2025-11-13T16:37:11.496799

Grain alignment and dust evolution physics with polarisation (GRADE-POL). I. Dust polarisation modelling for isolated starless cores

Tram, Hoang, Lazarian et al.

The polarisation of light induced by aligned interstellar dust serves as a significant tool in investigating cosmic magnetic fields, dust properties, and poses a challenge in characterising the polarisation of the cosmic microwave background and other sources. To establish dust polarisation as a reliable tool, the physics of the grain alignment process needs to be studied thoroughly. The Magnetically enhanced Radiative Torque (MRAT) alignment is the only mechanism that can induce highly efficient alignment of grains with magnetic fields required by polarisation observations of the diffuse interstellar medium. Our numerical modelling of dust polarisation using the MRAT theory demonstrated that the alignment efficiency of starlight polarisation ($p_{\rm ext}/A_{\rm V}$) and the degree of thermal dust polarisation ($p_{\rm em}$) first decrease slowly with increasing visual extinction ($A_{\rm V}$) and then falls steeply as $\propto A^{-1}_{\rm V}$ at large $A_{\rm V}$ due to the loss of grain alignment, which explains the phenomenon known as polarisation holes. Visual extinction at the transition from shallow to steep slope ($A^{\rm loss}_{\rm V}$) increases with the maximum grain size. By applying physical profiles suitable for a starless core 109 in the Pipe Nebula (Pipe-109), our model successfully reproduces the existing observations of starlight polarisation at R-band ($0.65\,Î¼$m) and H-band ($1.65\,Î¼$m), as well as emission polarisation at submillimetre ($870\,Î¼$m). Successful modelling of observational data requires perfect alignment of large grains as evidence of the MRAT mechanism, and larger maximum size with higher elongation at higher $A_{\rm V}$. The latter reveals the first evidence for the new model of anisotropic grain growth induced by magnetic grain alignment.

academic

Grain alignment and dust evolution physics with polarisation (GRADE-POL). I. Dust polarisation modelling for isolated starless cores

Basic Information

Paper ID: 2501.16079
Title: Grain alignment and dust evolution physics with polarisation (GRADE-POL). I. Dust polarisation modelling for isolated starless cores
Authors: Le Ngoc Tram, Thiem Hoang, Alex Lazarian, Daniel Seifried, B-G Andersson, Thushara G.S. Pillai, Bao Truong, Pham Ngoc Diep, Lapo Fanciullo
Classification: astro-ph.GA (Astrophysics - Galactic Astrophysics)
Publication Date: October 14, 2025
Journal: Astronomy & Astrophysics
Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.16079

Abstract

This paper establishes a dust polarization numerical model based on magnetically-enhanced radiation alignment torque (MRAT) theory to investigate dust grain alignment and evolution physics in isolated starless cores. The model successfully explains the variation of starlight polarization efficiency ( $p_{\rm ext}/A_{\rm V}$ ) and thermal dust polarization degree ( $p_{\rm em}$ ) with increasing visual extinction ( $A_{\rm V}$ ): slow decline at low $A_{\rm V}$ , followed by steep decline proportional to $A_V^{-1}$ at large $A_{\rm V}$ , explaining the "polarization hole" phenomenon. Through modeling of the Pipe-109 starless core, the model successfully reproduces observational data in the R-band, H-band, and submillimeter wavelengths, providing evidence for the MRAT mechanism and revealing for the first time observational evidence of magnetically-aligned anisotropic grain growth.

Research Background and Motivation

Scientific Questions

Physical mechanisms of dust polarization: Interstellar dust alignment-induced polarization is an important tool for probing cosmic magnetic fields and dust properties, but the physical processes of grain alignment require deeper understanding
Polarization hole phenomenon: The sharp decline in polarization degree observed at the centers of dense cloud cores requires theoretical explanation
Grain growth mechanisms: Traditional theory assumes isotropic grain growth, but detailed studies of shape evolution are lacking

Research Significance

Dust polarization is the primary means of detecting interstellar magnetic fields
Affects characterization of foreground contamination in cosmic microwave background polarization
Critical for understanding dust evolution during star formation

Limitations of Existing Methods

Classical radiation alignment torque (RAT) theory cannot explain efficient grain alignment observed in diffuse interstellar medium
Lack of physical models simultaneously considering multi-wavelength polarization observations
Insufficient understanding of shape evolution during grain growth processes

Core Contributions

Established the GRADE-POL framework: A multi-wavelength dust polarization physical model based on MRAT theory
Explained the polarization hole phenomenon: Through grain alignment loss mechanisms, explaining the observed $p \propto A_V^{-1}$ characteristics
Verified the MRAT mechanism: Providing direct evidence for MRAT through successful fitting of Pipe-109 observational data
Discovered anisotropic grain growth: First observational evidence supporting magnetically-aligned grain growth accompanied by shape changes

