Gravitational waves decohere quantum superpositions

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2501.18111
• Title: Gravitational waves decohere quantum superpositions
• Authors: Flynn Linton (ETH Zürich), Shubhanshu Tiwari (University of Zürich)
• Classification: gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology), quant-ph (Quantum Physics)
• Publication Date: January 30, 2025 (arXiv v2)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.18111

Abstract

This paper investigates how gravitational waves induce decoherence in quantum spatial superposition states. The authors explore how gravitational radiation bursts from distant sources affect the coherence of quantum superpositions, identifying the individual contributions of oscillatory and memory components of incident gravitational waves to decoherence, corresponding respectively to hard and soft graviton emission. The study demonstrates that memory contributions typically dominate, while decoherence from oscillatory components strongly depends on the phase at which the burst terminates. This work illustrates how decoherence in quantum systems arises through interaction with classical gravitational fields.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Core Problem

The central problem addressed in this research is understanding the interaction between quantum mechanical systems and gravity, particularly how gravitational waves affect the coherence of quantum superposition states. This represents one of the key steps toward unifying quantum mechanics and general relativity.

2. Problem Significance

• Theoretical Importance: Understanding whether gravity possesses quantum properties is one of the most important open questions in physics
• Experimental Relevance: Provides theoretical foundations for possible experimental verification
• Unified Theory: Constitutes an important step in the development of quantum gravity theory

3. Limitations of Existing Research

Existing work primarily focuses on:

• Decoherence effects in black hole environments
• Local and global properties of static spacetimes
• Lack of systematic study of dynamic gravitational radiation effects

4. Research Motivation

Building on Danielson et al.'s discovery that decoherence is directly related to the memory effect of gravitational radiation, the authors aim to systematically investigate the specific mechanisms by which gravitational wave bursts affect the coherence of quantum superposition states.

Core Contributions

1. Separation of Contribution Mechanisms: First systematic identification and separation of distinct contributions from oscillatory and memory components of gravitational waves to quantum decoherence
2. Quantitative Analysis: Provides quantitative estimates of decoherence degree, including specific contributions from soft gravitons (memory effect) and hard gravitons (oscillatory effect)
3. Phase Dependence: Discovers that decoherence from oscillatory components strongly depends on the phase at which the gravitational wave burst terminates
4. Method Verification: Validates the theoretical framework through consistency between classical quadrupole moment calculations and quantum field theory methods
5. Electromagnetic Analogy: Establishes correspondence between gravitational and electromagnetic cases, providing broader theoretical perspective

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Study the decoherence behavior of a quantum spatial superposition state (Alice's experiment) when subjected to gravitational radiation bursts emitted by distant gravitational wave sources. Inputs are characteristic parameters of gravitational waves (frequency ω₀, amplitude h, duration T_GW), and outputs are the decoherence degree D of the quantum state.

Theoretical Framework

1. Gedankenexperiment Setup

• Alice uses a Stern-Gerlach apparatus to create spatially separated quantum superposition states during time T₁
• Superposition state components have initial separation d₀, moving along inertial trajectories for time T
• During superposition maintenance, subjected to gravitational wave burst lasting T_GW ≪ T
• Finally, reverse Stern-Gerlach apparatus recombines the state during time T₂

2. Gravitational Wave Model

Displacement induced by gravitational waves contains two components:

Oscillatory Component:

d_osc(t) = (d₀/2)h sin(ω₀(t + T_GW/2))

Memory Component:

d_mem(t) = d_m Θ(t + T_GW/2)

where Θ is the step function and d_m is the permanent displacement.

3. Decoherence Quantification

Decoherence degree is defined as:

D = 1 - |⟨Ψ₁|Ψ₂⟩_I⁺|

For coherent states:

D = 1 - exp(-½⟨N⟩)

where ⟨N⟩ is the number of gravitons radiated by Alice to null infinity.

Calculation Methods

1. Classical Quadrupole Moment Method

Estimate gravitational wave energy radiated by calculating the time-dependent quadrupole moment Q = md² of Alice's state:

E_rad = (2/5)∫dt |Q̈ᵢⱼ|²

2. Quantum Field Theory Method

Use the two-point function of Alice's gravitational field:

⟨N⟩ = m² ∫dt dt' d²(t)d²(t')⟨s^a s^b E^in_ab(t,X) s^c s^d E^in_cd(t',X)⟩_Ω

In frequency space:

⟨N⟩ ~ m² Σ(l=2 to ∞) (1/r⁶) ∫(ω_IR to ω_UV) (dω/ω)|d̂₂(ω)|²|R_ωl(r)|²

Technical Innovations

1. Component Separation: Systematically separate soft mode (memory) and hard mode (oscillatory) contributions through Fourier analysis
2. Phase Effects: Discover and quantify the influence of gravitational wave termination phase on decoherence
3. Multi-method Verification: Combine classical and quantum methods to ensure result reliability
4. Infrared/Ultraviolet Cutoff: Properly handle infrared divergence issues in soft graviton emission

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Experimental Parameters

• Time Scale Hierarchy: T ≫ T_GW ≫ T₁, T₂
• Frequency Cutoffs:
  • Infrared cutoff: ω_IR ~ 1/T
  • Ultraviolet cutoff: ω_UV ~ 1/min(T₁,T₂)
• Gravitational Wave Parameters: frequency ω₀, amplitude h ≪ 1, duration T_GW

Approximation Methods

1. Soft Frequency Dominance: Expand integrals near ω ≪ 1
2. Oscillatory Term Averaging: Handle large T oscillatory terms using ⟨sin²(ωT/2)⟩ = 1/2
3. Dominant Angular Momentum Mode: l = 2 mode dominates when ωr ≪ 1

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Classical Quadrupole Moment Calculation Results

Total number of gravitons radiated:

⟨N⟩ ~ m²(d₀⁴ + d₀³d_m + d₀⁴h sin(ω₀T_GW))/T_SG⁴

where T_SG = min(T₁,T₂).

