Josephson traveling-wave parametric amplifier based on low-intrinsic-loss coplanar lumped-element waveguide

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2503.07559
• Title: Josephson traveling-wave parametric amplifier based on low-intrinsic-loss coplanar lumped-element waveguide
• Authors: C. W. Sandbo Chang, Arjan F. Van Loo, Chih-Chiao Hung, Yu Zhou, Christian Gnardt, Shuhei Tamate, Yasunobu Nakamura
• Classification: physics.app-ph quant-ph
• Publication Date: October 30, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.07559

Abstract

This paper presents a Josephson traveling-wave parametric amplifier (JTWPA) based on a low-loss coplanar lumped-element waveguide architecture. By employing open-stub-line capacitors and Manhattan-style junctions, the device achieves insertion loss below 1 dB below 12 GHz. The study introduces windowed sinusoidal modulation for phase matching and demonstrates that smooth transitions in impedance modulation strength effectively suppress intrinsic gain ripple. Using Tukey window modulation with 8% impedance variation, the device achieves 20-23 dB gain within a 5 GHz bandwidth under ideal matching conditions. In practical circuits with impedance mismatch, the device maintains 17-20 dB gain over a 4.8 GHz bandwidth, with added noise of 0.18 quanta above the standard quantum limit at 20 dB gain, saturation power of -99 dBm, and zero-to-negative reverse gain characteristics below the bandgap frequency.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

In superconducting quantum computing, quantum-limited amplification is crucial for achieving high-fidelity single-shot qubit readout. While traditional resonator-based Josephson parametric amplifiers (JPA) provide high gain and near-quantum-limited noise performance, their resonant nature imposes fundamental limitations on instantaneous bandwidth.

Significance

The Josephson traveling-wave parametric amplifier (JTWPA), as a promising alternative, overcomes these constraints through transmission-line-based architecture, enabling high gain over wide bandwidth while maintaining high saturation power. This is particularly important for applications such as simultaneous single-shot readout of frequency-multiplexed qubits.

Limitations of Existing Approaches

Despite JTWPA's advantages, several implementation challenges have hindered widespread adoption:

1. Manufacturing challenges: Requires fabrication of hundreds to thousands of highly uniform Josephson junctions
2. Phase matching issues: Nonlinear phase shifts induced by strong pump waves impede effective parametric gain
3. Insertion loss: Existing designs suffer from significant insertion loss due to dielectric material selection or grounding material usage
4. Gain ripple: Designs based on periodic modulation exhibit substantial intrinsic gain ripple

Research Motivation

This work aims to simultaneously address two fundamental challenges in JTWPA implementation—device loss and gain ripple formation—through a novel coplanar lumped-element architecture and windowed modulation scheme.

Core Contributions

1. Proposed low-loss CP-JTWPA architecture: Employing open-stub-line capacitors and Manhattan-style Josephson junctions, achieving insertion loss below 1 dB below 12 GHz
2. Developed windowed modulation scheme: Through theoretical analysis and experimental validation, demonstrating that windowing effectively suppresses gain ripple in periodic modulation
3. Achieved excellent device performance: Tukey-windowed device reaches 20-23 dB gain with 5 GHz bandwidth under ideal conditions, with near-quantum-limited noise performance
4. Provided complete theoretical framework: Established coupled-mode theory analysis, revealing connections between window function selection and transmission spectrum

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Design and implement a Josephson traveling-wave parametric amplifier with low insertion loss, wide bandwidth, high gain, and minimal gain ripple for quantum-limited amplification applications in superconducting quantum computing.

Device Architecture Design

Open-Stub-Line Transmission Line Structure

The core innovation is based on a coplanar waveguide (CPW) open-stub-line architecture:

1. Basic unit: Each unit contains a Josephson junction and a pair of open-stub-line capacitors
2. Impedance control: Adjusting stub-line length to compensate for the series inductance added by the Josephson junction, maintaining 50Ω line impedance
3. Low-loss design: Using silicon substrate and vacuum as primary dielectric materials, avoiding lossy dielectric materials

The equivalent circuit model is: $Z = \sqrt{\frac{L_J + L_s}{C_g}}$

where $L_J$ is the junction inductance, $L_s$ is the geometric inductance, and $C_g$ is the stub-line capacitance.

Extended-Area Manhattan-Style Junctions

To address the insufficient critical current of conventional Manhattan-style junctions, extended Manhattan-style junctions with area exceeding 1 μm² were developed:

• Using thick top-layer imaging layer (2 μm) and thin bottom-layer undercut layer (200 nm) electron-beam resist stack
• Achieving high uniformity with normal-state junction resistance standard deviation less than 2% across the device area
• Near-perfect yield rate

Windowed Modulation Scheme

Theoretical Analysis

Based on coupled-mode theory, transmission and reflection coefficients are approximated as:

$t \approx \frac{1}{\cosh(\kappa|F(0,l)|)}$

$r \approx j\frac{F^*(0,l)}{|F(0,l)|}\tanh(\kappa|F(0,l)|)$

where the $F$ function represents the integral of the window function: $F(0,l) = \int_0^l W(z')e^{j2\Delta\beta z'}dz'$

Window Function Design

Three window functions were compared:

1. Boxcar window: $W(z) = 1$ (uniform modulation)
2. Hann window: $W(z) = \sin^2(\pi z/l)$
3. Tukey window: Combining cosine taper and constant amplitude region, parameter α=0.5

The Tukey window achieves optimal balance between ripple suppression and phase correction strength, with RMS modulation amplitude of 0.83 (relative to uniform modulation).

