Flexible generation of optomagnonic quantum entanglement and quantum coherence difference in double-cavity-optomagnomechanical system

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.15364
• Title: Flexible generation of optomagnonic quantum entanglement and quantum coherence difference in double-cavity-optomagnomechanical system
• Authors: Xiaomin Liu, Rongguo Yang, Jing Zhang, Tiancai Zhang
• Classification: quant-ph (Quantum Physics)
• Published Journal: Optica Journal
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.15364

Abstract

Quantum entanglement and quantum coherence are important resources in quantum information and quantum computing. This paper proposes a flexible scheme for generating optomagnonic quantum entanglement and quantum coherence difference based on a double-cavity optomagnomechanical system. We systematically investigate the parameter dependence of bipartite optomagnonic entanglement, genuine tripartite optomagnonic entanglement, quantum coherence difference, and system stability. The results demonstrate that the proposed scheme provides greater flexibility for magnon modes to select different mechanisms while maintaining system stability. This work has significant value for future applications in connecting different nodes in quantum networks and for optically manipulating magnon states.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Importance of quantum resources: Quantum entanglement and quantum coherence are core resources for quantum computing, quantum communication, and quantum networks, used to correlate different nodes
2. Advantages of optomagnomechanical systems: Phonon and magnon modes in optomagnomechanical systems can interact with physical modes of various frequencies, making them promising platforms for connecting different components in hybrid quantum systems
3. Limitations of existing research: Previous work requires specific mechanisms for each mode to create macroscopic quantum effects, lacking flexibility

Research Motivation

This paper aims to propose a more flexible scheme that enables magnon modes to select either red-detuned or blue-detuned driving microwave fields, i.e., to manipulate magnons by adjusting the frequency of the driving microwave field while maintaining system stability.

Core Contributions

1. Proposed a flexible double-cavity optomagnomechanical system: Designed a system architecture containing two optical cavities and a YIG crystal
2. Implemented two operational schemes:
   • Scheme (i): Magnon mode driven by red-detuned microwave field (state transfer mechanism)
   • Scheme (ii): Magnon mode driven by blue-detuned microwave field (entanglement creation mechanism)
3. Comprehensive parameter dependence analysis: Systematically investigated the parameter dependencies of bipartite and tripartite optomagnonic entanglement and quantum coherence difference
4. Stability region analysis: Detailed analysis of system stability regions under different parameter conditions

Methodology Details

System Model

The system comprises:

• Two optical cavities (frequencies ωₐ, ωc, decay rates κₐ, κc)
• A micromechanical YIG crystal with magnon mode (frequency ωₘ, decay rate κₘ) and phonon mode (frequency ωᵦ, decay rate γᵦ)
• Laser driving (frequency ωL) and microwave driving (frequency ω₀)

Hamiltonian

The system Hamiltonian is:

Ĥ/ℏ = ωₐâ†â + ωcĉ†ĉ + ωₘm̂†m̂ + ωᵦ/2(q² + p²)
     - gₐâ†âq + gcĉ†ĉq + gₘm̂†m̂q
     + iηₐ(â†e^(-iωLt) - âe^(iωLt)) + iηc(ĉ†e^(-iωLt) - ĉe^(iωLt))
     + iΩ(m̂†e^(-iω₀t) - m̂e^(iω₀t))

Two Operational Schemes

• Scheme (i): Cavity mode a resonant with the Stokes sideband of the laser, cavity mode c resonant with the anti-Stokes sideband, magnon mode m driven by red-detuned microwave field (Δₘ = ωᵦ)
• Scheme (ii): Same cavity mode configuration, but magnon mode m driven by blue-detuned microwave field (Δₘ = -ωᵦ)

Quantification Metrics

• Bipartite entanglement: Quantified using logarithmic negativity EN
• Tripartite entanglement: Quantified using minimal residual entanglement Rₘᵢₙ
• Quantum coherence difference: Quantified using ΔCQ to measure inter-mode coherence

Experimental Setup

System Parameters

• Phonon frequency: ωᵦ/2π = 25 MHz
• Cavity decay rates: κₐ/2π = 1 MHz, κc/2π = 2 MHz
• Magnon decay rate: κₘ/2π = 1 MHz
• Phonon decay rate: γᵦ/2π = 100 Hz
• Temperature: T = 10 mK
• Coupling strengths: Gₐ/2π = 1.5 MHz, Gc/2π = 8 MHz
• Detunings: Δₐ = -ωᵦ, Δc = ωᵦ

