2025-11-12T17:40:11.642331

Global existence of weak solutions to a cell migration and (de)differentiation model with double haptotaxis in the context of tissue regeneration

Mohan, Surulescu
We study a model for the spread and (de)differentiation of mesenchymal stem cells and chondrocytes in a scaffold whose fibers are coated with hyaluron. The chondrocytes produce new extracellular matrix, which, together with hyaluron, serves as haptotactic cue for the stem cell migration. We prove global existence of weak solutions of the corresponding cross-diffusion system with double haptotaxis.
academic

Global existence of weak solutions to a cell migration and (de)differentiation model with double haptotaxis in the context of tissue regeneration

Basic Information

  • Paper ID: 2502.17098
  • Title: Global existence of weak solutions to a cell migration and (de)differentiation model with double haptotaxis in the context of tissue regeneration
  • Authors: Nishith Mohan, Christina Surulescu (RPTU Kaiserslautern-Landau)
  • Classification: math.AP (Analysis of PDEs)
  • Publication Date: February 25, 2025
  • Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502.17098

Abstract

This paper investigates a model of diffusion and differentiation/dedifferentiation of mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) and chondrocytes in hyaluronic acid-coated scaffolds in the context of tissue regeneration. Chondrocytes produce new extracellular matrix (ECM), which together with hyaluronic acid serves as haptotactic cues for stem cell migration. The paper establishes global existence of weak solutions to a cross-diffusion system with double haptotaxis.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Research Problem

This paper addresses mathematical modeling in tissue regeneration (particularly cartilage repair), focusing on:

  • Migration and differentiation of mesenchymal stem cells in hyaluronic acid-coated scaffolds
  • Generation and dedifferentiation of chondrocytes
  • Cellular response to double haptotaxis toward hyaluronic acid and extracellular matrix

2. Problem Significance

  • Clinical Relevance: Tissue regeneration is an expanding research field, crucial for cartilage/bone repair following trauma or joint degeneration
  • Interdisciplinary Integration: Cross-disciplinary research combining mathematical modeling, biology, medicine, and biomedical engineering shows promising prospects for achieving therapeutic goals
  • Theoretical Challenge: Haptotaxis models present significant mathematical analysis challenges due to degenerate diffusion of haptotactic cues and lack of regularity

3. Limitations of Existing Approaches

  • Most multi-haptotaxis models distribute corresponding convection terms across equations for different cell populations
  • Existing research primarily involves unidirectional repulsion or dispersed haptotaxis
  • Few studies address double attractive haptotaxis concentrated in models of a single cell population

4. Research Motivation

Based on the multiscale approach in 4 and data-driven numerical simulations in 6, this paper investigates a simplified yet biologically reasonable model, focusing on addressing mathematical analysis difficulties arising from double attractive haptotaxis.

Core Contributions

  1. Established a new mathematical model for tissue regeneration: Describes the dynamics of MSCs and chondrocytes in hyaluronic acid-coated scaffolds, incorporating double haptotaxis, differentiation/dedifferentiation, and limited proliferation
  2. Proved global existence of weak solutions (main result Theorem 1.2): For a cross-diffusion system with double attractive haptotaxis, under appropriate initial conditions and parameter assumptions, global weak solution existence is established
  3. Developed regularization approximation methods: Constructed a family of regularized problems by introducing artificial diffusion and regularization terms, progressively establishing estimates and obtaining solutions to the original problem through limiting processes
  4. Established critical entropy-type functional estimates: Utilized entropy-type functionals to derive a priori estimates independent of regularization parameters, which is the core technique for proving global existence

Detailed Methodology

Problem Formulation

Study global weak solution existence for the following PDE system:

