2025-11-15T17:01:10.701216

Skew odd orthogonal characters and interpolating Schur polynomials

Jing, Li, Wang et al.
We introduce two vertex operators to realize skew odd orthogonal characters $so_{λ/μ}(x^{\pm})$ and derive the Cauchy identity for the skew characters via Toeplitz-Hankel-type determinant similar to the Schur functions. The method also gives new proofs of the Jacobi--Trudi identity and Gelfand--Tsetlin patterns for $so_{λ/μ}(x^{\pm})$. Moreover, combining the vertex operators related to characters of types $C,D$ (\cite{Ba1996,JN2015}) and the new vertex operators related to $B$-type characters, we obtain three families of symmetric polynomials that interpolate among characters of $SO_{2n+1}(\mathbb{C})$, $SO_{2n}(\mathbb{C})$ and $Sp_{2n}(\mathbb{C})$, Their transition formulas are also explicitly given among symplectic and/or orthogonal characters and odd orthogonal characters.
academic

Skew odd orthogonal characters and interpolating Schur polynomials

Basic Information

  • Paper ID: 2502.15586
  • Title: Skew odd orthogonal characters and interpolating Schur polynomials
  • Authors: Naihuan Jing, Zhijun Li†, Danxia Wang, Chang Ye, and appendix with Xinyu Pan
  • Classification: math.RT (Representation Theory), math.CO (Combinatorics), math.QA (Quantum Algebra)
  • Publication Date: February 21, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
  • Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502.15586

Abstract

This paper introduces two vertex operators to realize skew odd orthogonal characters soλ/μ(x±)so_{\lambda/\mu}(x^{\pm}) and derives Cauchy identities for skew characters through Toeplitz-Hankel type determinants analogous to Schur functions. This approach also provides new proofs for the Jacobi-Trudi identities and Gelfand-Tsetlin patterns of soλ/μ(x±)so_{\lambda/\mu}(x^{\pm}). Furthermore, by combining vertex operators associated with C and D type characters with new vertex operators related to B type characters, three families of symmetric polynomials are obtained that interpolate between the characters of SO2n+1(C)SO_{2n+1}(\mathbb{C}), SO2n(C)SO_{2n}(\mathbb{C}), and Sp2n(C)Sp_{2n}(\mathbb{C}). Explicit conversion formulas between symplectic, orthogonal, and odd orthogonal characters are provided.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

  1. Classical group representation theory foundations: The irreducible characters of the general linear group GLn(C)GL_n(\mathbb{C}) are Schur functions sλ(x)s_\lambda(x) indexed by partitions λ\lambda, which form an orthogonal basis of the ring of symmetric functions. Skew Schur functions sλ/μ(x)s_{\lambda/\mu}(x) are fundamental tools for studying restrictions to subrepresentations.
  2. Classical group characters: The irreducible characters of the classical groups Sp2n(C)Sp_{2n}(\mathbb{C}), SO2n(C)SO_{2n}(\mathbb{C}), and SO2n+1(C)SO_{2n+1}(\mathbb{C}) are called symplectic characters spλ(x±)sp_\lambda(x^{\pm}), (even) orthogonal characters oλ(x±)o_\lambda(x^{\pm}), and odd orthogonal characters soλ(x±)so_\lambda(x^{\pm}), respectively.
  3. Current state of research: Baker and Jing-Nie have constructed vertex operator realizations for symplectic and orthogonal characters. The authors previously used vertex algebra methods to derive combinatorial structures for skew symplectic and skew (even) orthogonal characters.

Research Motivation

  1. Completing the theoretical framework: Vertex operator realizations for the skew versions of odd orthogonal characters (B type) have not yet been established, necessitating a unified theoretical framework for classical group characters.
  2. Interpolating polynomials: There is a need to construct symmetric polynomials that interpolate between characters of different types of classical groups to provide a unified study of their properties.
  3. Combinatorial identities: Important combinatorial structures such as Jacobi-Trudi identities, Gelfand-Tsetlin patterns, and Cauchy-type identities need to be established for skew odd orthogonal characters.

Core Contributions

  1. Introduction of new vertex operators: Two new vertex operators U(z)U(z) and U(z)U^*(z) are constructed for odd orthogonal characters soλ(x±)so_\lambda(x^{\pm}), completing the vertex operator realization for B type.
  2. Establishment of combinatorial theory for skew odd orthogonal characters:
    • Derivation of Jacobi-Trudi identities for skew odd orthogonal characters soλ/μ(x±)so_{\lambda/\mu}(x^{\pm})
    • Establishment of Gelfand-Tsetlin patterns
    • Proof of Cauchy-type identities
  3. Construction of three families of interpolating Schur polynomials:
    • BD interpolating polynomials sλBD(x;α)s^{BD}_\lambda(x;\alpha): interpolating between B and D type characters
    • BC interpolating polynomials sλBC(x;α)s^{BC}_\lambda(x;\alpha): interpolating between B and C type characters
    • CD interpolating polynomials sλCD(x;α)s^{CD}_\lambda(x;\alpha): interpolating between C and D type characters
  4. Establishment of conversion formulas: Explicit conversion relationships between symplectic, orthogonal, and odd orthogonal characters are provided.
  5. Discovery of new determinant identities: Three Toeplitz-Hankel type determinant identities related to Schur functions are established.

