The Hopf-Rinow theorem and the Mañé critical value for magnetic geodesics on odd-dimensional spheres

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2503.02406
• Title: The Hopf-Rinow theorem and the Mañé critical value for magnetic geodesics on odd-dimensional spheres
• Authors: P. Albers, G. Benedetti, L. Maier
• Classification: math.SG (symplectic geometry), math.DG (differential geometry), math.DS (dynamical systems)
• Publication Date: July 24, 2025 (arXiv v2)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.02406

Abstract

This paper investigates magnetic geodesics on odd-dimensional spheres equipped with the standard round metric and magnetic potential given by the standard contact form. The authors compute the Mañé critical value of the system and prove that all pairs of points on the sphere can be connected by magnetic geodesics of a given energy value if and only if the energy is supercritical. The research methodology is based on explicit descriptions of flow-invariant submanifolds and system symmetries, introducing the concepts of totally magnetic submanifolds and magnetic homomorphisms for general magnetic systems. The paper reaffirms the superintegrability of the system: the three-sphere obtained by intersection with the complex plane is totally magnetic, and every magnetic geodesic is tangent to a two-dimensional Clifford torus.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

The core problem addressed in this paper is: for the magnetic system on odd-dimensional spheres $S^{2n+1}$ equipped with the standard metric $g$ and magnetic field $d\alpha$ (where $\alpha$ is the standard contact form), investigate the connectivity of magnetic geodesics, namely determine which pairs of points can be connected by magnetic geodesics of a given energy.

Research Significance

1. Generalization of the classical Hopf-Rinow theorem: The classical theorem states that any two points on a complete Riemannian manifold can be connected by a geodesic; this paper studies the analogous problem in the presence of a magnetic field.
2. Geometric significance of the Mañé critical value: Reveals the crucial role of the Mañé critical value in the connectivity of magnetic geodesics.
3. Connection between contact geometry and dynamical systems: Achieves interpolation between magnetic flow and sub-Riemannian geodesic flow and Reeb flow through contact angle parametrization.

Limitations of Existing Methods

• For general magnetic systems, except for Kähler magnetic systems with constant holomorphic curvature, there is a lack of precise understanding of point-pair connectivity at subcritical energies.
• Explicit description and classification of magnetic geodesics in higher dimensions remains difficult.

Core Contributions

1. Computation of the Mañé critical value: Proves that the Mañé critical value of $(S^{2n+1}, g, d\alpha)$ is $c = \frac{1}{8}$.
2. Complete characterization of magnetic geodesic connectivity: Provides necessary and sufficient conditions for arbitrary points $q_0, q_1 \in S^{2n+1}$ to be connected by magnetic geodesics of energy $k$.
3. Introduction of new concepts: Defines totally magnetic submanifolds and magnetic homomorphisms, providing a systematic symmetry theory for magnetic systems.
4. Establishment of Clifford torus theory: Proves that every magnetic geodesic is contained in a two-dimensional Clifford torus and provides explicit parametrization.
5. Realization of flow interpolation: Achieves interpolation of magnetic flow between sub-Riemannian geodesic flow and Reeb flow through contact angle parametrization.

Detailed Methodology

Fundamental Theory of Magnetic Systems

For a magnetic system $(M, g, \sigma)$, where $\sigma$ is a closed two-form (magnetic field), magnetic geodesics satisfy: $\nabla_{\dot{\gamma}} \dot{\gamma} = Y_\gamma \dot{\gamma}$ where $Y$ is the Lorentz force, defined by $g_q(Y_q u, v) = \sigma_q(u, v)$.

Mañé Critical Value Theory

For Killing magnetic Lagrangian systems, the authors prove:

Theorem 2.4: If $L$ is a Killing Lagrangian, then its Mañé critical value is: $c(L) = \frac{1}{2}\|\alpha\|_\infty^2$

For the standard contact form $\alpha$, we have $\|\alpha\|_\infty = \frac{1}{2}$, thus $c = \frac{1}{8}$.

Characterization of Totally Magnetic Submanifolds

Theorem 1.4: A submanifold $N \subset M$ is totally magnetic if and only if:

1. The second fundamental form vanishes identically: $II_q(v) = 0, \forall (q,v) \in TN$
2. The Lorentz force preserves the tangent bundle: $Y^M_q v \in TN, \forall (q,v) \in TN$

Clifford Torus Parametrization

For unit-speed magnetic geodesics with strength $s$ and contact angle $\psi$, the form is: $\gamma(t) = e^{i\frac{s}{2}t}(e^{-i|C_s(\psi)|t}w_0 + e^{i|C_s(\psi)|t}w_1)$

where $(w_0, w_1)$ is an admissible pair and $C_s(\psi) = (-\frac{s}{2} + \cos\psi, \sin\psi)$.