2. Quantum Field Theory Calculation Results

⟨N⟩ ~ m²(d₀⁴ + d₀³d_m + d₀⁴h sin(ω₀T_GW))(1/min(T₁,T₂)⁴ - r²/min(T₁,T₂)⁶)

Leading terms are in complete agreement with classical results, with subleading terms representing quantum corrections.

3. Relative Decoherence Ratio

⟨N⟩/⟨N⟩_(GW off) ~ (1 + d_m/d₀ + h sin(ω₀T_GW))(1 - r²/min(T₁,T₂)²)

Key Findings

1. Memory Dominance: Memory contribution (∝ d_m/d₀) dominates at linear order
2. Oscillatory Suppression: Oscillatory contribution is suppressed by gravitational wave amplitude h and depends on phase sin(ω₀T_GW)
3. Phase Selection: Oscillatory contribution nearly vanishes when ω₀T_GW ≈ nπ
4. Soft Mode Dominance: Soft graviton emission (ω → 0) is the primary decoherence mechanism

Ablation Analysis

Memory-Only Case (h → 0):

|d̂₂(ω)|² = (4sin²(ωT/2)/ω²)[d₀⁴ + 2d₀³d_m(1 + sin(ωT_GW/2)/sin(ωT/2))]

Oscillation-Only Case (d_m → 0):

Decoherence appears only at O(h) order, manifesting as phase term contribution.

Related Work

Core Related Research

1. Danielson et al. Series 1-4: Established theoretical foundations for decoherence induced by black holes and Killing horizons
2. Mari et al. 8: Proposed the original gedankenexperiment framework
3. Electromagnetic Analogy Studies 10,11: Related calculations by Zhou & Yu, Menezes in electromagnetic cases

Unique Contributions of This Work

• First systematic study of dynamic gravitational radiation effects
• Separation and quantification of memory and oscillatory effects
• Establishment of gravitational-electromagnetic correspondence

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Gravitational Waves Indeed Cause Quantum Decoherence: Verified through two independent methods
2. Memory Effect Dominates: At linear order, memory contribution far exceeds oscillatory contribution
3. Phase Sensitivity: Oscillatory contribution strongly depends on gravitational wave termination phase
4. Soft Graviton Mechanism: Decoherence is primarily caused by soft graviton emission

Limitations

1. Simplified Waveforms: Uses idealized oscillatory and step function waveforms
2. Linear Approximation: Analysis limited to linear order in h and d_m
3. Point Particle Approximation: Treats superposition state components as point masses
4. Adiabatic Assumption: Assumes creation and recombination processes contribute negligibly to total decoherence

Future Directions

1. Realistic Waveforms: Numerical calculations using realistic gravitational waveforms from astrophysical sources
2. Nonlinear Effects: Study higher-order nonlinear contributions
3. Experimental Feasibility: Explore possibilities for experimental verification
4. Quantum Gravity: Extension toward fully quantized gravitational theory

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Rigor: Results verified through two independent methods, enhancing credibility
2. Deep Physical Insights: Clearly separates contributions from different physical mechanisms
3. Precise Mathematical Treatment: Properly handles technical issues such as infrared divergence
4. Clear Presentation: Logical structure and detailed mathematical derivations

Weaknesses

1. Experimental Verification Difficulty: Required experimental conditions are extremely stringent, difficult to verify in the near term
2. Approximation Limitations: Multiple simplifying assumptions may affect result universality
3. Lack of Numerical Verification: Primarily relies on analytical estimates without numerical simulation verification

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new understanding of quantum effects in semiclassical gravity
2. Methodological Value: Established analytical framework applicable to related problems
3. Cross-disciplinary Significance: Connects gravitational wave physics and quantum information theory

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Physics Research: Theoretical studies of quantum gravity and semiclassical gravity
2. Precision Measurement: Theoretical guidance for future high-precision quantum interferometry experiments
3. Gravitational Wave Detection: Provides foundation for research on gravitational wave effects on quantum systems

Technical Details Supplement

Electromagnetic Analogy

In the appendix, the authors establish complete electromagnetic analogy:

• Gravitational case: q → m, h → E, T_GW → T_EM
• Dominant multipole moments: Gravity (quadrupole) vs Electromagnetism (dipole)
• Frequency Dependence: Gravitational decoherence shows stronger frequency dependence

Mathematical Techniques

1. Spherical Harmonic Expansion: Uses spherical harmonic decomposition of gravitational wave solutions
2. Bessel Functions: Mode function expressions in Minkowski limit
3. Fourier Analysis: Handles time-dependent separation distance

This paper makes important contributions to semiclassical theory in quantum gravity, providing new perspectives and quantitative tools for understanding the interaction between gravity and quantum systems.