\partial_t c_1 = a_1\Delta c_1 - \nabla \cdot (b_h c_1\nabla h) - \nabla \cdot (b_\tau c_1\nabla \tau) - \alpha_1(\tau)c_1 + \alpha_2(\tau)c_2 \\ \quad\quad\quad + \beta c_1(1 - c_1 - c_2 - \tau), & x \in \Omega, t > 0 \\ \partial_t c_2 = a_2\Delta c_2 + \alpha_1(\tau)c_1 - \alpha_2(\tau)c_2, & x \in \Omega, t > 0 \\ \partial_t h = -\gamma_1 hc_1 - \gamma_2 hc_2 - \mu h + \frac{c_2}{1+c_2}, & x \in \Omega, t > 0 \\ \partial_t \tau = -\delta c_1\tau - \sigma\tau + \frac{c_2}{1+c_2}, & x \in \Omega, t > 0 \end{cases}$$ where: - $c_1, c_2$: densities of mesenchymal stem cells and chondrocytes - $h, \tau$: concentrations of hyaluronic acid and ECM - Boundary conditions: zero flux (Neumann boundary conditions) - Initial conditions satisfy regularity assumptions (1.4) ### Model Architecture #### 1. Regularization Problem Construction (Section 2) Introduce regularization parameter $\epsilon \in (0,1)$ and construct regularized problem (2.13): - Add artificial diffusion terms $\epsilon\Delta h_\epsilon$ and $\epsilon\Delta\tau_\epsilon$ to $h$ and $\tau$ equations - Add absorption term $-\epsilon c_1^\theta$ ($\theta > \max\{2,n\}$) to $c_1$ equation - Replace $c_{2\epsilon}$ with $F_\epsilon(c_{2\epsilon}) = \frac{c_{2\epsilon}}{1+\epsilon c_{2\epsilon}}$ #### 2. Global Existence for Regularized Problem (Section 3) **Lemma 3.1**: Local classical solution existence for the regularized problem is established using standard parabolic theory **Key A Priori Estimates**: - **Lemma 3.2**: Mass estimates $$\int_\Omega c_{1\epsilon}(\cdot,t) \leq C(T), \quad \int_\Omega c_{2\epsilon}(\cdot,t) \leq C(T)$$ $$\int_0^{\tilde{T}_\epsilon}\int_\Omega c_{1\epsilon}^2 \leq C(T), \quad \epsilon\int_0^{\tilde{T}_\epsilon}\int_\Omega c_{1\epsilon}^\theta \leq C(T)$$ - **Lemma 3.3**: $L^\infty$ estimates $$\|h_\epsilon(\cdot,t)\|_{L^\infty(\Omega)} \leq M_h, \quad \|\tau_\epsilon(\cdot,t)\|_{L^\infty(\Omega)} \leq M_\tau$$ - **Lemma 3.4**: Global existence $T_{\max,\epsilon} = \infty$ Establish $C^{2+\vartheta,1+\vartheta/2}$ estimates via Sobolev regularity and Hölder estimates, contradicting the blow-up criterion #### 3. Entropy-Type Functional Estimates (Section 4) This is the core technical innovation of the paper. Define the entropy-type functional: $$F_\epsilon(t) := \int_\Omega(c_{1\epsilon}\ln c_{1\epsilon} + \frac{1}{e}) + \xi\int_\Omega(c_{2\epsilon}\ln c_{2\epsilon} + \frac{1}{e}) + \frac{b_h}{2\gamma_1}\int_\Omega\frac{|\nabla h_\epsilon|^2}{h_\epsilon} + \frac{b_\tau}{2\delta}\int_\Omega\frac{|\nabla\tau_\epsilon|^2}{\tau_\epsilon}$$ **Key Lemmas**: - **Lemmas 4.1-4.4**: Establish logarithmic entropy inequalities for $c_1, c_2, h, \tau$ respectively - **Lemma 4.5**: Comprehensive estimate proving $$F_\epsilon(t) \leq C(T), \quad \int_0^T D_\epsilon(t)dt \leq C(T)$$ where $D_\epsilon$ contains gradient terms and nonlinear dissipative terms **Technical Highlights**: - Test $c_1$ equation with $\ln c_{1\epsilon}$ and $h$ equation with $\frac{|\nabla h_\epsilon|^2}{h_\epsilon}$ - Haptotaxis terms achieve favorable cancellation: $b_h\int\nabla c_1\cdot\nabla h$ cancels with $\gamma_1\int\nabla c_1\cdot\nabla h$ - Unfavorable sign terms $\int c_2\ln c_1$ are controlled via Gagliardo-Nirenberg inequalities ### Technical Innovations 1. **Handling Double Haptotaxis**: Through carefully designed entropy-type functionals, the two haptotaxis terms are made to cancel with corresponding gradient dissipation terms, which is key to handling double attractive haptotaxis 2. **Overcoming Degenerate Diffusion**: Since $h$ and $\tau$ do not diffuse (in the original problem) or have only artificial diffusion (in the regularized problem), degenerate regularity is overcome through $\frac{|\nabla h|^2}{h}$-type estimates 3. **Control of Cross Terms**: Unfavorable sign cross terms $\int c_2\ln c_1$ are controlled through a combination of Young's inequality, Gagliardo-Nirenberg inequalities, and logarithmic inequalities $\ln s \leq (\frac{4}{e})s^{1/4}$ 4. **Compactness Arguments**: Establish strong precompactness (Lemma 4.9) using the Aubin-Lions