Specific Parameters for Two Schemes

• Scheme (i): Δₘ = ωᵦ, Gₘ/2π = 6 MHz
• Scheme (ii): Δₘ = -ωᵦ, Gₘ/2π = 1.5 MHz

Experimental Results

Main Results

Bipartite Optomagnonic Entanglement

1. Entanglement Eₐₘ: Reaches maximum near Δₐ = -ωᵦ, with maximum value approximately 0.25
2. Entanglement Ecₘ: Reaches maximum near Δc = ωᵦ, with maximum value approximately 0.2
3. Magnon parameter dependence:
   • Eₐₘ primarily exists near Δₘ = ωᵦ (red-detuned)
   • Ecₘ primarily exists near Δₘ = -ωᵦ (blue-detuned)

Tripartite Entanglement

1. Genuine tripartite entanglement Rₘᵢₙₐcₘ: Observable in both schemes, with maximum value approximately 0.01
2. Greater parameter sensitivity: Compared to bipartite entanglement, tripartite entanglement is more sensitive to cavity decay rates
3. Non-monotonic behavior: Exhibits an increase-then-decrease trend with increasing magnomechanical coupling strength Gₘ

Quantum Coherence Difference

1. ΔCₐₘ and ΔCcₘ: Observable in both schemes, with maximum value approximately 0.2
2. Mechanism sensitivity: Quantum coherence difference is sensitive to the operating mechanism, existing in a narrow coupling strength region under the entanglement creation mechanism and in a wider region under the state transfer mechanism

Stability Analysis

1. Stability regions: Determined by analyzing eigenvalues of the drift matrix A
2. Scheme comparison: Scheme (i) has larger stability regions than scheme (ii) due to stronger state transfer capability
3. Parameter effects: Weak entanglement creation and moderate state transfer mechanisms help maintain system stability

Environmental Robustness

1. Temperature robustness: Entanglement can exist at temperatures above 150 mK
2. Decay effects: The system is relatively robust to phonon decay until γᵦ/2π ~ 10⁴ Hz, where significant degradation occurs

Related Work

Optomagnomechanical System Research

1. Single-cavity systems: Early work primarily focused on optomagnonic entanglement generation in single-cavity optomagnomechanical systems
2. Multi-cavity systems: Recent research has extended to hybrid systems containing multiple microwave cavities
3. PT-symmetric systems: Some work explores entanglement enhancement in PT-symmetric optomagnomechanical systems

Quantum Coherence Research

1. Optomechanical systems: Realization of quantum coherence and coherence difference in cavity optomechanical systems
2. Magnomechanical systems: Investigation of quantum coherence in hybrid Laguerre-Gaussian cavity magnomechanical systems

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Enhanced flexibility: The proposed scheme enables magnon modes to select either red-detuned or blue-detuned driving, providing greater operational flexibility
2. Multiple quantum resources: Successfully generates bipartite entanglement, tripartite entanglement, and quantum coherence difference
3. Stability assurance: Detailed stability analysis ensures quantum effects are realized within stable regions

Limitations

1. Parameter sensitivity: Tripartite entanglement is relatively sensitive to system parameters, requiring precise parameter control
2. Temperature constraints: Although relatively robust, still requires millikelvin-level cryogenic environments
3. Coupling strength limitations: Excessively strong coupling may lead to system instability

Future Directions

1. Experimental implementation: Verify theoretical predictions in practical YIG-cavity systems
2. Network applications: Explore specific applications in quantum networks
3. Parameter optimization: Further optimize system parameters to enhance quantum effects

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical completeness: Provides a comprehensive theoretical framework with detailed mathematical derivations
2. Systematic analysis: Comprehensively analyzes the effects of various parameters on quantum effects
3. Practical value: Provides theoretical foundation for practical quantum network applications
4. Innovation: The proposed dual-scheme design increases system flexibility

Weaknesses

1. Lack of experimental verification: The paper is primarily theoretical work lacking experimental validation
2. Parameter selection: Some parameter choices lack sufficient physical justification
3. Limited application scenarios: Discussion of specific application scenarios is relatively limited

Impact

1. Academic contribution: Provides a new theoretical framework for quantum effects research in optomagnomechanical systems
2. Technical value: Provides potential technical pathways for quantum networks and quantum information processing
3. Reproducibility: Detailed mathematical derivations and parameter settings facilitate result reproduction

Applicable Scenarios

1. Quantum networks: Connecting different types of quantum nodes
2. Quantum information processing: Magnon-based quantum information storage and processing
3. Hybrid quantum systems: Quantum effects research in optical-magnetic-mechanical hybrid systems

References

The paper cites 39 relevant references covering important work in quantum computing, quantum communication, optomechanical systems, magnomechanical systems, and other fields, providing a solid theoretical foundation for the research.

This work makes important theoretical contributions to quantum effects research in optomagnomechanical systems, particularly in system flexibility and unified generation of multiple quantum resources. Although lacking experimental verification, the detailed theoretical analysis and parameter investigation provide a solid foundation for future experimental work.