Detailed Methodology

Core Vertex Operator Definitions

The paper introduces two key vertex operators based on the Heisenberg algebra:

U(z)=(1+z)exp(n=1annzn)exp(n=1ann(zn+zn))U(z) = (1 + z) \exp\left(\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{a_{-n}}{n}z^n\right) \exp\left(-\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{a_n}{n}(z^n + z^{-n})\right)

U(z)=(1z)exp(n=1annzn)exp(n=1ann(zn+zn))U^*(z) = (1- z) \exp\left(-\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{a_{-n}}{n}z^n\right) \exp\left(\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{a_n}{n}(z^n + z^{-n})\right)

Partition Element Construction

For a generalized partition λ=(λ1,λ2,,λl)\lambda = (\lambda_1, \lambda_2, \ldots, \lambda_l), define:

  • λso=Uλ1Uλ2Uλl0|\lambda^{so}\rangle = U_{-\lambda_1}U_{-\lambda_2} \cdots U_{-\lambda_l}|0\rangle
  • λso=0UλlUλ1\langle\lambda^{so}| = \langle 0|U^*_{-\lambda_l} \cdots U^*_{-\lambda_1}

Semi-vertex Operators

Multiple semi-vertex operators are introduced for different purposes:

  • Γ+(z)=exp(n=1annzn)\Gamma_+(z) = \exp(\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{a_n}{n}z^n)
  • Γ(z)=exp(n=1annzn)\Gamma_-(z) = \exp(\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{a_{-n}}{n}z^n)
  • Γ~+(z)=exp(n=1a2nnzn)\tilde{\Gamma}_+(z) = \exp(-\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{a_{2n}}{n}z^n)

Technical Innovations

  1. Generalized Clifford algebra structure: Using the Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff formula, it is proven that vertex operators satisfy the anticommutation relations of a generalized Clifford algebra: UiUj+Uj+1Ui1=0U_iU_j + U_{j+1}U_{i-1} = 0UiUj+Uj1Ui+1=0U^*_iU^*_j + U^*_{j-1}U^*_{i+1} = 0UiUj+Uj+1Ui+1=δi,jU_iU^*_j + U^*_{j+1}U_{i+1} = \delta_{i,j}
  2. Orthogonality relations: Orthogonality of partition elements is established: μsoλso=δλμ\langle\mu^{so}|\lambda^{so}\rangle = \delta_{\lambda\mu}
  3. Matrix element realization: Skew odd orthogonal characters can be expressed as matrix elements of vertex operators: soλ/μ(x±)=μsoΓ+(x±)λsoso_{\lambda/\mu}(x^{\pm}) = \langle\mu^{so}|\Gamma_+(x^{\pm})|\lambda^{so}\rangle

Main Results

Jacobi-Trudi Identity

Theorem 3.1: For generalized partitions μ=(μ1,,μl)\mu = (\mu_1, \ldots, \mu_l) and λ=(λ1,,λl+N)\lambda = (\lambda_1, \ldots, \lambda_{l+N}):

soλ/μ(x±)=det(aij)1i,jl+Nso_{\lambda/\mu}(x^{\pm}) = \det(a_{ij})_{1\leq i,j\leq l+N}

where the matrix elements are:

