Notes on conformal integrals: Coulomb branch amplitudes, magic identities and bootstrap

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2502.08871
• Title: Notes on conformal integrals: Coulomb branch amplitudes, magic identities and bootstrap
• Authors: Song He, Xuhang Jiang, Jiahao Liu, Yao-Qi Zhang
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Publication Date: October 16, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502.08871

Abstract

This paper investigates multi-loop conformal integrals of four-point correlation functions in planar $\mathcal{N}=4$ super Yang-Mills theory, with particular focus on contributions to Coulomb branch amplitudes in the ten-dimensional collinear limit. In this limit, linear combinations of integrals are determined by the large R-charge octagon, which is exactly known from integrability. Utilizing known integrand results, the authors review dual conformal invariant (DCI) integral combinations that must evaluate to trapezoid determinants, generalizing the simplest cases of Basso-Dixon fishnet integrals. They summarize all-loop predictions for integrands contributing to Coulomb branch amplitude components. Furthermore, this investigation yields new "magic identities," with explicit enumeration and simplification of such identities up to six loops. On the other hand, based on leading singularities and pure function spaces, the authors consider a bootstrap program for DCI integrals, successfully bootstrapping 3 non-trivial DCI integrals at four loops for Coulomb branch amplitudes, as well as most results for 34 DCI integrals at five loops.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Importance of four-point correlation functions: Four-point correlation functions of half-BPS operators in $\mathcal{N}=4$ super Yang-Mills theory play a crucial role at the intersection of perturbative calculations, integrability, and conformal bootstrap.
2. Challenges in integral calculations: While planar loop integrands of four-point correlation functions and amplitudes have been determined to impressively high orders, understanding of integral results remains very limited. Conformal integrals beyond three loops involve new leading singularities and novel transcendental functions beyond simple harmonic polylogarithms.
3. Discovery of hidden ten-dimensional conformal symmetry: Reference 28 discovered hidden ten-dimensional conformal symmetry, which not only allows packing all high-charge four-point correlation functions into a 10-dimensional correlation function, but also provides exact integral results for the ten-dimensional collinear limit, known as the large R-charge correlation function or octagon.

Research Motivation

1. Coulomb branch amplitudes: Through duality with the octagon, these amplitudes are solved at all orders, given by determinants of trapezoid integrals.
2. Magic identities: By utilizing the fact that certain DCI integral combinations equal various Coulomb branch amplitude components, non-trivial "magic identities" can be derived.
3. Bootstrap methodology: A systematic approach is needed to compute analytic results for high-loop four-point conformal integrals.

Core Contributions

1. All-loop predictions from f-graph constraints: Through the 10-dimensional limit, certain f-graph coefficients are determined, including interesting connections between large classes of vanishing coefficients and special DCI integrals (such as Basso-Dixon fishnet and its generalizations).
2. Systematic study of magic identities: Continuing the investigation of "magic identities" begun in reference 28, these identities are simplified by subtracting known "zeros," with enumeration of non-trivial simplified magic identities up to six loops.
3. Bootstrap of four-loop DCI integrals: Successfully bootstrapped 3 non-trivial four-loop DCI integrals, all appearing as single-valued harmonic polylogarithms (SVHPL) of weight 8, providing independent verification of four-loop magic identities.
4. Leading singularity analysis of five-loop integrals: Computed all leading singularities and most pure functions for 34 DCI integrals contributing to five-loop amplitudes, discovering that certain integrals not only evaluate to functions beyond harmonic polylogarithms but also contain lower-weight components.

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Study multi-loop conformal integrals of four-point half-BPS operator correlation functions in planar $\mathcal{N}=4$ super Yang-Mills theory, particularly those DCI integrals contributing to Coulomb branch amplitudes in the ten-dimensional collinear limit.

f-graph Method

1. f-graph representation: The ℓ-loop integrand can be written as a linear combination of all (4+ℓ)-point f-graphs: $H^{(\ell)}_{2222} = \sum_{i=1}^{N_\ell} c_i^{(\ell)} f_i^{(\ell)}$ where solid lines represent poles $1/x_{ij}^2$ and dashed lines represent numerators $x_{ij}^2$.
2. Full permutation symmetry: The integrand is invariant under arbitrary permutations of $x_1, \cdots, x_{4+\ell}$, i.e., possesses full permutation symmetry $S_{4+\ell}$.

Ten-dimensional Uplift and Coulomb Branch Amplitudes

1. Master correlation function: All correlation functions of different R-charges originate from a single master four-point correlation function: $G(x_{ij}^2, y_{ij}^2) = \langle O(x_1,y_1)O(x_2,y_2)O(x_3,y_3)O(x_4,y_4)\rangle$
2. Ten-dimensional collinear limit: $X_{i,i+1}^2 \to 0 \Leftrightarrow d_{i,i+1} \to 1 \Leftrightarrow y_{ij}^2 \to -x_{ij}^2$ corresponds to the large R-charge limit of the master correlation function.
3. Coulomb branch amplitude decomposition: $M = 1 + \sum_{a,b \geq 1} (1-d_{13})^a(1-d_{24})^b M_{a,b}$

Bootstrap Method

1. Leading singularity analysis: Determine the structure of function spaces by analyzing leading singularities of integrals.
2. SVHPL basis: Use single-valued harmonic polylogarithms as the function basis with determined parity properties:
   • Odd parity: $L_{odd}(z,\bar{z}) = -L_{odd}(\bar{z},z)$
   • Even parity: $L_{even}(z,\bar{z}) = L_{even}(\bar{z},z)$
3. Asymptotic expansion constraints: Utilize asymptotic expansions in various kinematic regions to determine parameters.

