δ = 0
• Different system sizes: L = 16, 40, 60, 100, 120, etc.
• s-wave superconductor: Verification of method universality

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Emergence of Point-Gapped Topological Phase

• In the Hermitian limit (δ = 0), the system is in a topologically trivial gapless phase
• Upon introducing non-Hermiticity (δ ≠ 0), point gaps emerge carrying Majorana zero modes
• Topologically nontrivial region: μ ∈ (8, 12)

2. Dual Phase Transition Phenomenon

• Topological phase transition: From gapless trivial phase to point-gapped topological phase
• PT symmetry breaking: Non-Bloch PT symmetry breaks simultaneously
• Critical condition: Both phase transitions occur at Lc ∼ 1/δ

3. Floquet Z₂ Skin Effect

• Particle states localize at one end of the chain, hole states at the other end
• Winding number relation: Wp = -1, Wh = +1
• Protected by particle-hole symmetry

Ablation Studies

1. Size Dependence Analysis

• Complex quasienergy ratio P = Nc/N varies with system size
• Below critical size: P = 0 (real spectrum)
• Above critical size: P > 0 (complex spectrum)

2. Effective Hamiltonian Analysis

For the two-photon resonance case:

Heff(β) = h₀(β) + [1 - ω/h(β)][h⃗(β) + 4h(β)/(3ω)·D⃗⊥(β)]·σ⃗

Topological phase boundary: ω = |μ ± 2t|

3. s-wave Superconductor Verification

• Four-band model validates method universality
• Simultaneous emergence of Majorana zero modes and π modes
• Fidelity susceptibility confirms phase transition points

Experimental Findings

1. Scaling Behavior

• Decay length: κ ∝ ±c/L^{4/3} (different from previous -1 scaling)
• Fidelity susceptibility: χm ∝ -L³
• Finite-size scaling of critical chemical potential

2. Geometric Features

• Cusp formation in finite-size GBZ
• Bloch point (BP) splitting marks phase transition
• Conjugate BP pairs: β(εr) = β*(−εr)

Related Work

Non-Hermitian Topological Physics

1. Fundamental theory: Topological classification of non-Hermitian systems and bulk-boundary correspondence
2. Skin effects: Non-Hermitian skin effect and non-Bloch band theory
3. PT symmetry: Parity-time symmetry and its breaking

Floquet Engineering

1. Periodically driven systems: Floquet topological insulators and superconductors
2. Anomalous edge states: Topological phenomena like π modes absent in static systems
3. Non-Hermitian Floquet systems: Realization of gain/loss and nonreciprocal hopping

Point-Gapped Topology

1. Topological classification: Non-Hermitian topological phase classification based on gap structure
2. Anomalous topological insulators: Theory and experimental studies of point-gapped topological insulators
3. Bulk-boundary correspondence: Generalized bulk-boundary correspondence in point-gapped topological phases

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Universal construction method: Proposed a method for constructing point-gapped topological phases based on Floquet engineering and particle-hole symmetry
2. Physical mechanism: Clarified the mechanism of point gap generation through overlap of Floquet bands with opposite winding numbers
3. Multiple effects: Discovered the synergistic emergence of topological phase transitions, PT symmetry breaking, and Z₂ skin effects
4. Size effects: Revealed size-dependent phenomena caused by critical skin effects

Limitations

1. Model restrictions: Primarily verified in one-dimensional systems; higher-dimensional generalizations require further investigation
2. Experimental implementation: Periodic driving and precise parameter control may be challenging in practical systems
3. Finite-size effects: Scaling behavior of critical skin effects may be limited in actual finite systems

Future Directions

1. Higher-dimensional generalization: Extend the method to two-dimensional and three-dimensional non-Hermitian systems
2. Experimental platforms: Implement theoretical predictions in optical, cold atom, or solid-state systems
3. Application exploration: Explore applications of point-gapped topological phases in quantum computing and topological quantum devices
4. Novel phenomena: Investigate higher-order topological states, hybrid skin-topological effects, etc.

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical innovation: First systematic proposal of Floquet engineering method for point-gapped topological phases
2. Physical insights: Deeply reveals intrinsic connections among multiple physical effects in non-Hermitian systems
3. Mathematical rigor: Provides strict theoretical foundation using non-Bloch theory and GBZ analysis
4. Universality verification: Validates method effectiveness across different types of superconductor models
5. Experimental guidance: Provides clear pathways for experimental detection through observable quantities like fidelity susceptibility

Shortcomings

1. Complexity: Theoretical framework is relatively complex, requiring deep background in non-Hermitian physics
2. Parameter sensitivity: System is sensitive to driving parameters and non-Hermitian strength
3. Experimental challenges: Precise periodic driving and parameter control may be difficult experimentally
4. Finite-size limitations: Observation of critical skin effects requires sufficiently large system sizes

Impact

1. Field contribution: Provides new theoretical tools and physical insights for non-Hermitian topological physics
2. Practical value: May find applications in topological quantum computing and novel quantum devices
3. Reproducibility: Detailed theoretical calculations and numerical results are reproducible
4. Inspirational value: Provides new ideas and methods for related research fields

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical physics research: Research in non-Hermitian topological physics and quantum many-body systems
2. Numerical simulation: Numerical computation and analysis of complex quantum systems
3. Experimental physics: Optical systems, cold atom systems, superconducting quantum devices, etc.
4. Quantum technology: Applications in topological quantum computing, quantum sensing, etc.

References

The paper cites 86 relevant references, covering fundamental works and recent advances in multiple important fields including non-Hermitian physics, Floquet engineering, and topological superconductors, providing a solid theoretical foundation for this research.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that makes important contributions to non-Hermitian topological physics. The proposed Floquet engineering method provides new pathways for constructing point-gapped topological phases, with in-depth theoretical analysis and sufficient numerical verification, possessing significant academic value and potential application prospects.