Lyapunov-like Stability Inequality with an Asymmetric Matrix and Application to Suboptimal LQ Control Design

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2502.11556
• Title: Lyapunov-like Stability Inequality with an Asymmetric Matrix and Application to Suboptimal LQ Control Design
• Author: Avinash Kumar
• Classification: math.OC (Optimization and Control)
• Publication Date: February 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502.11556

Abstract

The Lyapunov inequality is a fundamental tool for stability analysis in linear control theory, providing necessary and sufficient conditions for the stability of autonomous linear time-invariant systems through the existence of a symmetric positive-definite Lyapunov matrix. This paper proposes a novel variant of this inequality that allows the Lyapunov matrix to be asymmetric. After analyzing the properties of this inequality for a class of matrices, the author derives new results for stabilization of linear systems. Subsequently, these results are utilized to obtain sufficient conditions for suboptimal linear quadratic control design problems, where the asymmetric Lyapunov matrix serves as the design matrix. The cost of the computed stabilizing suboptimal control law is characterized by deriving cost upper bound expressions based on the system's initial conditions.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Limitations of Traditional Lyapunov Theory: The classical Lyapunov inequality $A^T P + PA \prec 0$ requires the Lyapunov matrix P to be symmetric positive-definite, an assumption that is ubiquitous in all results based on the Lyapunov inequality.
2. Rationale for the Symmetry Assumption:
   • Symmetric matrices possess favorable properties (real eigenvalues, diagonalizability)
   • Quadratic forms satisfy $z^T Mz = z^T M_{sym}z$, where $M_{sym} = \frac{1}{2}(M + M^T)$
   • The concept of positive definiteness is easily transferred from quadratic forms to symmetric matrices
3. Requirements for Suboptimal LQ Control: The optimal LQ control solution may be infeasible due to input saturation constraints, bounded norm requirements on feedback gain matrices, or structural conditions, necessitating the study of suboptimal solutions.

Research Motivation

1. Expanding the Design Space: By relaxing the symmetry assumption, extend the search space for the design matrix P from symmetric positive-definite matrices to a larger set of matrices
2. Avoiding Preset Cost Upper Bounds: Existing methods require pre-specifying a cost upper bound γ, which may lead to infeasibility, particularly in networked control design
3. Satisfying Structured Control Requirements: Certain problems (e.g., multi-agent consensus protocols) inherently require asymmetric design matrices

Core Contributions

1. Proposes a Novel Lyapunov-like Stability Inequality (LSI): $AP + P^T A \prec 0$, where P is not required to be symmetric
2. Establishes Stability Theory for Asymmetric Matrices: Proves that when A is symmetric negative-definite, matrices P satisfying LSI possess eigenvalues with positive real parts
3. Develops a New Method for Suboptimal LQ Control: Computes cost upper bounds based on initial conditions rather than pre-specifying them
4. Provides Cost Quantification Results: Derives explicit cost upper bound expressions $\gamma(x_0) = \text{trace}(P - \bar{P} + \hat{P})x_0^T x_0$

Methodology Details

Problem Formulation

Consider a linear time-invariant system: $\dot{x}(t) = Ax(t) + Bu(t)$ The objective is to design a control law $u(t) = -R^{-1}B^T Px(t)$ to stabilize the system and minimize the quadratic cost: $J = \int_0^{\infty} (x^T(t)Qx(t) + u^T(t)Ru(t))dt$

Core Theoretical Results

1. Lyapunov-like Stability Inequality (LSI)

Proposition 1: Assume $A \in \mathbb{R}^{n \times n}$ is a symmetric negative-definite matrix. If there exists a matrix $P \in \mathbb{R}^{n \times n}$ satisfying LSI: $AP + P^T A \prec 0$ then $\text{Re}(\lambda_i(P)) > 0, \forall i \in \{1,2,\ldots,n\}$, and therefore $\text{trace}(P) > 0$.

Proof Sketch: For any eigenvalue λ and corresponding eigenvector v, derive $\text{Re}(\lambda) > 0$ through $v^H(AP + P^T A)v < 0$.

2. Linear System Stabilization Result

Proposition 2: If there exist matrices $X \succ 0$ and $Y$ satisfying: $XA^T + AX - Y^T BR^{-1}B^T - BR^{-1}B^T Y \prec 0$ then the matrix $A - BR^{-1}B^T P$ is Hurwitz, where $P = YX^{-1}$.

3. Main Theorem on Suboptimality Quantification

Theorem 3: Assume there exist matrices $X \succ 0$, $W \succ 0$, $Y$, $P$ satisfying: $XA^T + AX - Y^T BR^{-1}B^T - BR^{-1}B^T Y \prec 0$$\begin{bmatrix} A^T P + P^T A - Q + W & (I + Y^T A)^T(P^T B) \\ (P^T B)^T & R \end{bmatrix} \succ 0$

If the closed-loop matrix $A - BR^{-1}B^T P$ is symmetric and there exists $\hat{P}$ such that: $(A - BR^{-1}B^T P)\hat{P} + \hat{P}^T(A - BR^{-1}B^T P) + W = 0$

then the control law solves Problem 2, with cost upper bound: $\gamma(x_0) = \text{trace}(P - \bar{P} + \hat{P})x_0^T x_0$

