Star-products for Lie-algebraic noncommutative Minkowski space-times

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2503.07176
• Title: Star-products for Lie-algebraic noncommutative Minkowski space-times
• Authors: Valentine Maris, Filip Požar, Jean-Christophe Wallet
• Classification: hep-th math-ph math.MP
• Publication Date: March 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.07176

Abstract

This paper constructs star products and involutions for T-Minkowski spacetimes based on Zakrzewski's classification of Poisson structures on the Poincaré group. A broad family of Lie algebras is investigated, covering 11 out of 17 Lie algebras in T-Minkowski spacetimes. It is demonstrated that the Lebesgue integral defines either a trace or a KMS weight ("twisted trace") depending on whether the Lie group corresponding to the coordinate Lie algebra is unimodular. Finally, a Poincaré Hopf algebra compatible with the star products is presented.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Effective description of quantum gravity: Deformations of quantum Minkowski spacetime are considered to have significant physical importance in effective theories of quantum gravity, potentially related to Double Special Relativity and Relative Locality.
2. Limitations of κ-Minkowski spacetime: Although κ-Minkowski spacetime has received considerable attention due to its remarkable properties, other Lie-algebraic deformations of Minkowski spacetime remain insufficiently studied.
3. Applications of classification theory: Zakrzewski's classification of Poisson structures on the Poincaré group provides a theoretical foundation for constructing various quantum Minkowski spacetimes, with Mercati demonstrating 17 classes of T-Minkowski spacetimes based on this classification.

Research Motivation

• To provide a systematic method for constructing star products for Lie-algebraic noncommutative spacetimes
• To establish complete *-algebra structures to support quantum field theory constructions
• To explore the mathematical structures and physical properties of different types of spacetime deformations

Core Contributions

1. Systematic construction of star products and involutions: Explicit star product expressions and corresponding involution operations are constructed for Lie algebras of 11 T-Minkowski spacetimes.
2. Establishment of trace classification theory: It is proven that the Lebesgue integral defines:
   • Standard trace for unimodular groups
   • KMS weight (twisted trace) for non-unimodular groups
3. Construction of symmetry Hopf algebras: A Poincaré Hopf algebra structure compatible with the star products is provided, particularly for spacetimes 13-16.
4. Provision of practical computational framework: The construction method based on convolution algebras and Weyl quantization facilitates practical calculations and field theory applications.

Detailed Methodology

Theoretical Framework

The paper employs the von Neumann-Weyl quantization method, combining properties of convolution algebras with Weyl quantization mappings.

Core Construction

1. Lie Group Structure

All considered Lie groups possess a semidirect product structure: $G = H \ltimes_\phi \mathbb{R}^n$ where $H \subset GL(n,\mathbb{R})$ is an abelian Lie group and $\phi: H \to \text{Aut}(\mathbb{R}^n)$ defines the action.

2. Convolution Product and Involution

Convolution product: $(F \circ G)(s) = \int_G d\mu_G(t) F(st) G(t^{-1})$

Involution: $F^\star(u) = \overline{F(u^{-1})} \Delta_G(u^{-1})$

3. General Form of Star Product

Through Fourier transformation, the general expression for the star product is obtained: $f \star g = \frac{1}{2\pi} \int dp_M dy_M e^{-ip_M y_M} f(x + y_M) g(A(p_M)x)$

where $A(p_M) = I_M \oplus a^T(p_M) \oplus^{4-n-1} I$, and $a(p_M)$ is a matrix related to the Lie group structure.

4. Expression of Involution

$f^\dagger(x) = \frac{1}{2\pi} \int dp_M dy_M e^{-ip_M y_M} |det(A(p_M))|^2 f(A(p_M)x + y_M)$

Coordinate Commutation Relations

The coordinate commutation relations generated by the star product have the general form: $[x_M, x_\mu] = -i[\partial_{p_M} A(p_M)|_{p_M=0}]^\sigma_\mu x^\sigma$

Experimental Setup

Classification System

The paper classifies the 11 applicable spacetimes into two categories according to the unimodularity of the Lie groups:

Unimodular Groups (7 cases)

• Spacetimes 10, 11, 12: Heisenberg algebra and 4-dimensional nilpotent algebra
• Spacetimes 13, 14, 15: SE(2) group, corresponding to ρ-Minkowski type
• Spacetime 16: SE(1,1) group, Lorentz version of ρ-Minkowski

Non-unimodular Groups (4 cases)

• Spacetimes 7, 8, 17, 18: Involving complex exponential matrix structures

Technical Implementation

Each spacetime requires:

1. Determination of appropriate coordinate bases such that commutation relations conform to standard form (2.30)
2. Construction of the corresponding matrix $a(p_M)$
3. Calculation of explicit expressions for star products and involutions

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Successful Construction of Star Products