Methodology Details

Physical Model Setup

Geometric Configuration:

Spherically symmetric starless core with radius $r_{\rm out}$ and central density $n_0$
Density distribution: $n_H(r) = n_0(r/r_{\rm flat})^{-\alpha}$ (when $r > r_{\rm flat}$ )

Radiation Field Attenuation: $U(A_V^{\rm ext}) = \frac{U_0}{1 + 0.42 \times (A_V^{\rm ext})^{1.22}}$

Mean Wavelength Evolution: $\bar{\lambda}(A_V^{\rm ext}) = \bar{\lambda}_0[1 + 0.27 \times (A_V^{\rm ext})^{0.76}]$

Grain Alignment Theory

Radiation Torque: $\bar{\Gamma}_{\rm RAT} = \pi a^2 \gamma u_{\rm rad}\left(\frac{\bar{\lambda}}{2\pi}\right)\bar{Q}_\Gamma$

where the RAT efficiency is:

2(\bar{\lambda}/a)^{-2.7} & \text{if } a \leq \bar{\lambda}/1.8 \\ 0.4 & \text{if } a > \bar{\lambda}/1.8 \end{cases}$$ **Alignment Size**: Determined by solving $\omega_{\rm RAT}(a_{\rm align}) = 3\sqrt{15k_BT_{\rm gas}/(8\pi\rho a_{\rm align}^5)}$ **Alignment Function**: $$f(a) = f_{\rm max}[1 - e^{-(0.5a/a_{\rm align})^3}]$$ ### Polarization Degree Calculation **Starlight Polarization**: $$p_{\rm ext}(A_V) = 100 \times \int_s n_H ds \left(\int_{a_{\rm min}}^{a_{\rm max}} \pi a^2 Q_{\rm ext}^{\rm pol} F_{\rm turb}\sin^2\psi f(a)\frac{1}{n_H}\frac{dn}{da}da\right)$$ **Thermal Dust Polarization**: $$p_{\rm em}(A_V) = 100 \times \frac{\int_s dI_{\rm pol}}{\int_s dI_{\rm em}}$$ ## Experimental Setup ### Model Parameters - **Physical parameters**: $n_0 = 5 \times 10^5$ cm$^{-3}$, $r_{\rm flat} = 0.024$ pc, $r_{\rm out} = 0.6$ pc - **Radiation field**: $U_0 = 1$, $\gamma = 0.3$, $\bar{\lambda}_0 = 1.2$ μm - **Dust model**: Astrodust composition, oblate ellipsoidal shapes, axis ratios 1.4-3.0 - **Grain distribution**: MRN distribution, $dn/da \propto a^{-3.5}$ ### Observational Data Multi-wavelength polarization observations of the Pipe-109 starless core: - R-band (0.65 μm) starlight polarization - H-band (1.65 μm) starlight polarization - Submillimeter (870 μm) thermal dust polarization ### Fitting Strategy Fitting the $p_{\rm ext}/A_V$-$A_V$ and $p_{\rm em}$-$A_V$ relationships across different wavelengths by adjusting maximum grain size ($a_{\rm max}$) and grain axis ratios ## Experimental Results ### Main Findings **Polarization-Extinction Relationship**: - Slow decline of polarization degree at low $A_V$ - Sharp decline proportional to $A_V^{-1}$ at $A_V > A_V^{\rm loss}$ - $A_V^{\rm loss}$ increases with maximum grain size **Multi-wavelength Fitting Results**: - R-band: $a_{\rm max} = 0.21-0.34$ μm, axis ratio 1.4 - H-band: $a_{\rm max} = 0.28-0.45$ μm, axis ratio 1.4 - Submillimeter: $a_{\rm max} \geq 1$ μm, axis ratio >1.4 ### Key Evidence **MRAT Mechanism Verification**: - Requires $f_{\rm max} = 1$ (perfect alignment) to fit observations - Classical RAT theory ($f_{\rm max} \sim 0.2-0.4$) cannot explain the data **Anisotropic Grain Growth**: - Deeper cloud cores ($larger A_V$) require larger ($a_{\rm max}$) and more elongated grains - First observational evidence supporting theoretical predictions by Hoang (2022) ### Magnetic Field Geometry Effects Considering magnetic field inclination angle $\psi = 35°$: - Polarization degree reduction factor $\sin^2\psi \approx 1/3$ - Requires higher grain axis ratios (~3) to compensate ## Related Work ### Development of Grain Alignment Theory - **Classical RAT theory** (Lazarian & Hoang 2007): Fundamental radiation torque mechanism - **MRAT theory** (Hoang & Lazarian 2016): Magnetic enhancement effects enabling efficient alignment - **RAT paradigm** (Hoang et al. 2019): Combined alignment and disruption mechanisms ### Polarization Observation Studies - **Diffuse medium** (Hensley & Draine 2023): Requires efficient alignment mechanisms - **Molecular clouds** (Reissl et al. 2020): Demands for MRAT mechanism - **Protostellar environments** (Giang et al. 2023): ALMA high polarization observations ### Grain Growth Theory - **Traditional models**: Isotropic growth considering only size changes - **New theory** (Hoang 2022): Magnetically-aligned anisotropic growth ## Conclusions and Discussion ### Main Conclusions 1. **Polarization hole mechanism**: Caused by small grains losing alignment in dense