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Verification

This is primarily a theoretical work, with results verified through rigorous mathematical proofs:

1. Mañé critical value computation: Uses Killing vector field theory and K-contact structures.
2. Connectivity conditions: Established through complex analysis and Clifford torus geometry.
3. Symmetry analysis: Utilizes the action of the unitary group $U(n+1)$.

Specific Case Analysis

The authors provide detailed analysis of the $S^3$ case, projecting the problem to the two-dimensional sphere via the Hopf fibration $\pi: S^3 \to S^2(\frac{1}{2})$.

Experimental Results

Main Theorems

Theorem 1.1 (Main Result): For the magnetic system on $S^{2n+1}$, let $q_0, q_1 \in S^{2n+1}$, and $G_k(q_0, q_1)$ denote the set of magnetic geodesics of energy $k$ connecting the two points:

1. Supercritical case ($k > \frac{1}{8}$): $G_k(q_0, q_1) \neq \emptyset$ holds for all pairs of points.
2. Critical case ($k = \frac{1}{8}$): $G_k(q_0, q_1) \neq \emptyset$ if and only if $\langle q_0, q_1 \rangle \neq 0$.
3. Subcritical case ($k < \frac{1}{8}$):
   • If $|\langle q_0, q_1 \rangle| > \sqrt{1-8k}$, then $G_k(q_0, q_1) \neq \emptyset$
   • If $|\langle q_0, q_1 \rangle| = \sqrt{1-8k}$, then discrete conditions exist
   • If $|\langle q_0, q_1 \rangle| < \sqrt{1-8k}$, then $G_k(q_0, q_1) = \emptyset$

Symmetry Results

Corollary 1.5:

• The magnetic homomorphism group is $\text{Mag}(S^{2n+1}, g, d\alpha) = U(n+1)$
• Closed connected totally magnetic submanifolds must be of the form $S^{2n+1} \cap V$, where $V$ is a complex vector subspace of $\mathbb{C}^{n+1}$.

Application of Hopf Fibration

Theorem 1.12: For a magnetic geodesic $\gamma$ on $S^3$, its Hopf projection $\pi(\gamma)$ is a magnetic geodesic on $S^2(\frac{1}{2})$ with magnetic field strength: $a_s(\psi) = \frac{2\cos\psi - s}{\sin\psi}$

Related Work

Magnetic Systems Research

• Arnold (1960s): Incorporated the motion of charged particles in magnetic fields into the modern dynamical systems framework.
• Contact metric structures: Research on three-tori, Berger spheres, Heisenberg groups, etc.
• Integrable systems: Connections between magnetic systems and integrable systems theory.

Mañé Critical Value Theory

• Contreras: Variational proof of connectivity in the supercritical case.
• Merry: Generalization to weakly exact magnetic fields.
• Symplectic invariants: Relationship with Hofer-Zehnder capacity.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Completely resolves the Hopf-Rinow problem for magnetic systems on odd-dimensional spheres.
2. The Mañé critical value $\frac{1}{8}$ precisely separates full connectivity from partial connectivity.
3. The contact angle provides a natural interpolation between magnetic flow and classical geometric flows.
4. The superintegrability of the system is perfectly embodied through Clifford torus geometry.

Limitations

1. The methodology heavily depends on the special geometric structure of spheres.
2. Generalization to other manifolds requires different techniques.
3. Variational proofs for the subcritical case require further work.

Future Directions

1. Infinite-dimensional generalization: The third author has already extended the results to the infinite-dimensional case in 26.
2. Hofer-Zehnder capacity: Applications in 10.
3. Other contact manifolds: Application of the methodology to other contact metric manifolds.

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical completeness: Provides a complete solution to the problem, including all critical cases.
2. Methodological innovation: Introduces the concepts of totally magnetic submanifolds and magnetic homomorphisms, providing a systematic theoretical framework for magnetic systems.
3. Geometric insight: Reveals deep geometric structures through Clifford tori and contact angles.
4. Explicit construction: All results have explicit geometric and algebraic expressions.

Weaknesses

1. Scope of applicability: The methodology is specialized to sphere geometry with limited generalizability.
2. Computational complexity: Although results are explicit, actual computation remains complex.
3. Physical interpretation: Lacks physical intuition for the results.

Impact

1. Theoretical contribution: Provides important tools and concepts for the geometric theory of magnetic systems.
2. Application prospects: Has broad applications in symplectic geometry, dynamical systems, and partial differential equations.
3. Methodological value: Demonstrates the power of contact geometry in the study of dynamical systems.

Applicable Scenarios

1. Analysis of magnetic systems on odd-dimensional spheres.
2. Cross-disciplinary research between contact geometry and dynamical systems.
3. Computation of symplectic capacities and invariants.
4. Geometric analysis of integrable systems.

References

The paper contains 36 references covering important works in magnetic systems theory, contact geometry, dynamical systems, and symplectic geometry, particularly Arnold's pioneering work and recent related research developments.