h_{\lambda_i-\mu_j-i+j}(x^{\pm}) & 1 \leq j \leq l \\ h_{\lambda_i-i+j}(x^{\pm}) + h_{\lambda_i-i-j+2l+1}(x^{\pm}) & l+1 \leq j \leq l+N \end{cases}$$ ### Gelfand-Tsetlin Pattern **Theorem 3.5**: For partitions $\mu \subset \lambda$: $$so_{\lambda/\mu}(x^{\pm}) = \sum_{\mu=z^0 \prec z^1 \prec \cdots \prec z^{2N}=\lambda} \prod_{i=1}^N x_i^{2|z^{2i-1}|-|z^{2i}|-|z^{2i-2}|}$$ where the partitions $z^k$ satisfy the interlacing conditions of the odd orthogonal Gelfand-Tsetlin pattern. ### Cauchy-Type Identity **Proposition 3.7**: $$\sum_{\mu} so_\mu(x^{\pm})s_\mu(y) = \frac{\prod_{k=1}^N(1+y_k)\prod_{1\leq k<l\leq N}(1-y_ky_l)}{\prod_{i,j=1}^N(1-x_iy_j)(1-x_i^{-1}y_j)}$$ ### Conversion Relations for Interpolating Polynomials 1. **BD interpolation**: $s^{BD}_\lambda(x;0) = so_\lambda(x^{\pm})$, $s^{BD}_\lambda(x;1) = o_\lambda(x^{\pm})$ 2. **BC interpolation**: $s^{BC}_\lambda(x;0) = so_\lambda(x^{\pm})$, $s^{BC}_\lambda(x;-1) = sp_\lambda(x^{\pm})$ 3. **CD interpolation**: $s^{CD}_\lambda(x;0) = sp_\lambda(x^{\pm})$, $s^{CD}_\lambda(x;1) = o_\lambda(x^{\pm})$ ### Conversion Formulas Between Classical Group Characters **Theorem 4.1**: $$so_\lambda(x^{\pm}) = \sum_{\mu=\lambda-\varepsilon} sp_\mu(x^{\pm})$$ $$o_\lambda(x^{\pm}) = \sum_{\mu=\lambda-\varepsilon} (-1)^{|\lambda/\mu|}so_\mu(x^{\pm})$$ where $\varepsilon = (\varepsilon_1, \ldots, \varepsilon_N)$ with $\varepsilon_i \in \{0,1\}$. ## Theoretical Significance and Applications ### Refinement of Symmetric Function Theory This paper completes the vertex operator theoretical framework for classical group characters, providing a unified algebraic structure for symmetric function theory. ### Toeplitz-Hankel Type Determinants **Theorem 3.12** establishes three important determinant identities that express Schur functions as Toeplitz-Hankel type determinants, which have significant implications in combinatorics and random matrix theory. ### Development of Interpolation Theory The three families of interpolating polynomials provide powerful tools for studying relationships between characters of different types of classical groups, generalizing the CB and DB interpolating polynomials of Bisi-Zygouras. ## Related Work ### Historical Development 1. **Schur function theory**: Classical theory established by Weyl, Littlewood-Richardson, and others 2. **Vertex operator methods**: Jing first introduced vertex operators to the study of symmetric functions 3. **Classical group characters**: Baker and Jing-Nie established vertex operator realizations for C and D types 4. **Skew functions**: Previous work by the authors established theory for skew symplectic and orthogonal characters ### Relationship to Recent Research The results in this paper are consistent with the dual Jacobi-Trudi formulas obtained by Albion et al. through lattice path methods, verifying the equivalence of different approaches. ## Technical Details and Innovations ### Complete Dual Space $\tilde{M}^*$ To handle generalized partitions containing zero parts, a complete dual space $\tilde{M}^*$ is introduced, representing an important technical innovation. ### Application of BCH Formula Clever use of the Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff formula establishes commutation relations between vertex operators, which is a key technique for proving various identities. ### Uniformity of Determinant Representations All combinatorial identities can be uniformly expressed in determinant form, reflecting the underlying algebraic structure. ## Limitations and Future Directions ### Current Limitations 1. **Computational complexity**: For large partitions, the complexity of determinant calculations is high 2. **Degree of generalization**: Currently limited mainly to classical groups; extension to exceptional groups has not been addressed 3. **Application scope**: Applications to concrete physical or engineering problems require further exploration ### Future Research Directions 1. **Quantum group generalization**: Extension of results to quantum groups and affine Lie algebras 2. **Elliptic generalization**: Study of analogous theory for elliptic Schur functions 3. **Combinatorial applications**: Seeking more applications in enumerative combinatorics 4. **Computational algorithms**: Development of efficient numerical computation methods ## In-Depth Evaluation ### Strengths 1. **Theoretical completeness**: Completes the final piece of the vertex operator theory for classical group characters 2. **Methodological innovation**: Vertex operator methods demonstrate powerful capability in handling skew functions 3. **Rich results**: Multiple important combinatorial identities are established simultaneously 4. **Uniformity**: Provides a unified theoretical framework for different types of classical groups ### Technical Contributions 1. **New vertex operators**: The construction of $U(z)$ and $U^*(z)$ is original 2. **Interpolating polynomials**: The construction of three families of interpolating polynomials is clever and natural 3. **Conversion formulas**: Explicit conversion relationships facilitate applications ### Impact Assessment 1. **Academic value**: Significant value in representation theory, combinatorics, and symmetric function theory 2. **Methodological significance**: Further development and refinement of vertex operator methods 3. **Subsequent research**: Provides important foundation for related subsequent research ### Technical Quality The mathematical reasoning in the paper is rigorous, proofs are complete, and technical treatment is meticulous. The technical innovations in handling generalized partitions and complete dual spaces are particularly commendable. ## Conclusion Through the introduction of new vertex operators, this paper successfully establishes a complete theory for skew odd orthogonal characters, including Jacobi-Trudi identities, Gelfand-Tsetlin patterns, and Cauchy-type identities. More importantly, by constructing three families of interpolating polynomials, it provides a unified framework for conversions between classical group characters. This work not only refines symmetric function theory but also establishes an important foundation for subsequent research in related fields. The paper demonstrates high technical level, rich results, and makes significant contributions at the intersection of representation theory and combinatorics. Although there is room for improvement in computational complexity and application scope, its theoretical value and methodological significance are substantial.