gas, explaining the $p \propto A_V^{-1}$ phenomenon 2. **MRAT evidence**: Successful modeling of Pipe-109 requires perfect alignment ($f_{\rm max} = 1$), supporting the MRAT mechanism 3. **Grain evolution**: Simultaneous growth of grain size and shape with depth observed, validating anisotropic growth theory 4. **Multi-wavelength diagnostics**: Different wavelengths probe different depths; longer wavelengths probe deeper regions ### Limitations 1. **Geometric assumptions**: Spherical symmetry and uniform magnetic field assumptions; actual situations are more complex 2. **Grain model**: Assumption of constant $a_{\rm max}$ along line-of-sight is oversimplified 3. **Temperature coupling**: Assumption of $T_{\rm gas} = T_{\rm dust}$ may not hold in low-density regions 4. **Optical depth**: May violate optically thin assumptions in certain wavelengths ### Future Directions 1. **Three-dimensional magnetic field modeling**: Considering complex effects of magnetic field geometry and turbulence 2. **Grain evolution models**: Self-consistent modeling of spatial distribution of grain size and shape 3. **Larger sample studies**: Extension to starless cores under different physical conditions 4. **Radiative transfer**: Including complete radiative transfer processes ## In-Depth Evaluation ### Strengths 1. **Theoretical innovation**: First multi-wavelength dust polarization physical model based on MRAT 2. **Observational verification**: Successfully explains three-wavelength observational data of Pipe-109 3. **Important discovery**: Provides first observational evidence of anisotropic grain growth 4. **Complete methodology**: Comprehensive framework from fundamental physics to observational comparison ### Technical Highlights 1. **Physical self-consistency**: Modeling based on first-principles RAT theory 2. **Multi-wavelength constraints**: Simultaneous fitting of optical, near-infrared, and submillimeter observations 3. **Parameter sensitivity**: Systematic study of grain size and shape effects 4. **Open-source code**: DustPOL_py code publicly available ### Shortcomings 1. **Sample limitation**: Analysis of only one starless core; more samples needed for verification 2. **Model simplification**: Spherical symmetry assumption limits application to complex structures 3. **Parameter degeneracies**: Degeneracies exist between grain size, shape, and magnetic field geometry 4. **Theory dependence**: Strong dependence on correctness of MRAT theory ### Impact Assessment **Academic Value**: - Provides new theoretical framework for dust polarization research - Advances understanding of interstellar grain alignment mechanisms - Provides observational constraints on grain growth theory **Practical Value**: - Applicable to polarization modeling in other astrophysical environments - Provides theoretical support for future polarization observation projects - Aids in cosmic microwave background foreground removal ### Applicable Scenarios 1. **Starless core research**: Magnetic fields and dust properties in dense cloud cores 2. **Star-forming regions**: Polarization modeling in protostellar environments 3. **Galactic scales**: Dust polarization studies in external galaxies 4. **Cosmological applications**: CMB foreground modeling and removal ## References **Core Theoretical Literature**: - Lazarian & Hoang (2007): RAT theory foundations - Hoang & Lazarian (2016): MRAT mechanism - Hensley & Draine (2023): Astrodust model **Observational Comparison Literature**: - Alves et al. (2014): Pipe-109 polarization observational data - Kandori et al. (2018, 2020): Magnetic field geometry studies **Methodological Literature**: - Lee et al. (2020), Tram et al. (2021a): DustPOL_py model development --- **Overall Assessment**: This is a high-quality astrophysical research paper combining theory and observations, achieving important progress in dust polarization physics modeling. It is particularly pioneering in MRAT mechanism verification and the discovery of anisotropic grain growth. Despite some limitations from model simplifications, it establishes a solid foundation for future developments in this field.