lemma, completing the limiting process through weak convergence and almost everywhere convergence ## Experimental Setup **Note**: This is pure mathematical theoretical research with no numerical experiments or actual data. ### Theoretical Framework - **Spatial Dimension**: $n \in \{2,3\}$ - **Domain**: $\Omega \subset \mathbb{R}^n$ bounded convex domain with sufficiently smooth boundary - **Parameter Assumptions**: All physical parameters $a_1, a_2, b_h, b_\tau, \beta, \gamma_1, \gamma_2, \delta, \mu, \sigma$ are positive constants - **Transition Functions**: $\alpha_i(z) \in C^{\vartheta,\vartheta/2}(\bar{\Omega}\times[0,T])$, bounded and positive ### Weak Solution Definition (Definition 1.1) Weak solution $(c_1, c_2, h, \tau)$ must satisfy: - **Regularity**: $$c_1 \in L^2(\Omega\times(0,T)) \cap L^{4/3}((0,T);W^{1,4/3}(\Omega))$$ $$c_2 \in L^{5/4}((0,T);W^{1,5/4}(\Omega))$$ $$h, \tau \in L^\infty(\Omega\times(0,T)) \cap L^2((0,T);W^{1,2}(\Omega))$$ - **Weak Formulation**: For all test functions $\phi \in C_0^\infty(\bar{\Omega}\times[0,T])$, integral identities (1.6)-(1.9) are satisfied ## Experimental Results ### Main Result (Theorem 1.2) **Theorem Statement**: Assuming initial conditions (1.4) and transition functions (1.5) hold, problem (1.1)-(1.3) admits at least one global weak solution in the sense of Definition 1.1. ### Proof Strategy (Section 5) 1. **Construction of Regularized Sequence**: Select subsequence $\epsilon_j \to 0$ 2. **Weak Convergence**: - $c_{1\epsilon_j} \rightharpoonup c_1$ in $L^2_{loc}$, $\nabla c_{1\epsilon_j} \rightharpoonup \nabla c_1$ in $L^{4/3}_{loc}$ - $c_{2\epsilon_j} \to c_2$ in $L^{5/4}_{loc}$ (strong convergence) - $h_{\epsilon_j} \to h$, $\tau_{\epsilon_j} \to \tau$ in $L^2_{loc}$ (strong convergence) 3. **Critical Convergence**: - Artificial terms: $\epsilon c_{1\epsilon}^\theta \to 0$ (guaranteed by (4.71)) - Nonlinear terms: $c_{1\epsilon}c_{2\epsilon} \to c_1c_2$ in $L^{5/4}$ (by combination of strong-weak convergence) - Regularization terms: $F_\epsilon(c_{2\epsilon}) \to c_2$ (by Vitali convergence theorem) 4. **Limiting Process**: In the weak formulation (5.118)-(5.131) of the regularized problem, let $\epsilon = \epsilon_j \to 0$ to obtain the weak formulation (5.129)-(5.138) of the original problem ### Summary of Key Estimates | Estimate Type | Result | Lemma Number | |---------------|--------|--------------| | Mass Conservation | $\int_\Omega(c_1+c_2) \leq C(T)$ | Lemma 3.2 | | $L^\infty$ Bounds | $\|h\|_{L^\infty}, \|\tau\|_{L^\infty} \leq C$ | Lemma 3.3 | | Entropy Estimates | $\int c_1\ln c_1 + \int\frac{\|\nabla h\|^2}{h} \leq C(T)$ | Lemma 4.5 | | Gradient Estimates | $\int_0^T\int\frac{\|\nabla c_1\|^2}{c_1} \leq C(T)$ | Lemma 4.5 | | Time Derivatives | $\|\partial_t h\|_{L^1((0,T);(W^{k,2}_0)^*)} \leq C(T)$ | Lemma 4.7 | | Strong Precompactness | $\{c_{1\epsilon}\}$ strongly precompact in $L^{4/3}(\Omega\times(0,T))$ | Lemma 4.9 | ## Related Work ### 1. Mathematical Theory of Haptotaxis Models - **Single Haptotaxis**: Classical Keller-Segel-type models and variants - **Multiple Haptotaxis**: Classification framework proposed in [7]; this paper belongs to category (ii) (lacking chemotaxis) - **Double Haptotaxis Pioneering Work**: [7] studied double haptotaxis with one-sided repulsion, [13] studied viral therapy models ### 2. Biomedical Applications - **Tissue Regeneration Modeling**: Multiscale approach in [4], data-driven simulations in [6] - **Cancer Invasion Models**: Haptotaxis-chemotaxis systems in [2,3,9,15,17,20] - **Stem Cell Migration**: Multiscale cancer stem cell migration model in [10] ### 3. Mathematical Techniques - **Entropy Methods**: Classical technique originating from Keller-Segel models - **Regularization Approximation**: Similar strategies in [11,13] - **Sobolev Regularity**: Maximal Sobolev regularity theory in [5] - **Heat Semigroup Estimates**: Neumann heat semigroup lemma in [19] ### Advantages of This Work 1. First to address double **attractive** haptotaxis concentrated in a single cell population for tissue regeneration