Experimental Setup

Data and Tools

1. HyperlogProcedures package: Used for computing SVHPL functions and certain conformal integrals.
2. pySecDec: Used for numerical verification of analytic results.
3. f-graph data: Utilizes known f-graph coefficient data from graph bootstrap results in references 34,35.

Computational Strategy

1. Magic identity verification: Verify linear combinations of DCI integrals through known octagon results.
2. Asymptotic expansion matching: Use asymptotic expansions provided in reference 27 as boundary conditions.
3. Numerical verification: Use pySecDec for numerical verification at $O(10^{-6})$ precision.

Experimental Results

Four-loop Integral Results

Successfully bootstrapped 3 non-trivial four-loop DCI integrals $I_d^{(4)}, I_f^{(4)}, I_{f2}^{(4)}$, verifying the magic identity: $I_{d2}(u,v) + I_{d2}(v,u) + I_{f2}(u,v) = I_f(u,v) + I_f(v,u)$

All integrals are expressed as weight-8 SVHPL functions in concise form. For example: $I_f\left(\frac{u}{v}, \frac{1}{v}\right) = \frac{u-v-1}{\Delta^2}(\text{weight-8 SVHPL combination}) - \frac{1}{\Delta}(\text{weight-8 SVHPL combination})$

Five-loop Integral Analysis

1. Known integrals: 25 of the 34 DCI integrals can be computed via HyperlogProcedures or by solving "boxing" differential equations.
2. Trapezoid equivalence: 14 integrals equal the five-loop trapezoid integral $F_5$: $I_9^{(5)} = I_{10}^{(5)} = \cdots = I_{32}^{(5)} = F_5$
3. Non-uniform weights: Certain integrals contain lower-weight components, such as $I_{33}^{(5)}$ being a pure weight-9 function.

Leading Singularity Classification

Table V summarizes the leading singularities of all 34 five-loop DCI integrals:

• Most integrals possess leading singularities of type $1/\Delta$
• Certain integrals exhibit more complex singularity structures, such as $\frac{1-u+v}{\Delta^2}, \frac{1}{\Delta^2}, -\frac{1}{(u-v)\Delta}$, etc.

Related Work

Conformal Integral Theory

1. Classical results: The three-loop results by Drummond et al. in reference 25 laid the foundation.
2. Magic identities: Originated from double-box integral identities in reference 49, subsequently generalized in reference 28.

Integrability Methods

1. Octagon: Octagon results in references 48,63,64 provide exact integral results.
2. Hexagon form: The program in references 67,68 allows lifting free correlation functions to finite coupling correlation functions.

Bootstrap Techniques

1. Graph bootstrap: Graph bootstrap programs in references 31-35 determine high-loop integrands.
2. Function bootstrap: Bootstrap methods based on leading singularities and pure function spaces.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Systematic framework: Establishes a systematic framework for studying DCI integrals in Coulomb branch amplitudes, connecting f-graphs, magic identities, and bootstrap methods.
2. Computational breakthrough: Successfully bootstraps multiple DCI integrals at four and five loops for the first time, revealing their analytic structures.
3. Mathematical structure: Discovers deep mathematical relationships between DCI integrals, manifested through magic identities.

Limitations

1. Computational complexity: Certain four-loop conformal integrals contain elliptic sectors, preventing complete calculations.
2. Function complexity: Five-loop and higher integrals involve functions beyond harmonic polylogarithms, increasing computational difficulty.
3. Boundary data: Bootstrap methods require sufficient boundary conditions, which remain lacking for certain integrals.

Future Directions

1. Higher-loop generalization: Extend methods to higher loops and more points.
2. Geometric understanding: Seek geometric or algebraic explanations for magic identities.
3. Application expansion: Apply results to calculations of other physical quantities.

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical contribution: Systematically investigates the structure of DCI integrals, establishing deep connections between f-graphs, octagon results, and bootstrap methods.
2. Technical innovation: Develops bootstrap techniques based on leading singularities and SVHPL function spaces, successfully computing multiple high-loop integrals.
3. Mathematical insight: Discovers and systematizes magic identities, revealing deep relationships between seemingly different DCI integrals.
4. Computational achievement: Provides explicit analytic expressions for 3 four-loop and most five-loop DCI integrals.

Limitations

1. Completeness constraints: Some integrals remain incompletely determined, particularly those involving elliptic functions.
2. Method applicability: Bootstrap method's dependence on boundary data limits its application in more complex scenarios.
3. Theoretical explanation: Lacks complete theoretical explanation for the underlying principles of magic identities.

Impact

1. Field advancement: Provides new systematic methods for computing high-loop conformal integrals.
2. Tool value: Developed bootstrap techniques are applicable to similar problems.
3. Theoretical significance: Revealed mathematical structures are important for understanding transcendental structures in quantum field theory.

Applicable Scenarios

This method is particularly suitable for:

1. Multi-loop calculations in planar $\mathcal{N}=4$ super Yang-Mills theory
2. Conformal integrals with special symmetries
3. Physical systems where integrability results can be exploited
4. Theoretical calculations requiring high-precision analytic results

References

The paper cites 100 important references, covering conformal integral theory, integrability methods, bootstrap techniques, and other aspects, providing a comprehensive literature foundation for the field.