Explicit star product expressions are successfully constructed for all 11 spacetimes, for example:

Spacetime 13 (time-noncommutative ρ-Minkowski): $a(p_0) = \begin{pmatrix} \cos(\lambda p_0) & -\sin(\lambda p_0) \\ \sin(\lambda p_0) & \cos(\lambda p_0) \end{pmatrix}$

Spacetime 7 (non-unimodular case): $a(\lambda p_0) = \begin{pmatrix} e^{-\alpha\lambda p_0} & 0 & 0 \\ 0 & e^{-\alpha\lambda p_0}\cos(\lambda p_0) & -e^{-\alpha\lambda p_0}\sin(\lambda p_0) \\ 0 & e^{-\alpha\lambda p_0}\sin(\lambda p_0) & e^{-\alpha\lambda p_0}\cos(\lambda p_0) \end{pmatrix}$

2. Classification of Traces

• Unimodular groups: $\det A(p_M) = 1$, Lebesgue integral serves as standard trace
• Non-unimodular groups: $\det A(p_M) = e^{-np_M}$, producing KMS weights

3. Structure of KMS Weights

For non-unimodular groups, the twisted operator is: $(\sigma \triangleright g)(x_0, \vec{x}) = g(x_0 + in, \vec{x})$

generating a one-parameter automorphism group $\{\sigma_t = e^{tn\partial_0}\}_{t\in\mathbb{R}}$, corresponding to time evolution.

Hopf Algebra Results

A compatible Poincaré Hopf algebra is successfully constructed for spacetimes 13-16, with the coproduct for spacetime 13 given by: $\Delta(M_{10}) = M_{10} \otimes 1 + \lambda P_1 \otimes M_{21} + C \otimes M_{10} + S \otimes M_{20}$

where $C = \cos(\lambda P_M)$ and $S = \sin(\lambda P_M)$.

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Zakrzewski classification: Complete classification of Poisson structures on the Poincaré group
2. κ-Minkowski research: As the most studied quantum spacetime, extensive research results are available
3. ρ-Minkowski development: Recent advances in localization, observer theory, and related areas

Method Comparison

• Drinfeld twist method: Based on twist elements, ensuring compatibility with Hopf algebras
• Present method: Based on convolution algebras, providing more intuitive integral expressions, though Hopf algebra compatibility requires case-by-case verification

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Complete *-algebra structures are successfully constructed for 11 T-Minkowski spacetimes
2. A classification theory of traces and KMS weights is established, revealing the crucial role of unimodularity
3. Compatible Poincaré Hopf algebras are found for 4 spacetimes (13-16)

Limitations

1. Coverage: Only 11 out of 17 spacetimes are addressed; the remaining 6 require more complex group structures
2. Hopf algebra compatibility: In most cases, standard Poincaré actions cannot produce closed coproducts
3. Physical applications: Deeper exploration of applications in concrete physical theories remains to be done

Future Directions

1. Field theory construction: Construction and study of quantum field theories on these spacetimes
2. Gauge theory: Development of corresponding gauge theory frameworks
3. Physical phenomenology: Exploration of KMS weights in thermodynamic time hypothesis applications
4. Complete classification: Treatment of the remaining 6 spacetime cases

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong systematicity: Provides a unified framework for handling Lie-algebraic noncommutative spacetimes
2. Mathematical rigor: Based on mature operator algebra theory with reliable and complete constructions
3. Computational friendliness: Star product expressions are suitable for practical calculations and numerical simulations
4. Theoretical depth: Reveals the deep connection between unimodularity and trace structure

Weaknesses

1. Insufficient physical interpretation: Lacks in-depth discussion of the physical significance of different spacetime deformations
2. Limited applications: Remains primarily at the mathematical structure level; practical physical applications require further development
3. Technical complexity: Calculations in certain cases are quite involved, potentially limiting practical utility

Impact

1. Theoretical contribution: Provides important tools for noncommutative geometry and quantum gravity phenomenology
2. Methodological value: Application of Weyl quantization methods in broader contexts
3. Future potential: Establishes foundation for related field theory and phenomenology research

Applicable Scenarios

• Research on effective theories of quantum gravity
• Mathematical physics applications of noncommutative geometry
• Deformed symmetries and Hopf algebra theory
• Extensions of quantum field theory to curved or noncommutative backgrounds

References

The paper cites extensive related work, primarily including:

• Zakrzewski's classification work on Poisson structures of the Poincaré group
• Mercati's construction of T-Minkowski spacetimes
• Related research on κ-Minkowski and ρ-Minkowski spacetimes
• Mathematical literature on operator algebras and KMS theory

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality mathematical physics paper that provides important theoretical tools for noncommutative spacetime geometry. While further development in physical applications remains to be done, the completeness and systematicity of its mathematical framework make it a significant contribution to the field.