models 2. Develops new entropy-type functional techniques for handling interactions of double haptotaxis 3. Proves global existence within biologically relevant parameter ranges ## Conclusions and Discussion ### Main Conclusions This paper successfully establishes global weak solution existence for tissue regeneration models with double haptotaxis, representing important theoretical progress in the field. The proof relies on: 1. Carefully designed regularization schemes 2. Critical a priori estimates derived from entropy-type functionals 3. Rigorous arguments for strong precompactness and limiting processes ### Limitations 1. **Only Existence Proven**: Does not address uniqueness, regularity, or long-time asymptotic behavior of solutions 2. **Weak Solution Framework**: Solution regularity is relatively low ($c_1 \in L^{4/3}(W^{1,4/3})$), potentially insufficient for describing certain biological details 3. **Parameter Restrictions**: Requires transition functions $\alpha_i$ to satisfy Hölder continuity and boundedness assumptions 4. **Dimensional Restriction**: $n \in \{2,3\}$; while covering practical applications, theoretically limited 5. **No Numerical Verification**: Pure theoretical work without comparison to numerical simulations in [6] ### Future Directions While not explicitly stated in the paper, natural research directions include: 1. Solution uniqueness and regularity 2. Long-time asymptotic behavior and steady-state analysis 3. Design and convergence analysis of numerical methods 4. Quantitative comparison with experimental data 5. Extension to more general nonlinear diffusion or more complex biological mechanisms ## In-Depth Evaluation ### Strengths 1. **Theoretical Rigor**: - Clear proof structure, logically sound progression from regularized problems to limiting processes - All estimates are independent of regularization parameters, ensuring validity of limits - Sufficient technical detail, such as specific applications of Sobolev embeddings and Gagliardo-Nirenberg inequalities 2. **Methodological Innovation**: - Clever design of entropy-type functional $F_\epsilon$ that balances contributions from four equations - Cancellation technique for haptotaxis terms ($b_h\int\nabla c_1\cdot\nabla h$ cancels with $\gamma_1\int\nabla c_1\cdot\nabla h$) is key innovation for handling double haptotaxis - Effective control of cross terms through combination of logarithmic entropy inequalities and Gagliardo-Nirenberg inequalities 3. **Biological Relevance**: - Model based on actual tissue regeneration research in [4,6], with clear biological background - Reasonable parameter settings reflecting real processes such as stem cell differentiation and ECM production - Double haptotaxis (toward hyaluronic acid and ECM) consistent with experimental observations 4. **Writing Quality**: - Clear structure: model introduction → regularization → a priori estimates → limiting process - Well-organized lemmas with clear roles for each estimate - Consistent notation system, easy to follow ### Weaknesses 1. **Incomplete Theoretical Framework**: - Uniqueness not established: weak solutions may not be unique - No discussion of regularity enhancement: do stronger solutions exist? - Lacks rigorous analysis of solution qualitative properties (e.g., strict positivity preservation, mass conservation) 2. **Technical Limitations**: - Low regularity requirement for $c_1$ ($L^{4/3}(W^{1,4/3})$) may result in insufficient integrability of gradient term $\nabla c_1$ for handling certain nonlinear terms - Artificial absorption term requires $\theta > \max\{2,n\}$; for $n=3$ this demands $\theta > 3$, potentially limiting method applicability - Hölder continuity assumption (1.5) on $\alpha_i$ is strong; practical applications may require verification 3. **Disconnect from Numerical Work**: - Reference [6] provides numerical simulations, but no comparison with this work - Lacks numerical verification of theoretical predictions (e.g., solution existence, mass conservation) - No discussion of numerical method design or convergence 