Technical Innovations

1. Coordinated modulation scheme: Simultaneously modulating junction area and stub-line length, reducing required geometric variation from 16% to 8%
2. Air-bridge structures: Inserting air-bridges connecting ground planes to suppress slot-line modes, providing additional ground current paths
3. Phase matching optimization: Implementing phase matching for four-wave mixing by applying pump near the bandgap frequency

Experimental Setup

Device Fabrication

Three CP-JTWPA samples (devices A, B, C) were fabricated, each containing approximately 2400 unit cells, with chip area of 5×5 mm²:

• Device A: Boxcar window, 5% impedance modulation
• Device B: Hann window, 8% impedance modulation
• Device C: Tukey window, 8% impedance modulation

Measurement Configuration

Measurements were performed in a dilution refrigerator at 12 mK temperature, alternating measurements between the CP-JTWPA and a reference qubit-coupled transmission line via microwave switches, ensuring equivalent signal paths.

Evaluation Metrics

• Insertion loss: Comparison with 50Ω SMA adapters
• Gain performance: Transmission comparison with pump on versus off
• Noise performance: Added noise and system noise measurements
• Saturation power: 1-dB compression point measurement

Experimental Results

Main Results

Low Insertion Loss Performance

All devices achieved insertion loss below 1 dB below 12 GHz, representing a major advance for superconducting artificial nonlinear transmission lines.

Gain Performance Comparison

Noise Performance

Tukey device at 5.563 GHz frequency:

• Added noise at 21 dB gain: 0.68 quanta
• Quantum efficiency: 84% (relative to ideal quantum-noise-limited amplifier)
• Input-referred system noise temperature: 382 mK (1.43 quanta)

Saturation Characteristics

• Saturation power: -99 dBm
• Linear range: -150 dBm to -104 dBm

Ablation Studies

By comparing device performance across different window functions, the following were verified:

1. Boxcar window produces significant gain ripple, consistent with theoretical predictions
2. Hann window effectively suppresses ripple but reduces overall gain
3. Tukey window achieves optimal balance between ripple suppression and gain

Experimental Findings

1. Negative reverse gain: Zero-to-negative reverse gain observed below the bandgap frequency, suggesting potential isolation mechanism
2. Impedance mismatch effects: Impedance mismatch in practical environments reduces gain and produces irregular ripple
3. Manufacturing fault tolerance: Coordinated modulation scheme maintains good fault tolerance to junction critical current variations

Related Work

Major Research Directions

Design approaches in JTWPA development include:

1. Dispersion engineering: Using resonant structures to compensate phase shift
2. Nonlinearity engineering: Using SQUID or SNAIL elements
3. Periodic modulation: Periodic modulation of transmission line parameters

Advantages of This Work

Compared to existing work, the CP-JTWPA presented here offers:

• Lower insertion loss (<1 dB vs. typically >2 dB)
• Simpler implementation (no magnetic flux bias control required)
• Smoother gain profile (through windowed modulation)
• Easier fabrication (based on mature electron-beam lithography process)

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully demonstrated low-loss CP-JTWPA based on open-stub-line architecture
2. Windowed modulation effectively addresses gain ripple issues in periodic modulation
3. Tukey-windowed device achieves excellent comprehensive performance: high gain, wide bandwidth, low noise

Limitations

1. Window function optimization: Tukey window's relatively short taper segment still exhibits residual transmission variation
2. Impedance matching sensitivity: Impedance mismatch in practical environments still limits maximum achievable gain
3. Manufacturing complexity: High-density patterning requires strict control of visible defects

Future Directions

1. Window function exploration: Investigating alternative window functions such as cosine or Lanczos windows
2. Integration optimization: Integrating electron-beam lithography qubits on the CP-JTWPA chip for more reliable noise characterization
3. Isolation mechanism: Investigating the physical mechanism underlying negative reverse gain

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Technical innovation: Open-stub-line architecture and windowed modulation scheme demonstrate significant novelty
2. Theoretical completeness: Provides comprehensive coupled-mode theory analysis framework
3. Experimental sufficiency: Systematic comparison of three window functions validates theoretical predictions
4. Practical value: Achieved performance metrics meet quantum computing application requirements
5. Reproducibility: Provides detailed fabrication process flow

Weaknesses

1. Theoretical limitations: Coupled-mode analysis only applicable to weak modulation regime
2. Environmental sensitivity: Device performance relatively sensitive to impedance matching environment
3. Manufacturing challenges: While uniformity improved, still requires high-precision fabrication process

Impact

1. Academic contribution: Provides new architectural paradigm for JTWPA design
2. Technical advancement: Significantly improves insertion loss and gain ripple issues
3. Application prospects: Likely to promote widespread adoption of JTWPA in quantum computing

Applicable Scenarios

• Qubit readout in superconducting quantum computing
• Frequency-multiplexed quantum systems
• Microwave quantum optics experiments
• Quantum applications requiring wide-band, low-noise amplification

References

The paper cites 50 important references covering JTWPA development history, related technologies, and theoretical foundations, providing a solid academic basis for the research.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality technical paper achieving important breakthroughs in JTWPA design. Through innovative architectural design and theoretical analysis, it effectively addresses key technical challenges in the field, making significant contributions to the development of superconducting quantum computing.