Technical Innovations

1. Asymmetric Design Matrices: First systematic study of asymmetric Lyapunov matrices in control design applications
2. Initial Condition-Based Cost Bounds: Directly compute cost upper bounds based on system initial states, avoiding preset parameters
3. Applicability to Structured Control: Particularly suitable for structured control problems requiring asymmetric design matrices

Experimental Setup

Numerical Example 1: Unstable LTI System

• System Matrices: $A = \begin{bmatrix} 1 & 2 \\ 0 & 2 \end{bmatrix}$, $B = \begin{bmatrix} 4 & 2 \\ 0 & 2 \end{bmatrix}$
• Initial Condition: $x_0 = [0.1, -0.2]^T$
• Weight Matrices: $Q = 10I_{2 \times 2}$, $R = 0.05I_{2 \times 2}$
• Tool: CVX toolbox for LMI solving

Numerical Example 2: Multi-Agent Consensus Protocol

• Number of Agents: 4 scalar unstable agents
• Dynamics: $\dot{x}_i(t) = x_i(t) + u_i(t)$
• Communication Topology: Directed graph with limited information exchange
• Objective: Achieve state consensus $|x_i(t) - x_j(t)| \to 0$

Evaluation Metrics

1. Stability: Hurwitz property of the closed-loop system
2. Cost Performance: Comparison between actual cost J and theoretical upper bound $\gamma(x_0)$
3. Feasibility: Solvability of LMI constraints

Experimental Results

Main Results

Example 1 Results

• Optimal Cost: $J^* = 0.0207$
• Suboptimal Control Law: $u(t) = -\begin{bmatrix} 1.3604 & -1.0302 \\ 0.0034 & 3.0638 \end{bmatrix}x(t)$
• Design Matrix: $P = \begin{bmatrix} 0.0170 & -0.0129 \\ -0.0169 & 0.0895 \end{bmatrix}$ (asymmetric)
• Cost Upper Bound: $\gamma(x_0) = 1.1374$
• Actual Cost: $J = 0.0627$

Example 2 Results

• Structured Gain Matrix: Sparse structure determined by communication topology
• Asymmetric Design Matrix: $P = \begin{bmatrix} 0.0350 & 0.0350 & 0 \\ 0 & 0.1049 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 0.1049 \end{bmatrix}$
• Cost Upper Bound: $\gamma(x_0) = 1.8426$
• Actual Cost: $J = 0.1407$

Key Findings

1. Necessity of Asymmetry: Example 2 demonstrates that certain problems inherently require asymmetric design matrices
2. Effectiveness of Cost Bounds: Theoretical bounds effectively constrain actual costs
3. Practical Applicability: The method can handle structured control constraint problems

Related Work

Traditional Lyapunov Theory

• Classical Results: Lyapunov inequality $A^T P + PA \prec 0$ provides necessary and sufficient conditions for stability
• LMI Development: Widespread application of linear matrix inequalities in control theory

Suboptimal LQ Control

• Existing Methods: Pre-specify cost upper bound γ and derive sufficient conditions
• Limitations: May lead to infeasibility, particularly when the optimal cost is unknown

Structured Control

• Multi-Agent Systems: Structured constraints in consensus protocol design
• Networked Control: Restrictions on controller structure imposed by communication topology

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Theoretical Contribution: Proposes a novel stability inequality allowing asymmetric Lyapunov matrices
2. Practical Value: Provides a new design method for suboptimal LQ control
3. Application Prospects: Particularly suitable for networked systems requiring structured control

Limitations

1. Applicability Conditions: Requires the closed-loop matrix to be symmetric negative-definite, limiting the method's generality
2. Computational Complexity: Requires solving multiple coupled LMI constraints
3. Conservatism: Provides sufficient rather than necessary conditions

Future Directions

1. Extension to More General Systems: Study cases with asymmetric system matrices
2. Networked Control Applications: Explore applications in more complex network topologies
3. Robustness Analysis: Consider parametric uncertainty and external disturbances

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong Innovation: First systematic relaxation of the symmetry assumption on Lyapunov matrices
2. Theoretical Rigor: Provides complete mathematical proofs and theoretical analysis
3. Good Practicality: Validates the method's effectiveness through numerical examples
4. Application Value: Particularly suitable for structured control problems

Weaknesses

1. Limited Applicability: Symmetry requirements on system matrices restrict the method's generality
2. Insufficient Experiments: Only two relatively simple numerical examples provided
3. Lack of Comparison: Missing quantitative comparisons with other suboptimal control methods
4. Missing Computational Efficiency Analysis: Does not discuss computational complexity of LMI solving

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new perspectives and tools for Lyapunov theory
2. Practical Value: Offers new insights for structured control design
3. Research Inspiration: May open new research directions in asymmetric design matrices

Applicable Scenarios

1. Multi-Agent Systems: Consensus protocol design
2. Networked Control: Distributed control with communication constraints
3. Structured Control: Control problems requiring specific gain matrix structures
4. Suboptimal Control: Alternative solutions when optimal solutions are infeasible

References

The paper cites classical control theory literature, including:

• Foundational works on Lyapunov stability theory
• Related research on linear matrix inequalities
• Existing methods for suboptimal LQ control
• Related work on multi-agent system consensus control

Overall Assessment: This is an innovative control theory paper that provides new theoretical tools for suboptimal control design by relaxing the traditional symmetry assumption on Lyapunov matrices. While there is room for improvement in applicability scope and experimental validation, its theoretical contributions and practical value are noteworthy, particularly in demonstrating advantages for structured control problems.