4. **Insufficient Biological Interpretation**: - No discussion of biological meaning of weak solutions: is low regularity sufficient for describing cell migration? - Missing parameter sensitivity analysis: which parameters most significantly affect solution behavior? - No quantitative comparison with experimental data 5. **Presentation Details**: - Constant dependence in some estimates unclear (e.g., does $C(T)$ depend on $\epsilon$?) - Specific value of $\xi$ in Lemma 4.5 not optimized, possibly not optimal choice - Proof of some convergences in limiting process (e.g., (5.127)) too brief ### Impact 1. **Contribution to Field**: - **Theoretical Significance**: First global existence result for double **attractive** haptotaxis models in tissue regeneration, enriching mathematical theory of haptotaxis models - **Methodological Contribution**: Entropy-type functional techniques generalizable to other multi-haptotaxis models - **Application Value**: Provides theoretical foundation for tissue regeneration mathematical modeling 2. **Practical Value**: - Moderate: theoretical results provide mathematical guarantees for numerical simulations, but do not directly produce practical algorithms - Requires subsequent numerical work to translate theory into applications 3. **Reproducibility**: - **High**: Proof steps detailed, lemmas well-organized, mathematically fully reproducible - No code or data required; pure theoretical work 4. **Anticipated Citations**: - Expected high citation in PDE analysis, biomathematics, and tissue engineering modeling - May inspire mathematical analysis of similar models (bone regeneration, wound healing) ### Applicable Scenarios 1. **Direct Application**: - Mathematical modeling of cartilage tissue regeneration - Study of stem cell migration and differentiation in scaffolds - Biological systems requiring double haptotaxis description 2. **Method Generalization**: - Other tissue regeneration models (bone, skin, etc.) - Multi-haptotaxis-chemotaxis models in cancer invasion - Global existence analysis for general cross-diffusion systems 3. **Theoretical Extension**: - Incorporating chemotaxis into complete models - More complex cell-cell interactions - Spatial heterogeneity or stochastic perturbations 4. **Inapplicable Scenarios**: - Problems requiring high-regularity solutions (e.g., shock formation) - Higher dimensions ($n \geq 4$) - Strongly nonlinear diffusion or degenerate parabolic systems ## Selected References 1. **[4] Grosjean et al. (2024)**: An in-silico approach to meniscus tissue regeneration - Source of multiscale derivation for this paper's model 2. **[6] Jäger et al. (2024)**: Cell seeding dynamics in porous scaffold - Numerical simulations verifying biological reasonableness of similar models 3. **[7] Kolbe et al. (2021)**: Modeling multiple taxis - Classification framework for multi-haptotaxis models 4. **[11] Stinner, Surulescu, Winkler (2014)**: Global weak solutions in PDE-ODE system - Similar regularization approximation methods 5. **[13] Tao (2021)**: Oncolytic viral therapy model with doubly haptotactic terms - Pioneering work on double haptotaxis 6. **[19] Winkler (2010)**: Keller-Segel model - Classical reference for heat semigroup estimates --- ## Summary This paper represents important theoretical work in mathematical modeling of tissue regeneration, successfully addressing the challenging problem of global weak solution existence for double attractive haptotaxis models. Through carefully designed entropy-type functionals and regularization approximation methods, the authors overcome technical difficulties arising from degenerate diffusion and nonlinear cross terms. While as pure theoretical research it has certain limitations (lack of uniqueness results, numerical verification, and biological interpretation), its rigorous mathematical arguments and innovative techniques provide solid foundation for subsequent research. This work has significant value for PDE analysis, biomathematics, and tissue engineering modeling, with anticipated substantial academic impact.